The ten promised Paradise | Episode (20) | Ali bin Abi Talib, may God be pleased with him (Part 6) The Battle of Siffin - The killing of Ammar

◉ 3167 views ⏱ 15:04 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson timeline

  1. 00:00 Love of the Companions and kin
  2. 01:00 Murder of Uthman and his bloodstained shirt
  3. 02:00 Muawiya seeks retribution for Uthman's killers
  4. 04:00 Ali appoints governors over the provinces
  5. 05:01 Syria refuses allegiance; preparations for war
  6. 06:01 Control of water at Siffin
  7. 07:01 Fighting begins and Ammar ibn Yasir's martyrdom
  8. 10:03 The Qur'ans raised and the call for arbitration
  9. 12:05 Choosing the arbiters and Kharijite movements
  10. 14:07 A glad tidings vision and supplication for the Companions

Lesson summary

The final lesson of the series "The Ten Promised Paradise" covers the Battle of Siffin between Ali ibn Abi Talib and Mu'awiya, may Allah be pleased with them, after the killing of Uthman. The sheikh explains that Mu'awiya sought retribution against Uthman's killers rather than the caliphate, and that he saw himself as right. It also describes the death of Ammar ibn Yasir and the Prophet's ﷺ words about him, then the arbitration and its outcome. The lesson concludes by urging good opinion of the Companions from both sides, refraining from speaking about their disputes, and reflecting on a encouraging dream about Allah's vast forgiveness for them.

Key takeaways

  • Mu'awiya's stance centred on demanding retribution from Uthman's killers, not on seeking the caliphate, as the sheikh clarifies.
  • Ijtihad in that fitna: each side believed it was upon the truth; the correct mujtahid has two rewards and the mistaken one has the reward of his effort.
  • The death of Ammar ibn Yasir fulfilled the Prophet's ﷺ words: "the rebellious group will kill him."
  • Arbitration, requested by the Syrian side and accepted by Ali, was meant to end the fighting, with Abu Musa al-Ash'ari and Amr ibn al-As as arbiters.
  • Both armies were instructed not to finish off the wounded, not to kill those fleeing, and not to plunder the dead.
  • It is obligatory to think well of the Companions from both sides and to refrain from what passed between them.
  • A reported dream of Abu Maysara 'Amr ibn Shurahbil points to Allah's wide forgiveness for the Companions.

Questions & answers

What caused the Battle of Siffin?

According to the sheikh, it began after Uthman's killing, when Mu'awiya, may Allah be pleased with him, demanded retribution against his killers and refused to pledge allegiance to Ali before that.

What is the lesson's stance on the Companions who fought at Siffin?

The sheikh urges thinking well of the Companions from both sides, refraining from what passed between them, and regarding them as mujtahids who sought no sin or worldly gain.

Why was Ammar ibn Yasir killed at Siffin?

The sheikh notes he was killed on the opposing side, and that the Prophet ﷺ had foretold a rebellious group would kill him; Mu'awiya's view was that Ali's side threw him among their swords.

How did the Battle of Siffin end?

