Riyadh Al-Salehin | Episode (184) | Chapter on the prohibition of pointing at a Muslim with a weapon

◉ 139 views ⏱ 11:17 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson timeline

  1. 00:00 Prohibition of pointing weapons at a Muslim
  2. 01:00 Lessons from the hadith on weapons
  3. 02:01 Prohibition of handling a drawn sword
  4. 03:05 Disliking leaving the mosque after the adhan
  5. 04:05 Recommendation to accept the gift of basil
  6. 05:09 Disliking flattery to a person's face
  7. 06:10 The Prophet's words: you have cut your companion's neck
  8. 07:11 Praise with good opinion, avoiding certainty
  9. 08:12 Throwing pebbles at flatterers' faces
  10. 09:16 Reconciling hadiths of prohibition and permission

Lesson summary

In this episode of Riyad as-Salihin, the sheikh explains hadiths forbidding pointing a weapon at a Muslim, even in jest, and forbidding carrying an unsheathed sword. He also covers the dislike of leaving the mosque after the adhan without an excuse, the dislike of refusing fragrant herbs offered as a gift, and the dislike of praising a person to his face when there is fear of conceit or similar harm. He notes that the general principle is to act on the apparent meaning of the texts, and that definitive praise is disliked, with good opinion of a person left to Allah.

Key takeaways

  • Pointing a weapon at a Muslim is forbidden even as a joke, since Satan may incite the hand and cause a killing.
  • Blocking the means: the prohibition covers anything that leads to harming Muslims, even if harm is not certain.
  • Carrying an unsheathed sword is forbidden, since the carrier may be injured.
  • Leaving the mosque after the adhan before praying the obligatory prayer is disliked unless there is an excuse, as it opposes the Prophet's ﷺ guidance.
  • It is recommended to accept a gift of fragrant herbs and not refuse it, as the Prophet ﷺ did not refuse perfume.
  • Excessive praise to someone's face is forbidden, and praise should be expressed as good opinion without certainty, leaving the outcome to Allah.
  • The principle is to act on the apparent meaning of the texts, as al-Miqdad understood and 'Uthman رضي الله عنه affirmed.

Questions & answers

What is the ruling on pointing a weapon at a Muslim as a joke?

The sheikh explains that the hadith forbids pointing a weapon at a Muslim even if one is joking, because Satan may incite someone to hurt his brother, thereby achieving his aim of creating enmity.

Is it permissible to praise a person to his face?

The sheikh clarifies that praising someone to his face is disliked when there is fear of conceit or self-admiration. Someone who is secure from that, with complete faith and certainty, may be praised, though it is better to express good opinion and leave the person's state to Allah.

What is the ruling on refusing fragrant herbs or perfume given as a gift?

The sheikh notes that the hadith recommends accepting a gift of fragrant herbs and not refusing it, since it is light to carry and pleasant in scent, and the Prophet ﷺ never refused perfume. Accepting such gifts fosters affection and closeness among Muslims.

Is it permissible to leave the mosque after the adhan?

