Part of Sahih Al-Bukhari · Lesson 10 of 113

Summary of Sahih Al-Bukhari | Episode (10) | Book of Science -4

◉ 104 views ⏱ 31:30 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson timeline

  1. 00:00 Taking turns in learning and Umar's eagerness to ask
  2. 02:04 Wives' disputes and the Prophet's displeasure with them
  3. 04:05 The Prophet's seclusion from his wives
  4. 06:06 Umar enters the Prophet and sees his modest home
  5. 08:07 End of the month and the verse of choice
  6. 10:07 Explanation of terms in the previous hadith
  7. 12:09 Lessons from the hadith on taking turns in learning
  8. 14:12 Hadith of Abu Mas'ud on shortening the prayer
  9. 19:22 Hadith on lost property and its rulings
  10. 26:28 Excessive questioning and its prohibition

Lesson summary

This lesson from the Book of Knowledge in the abridged Sahih al-Bukhari covers the chapter on taking turns in seeking knowledge, including Ibn Abbas's hadith about his eagerness to ask Umar about the two wives of the Prophet ﷺ, and Umar's account of taking turns attending the Prophet ﷺ with his Ansari neighbour. The sheikh then covers the chapter on anger in admonition, the hadith of Zayd ibn Khalid on lost property, and Abu Musa's hadith on disliking excessive questioning. It concludes with the chapter on sitting on the knees before the imam or narrator, and Anas's hadith on the Companions questioning the Prophet ﷺ. The sheikh draws several lessons on seeking knowledge, the etiquette of asking, and good conduct.

Key takeaways

  • Eagerness for knowledge, and students taking turns attending a scholar as Umar did with his neighbour.
  • That serving a noble man of rank or a scholar is permissible and does not diminish him.
  • Disliking excessive questioning done out of hard-headedness or pretence, and limiting questions to what one needs of knowledge.
  • That anger in admonition arises when something disliked is seen, and that the imam should shorten the prayer out of consideration for the weak and those with needs.
  • Observing etiquette with the scholar and not pressing him with questions, along with the Companions' reverence for the Prophet ﷺ.
  • That a person should manage his livelihood well and secure what helps him in seeking knowledge, and be content with Allah's decree.
  • Seeking forgiveness and asking prayers from people of virtue and goodness.

Questions & answers

What is meant by the chapter on taking turns in knowledge?

It means that students and peers take turns attending the Prophet ﷺ or a scholar, so one attends one day and the other attends the next, and each informs the other of the knowledge and events of that day.

What ruling does the lesson give on excessive questioning?

The sheikh explains that the Prophet ﷺ disliked excessive questioning done out of hard-headedness or pretence, because it could lead to something being made unlawful for Muslims or cause harm to the asker and the one asked. One should only ask a scholar about what one needs.

What can be learned from the hadith about lost property?

It shows that picking up lost property is permitted after announcing it, and it distinguishes between a camel, which can protect itself and is left alone, and sheep, which may be taken. Benefiting from the found property after announcing it is permitted.

Why did the Prophet ﷺ become angry during the admonition?

He became angry when he saw that the imam was prolonging the prayer, which drove some worshippers away. He ordered that it be shortened while considering the elderly, the sick, the weak and those with needs.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Qur’an verses cited in this lesson

  • Al-Ma'idah 5:101 — O ye who believe! Ask not of things which, if they were made unto you, would trouble you; but if ye ask of them when the Qur'an is being revealed, they will be made known unto you. Allah pardoneth this, for Allah is Forgiving, Clement.
  • At-Tahrim 66:1 — O Prophet! Why bannest thou that which Allah hath made lawful for thee, seeking to please thy wives? And Allah is Forgiving, Merciful.
  • At-Tahrim 66:4 — If ye twain turn unto Allah repentant, (ye have cause to do so) for your hearts desired (the ban); and if ye aid one another against him (Muhammad) then lo! Allah, even He, is his Protecting Friend, and Gabriel and the righteous among the believers; and furthermore the angels are his helpers.

Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:03 Ifadah Center
0:06 for Humanities Studies and Research
0:09 presents
0:12 The Abridged Sahih al-Bukhari
0:17 Chapter: Taking Turns in Seeking Knowledge
0:21 Narrated by ‘Abdullah ibn ‘Abbas (may Allah be pleased with him):
0:26 I remained eager to ask ‘Umar (may Allah be pleased with him)
0:30 about the two women among the wives of the Prophet (peace be upon him)
0:35 regarding whom Allah said:
0:38 “If ye twain turn unto Allah repentant, (ye have cause to do so) for your hearts desired (the ban); and if ye aid one another against him (Muhammad) then lo! Allah, even He, is his Protecting Friend, and Gabriel and the righteous among the believers; and furthermore the angels are his helpers.” (66:4)
0:43 So, I performed Hajj with him.
0:45 He went aside, and I went with him, carrying a water skin.
0:48 He relieved himself and then returned.
0:51 I poured water from the skin over his hands.
0:54 He performed ablution.
0:56 I said,
0:57 "O Commander of the Faithful,
0:59 who are the two women among the wives of the Prophet (peace be upon him)
1:04 regarding whom Allah said:
1:06 “If ye twain turn unto Allah repentant, (ye have cause to do so) for your hearts desired (the ban); and if ye aid one another against him (Muhammad) then lo! Allah, even He, is his Protecting Friend, and Gabriel and the righteous among the believers; and furthermore the angels are his helpers.” (66:4)
1:09 He replied,
1:11 "I am amazed at you, O Ibn ‘Abbas!
1:14 They are ‘A’ishah and Hafsah."
1:16 Then ‘Umar began to relate the story.
1:20 He said,
1:21 "I and a neighbor of mine from the Ansar
1:24 lived in the tribe of Banu Umayyah ibn Zayd,
1:27 which is in the highlands of Madinah.
1:30 We used to take turns visiting the Prophet (peace be upon him);
1:35 he would go one day,
1:37 and I would go the next.
1:39 When I went,
1:40 I would bring him the news of that day regarding matters and other things,
1:45 and when he went, he would do the same.
1:48 We, the people of Quraysh, used to dominate our women.
1:52 But when we arrived among the Ansar,
1:55 we found them to be a people whose women dominated them.
1:59 Our women began to adopt the habits of the Ansar women.
2:04 I shouted at my wife,
2:06 and she retorted to me.
2:08 I disapproved of her retorting to me.
2:10 She said,
2:12 'Why do you disapprove of me retorting to you?
2:14 By Allah, the wives of the Prophet (peace be upon him) retort to him,
2:21 and one of them might even shun him for the day until nightfall.'
2:25 This alarmed me.
2:27 I said,
2:28 'Whoever does that among them is ruined and has committed a grave matter!'
2:32 Then I wrapped my garment around me
2:35 and went to Hafsah.
2:37 I said,
2:38 'O Hafsah,
2:40 does one of you really anger the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) for the day until nightfall?'
2:47 She said, 'Yes.'
2:49 I said,
2:50 'She is ruined and lost!
2:52 Do you feel secure that Allah will not be angry because of the anger of His Messenger (peace be upon him), and thus you perish?
3:00 Do not demand too much from the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him),
3:05 do not retort to him in any matter,
3:07 and do not shun him.
3:09 Ask me for whatever you need.
3:12 And do not let it deceive you that your neighbor is more beautiful than you
3:17 and more beloved to the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him),'
3:22 meaning ‘A’ishah.
3:24 We had been talking about the Ghassanids shoeing their horses to attack us.
3:30 My companion went down on his turn,
3:32 and he returned in the evening, knocking on my door violently.
3:37 He said,
3:39 'Is he sleeping?'
3:40 I was terrified,
3:42 and I went out to him.
3:43 He said,
3:45 'A grave matter has occurred.'
3:47 I asked, 'What is it?
3:49 Have the Ghassanids come?'
3:51 He said, 'No,
3:52 but something greater and more serious:
3:55 The Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) has divorced his wives.'
4:00 I said,
4:02 'Hafsah is ruined and lost!
4:05 I suspected that this was about to happen.'
4:08 I wrapped my garment around me
4:11 and prayed the dawn prayer with the Prophet (peace be upon him).
4:16 He then entered a loft of his
4:18 and withdrew into it.
4:20 I went to Hafsah,
4:22 and she was weeping.
4:25 I asked, 'Why are you weeping?
4:27 Did I not warn you?
4:30 Has the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) divorced you all?'