It ended with arbitration between Abu Musa al-Ash'ari and Amr ibn al-As, may Allah be pleased with them, at Adhruh near Dumat al-Jandal, closing that chapter of history.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Entirely Merciful, the Especially Merciful.
0:04 Mawaddah Association
0:06 presents:
0:07 The Ten Promised Paradise:
0:13 'Ali Ibn Abi Talib,
0:15 may Allah be pleased with him.
0:17 "Loving the Companions and the Prophet's kin is an established Sunnah,
0:22 with which I shall meet my Lord when He resurrects me."
0:27 Loving the Companions and the Prophet's kin...
0:31 When the rebel Kharijites stormed
0:33 the house of the Commander of the Faithful,
0:35 'Uthman Ibn 'Affan, may Allah be pleased with him,
0:37 intending to kill him,
0:39 his wife defended him:
0:41 Na'ilah bint al-Farafisah.
0:43 She shielded him from the sword with her bare hand,
0:45 and her fingers were severed,
0:48 and her husband 'Uthman (may Allah be pleased with him) was martyred.
0:51 Thereupon, she wrote a letter to
0:53 Mu'awiyah Ibn Abi Sufyan (may Allah be pleased with him)
0:56 in the Levant (al-Sham),
0:57 describing how they had broken in upon 'Uthman
1:00 and how he was assassinated.
1:02 She also sent him 'Uthman's tunic,
1:04 which he was wearing when he was killed,
1:06 stained with his blood,
1:08 along with her severed fingers
1:10 that had been cut off while defending him.
1:12 She urged him
1:14 to avenge her husband's blood,
1:16 and dispatched the letter with
1:18 al-Nu'man Ibn Bashir, may Allah be pleased with him.
1:20 When the letter arrived
1:22 to Mu'awiyah,
1:24 and he read its contents
1:26 and saw the tunic,
1:28 he was shaken to his very core.
1:30 He ordered the tunic to be taken
1:32 and paraded among the troops,
1:34 then placed upon the pulpit
1:36 for all the people to see,
1:38 with her fingers attached to the sleeve of the tunic.
1:41 The people wept bitterly at the sight,
1:43 stirring each other to tears,
1:45 and Mu'awiyah summoned the people
1:47 to seek this retribution.
1:49 The people began inciting
1:51 one another
1:52 to demand justice for the blood of 'Uthman,
1:54 may Allah be pleased with him,
1:56 against those who had murdered him among those
1:58 Kharijites.
2:00 As we have mentioned earlier,
2:02 Mu'awiyah (may Allah be pleased with him) was not
2:04 seeking the caliphate;
2:06 rather, he was demanding legal retribution (qisas)
2:08 against the murderers of 'Uthman, may Allah be pleased with him.
2:10 From
2:12 the foregoing,
2:14 we understand why he insisted on his demands,
2:16 why he was so uncompromising regarding them,
2:18 and why he withheld his pledge of allegiance
2:20 to 'Ali (may Allah be pleased with him)
2:22 until retribution was exacted—
2:24 for he considered
2:26 himself to be the next of kin entitled to seek retribution.
2:28 He genuinely believed he was in the right,
2:30 and that Allah would grant him victory.
2:32 For it had reached him
2:34 that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him)
2:36 was once seated
2:38 with some of his Companions,
2:40 when 'Uthman Ibn 'Affan
2:42 (may Allah be pleased with him) passed by,
2:44 and the Prophet (peace be upon him) said:
2:46 "A tribulation will surely emerge
2:48 from beneath the feet of
2:50 this man;
2:52 he and those who follow him on that day
2:54 will be upon guidance."
2:56 Mu'awiyah regarded himself
2:58 as one of the followers of 'Uthman (may Allah be pleased with him),
3:00 and thus upon guidance.
3:02 Moreover,
3:04 he considered himself among the Victorious Group,
3:06 who were said to be
3:08 the people of the Levant,
3:10 as conveyed by the Prophet,
3:12 peace and blessings be upon him.
3:14 Such reports reinforced
3:16 his conviction and that of his followers.
3:18 On the other hand, there is no doubt that
3:20 the Commander of the Faithful, 'Ali Ibn Abi Talib,
3:22 may Allah be pleased with him,
3:25 held a position strengthened by
3:27 the saying of the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him:
3:30 "A renegade faction will break away
3:32 at a time of division among the Muslims;
3:34 they will be fought by the closer
3:36 of the two parties to the truth."
3:38 And this is precisely what occurred,
3:40 as will be detailed later, if Allah wills.
3:42 For the Kharijites
3:44 emerged when the Muslims differed,
3:46 and 'Ali fought them,
3:48 may Allah be pleased with him,
3:50 thereby proving to be closer to the truth.
3:53 The Commander of the Faithful,
3:56 'Ali Ibn Abi Talib
3:58 (may Allah be pleased with him), inaugurated his caliphate
4:00 in the year 36 AH.
4:02 He proceeded
4:04 to appoint his governors
4:06 over the major provinces:
4:08 he appointed 'Abdullah Ibn 'Abbas
4:10 (may Allah be pleased with them both) over Yemen,
4:12 Samurah Ibn Jundub
4:14 (may Allah be pleased with him) over Basra,
4:16 'Ammar Ibn Shihab
4:18 over Kufa,
4:20 Qays Ibn Sa'd Ibn 'Ubadah
4:22 (may Allah be pleased with them both) over Egypt,
4:24 and Sahl Ibn Hunayf
4:26 (may Allah be pleased with him) over the Levant,
4:28 to replace Mu'awiyah,
4:30 may Allah be pleased with him.
4:33 Sahl Ibn Hunayf (may Allah be pleased with him)
4:35 departed for the Levant,
4:37 but was turned back by Mu'awiyah's cavalry.
4:39 Thereupon, the Commander of the Faithful,
4:41 'Ali Ibn Abi Talib
4:43 (may Allah be pleased with him), realized
4:45 that the Levant had defied his authority.
4:47 He dispatched Jarir Ibn 'Abdullah
4:49 al-Bajali to Mu'awiyah,
4:51 may Allah be pleased with them both,
4:53 bearing a letter
4:55 informing him of the consensus of the Muhajirun
4:57 and the Ansar in pledging allegiance to him,
4:59 and calling upon him to enter
5:01 into that which the people had entered.
5:03 Mu'awiyah summoned
5:05 'Amr Ibn al-'As and the notables
5:07 of the Levant to consult them,
5:09 and they refused to give the pledge of allegiance
5:11 until the killers of 'Uthman (may Allah be pleased with him)
5:13 were brought to justice,
5:15 or surrendered to them.
5:17 When they refused to enter
5:19 into the pledge of allegiance and cast off obedience,
5:21 at that point,
5:23 the Commander of the Faithful (may Allah be pleased with him) deemed them
5:25 rebels against whom
5:27 fighting was justified.
5:29 He mobilized from Kufa, determined
5:31 to march against the people of the Levant.
5:33 When Mu'awiyah
5:35 (may Allah be pleased with him) learned of the advance of
5:37 'Ali Ibn Abi Talib
5:39 (may Allah be pleased with him) from Kufa
5:41 at the head of fifty thousand warriors,
5:43 he prepared
5:45 likewise to march forth.
5:47 The military contingents of the Levant were mobilized,
5:49 and they gathered;
5:51 banners and standards were raised,
5:53 and they marched with around
5:55 forty thousand warriors
5:57 toward the Euphrates in the region of
5:59 Siffin.
6:01 They seized control of the water source in that area,
6:03 so as to compel
6:05 'Ali (may Allah be pleased with him)
6:07 and his men to withdraw
6:09 back to Iraq without engaging in battle.
6:12 'Ali Ibn Abi Talib
6:14 (may Allah be pleased with him) arrived with his army
6:16 at the plain of Siffin,
6:18 only to find Mu'awiyah's army already positioned there,
6:20 controlling the water.
6:22 Thereupon,
6:24 he commanded one of his generals to attack
6:26 the positions along the water
6:28 and liberate it from the hands of
6:30 the Levantine army.
6:32 When Mu'awiyah (may Allah be pleased with him) saw
6:34 that, he said:
6:36 "Leave them be, for water
6:38 is not to be withheld."
6:41 The two armies drew up their ranks,
6:43 and the two battle lines met in a spectacle
6:45 most solemn and distressing,
6:47 bringing tears to the eyes
6:49 and breaking the heart.
6:51 For you would see
6:53 that whenever this side proclaimed the Takbir,
6:55 the other proclaimed the Takbir;
6:57 and whenever the latter proclaimed the Tahlil,
6:59 These people also raised their voices with praise;
7:01 two great parties of the believers
7:03 were clashing with swords,
7:05 each side believing itself
7:07 to be in the right—