The sheikh explains that leaving the mosque after the adhan is disliked without an excuse until one has prayed the obligatory prayer, because it opposes the Prophet's ﷺ guidance and shows the great merit of congregational prayer.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 Riyad al-Salihin
0:03 From the words of the Master of the Messengers, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him.
0:09 Chapter: The Prohibition of Pointing a Weapon or the Like at a Muslim.
0:17 Whether in earnest or in jest.
0:20 And the prohibition of handling a drawn sword.
0:25 On the authority of Abu Hurayrah, may Allah be pleased with him.
0:28 From the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, who said:
0:32 "None of you should point a weapon at his brother,
0:36 for he does not know if Shaytan might cause it to slip from his hand,
0:40 and he would fall into a pit of Fire."
0:44 Agreed upon.
0:46 In a narration by Muslim, he said:
0:49 Abu al-Qasim, peace be upon him, said:
0:53 "Whoever points a piece of iron at his brother,
0:56 the angels will curse him until he puts it down,
1:00 even if he is his brother by father and mother."
1:03 From the benefits of the hadith:
1:07 The prohibition of engaging in actions that lead
1:10 to the harm of Muslims in any way.
1:13 The prohibition of fighting a Muslim or killing him,
1:17 and the gravity of the matter.
1:19 The prohibition of pointing a weapon at a Muslim,
1:22 even if one is playing.
1:24 The eagerness of Shaytan to sow enmity
1:28 and hatred among Muslims.
1:31 For this reason, one who brandishes a weapon might be tempted,
1:34 and strike his brother with it,
1:37 thereby fulfilling the desire of Shaytan.
1:40 The prohibition of terrifying a Muslim,
1:42 because terrifying him is forbidden.
1:45 The prohibition of everything that leads to a prohibited outcome,
1:48 even if the outcome is not certain.
1:51 Whether that is done in earnest or in jest.
1:55 The great impact of this prohibition has become apparent
1:59 in our present time,
2:01 as the dangers of carrying and brandishing weapons are frequent,
2:04 especially at weddings and other occasions.
2:09 On the authority of Jabir, may Allah be pleased with him, he said:
2:13 The Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, forbade
2:16 handling a sword while it is drawn.
2:19 Narrated by Abu Dawud and al-Tirmidhi.
2:23 "Handling" means taking hold of it.
2:27 "Drawn" means out of its scabbard.
2:33 From the benefits of the hadith:
2:35 The prohibition of taking hold of a drawn sword,
2:38 because the one handling it might make a mistake,
2:41 and suffer a wound to his hand or some part of his body.
2:46 Included in the meaning of "sword" is a knife;
2:49 one should not throw it while the sharp edge is facing him.
2:56 Chapter: The Dislike of Leaving the Mosque After the Adhan,
2:59 unless there is an excuse, until the obligatory prayer is performed.
3:05 On the authority of Abu al-Sha'tha', who said:
3:07 We were sitting with Abu Hurayrah, may Allah be pleased with him, in the mosque,
3:12 when the mu'adhdhin called the Adhan.
3:14 A man stood up in the mosque and began to walk out.
3:17 Abu Hurayrah followed him with his gaze until he left the mosque.
3:23 Then Abu Hurayrah said:
3:25 "As for this man,
3:27 he has disobeyed Abu al-Qasim, peace be upon him."
3:31 Narrated by Muslim.
3:36 From the benefits of the hadith:
3:38 The dislike of leaving the mosque after the Adhan until the obligatory prayer is performed,
3:43 because that is a contradiction of the guidance of the Prophet, peace be upon him.
3:49 A reminder of the great virtue of congregational prayer.
3:53 Chapter: The Dislike of Refusing Fragrance Without an Excuse.
4:00 On the authority of Abu Hurayrah, may Allah be pleased with him, who said:
4:05 The Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, said:
4:09 "Whoever is offered fragrance should not refuse it,
4:13 for it is light to carry and pleasant in scent."
4:17 Narrated by Muslim.
4:19 "Light to carry" means easy to bear, not heavy.
4:27 On the authority of Anas ibn Malik, may Allah be pleased with him,
4:30 that the Prophet, peace be upon him, would not refuse perfume.
4:36 Narrated by al-Bukhari.
4:39 From the benefits of the hadith:
4:41 The recommendation of accepting the gift of fragrance,
4:44 for there is no great burden in accepting it.
4:47 It has become customary to be generous in offering it.
4:51 A Muslim should be pleasant-smelling,
4:56 and should use perfume and offer it to his brothers
5:00 when attending Friday prayers, congregations, and gatherings,
5:04 because that leads to harmony and love among Muslims.
5:09 Chapter: The Dislike of Praising Someone to Their Face if Corruption is Feared, Such as Arrogance and the Like,
5:18 and its Permissibility for One Who is Safe from That.
5:22 On the authority of Abu Musa al-Ash'ari, may Allah be pleased with him, who said:
5:28 The Prophet, peace be upon him, heard a man praising another and exaggerating in his commendation.