4:35 She said, 'I do not know.
4:37 He is there in the loft.'
4:39 I went out
4:40 and came to the pulpit,
4:42 where I found a group of people, some of whom were weeping.
4:46 I sat with them for a while,
4:49 but my distress overcame me.
4:51 I went to the loft where he was
4:54 and said to a black servant of his,
4:57 'Seek permission for ‘Umar.'
5:00 He entered,
5:01 spoke to the Prophet (peace be upon him),
5:05 and then came out and said,
5:07 'I mentioned you to him,
5:08 but he remained silent.'
5:10 So I left and sat with the group near the pulpit.
5:15 Then my distress overcame me again,
5:17 and I went
5:18 and mentioned the same.
5:20 I sat again with the group near the pulpit.
5:24 Then my distress overcame me again,
5:27 and I went to the servant
5:28 and said,
5:29 'Seek permission for ‘Umar.'
5:32 He mentioned the same.
5:34 As I was turning away to leave,
5:36 the servant called me.
5:38 He said,
5:40 'The Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) has given you permission.'
5:44 I entered upon him,
5:46 and he was lying on a mat of reeds,
5:50 with nothing between him and it.
5:53 The reeds had left marks on his side.
5:56 He was leaning on a leather pillow
5:59 stuffed with palm fibers.
6:01 I greeted him,
6:03 and then said while standing,
6:06 'Have you divorced your wives?'
6:08 He raised his eyes to me
6:11 and said, 'No.'
6:13 In another narration:
6:14 'No.'
6:15 'But I have sworn an oath to stay away from them for a month.'
6:19 And in another narration:
6:20 I said,
6:21 'Allahu Akbar!'
6:23 Then I said while standing,
6:26 'May I have your attention,
6:27 O Messenger of Allah?
6:29 If you could have seen me when we, the people of Quraysh,
6:32 used to dominate our women,
6:34 but then we arrived among a people whose women dominate them...'
6:38 and he mentioned the story.
6:40 The Prophet (peace be upon him) smiled.
6:44 Then I said,
6:46 'If you could have seen me when I entered upon Hafsah
6:49 and said,
6:50 "Do not let it deceive you that your neighbor is more beautiful than you and more beloved to the Prophet (peace be upon him),"'
6:58 meaning ‘A’ishah.
7:00 He smiled again.
7:03 I sat down when I saw him smile.
7:06 Then I raised my eyes in his room,
7:09 and by Allah, I saw nothing in it to catch the eye
7:13 except three hides.
7:16 I said,
7:17 'Supplicate to Allah to grant abundance to your Ummah,
7:21 for the Persians and the Romans have been granted abundance
7:24 and were given the world, even though they do not worship Allah.'
7:28 He was reclining,
7:30 and he said,
7:31 'Are you in doubt, O Ibn al-Khattab?
7:35 Those are a people whose good things were hastened for them in the life of this world.'
7:41 I said,
7:42 'O Messenger of Allah,
7:44 ask forgiveness for me.'
7:46 The Prophet (peace be upon him) had withdrawn because of that matter
7:52 when Hafsah disclosed it to ‘A’ishah.
7:55 He had said,
7:58 'I will not enter upon them for a month,'
8:01 due to the intensity of his displeasure with them
8:04 when Allah admonished him.
8:07 When twenty-nine days had passed,
8:09 he entered upon ‘A’ishah,
8:12 beginning with her.
8:14 ‘A’ishah said to him,
8:16 'You swore that you would not enter upon us for a month,
8:20 and we have reached the twenty-ninth night,
8:24 I have been counting them.'
8:26 The Prophet (peace be upon him) said,
8:30 'The month is twenty-nine days.'
8:32 And that month was indeed twenty-nine days.
8:36 ‘A’ishah said,
8:38 'Then the verse of choice was revealed.'
8:41 He began with me as the first wife,
8:43 and said,
8:45 'I am mentioning a matter to you,
8:48 and there is no harm if you do not rush
8:50 until you consult your parents.'
8:53 She said,
8:54 'I know that my parents would not command me to separate from you.'
8:59 Then he said,
9:01 'Allah said:
9:03 "O Prophet, say to your wives..."
9:07 up to His saying: "...a great reward."'
9:10 I said,
9:11 'Is it regarding this that I should consult my parents?
9:15 For I desire Allah, His Messenger, and the Home of the Hereafter.'
9:20 Then he gave his wives the choice,
9:22 and they said what ‘A’ishah had said.
9:27 Commentary on the hadith.
9:30 The chapter on alternating in the pursuit of knowledge.
9:33 "Naaba li" (He took my place).
9:34 Meaning: He stood in my stead.
9:36 The intended meaning:
9:37 This one takes a turn, and then that one takes a turn.
9:41 "Saghat" (Inclined).
9:42 Meaning: It leaned toward the truth and returned to it.
9:45 "Fa-'adala" (Then he deviated).