7:09 so the one who exercised ijtihad correctly
7:11 receives two rewards,
7:13 while the one who erred receives the reward of his striving.
7:15 And the decree of Allah
7:17 came to pass: the fighting
7:19 erupted, swords crossed,
7:21 souls departed,
7:23 and many of Allah's creation
7:25 were slain;
7:27 and there is no power nor might
7:29 except with Allah, the Most High,
7:31 the Supreme.
7:34 Amid these tumultuous events,
7:36 there emerged from the army of 'Ali,
7:38 may Allah be pleased with him,
7:40 a man of foremost faith,
7:42 an early pioneer in Islam
7:44 whose flesh and blood
7:46 were infused with belief;
7:48 a man who was the very benchmark
7:50 of justice in those conflicts,
7:52 about whom the Prophet,
7:54 peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, said:
7:56 "The transgressing group shall kill you."
7:58 Yes,
8:00 it was 'Ammar ibn Yasir,
8:02 may Allah be pleased with him.
8:04 He stepped forward between
8:06 the battle ranks,
8:08 though he was an elderly man, calling out to
8:10 his companions:
8:12 "Whoever wishes to be embraced by
8:14 the maidens of Paradise,
8:16 let him advance between the two ranks,
8:18 seeking Allah's reward!
8:20 By the One in Whose hand is my soul,
8:22 even if they strike us back so hard that they drive us
8:24 all the way to the date-palms of Hajar,
8:26 I would still know with certainty that we are on the truth
8:28 and that they are in error!"
8:30 Then he called for some milk,
8:32 drank from it, and said:
8:34 "Paradise has been brought near,
8:36 and the maidens of Paradise are wed!
8:38 Today we shall meet our beloved ones,
8:40 Muhammad, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and his Companions!
8:44 For indeed, the Prophet, peace be upon him,
8:46 pledged to me
8:48 that my last provision in
8:50 this worldly life would be a draught of
8:52 milk."
8:54 So he charged forward and fought a hero's
8:56 fight until he was martyred,
8:58 may Allah be pleased with him.
9:01 The army of the Levant was shaken
9:03 once word spread of the slaying of
9:05 'Ammar ibn Yasir, may Allah be pleased with him,
9:07 and their ranks fell into disarray.
9:09 'Amr ibn al-'As entered
9:11 upon Mu'awiyah, may Allah be pleased with
9:13 them both, in deep distress,
9:15 uttering the words of returning to Allah.
9:17 Mu'awiyah asked him, "What is the matter with you?"
9:19 'Amr replied,
9:21 "'Ammar has been killed!"
9:23 Mu'awiyah said to him,
9:25 "'Ammar has been killed—so what of it?"
9:27 'Amr said:
9:29 "I heard the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,
9:31 say:
9:33 'The transgressing group will kill him.'"
9:36 Mu'awiyah said to him:
9:38 "Did we kill him?
9:40 It was only 'Ali
9:42 and his companions who killed him, when they brought
9:44 him out and thrust him
9:46 right before our swords!"
9:49 The tide of battle turned decisively
9:51 in favor of the army of Kufa,
9:53 led by 'Ali ibn Abi Talib,
9:55 may Allah be pleased with him,
9:57 and the army of the Levant retreated
9:59 under the command of Mu'awiyah,
10:01 may Allah be pleased with him,
10:03 until they sought refuge upon a mountain.
10:06 At that point, the men of
10:08 Mu'awiyah raised copies of the Qur'an on their spears
10:10 and called for arbitration
10:12 by the Book of Allah.
10:14 This was to be done by each
10:16 side appointing an arbitrator to represent it;
10:18 the two arbitrators would then meet
10:20 and agree upon what serves
10:22 the best interests of the Muslims.
10:24 'Ali, may Allah be pleased with him,
10:26 accepted their proposal
10:28 and said: "Yes,
10:30 between us and you is the Book of Allah,
10:32 and I have more right to it than you."
10:35 Both armies agreed to arbitration
10:37 and to end the fighting.
10:40 Mu'awiyah chose 'Amr ibn al-'As,
10:42 may Allah be pleased with them both,
10:44 as the arbitrator representing his side;
10:46 and 'Ali chose 'Abdullah
10:48 ibn 'Abbas, may Allah be pleased with them both,
10:50 as the arbitrator representing his side.
10:52 However, the reciters among 'Ali's forces