5:35 He said: "You have destroyed—or cut—the man's back."
5:41 Agreed upon. "Exaggeration" is excessive praise.
5:48 From the benefits of the hadith: The prohibition of praising someone to their face,
5:52 because it is a cause for self-delusion and falling into vanity.
5:57 These traits are destructive to the servant's religion.
6:01 On the authority of Abu Bakrah, may Allah be pleased with him,
6:06 that a man was mentioned in the presence of the Prophet, peace be upon him,
6:10 and a man praised him highly.
6:13 The Prophet, peace be upon him, said:
6:16 "Woe to you! You have cut the neck of your companion,"
6:20 repeating it several times.
6:22 "If one of you must praise,
6:26 let him say: 'I think he is such and such,'
6:29 if he believes he is truly that way,
6:32 and Allah is his Reckoner.
6:34 No one can be purified before Allah."
6:37 Agreed upon.
6:39 "Exaggerating"
6:41 means going to excess in praising and commending him.
6:44 "Woe to you"
6:45 is a phrase used to express pity for one who has done something he does not deserve.
6:51 "Must"
6:54 means it is inevitable,
6:55 and he has no choice but to do so.
6:58 "I think"
7:00 means I suppose.
7:01 "Purified"
7:03 means no one can definitively assert the purity and freedom of someone from faults.
7:07 From the benefits of the hadith:
7:11 Whoever must praise,
7:13 let him ultimately entrust the state of the one being praised to Allah,
7:17 for He is his Reckoner and knows his state best.
7:20 Praising a servant
7:23 should be based on having a good opinion of him,
7:27 not on certainty and decisiveness.
7:30 The prohibition of being definitive in praise and judging the final outcomes of people,
7:35 as well as praising them randomly for things they do not possess.
7:39 On the authority of Hammam ibn al-Harith, from al-Miqdad, may Allah be pleased with him,
7:45 that a man began to praise Uthman, may Allah be pleased with him.
7:49 Al-Miqdad stood up,
7:51 knelt on his knees,
7:53 and began to throw pebbles at his face.
7:57 Uthman said to him:
7:59 "What is the matter with you?"
8:01 He replied:
8:02 "The Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, said:
8:06 'When you see those who praise others,
8:09 throw dust in their faces.'"
8:12 Narrated by Muslim.
8:14 "Stood up"
8:17 means he intended to do so.
8:19 "Knelt"
8:20 means he sat in the posture of one ready to spring.
8:23 "Throw"
8:24 means to cast.
8:26 "Pebbles"
8:28 means small stones.
8:30 From the benefits of the hadith:
8:34 The principle regarding textual evidence
8:36 is to act upon its literal meaning
8:38 as required by the Arabic language,
8:41 until something comes to divert it from that.
8:44 This is evident in the understanding of al-Miqdad ibn al-Aswad of the hadith,
8:48 and Uthman's approval of him.
8:51 It is not permissible to listen to the words of those who praise,
8:56 and one should not reward them for their praise,
8:59 except by throwing pebbles in their faces.
9:02 Among those included in this hadith
9:05 are the poets
9:06 who made praise a means of earning a living.
9:10 The swift response of the Companions, may Allah be pleased with them, to the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him,
9:16 and their implementation of his Sunnah.
9:18 The Sunnah may be hidden from the senior Companions, may Allah be pleased with them,
9:24 which is why this hadith was hidden from Uthman, may Allah be pleased with him.
9:29 The report of a just and precise narrator is a proof,
9:32 which is why Uthman accepted the report of al-Miqdad ibn al-Aswad, may Allah be pleased with them both, without further inquiry.
9:39 These are the hadiths regarding the prohibition.
9:43 There have also come many authentic hadiths regarding permissibility.
9:47 The scholars have said:
9:49 The way to reconcile these hadiths is to say:
9:53 If the one being praised possesses complete faith and certainty,
9:57 and self-discipline,
9:59 and full awareness such that he will not be tempted or deluded by it,
10:04 and his ego will not play with him,
10:07 then it is neither forbidden nor disliked.
10:10 But if there is a fear of any of these matters,
10:13 then praising him to his face is severely disliked.
10:17 It is upon this distinction that the various hadiths on this matter are interpreted.
10:22 Among what has come regarding permissibility
10:24 is his saying, peace be upon him, to Abu Bakr, may Allah be pleased with him:
10:29 "I hope you will be one of them,"
10:32 meaning those who will be called from all the gates of Paradise to enter it.
10:37 And in the other hadith:
10:39 "You are not one of them,"
10:41 meaning you are not one of those who let their garments trail out of pride.
10:45 And he said, peace be upon him, to Umar, may Allah be pleased with him:
10:50 "Shaytan never sees you walking on a path
10:53 but that he takes a path other than yours."
10:56 The hadiths regarding permissibility are numerous,
11:00 and I have mentioned a number of them in the book *al-Adhkar*.
11:05 Riyad al-Salihin