9:46 Meaning: He strayed from the path.
9:49 "Bil-idawah" (With the water skin).
9:50 Meaning: A small vessel made of leather.
9:53 Used for water.
9:55 "Fatabarraza" (He went to relieve himself).
9:56 Meaning: He fulfilled his need.
9:58 "Wa 'ajabi" (How strange!).
10:00 An expression of wonder at his eagerness to interpret the Book of Allah, the Almighty.
10:05 "Wa jaarun li" (And a neighbor of mine).
10:07 This is 'Utban Ibn Malik, may Allah be pleased with him.
10:11 "Awali al-Madinah" (The outskirts of Madinah).
10:12 Meaning: Villages near Madinah on the eastern side.
10:16 The closest of them to Madinah is two miles away or more.
10:20 And the furthest is eight miles.
10:22 "Natanaawabu" (We take turns).
10:24 Meaning: We alternate.
10:26 I take a turn, and he takes another.
10:29 Regarding worldly affairs and otherwise.
10:31 Meaning: Revelation and worldly matters.
10:33 "Naghlibu al-nisa'" (We dominate our women).
10:35 The intended meaning:
10:36 Harshness and severity in dealing with women.
10:40 This is blameworthy.
10:42 Because the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,
10:44 Adopted the way of the Ansar in his treatment of them,
10:47 And abandoned the way of his own people, the Quraysh.
10:50 "Fatafiqa nisa'una" (So our women began).
10:52 Meaning: They started doing that.
10:55 "Fa-ankartu an turaji'ani" (So I disapproved of her talking back to me).
10:57 Meaning: That she would argue with me in speech and reply.
11:00 And debate with me about it.
11:03 "Wa inna ihdahunna latuhjuruhu al-yawma hatta al-layl" (And one of them would indeed shun him for the day until night).
11:07 Meaning: For a full day.
11:09 "Fa-afza'ani" (So it alarmed me).
11:10 Meaning: It frightened me.
11:12 "Khabat man fa'ala minhunna bi-'azim" (Ruined is she who does something grave among them).
11:16 Meaning: She has lost.
11:17 Because she has committed a grave matter.
11:20 Which is angering the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him.
11:24 "Jama'tu 'alayya thiyabi" (I gathered my clothes upon me).
11:26 Meaning: I put them on.
11:28 "Ataghadabu?" (Do you get angry?).
11:30 An interrogative used for disapproval.
11:33 "Fatahliki" (Then you will perish).
11:35 Meaning: Due to the anger of Allah, the Almighty.
11:38 "La tastakthiri" (Do not ask for much).
11:40 Meaning: Do not demand many of your needs from him.
11:44 "Wa la tahjurihu" (And do not shun him).
11:45 Meaning: Do not shun the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him.
11:49 Even if he shuns you.
11:51 "Wa la yaghurrannaki" (And do not let it deceive you).
11:53 Meaning: Do not be deluded by that.
11:55 Because it is possible that you do not hold that status with him.
11:59 "Jaratuki" (Your neighbor).
12:01 Meaning: Your co-wife.
12:02 "Awda'u minki" (More radiant than you).
12:04 Meaning: More beautiful and better.
12:06 "Tan'alu al-ni'al lighazwina" (She shoes the horses for our raids).
12:09 Meaning: She makes the iron for the horses' hooves.
12:12 For the sake of our fighting.
12:14 "Yawma nawbatihi" (The day of his turn).
12:16 Meaning: The day of his scheduled visit.
12:18 "Faraja'a 'isha'" (So he returned at night).
12:20 Meaning: The late night prayer time.
12:22 Or after it.
12:24 "Fafazi'tu" (So I was terrified).
12:25 Meaning: I was afraid.
12:27 Nay, even greater and longer than that.
12:30 Meaning: Greater and longer in sorrow.
12:33 "Fadakhala mashrubatan lahu" (He entered a room of his).
12:35 "Al-mashrubah":
12:37 The upper room.
12:38 And "al-mashrubah" is also:
12:39 The storage room where his food and drink were kept.
12:44 "Raht" (A small group).
12:45 A collection of fewer than ten.
12:48 "Thumma ghalabani ma ajidu" (Then what I felt overcame me).
12:50 Meaning: From the preoccupation of his heart regarding what had reached him of the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, divorcing his wives.
12:57 Among whom was his daughter.
12:59 And in that was a hardship that is not hidden.
13:03 To a black servant of his.
13:06 His name was Rabah.
13:08 And it was the habit of the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,
13:11 That he had no doorkeeper.
13:13 It is possible that this one sat there.
13:16 So that people would not crowd him.
13:18 And he would inform them of his permission or refusal.
13:21 "Mudtaji'an 'ala rimal hasir" (Lying on the matting of a mat).
13:24 Meaning: Woven from matting.
13:27 "Qad aththara al-rimal bijanbihi" (The matting had left marks on his side).
