Summary of Sunni concepts | 28- Concepts about achieving interest and legitimate objectives | Concepts (397-407)

◉ 70 views ⏱ 7:00 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

The lesson explains that the rulings of the Sharia, whether obligatory, recommended, permissible, forbidden or disliked, were all legislated for the benefit of humanity in this life and the next. The sheikh explains that benefits in the scale of the Sharia are of three kinds: recognized, nullified and unrestricted (mursala). He then covers the conditions for relying on unrestricted benefit, its difference from innovation (bid'ah), and how conflicting benefits and harms are weighed according to set rules. He concludes that the objectives of the Sharia are derived from the texts and do not override them, and that setting objectives above the texts is the path of those who deviate.

Key takeaways

  • The rulings of the Sharia, from obligatory and recommended to permissible, forbidden and disliked, were all legislated for human benefit in this life and the next.
  • Recognized benefits are those the Sharia has affirmed with a specific proof and prescribed a ruling to achieve, such as protecting life through retaliation (qisas), protecting property through cutting the thief's hand, and protecting the intellect through the prohibition of wine.
  • Nullified benefits are those the Sharia has rejected, such as gaining wealth through riba or gambling, and the supposed benefit of banning polygamy, which the Sharia disregarded in favour of a higher benefit.
  • Unrestricted benefits have no specific text affirming or nullifying them, but they have a fitting meaning and fall under the general principles of the Sharia, such as the compilation of the Quran and the recording of the sciences.
  • Unrestricted benefit applies only where the meaning can be understood, not to pure acts of worship such as the number of prayer units or the details of ablution; this is a key difference from innovation.
  • When benefits conflict, what is certain takes precedence over what is probable, the general over the particular, and the greater over the lesser, and preventing harm takes precedence over securing benefit.
  • The objectives of the Sharia are derived from the texts, which are the foundation, so no text can truly conflict with a general objective of the Sharia.

Questions & answers

What are the types of benefit in the scale of the Sharia?

The sheikh explains there are three: recognized benefits affirmed by the Sharia, nullified benefits rejected by the Sharia, and unrestricted benefits for which no specific text exists either way.

What is the difference between unrestricted benefit and innovation?

The sheikh explains that unrestricted benefit applies only where the meaning can be understood, whereas innovation occurs in purely devotional acts of worship or in creed, which are firm fixed principles.

What are the conditions for relying on unrestricted benefit?

It must not be contradicted by a legal text, consensus or analogy, and it must not forfeit a higher benefit.

How are conflicting benefits weighed?

