Part of Women's Suffering (series completed) · Lesson 16 of 18

The suffering of women in the time of Moses, peace be upon him | Episode (16) | Women and hard work outside the home

◉ 104 views ⏱ 10:14 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson timeline

  1. 00:00 The two women go out to herd sheep out of necessity
  2. 01:03 Human nature and women's inclination to stay home
  3. 02:07 The reality and hardship of Western women
  4. 04:09 Women's natural weakness in light of the hadith
  5. 05:09 The burdens of women working outside the home and their effect on the family
  6. 07:12 The Sharia guidelines for women's work
  7. 09:14 Artistic career versus family life for women

Lesson summary

This episode of the series on women's suffering examines how the two daughters of the righteous man went out to herd sheep out of necessity, since there was no man to do it, not out of a desire to work outside the home. The sheikh cites one daughter's advice to her father to hire the strong and trustworthy, as evidence that they preferred to stay home. He explains that sound human nature inclines women to remain at home, and notes that the Prophet ﷺ described women as weak. He then critiques the hardship and degradation women faced in the West, and presents the Islamic guidelines for women's work outside the home.

Key takeaways

  • The two women went out to herd sheep out of necessity, because their father was an elderly man who could not do it and there was no one else.
  • One daughter's suggestion to her father to hire the strong and trustworthy shows that they would rather have stayed at home.
  • Sound human nature inclines women to stay at home and they do not feel constrained by it, a tendency visible from childhood.
  • Women are weak by nature, as the Prophet ﷺ described them, so treating them like men and assigning them heavy labour is unjust.
  • The hardship and degradation of Western women is presented as a lesson, and the speaker cites a Western observer who acknowledged it.
  • Islam did not forbid women from working, but set conditions such as permissible work, avoiding mixing with men, and not harming the husband, children or religion.
  • Success and fame cannot compensate a woman for the absence of family life, as admitted by an American actress as quoted in the lesson.

Questions & answers

Why did the two daughters of the righteous man go out to herd sheep?

They went out out of necessity, because there was no man to herd on behalf of them, as their father was an elderly man unable to do it, not out of a desire to work outside the home.

What is the evidence that women naturally prefer to stay at home?

The sheikh cites one daughter's advice to her father to hire the strong and trustworthy at the first opportunity, and the fact that girls do not feel restless staying at home as boys often do.

Does Islam forbid women from working outside the home?

Islam does not forbid women's work, but it sets conditions. If a woman meets them, she may work; if she violates them, the work becomes forbidden or harmful to her. Key conditions include permissible work, avoiding mixing with men, and not compromising her religion.

What are the Islamic guidelines for women's work according to this lesson?

They include that the work must be permissible, that the woman observes the rules of going out, that she does not compete with men, that it does not neglect her husband and children, that it does not expose her to immoral company or harm, that it does not ruin her religion, and that it does not erase her femininity.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Qur’an verses cited in this lesson

  • Al-Qasas 28:26 — One of the two women said: O my father! Hire him! For the best (man) that thou canst hire in the strong, the trustworthy.

Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 The story of woman's struggle in the time of Moses, peace be upon him.
0:06 Women and arduous labor outside the home.
0:14 The two young women left their home to pasture the sheep out of sheer necessity,
0:21 because there was no man to carry out this task on their behalf.
0:26 For their father, as they described him, was an old man incapable of enduring the strenuous toil of shepherding.
0:33 Thus, there was no alternative to them going out.
0:35 She went out out of compulsion to shepherd, not out of any love for working outside the home.
0:40 The proof of this is that at the very first opportunity of an alternative being present,
0:45 one of them stepped forward to advise her father, saying:
0:50 “One of the two women said: O my father! Hire him! For the best (man) that thou canst hire in the strong, the trustworthy.” (28:26)
0:56 If they had loved working outside the home,
0:59 she would not have presented this proposal to her father.
1:03 Ibn Kathir, may Allah have mercy on him, said:
1:06 "She said to her father, 'O my father, hire him,'
1:09 meaning, to tend these sheep."
1:11 Another proof is their sound innate disposition.
1:16 For a woman naturally inclines toward remaining in the home,
1:20 and her soul is not constrained by doing so.
1:22 This can be observed in her from early childhood:
1:26 a male child's desire to go outside the house
1:29 and play outdoors is far greater than a female child's desire.
1:33 When a girl is instructed to stay inside the house and not go out,
1:39 she does not become disgruntled by that,
1:41 unlike a boy, whose chest tightens at the prospect of remaining indoors.
1:46 Indeed, the call for women to leave their homes
1:50 and renounce their innate disposition
1:52 first emerged in the West.
1:55 Among the motives behind this were:
1:58 man's abdication of his responsibilities toward woman,
2:02 and the desire of the dissolute among them to exploit woman for gratification in every sphere.
2:07 So what has this call produced?
2:10 It has produced a painful reality regarding which no rational person disagrees.
2:15 Dr. Al-Siba'i, may Allah have mercy on him, says:
2:19 "All Easterners who have visited the West agree,
2:23 especially Arab Muslims,
2:25 that the woman there has come to be in a painful, unenviable plight.
2:30 I have visited Europe four times,
2:33 and I was never pained by anything there as much as I was pained by the misery of the Western woman,
2:39 her degradation for the sake of earning a living,
2:42 or her desire to be exactly like a man.
2:46 The Western man has managed to exploit woman's vulnerability in this regard,
2:53 subjugating her to the utmost degree for his material gains and sexual desires.
3:00 It has become clear to me after all I have seen
3:03 that the Muslim woman, in her present state,
3:07 is in a happier condition and a more honored station than the Western woman.
3:12 It is therefore no surprise after this to hear and read of Western women calling
3:19 for woman's return to her home,
3:22 devoting herself to her children and husband,
3:25 so that she may find her true self."
3:28 In this proposal put forward by one of the two women lies
3:31 a third proof of their desire to settle at home
3:35 and relinquish the work of shepherding,
3:38 due to its incompatibility with their innate disposition and physical nature.
3:43 This is found in her saying:
3:45 “One of the two women said: O my father! Hire him! For the best (man) that thou canst hire in the strong, the trustworthy.” (28:26)
3:49 Al-Sa'di, may Allah have mercy on him, said:
3:52 "Meaning, Moses is the most deserving person to be hired,
3:55 for he has combined strength and trustworthiness.
3:58 And the best employee one can hire is he who combines the two:
4:02 namely, strength and capacity for what he is hired to do,
4:06 and trustworthiness therein by not betraying the trust."
4:09 The intended meaning here is strength,
4:14 which was lacking in the elderly father,
4:17 and which prompted the daughter to make this proposal to her father,
4:22 because it is generally absent in women.
4:25 For woman is inherently physically weak,
4:28 as evidenced by the saying of the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him:
4:32 "O Allah, I declare inviolable the rights of the two weak ones:
4:36 the orphan and the woman."
4:38 Narrated by Ibn Majah.
4:40 Thus, the Prophet (peace be upon him) counted her as weak
4:44 and grouped her with the orphan under the same attribute,
4:47 which is the attribute of weakness.
4:49 Since woman is inherently weak,
4:53 it is an injustice to treat her in the same manner as man
4:57 and assign her arduous male tasks
5:00 in implementation of the CEDAW convention articles.
5:04 Among the manifestations of this are:
5:06 the working hours imposed upon women
5:09 and the early start of the workday,
5:11 neither of which suits woman's physical nature and constitution,
5:15 nor the primary duty assigned to her—
5:18 namely, caring for the family,
5:20 including motherhood, child-rearing,
5:23 and attending to her husband and household.
5:26 Thus, we find the working woman waking before dawn
5:29 to prepare herself to go out to work,
5:32 standing in public queues
5:35 waiting for public transportation,
5:38 crowding alongside men in alarming congestion
5:43 to reach her workplace on time.
5:46 She then gives the best of her energy and cheerful demeanor during the work period,
5:52 which typically lasts eight continuous hours,
5:56 only to return once again to the whirlwind of waiting for crowded transit,
6:02 arriving home exhausted and spent.
6:06 She then collapses onto her bed to snatch a bit of rest,
6:11 or plunges into the domestic chores waiting for her at home,
6:15 adding further burdens to this exhausted body.
6:19 What, then, can be expected from such a working woman
6:23 in terms of offering her children love, tenderness, and a smile
6:28 before they leave the home for school?
6:31 What can we expect her to provide them in terms of a warm welcome,
6:36 wholesome food, and a comfortable home when they return
6:40 after the fatigue of a school day that paid no regard to their innocent childhood?
6:46 What can we expect her to contribute to her marital life
6:50 in terms of caring for a husband who seeks a tranquil sanctuary away from the hardships of the world?
6:59 Indeed, Islam did not forbid women from working,
7:02 but it established regulatory conditions for it.
7:05 Whoever fulfills these conditions is permitted to work,
7:09 while whoever violates these conditions
7:12 places her employment within the realm of the forbidden,
7:15 or within the realm of misfortune upon the woman herself.
7:18 First among these conditions is
7:21 that the work itself be permissible.
7:24 Singing and dancing are forbidden professions;
7:27 hair extensions and eyebrow plucking are forbidden acts;
7:31 and prostitution is a forbidden trade.
7:34 Second, that the woman adhere to the Islamic guidelines regarding leaving the house,
7:41 such as not going out wearing perfume or displaying her beauty inappropriately.
7:45 Third, that she does not mix freely with men;
7:49 thus, women are not permitted to work in gender-mixed environments,
7:54 because it causes them to fall into numerous religious transgressions,
7:59 including compromising modesty in dress,
8:03 breaking down the barrier of bashfulness between them and men,
8:07 compromising her chastity, and inciting men's desires, among other harms.
8:14 Fourth, that her employment does not lead to neglecting her husband's rights,
8:19 the neglect of her children, or falling short in household care.
8:24 Fifth, that her work does not lead her to associate with corrupt companions,
8:30 for a companion exerts a pull.
8:32 Sixth, that the work does not cause harm to her,
8:37 for the hadith states: "There shall be no harm nor reciprocating harm."
8:41 Narrated by Ibn Majah.
8:43 Seventh, that the work does not lead to the loss of her religious practice,
8:49 which is among the most paramount conditions.
8:52 Eighth, that the work does not extinguish her feminine nature,
8:57 alongside other religious guidelines regarding women's employment.
9:02 Consider this late admission by the American actress
9:07 Barbra Streisand in her recent press article,
9:12 where she said:
9:14 "I have begun to realize that I am missing many things.
9:19 I cared far too much about my artistic career
9:23 and forgot my life as a woman and a human being,
9:27 which today makes me envy women who have enough time
9:32 to take care of their husbands and children.
9:36 In truth,
9:37 success and fame are meaningless in the absence of a normal family life
9:43 wherein a woman feels she is truly a woman."
9:47 Have you then recognized the blessing of remaining settled at home
9:50 like a queen cared for by a man
9:53 who toils outside the home for her sake?
9:57 We shall continue in a future gathering, Allah willing.
10:02 Praise be to Allah, Lord of the worlds.
10:05 The story of woman's struggle in the time of Moses, peace be upon him.