13:30 Meaning: It had made lines on it.
13:33 " 'Ala wisadatin min adam" (On a pillow made of leather).
13:35 Meaning: On a cushion made of leather.
13:38 "Hashwuha lif" (Its stuffing was palm fiber).
13:40 "Al-lif" is what grows at the base of palm fronds.
13:44 Pillows and mattresses are stuffed with it.
13:47 And ropes are twisted from it.
13:50 "Ast'nisu" (I seek to find comfort/gauge the mood).
13:51 Meaning: I observe whether the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, will return to being pleased.
13:56 It is also said:
13:58 Do I speak freely and mention what I have?
14:01 And it is said:
14:03 Do I say something to cheer him up?
14:06 And remove his anger.
14:09 Then the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, smiled.
14:12 This is his nature.
14:14 For his laughter was a smile.
14:16 Out of honor for the one he smiles at.
14:19 "Rafa'tu basari fi baytihi" (I raised my gaze in his house).
14:22 Meaning: I looked around his house.
14:24 "Ghayra ihabati thalathah" (Except for three hides).
14:26 Meaning: Three leather skins.
14:28 "Al-ihab":
14:30 The hide before it is tanned.
14:33 "Aw fi shakkin anta ya Ibn al-Khattab?" (Are you in doubt, O Ibn al-Khattab?).
14:36 By way of rebuke and confirmation.
14:39 Meaning:
14:40 Are you in doubt that abundance in the Hereafter is better than abundance in this world?
14:47 "Istaghfir li" (Seek forgiveness for me).
14:48 A request for seeking forgiveness.
14:50 It was only because of his boldness in such speech.
14:53 In the presence of the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him.
14:57 And because he considered worldly adornments to be a grave matter.
15:01 The Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, withdrew.
15:04 Because of that hadith.
15:07 When Hafsah disclosed it to 'A'ishah.
15:10 His withdrawal was only because of the disclosure of that hadith.
15:15 There is a difference of opinion regarding what the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, forbade for himself.
15:20 And he was reproached for forbidding it.
15:22 Just as there is a difference regarding the reason for his oath.
15:25 Due to the intensity of his resentment toward them.
15:28 Meaning: Due to the intensity of his anger.
15:30 When Allah reproached him.
15:32 With the words of the Almighty:
15:34 “O Prophet! Why bannest thou that which Allah hath made lawful for thee, seeking to please thy wives? And Allah is Forgiving, Merciful.” (66:1)
15:40 Seeking the pleasure of your wives.
15:42 And Allah is Forgiving, Merciful.
15:45 The verse of choice (Takhayyur).
15:47 It is the saying of the Almighty:
15:49 "O Prophet, say to your wives..."
15:53 The verse.
15:55 From the benefits of the hadith:
15:59 It is derived from this hadith:
16:01 Eagerness to seek knowledge.
16:03 And the legitimacy of a noble man serving a ruler or a scholar.
16:08 And that there is no disgrace upon him in serving them.
16:11 And the legitimacy of alternating in the pursuit of knowledge among peers.
16:16 And the legitimacy of discussing knowledge in all circumstances.
16:19 While walking, on the roads, and in private.
16:23 And that it is upon the student of knowledge:
16:24 To look into his livelihood.
16:26 And to obtain what helps him in seeking knowledge.
16:30 And in the hadith also:
16:32 Acceptance of the report of a single narrator.
16:34 And that the Companions inform one another.
16:37 Of what they hear and attribute.
16:39 To the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him.
16:43 And this is the "Mursal" of the Companion.
16:45 And in it is the eagerness to track down the sources of knowledge in their proper places.
16:50 And in it is the permissibility of seeking assistance in wudu'.
16:54 And that it is customary for a person to keep some of his clothes in the house.
16:58 And when he goes out to the people, he puts them on.
17:01 And in it is the legitimacy of a man admonishing his married daughter.
17:06 And improving her character for her husband.
17:09 And in it is the permissibility of sadness and weeping for the affairs of the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him.
17:15 And showing concern for what concerns him.
17:18 And the permissibility of using upper rooms, rooftops, and the like.
17:22 As long as one does not look from them into the privacy of anyone.
17:25 And in it is the guidance toward the obligation of seeking permission for all people.