10:54 said, "We will accept none
10:56 other than Abu Musa al-Ash'ari,
10:58 may Allah be pleased with him."
11:00 Now Abu Musa al-Ash'ari
11:02 had withdrawn from the civil strife,
11:04 so 'Ali, may Allah be pleased with him, wrote to him
11:06 instructing him to join him
11:08 at Siffin.
11:10 An agreement was reached between the two armies
11:12 that the two arbitrators—
11:14 'Amr ibn al-'As
11:16 and Abu Musa al-Ash'ari,
11:18 may Allah be pleased with them both—
11:20 would meet in Ramadan of that year
11:22 in the village of Adhruh,
11:24 near Dawmat al-Jandal.
11:26 'Ali, may Allah be pleased with him, returned
11:28 with his army to Kufa,
11:30 while Mu'awiyah, may Allah be pleased with him, returned
11:32 with his army to the Levant.
11:34 And each leader strictly
11:36 instructed his men
11:38 that no wounded person was to be dispatched,
11:40 no fleeing warrior was to be killed,
11:42 no slain soldier was to be despoiled,
11:44 and none among them took any spoils of war
11:46 from that battle.
11:49 The two arbitrators convened
11:51 at the appointed time and place,
11:53 and the arbitration was attended by
11:55 Mu'awiyah ibn Abi Sufyan
11:57 and 'Abdullah ibn 'Umar, may Allah be pleased with them both.
11:59 However, 'Ali ibn Abi Talib,
12:01 may Allah be pleased with him, was unable to attend
12:03 because he was occupied
12:05 with the uprisings of the Kharijites
12:07 at that time.
12:09 'Amr said to Abu Musa al-Ash'ari,
12:11 may Allah be pleased with them both,
12:13 after their deliberations:
12:15 "What is your view concerning this matter?"
12:17 meaning the caliphate.
12:19 Abu Musa replied:
12:21 "I believe it belongs to those prominent men with whom
12:23 the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,
12:25 was well pleased when he passed away,"
12:27 meaning by this
12:29 'Ali, may Allah be pleased with him.
12:31 'Amr said:
12:33 "Then where do you place myself and Mu'awiyah?"
12:35 Abu Musa replied:
12:37 "If he seeks your help,
12:39 you can offer assistance;
12:41 and if he has no need of you,
12:43 Allah's decree has always been independent
12:45 of you both."
12:47 Thus the arbitration concluded on this note,
12:49 and a fateful chapter of history
12:51 was brought to a close—
12:53 the event known as the Battle of Siffin.
12:55 It is essential to point out here
12:58 that it is our duty
13:00 to maintain the best opinion
13:02 of the noble Companions on both sides,
13:04 to refrain from delving into the disputes
13:06 that broke out between them,
13:08 and to interpret their conflict charitably:
13:10 they were diligent scholars exercising ijtihad based on their best interpretation,
13:12 intending thereby
13:14 neither disobedience nor pure worldly ambition;
13:16 rather, each side genuinely believed
13:18 that it was upon the truth
13:20 and that its opponents had transgressed,
13:22 making it an obligation to fight them
13:25 in compliance with the divine command.
13:27 In concluding this painful chapter,
13:29 we recount
13:31 this gladsome dream
13:33 related by
13:35 Abu Maysarah, 'Amr ibn Shurahbil,
13:37 who was among the most distinguished
13:39 companions of 'Abdullah ibn Mas'ud,
13:41 may Allah be pleased with him.
13:43 He said: "I saw in
13:45 a dream as though I had entered
13:47 Paradise, and behold, there were
13:49 pitched pavilions.
13:51 So I asked, "Whose are these?"
13:53 They replied, "They belong to Dhu al-Kala'
13:55 and his companions."
13:57 And he was among those killed alongside
13:59 Mu'awiyah, may Allah be pleased with him.
14:01 So I asked, "Then where is
14:03 'Ammar?" They answered,
14:05 "Ahead of you."
14:07 I said, "Even though they killed
14:09 one another?"
14:11 They replied, "Indeed,
14:13 they found Allah, Mighty and Majestic,
14:15 all-embracing in forgiveness."
14:18 May Allah be pleased with the Companions,
14:20 all of them,
14:22 and unite us with them in the Gardens
14:24 of Eden on the Day of Judgment.
14:55 'Ubadah,
14:57 the two Sa'ds,
14:59 and the two caliphs...