Certain benefit is preferred over probable benefit; if these are equal, the general benefit is preferred over the particular; if equal in both certainty and generality, the greater benefit is preferred over the lesser.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 A summary of the concepts of the Ahl al-Sunnah.
0:09 Wherever the law of Allah is found, there lies the true interest.
0:13 Whatever Allah, the Almighty and Majestic, has legislated in His Book and upon the tongue of His Messenger, peace be upon him,
0:21 whether it be obligatory or recommended acts,
0:24 or permissible, prohibited, or disliked acts,
0:28 He, the Glorified, legislated them only for the benefit of humanity and their welfare in this world and the Hereafter.
0:35 Thus, wherever the law of Allah is found, there lies the true interest.
0:40 Interests in the balance of the Sharia.
0:45 Interests in the balance of the Sharia are of three types:
0:50 Recognized, nullified, and unrestricted (masalih mursala).
0:54 Recognized interests:
0:59 These are interests that the Sharia has attested to by accepting and validating them through specific evidence.
1:05 It has legislated a ruling to realize them.
1:08 These are interests that cannot be rejected,
1:12 and there is no disagreement regarding the legitimacy of adopting and implementing them.
1:16 Examples of this include:
1:18 The interest of preserving life,
1:20 for which the ruling of retaliation (qisas) was legislated.
1:23 The interest of preserving wealth,
1:26 for which the cutting of the thief's hand was legislated.
1:29 The interest of preserving the intellect,
1:31 for which the prohibition of intoxicants was legislated.
1:34 And so on, to the end of such examples.
1:38 Nullified interests:
1:44 These are interests that the Sharia has attested to by invalidating and rejecting them.
1:48 Examples of this include:
1:50 The interest of earning wealth through usury (riba), gambling, or games of chance.
1:55 The Sharia has invalidated these by prohibiting both usury and gambling.
2:00 Likewise, the perceived interest in banning polygamy
2:05 due to the expected harm arising from problems and jealousy between a woman and her co-wife.
2:11 The Sharia has disregarded this interest and did not consider it,
2:15 in order to realize a higher interest,
2:18 which is the increase of offspring, the facilitation of chastity,
2:22 and the protection of the soul.
2:24 Unrestricted interests (masalih mursala):
2:28 These are interests for which no specific evidence has come in the Sharia to either validate or nullify them.
2:34 They are "unrestricted" from the constraint of being explicitly recognized or nullified.
2:38 However, they contain a meaning suitable for a ruling to be legislated for them.
2:43 Furthermore, they fall under the general principles of the Sharia
2:47 regarding the consideration of interests and the warding off of harms.
2:51 Examples of this include:
2:53 The compilation of the Qur'an, the establishment of administrative registers, and the codification of sciences,
2:58 such as the Arabic linguistic sciences, the principles of fiqh, and the science of hadith terminology.
3:03 And other such interests that no rational person would doubt are in harmony with the Sharia.
3:12 Among the conditions for adopting an unrestricted interest:
3:19 That it does not contradict a Sharia proof from a text, consensus (ijma'), or analogy (qiyas).
3:25 And that adopting it does not result in the loss of a higher interest.
3:30 The difference between unrestricted interest and innovation (bid'ah):
3:36 Unrestricted interests only apply to matters where the meaning is rationally understood.
3:43 They have no place in purely devotional acts (ta'abbudat),
3:46 for which no specific rational meaning is sought.
3:51 Such as the details of ablution, the number of units in prayer, and the specification of fasting to a particular time,
3:58 or the standing at the sites of Hajj, and so on.
4:03 This is one of the most important distinctions between unrestricted interests
4:07 and the innovation that occurs in acts of worship based on pure devotion,
4:13 or in matters of creed, as these are fixed and established foundations.
4:18 The ruling on agreeing upon an unrestricted interest:
4:23 If the scholars or specialists reach a consensus on an unrestricted interest,
4:29 it is not permissible to act contrary to it.
4:32 If consensus is not reached, the one in charge acts upon the opinion of the majority of scholars.
4:38 The overlapping of interests and harms:
4:43 Interests and harms are rarely pure and isolated.
4:48 Rather, the norm is their intermingling or competition.
4:52 In such cases, the Muslim acts according to the general rules regarding this,
4:57 such as: warding off harm takes precedence over bringing about benefit,
5:01 prioritizing the higher of two interests over the lower,
5:05 and committing the lesser of two evils.
5:08 The competition of interests:
5:12 Prioritizing one interest over another when they compete
5:16 is done according to the following criteria:
5:19 First: Prioritizing an interest that is certain over one that is merely speculative.
5:27 Second: If the two interests are equal in their certainty,
5:33 the public interest is prioritized over the private.
5:37 Third: If the two interests are equal in their realization and general benefit,
5:43 the greater interest is prioritized over the lesser.
5:48 The objectives of legislation are derived from the texts of the Sharia, not rulers over them.
5:56 The general objectives of legislation are only known through examining the texts of the Sharia and its interpretive rulings.
6:05 By deriving the objectives from them, the texts are the foundation, and the objectives are the branches derived from them.
6:13 Therefore, it is impossible for any text or interpretive Sharia ruling to contradict a general objective of the legislation.
6:24 Such claims are only made by people of deviation and desire; when they were unable to confront the texts, they resorted to reinterpreting them
6:32 according to their misguided understanding of the general objectives of Islam.
6:37 They call this adopting the "purposive" (maqasidi) understanding of Islam instead of the "textual" understanding.
6:44 Examples of this include their claim that usury was only prohibited because of injustice,
6:50 so any form of it that does not lead to injustice is permissible—we seek refuge in Allah from deviation and misguidance.