17:30 Whether the one being visited has family with him or not.
17:35 And the legitimacy of leaving without being dismissed by the one being visited.
17:40 And the permissibility of repeating the request for permission to the same person.
17:44 And that the ruler may grant permission to whom he wishes, remain silent, or dismiss whom he wishes.
17:50 And the permissibility of asking the ruler about his actions.
17:54 If that is something that concerns those who obey him.
17:58 And in it is the etiquette of approaching a ruler.
18:00 And seeking comfort in his presence through conversation.
18:03 And obtaining his permission to speak.
18:06 And the legitimacy of sitting before the ruler.
18:09 Even if he does not command it, if one feels comfortable enough to be informal.
18:14 In the hadith is an indication of the legitimacy of acting according to the Qur'an.
18:19 The Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, smiled at 'Umar, may Allah be pleased with him.
18:24 When he mentioned the dominance of the Quraysh women over their men.
18:27 And the control of the Ansar women over them.
18:30 A proof that both matters are not forbidden.
18:35 And in it is a description of the asceticism of the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him.
18:39 And his moderation in worldly life and his patience with that.
18:43 And that moderation in the world is to save one's good things for the Abode of Permanence.
18:49 It is a better state than hastening them in the fleeting world.
18:53 And the one who hastens for them is closer to foolishness.
18:56 This contains guidance on being content with Allah and His decree.
19:00 No one should be dissatisfied with their situation or what Allah has apportioned for them.
19:05 Nor should they belittle the blessings Allah has bestowed upon them or His prior decree.
19:10 For one fears the weakness of one's own soul.
19:13 It also contains guidance on the necessity of seeking forgiveness (istighfar).
19:16 And the legitimacy of requesting supplication and forgiveness from people of virtue and goodness.
19:22 It also indicates that it is permissible for a man to discipline his wife for disobeying his command.
19:28 The hadith mentions that a month may consist of twenty-nine days.
19:33 This follows the lunar phases that Allah the Almighty has established as timekeepers for people in their affairs.
19:41 It also indicates that when a man returns from a journey or a matter arises concerning his wives,
19:48 he may begin with whomever he wishes among them.
19:50 And he is not obligated to start from where he left off before his departure or the occurrence of the matter.
19:57 It also indicates that there is no harm in a sensible woman consulting her parents and those of sound judgment among her family,
20:03 regarding her own affairs and her wealth.
20:06 It also clarifies the virtue of the wives of the Prophet, may Allah be pleased with them.
20:11 And it clarifies the virtue of ‘Umar, may Allah be pleased with him.
20:17 Chapter: Anger during preaching and teaching when one sees something disliked.
20:23 On the authority of Abu Mas‘ud al-Ansari, who said:
20:26 A man came to the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,
20:31 and said: "O Messenger of Allah,
20:34 by Allah, I stay behind from the morning prayer
20:38 because of such-and-such person, due to how long he makes it for us."
20:43 He said: I never saw the Prophet, peace be upon him,
20:48 more angry in a sermon than he was on that day.
20:53 Then he said: "O people, among you are those who drive people away.
21:00 So whoever leads the people in prayer, let him be brief,
21:04 for among them are the elderly," and in one narration,
21:08 "the sick, the weak, and those with needs."
21:13 Commentary on the hadith:
21:17 Anger is an emotional reaction resulting from the boiling of the blood
21:21 due to something that has entered the heart.
21:23 "I stay behind from the morning prayer":
21:26 Meaning, I do not attend it in congregation because of the length.
21:31 "Among you": This was the habit of the Prophet, peace be upon him;
21:36 he would not single out the person deserving of rebuke and discipline,
21:41 so that the person would not be embarrassed.
21:44 "Drive people away": Meaning, you turn them away from the congregations.
21:48 "Let him be brief": Meaning, let him lighten the prayer.
21:52 From the benefits of the hadith:
21:56 The hadith permits mentioning a person when making a complaint,
22:00 and seeking redress against them.
22:02 And the permissibility of staying behind from the congregation for valid excuses.
22:06 And the necessity of brevity in congregational prayer,
22:09 while still completing the standing, bowing, and prostration.
22:12 It also contains kindness toward the weak,
22:15 and compassion for them in matters of the Hereafter,
22:18 and likewise in worldly matters.
22:24 On the authority of Zayd ibn Khalid al-Juhani,
22:26 that the Prophet, peace be upon him,
22:29 was asked by a man about lost property (luqta).
22:32 He said: "Learn its drawstring,"
22:36 or he said: "its container,"
22:38 "and its wrapping."
22:40 "Then announce it for a year,
22:42 then enjoy it."
22:45 In one narration:
22:46 "Otherwise, spend it."
22:49 And in one narration:
22:51 "Otherwise, mix it with your wealth,
22:54 and if its owner comes,
22:56 then return it to him."
22:58 He said:
22:59 "What about stray camels?"
23:01 He became angry until his cheeks turned red,
23:05 or he said:
23:06 "his face turned red,"
23:08 and he said:
23:10 "What have you to do with them?
23:12 They have their water-skin and their hooves;
23:15 they reach the water and graze on the trees.
23:18 So leave them until their owner finds them."
23:22 He said:
23:24 "What about stray sheep?"
23:26 He said:
23:27 "They are for you, or for your brother, or for the wolf."
23:31 Commentary on the hadith:
23:35 The luqta (lost property):
23:36 It is either lost wealth whose owner is unknown,
23:40 or an animal whose owner is unknown,
23:43 which is the stray (dallah).
23:45 "Its drawstring" (wikauha):
23:47 Meaning the string with which the pouch or similar item is tied.
23:51 "Its container" (wi‘auha):
23:53 Meaning the vessel for its food.
23:55 "Its wrapping" (‘ifasuha):
23:57 Meaning the container made of leather or otherwise.
24:01 "Their water-skin and their hooves":
24:03 A comparison to a traveler who has his shoes and water-skin,
24:08 for he is then strong enough to cross the deserts.
24:12 "For you, or for your brother, or for the wolf":
24:15 Everything whose financial value is feared to be lost to its owner,
24:19 it is permissible to pick it up.
24:21 From the benefits of the hadith:
24:25 One learns from the hadith
24:27 the permissibility of taking lost property.
24:29 And whether it is recommended or obligatory,
24:32 there is a difference of opinion.
24:34 The hadith also permits benefiting from the lost property after announcing it.
24:39 On the authority of Abu Musa, who said:
24:44 The Prophet, peace be upon him, was asked about things he disliked.
24:50 When they persisted in questioning him,
24:52 he became angry.
24:53 Then he said to the people:
24:55 "Ask me whatever you wish."
24:58 A man said:
25:00 "Who is my father?"
25:01 He said:
25:02 "Your father is Hudhafah."
25:05 Another stood up and said:
25:07 "Who is my father, O Messenger of Allah?"
25:10 He said:
25:11 "Your father is Salim,
25:13 the freed slave of Shaybah."
25:15 When ‘Umar saw what was on his face,
25:18 he said:
25:19 "O Messenger of Allah,
25:21 we repent to Allah the Almighty."
25:26 Commentary on the hadith:
25:30 "He disliked it":
25:31 Because it might have been a cause for something to be forbidden to the Muslims,
25:36 or perhaps the answer might have been something that displeased the questioner,
25:40 or perhaps they burdened him, peace be upon him,
25:44 and caused him hardship and harm,
25:47 which would be a cause for their destruction.
25:51 "What was on his face":
25:52 Meaning, the traces of anger.
25:55 From the benefits of the hadith:
25:59 One learns from the hadith
26:01 that one is forbidden from excessive questioning out of affectation and stubbornness.
26:05 And the clarification of the virtue of ‘Umar, may Allah be pleased with him.
26:08 And not to ask the scholar except about what is necessary.
26:16 Chapter: Sitting on one's knees before an Imam or a teacher.
26:21 On the authority of Anas ibn Malik, may Allah be pleased with him,
26:25 that the Prophet, peace be upon him,
26:28 went out when the sun had passed its zenith,
26:31 and prayed the Dhuhr prayer.
26:33 When he finished the salutation,
26:34 he stood on the pulpit.
26:37 In one narration:
26:38 He said:
26:40 "If you knew what I know,
26:42 you would laugh little,
26:44 and weep much."
26:47 He mentioned the Hour,
26:49 and mentioned that before it are momentous events.
26:53 Then he said:
26:55 "Whoever wishes to ask about anything,
26:58 let him ask about it.
27:00 By Allah, you will not ask me about anything
27:03 but I will inform you of it,
27:05 as long as I am in this place of mine."
27:08 Anas said:
27:10 The people wept profusely,
27:12 and the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, kept saying:
27:18 "Ask me."
27:19 Anas said:
27:21 A man stood up to him and said:
27:24 "Where is my entrance, O Messenger of Allah?"
27:27 He said:
27:28 "The Fire."
27:30 Then ‘Abdullah ibn Hudhafah stood up and said:
27:34 "Who is my father, O Messenger of Allah?"
27:37 He said:
27:38 "Your father is Hudhafah."
27:40 He said:
27:41 Then he kept saying:
27:44 "Ask me, ask me."
27:46 So ‘Umar knelt on his knees and said:
27:50 "We are pleased with Allah as Lord,
27:52 with Islam as religion,
27:55 and with Muhammad, peace be upon him, as Messenger."
28:00 In one narration:
28:02 "We seek refuge in Allah from trials."
28:05 He said:
28:06 The Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, fell silent
28:10 when ‘Umar said that.
28:12 In one narration:
28:14 He gestured with his hands toward the qiblah of the mosque.
28:18 Then the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, said:
28:23 "By Him in whose hand is my soul,
28:25 Paradise and Hell were presented to me just now,
28:29 in the direction of this wall,
28:32 while I was praying.
28:34 I have not seen the like of today in terms of good and evil."
28:38 In one narration:
28:40 And there was revealed:
28:41 “O ye who believe! Ask not of things which, if they were made unto you, would trouble you; but if ye ask of them when the Qur'an is being revealed, they will be made known unto you. Allah pardoneth this, for Allah is Forgiving, Clement.” (5:101)
28:47 the verse.
28:49 Commentary on the hadith:
28:53 "The sun had passed its zenith":
28:54 Meaning, it inclined and moved away.
28:57 "Before it are momentous events":
29:00 The momentous events
29:02 are the signs of the Hour,
29:03 such as the appearance of the Dajjal.
29:06 "By Allah, you will not ask me about anything
29:08 but I will inform you of it":
29:11 It reached him, peace be upon him, that a group of hypocrites were asking him
29:17 and trying to incapacitate him with some of what they asked.
29:20 He became enraged and spoke his piece.
29:23 The people wept profusely,
29:26 when they heard of the momentous and terrifying matters that lay before them.
29:31 It has been said,
29:32 they wept for fear that the punishment would descend upon them.
29:36 "Where is my place of entry, O Messenger of Allah?"
29:38 He replied, "The Fire."
29:40 The explanation for this is that he was a hypocrite,
29:44 or that the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, knew the wretchedness of his final state.
29:49 Then he repeatedly said, "Ask me, ask me."
29:53 The Prophet’s, peace be upon him, insistence on being asked questions,
29:58 was done out of a sense of anger.
30:01 "Paradise and Hell were presented to me,"
30:04 meaning they were depicted for me and I saw them,
30:08 just now,
30:10 that is, at this very moment,
30:12 in the direction of this wall,
30:14 meaning its side,
30:15 though it is also said its center.
30:17 "I have not seen the like of today in terms of good and evil,"
30:21 meaning I have never witnessed such good,
30:24 which is Paradise,
30:26 and such evil,
30:27 which is the Fire.
30:30 Among the benefits of the hadith:
30:34 The scholars are in consensus that the time for the Dhuhr prayer begins when the sun passes its zenith.
30:39 The hadith indicates the dislike of excessive questioning out of obstinacy or affectation.
30:44 It provides guidance on the necessity of maintaining proper etiquette with a scholar,
30:47 and refraining from pestering them with questions.
30:50 The hadith also demonstrates the reverence the Companions, may Allah be pleased with them, held
30:54 for the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him.
30:58 Furthermore, the hadith
30:59 serves as evidence of the tenderness of the hearts of the Companions, may Allah be pleased with them.
31:05 It also highlights the virtue of 'Umar, may Allah be pleased with him,
31:08 and the sharpness of his understanding.
31:09 This hadith contains evidence that Allah the Exalted
31:13 intended to exonerate 'Abdullah ibn Hudhafah from any aspersions cast upon his lineage.
31:18 The hadith also indicates
31:20 that Paradise and Hell are already created and in existence.