budoorzahera launched in 2026 to carry the light of knowledge to every heart, in every language. Every lesson is available in the original audio with a full synced transcript, translated into fifteen other languages, with translated-audio listening available for a number of them.
You can copy any line of the transcript while listening, download the full text in multiple formats (TXT · SRT · VTT), or share a lesson with someone you care about in one tap. We ask God to make this work beneficial.
4192audio lessons
59complete series
16world languages
Error log
An automatic log of the most recent errors the app ran into on your device — copying and sending it to us helps a lot when troubleshooting a problem.
This lesson addresses a number of pitfalls in seeking and carrying knowledge. The sheikh explains that some knowledge can harm its possessor, and that beneficial knowledge only benefits when it is combined with piety and freedom from personal desires. He warns against concealing the truth or mixing it with falsehood, against pretension to knowledge and issuing fatwas before being qualified, and against blind imitation and harmful argumentation. The lesson concludes by distinguishing matters of legitimate scholarly difference from matters of ijtihad, and by refuting the claim that the religion is divided into husks and kernels, stressing commitment to all of Islam.
Key takeaways
Some knowledge can harm its possessor when it does not prevent him from following his desires; knowledge that does not lead to the truth does not benefit.
A scholar's arrogance about his knowledge stems from his ignorance of himself and of Allah, since his knowledge is a gift from Allah and is little compared to Allah's knowledge.
Concealing the truth or mixing it with falsehood is among the greatest injustices, whether out of love of worldly gain or fear of harm; temporary silence may be permitted when one is unable to speak and hopes someone else will speak out.
Pretension to knowledge and the premature issuing of fatwas by young people is a serious affliction, and its main cause is the scholars' neglect of their duty.
There is a clear difference between legitimate scholarly disagreement and matters of ijtihad; not every disagreement justifies acting on it, and the Qur'an and Sunnah are the proof.
The claim that the religion is divided into husks and kernels is a false claim; the whole religion is firm and legislated by the All-Knowing, and must be followed in full.
Blind imitation and fanatical attachment to the opinions of men lead to division and distance the Ummah from the evidence.
Questions & answers
Is all knowledge beneficial to its possessor?
Not all knowledge is beneficial; some knowledge can harm people and even the learner himself. Beneficial knowledge is that which prevents its possessor from following the desires of Allah's enemies and leads him to the truth.
What is the ruling on concealing the truth when it is needed?
Concealing the truth and mixing it with falsehood is among the greatest injustices and is not permitted out of love of worldly gain. Silence out of fear of severe harm may be permitted, and the matter ultimately depends on fearing Allah and averting harm as far as possible.
Is it permissible to follow a scholar even if he contradicts the evidence?
Lay people following a trusted scholar is permissible, but blindly following one who contradicts the evidence is fanatical imitation of men, which is blameworthy. The established Sunnah of the Prophet ﷺ is not to be abandoned for anyone's opinion.
What is the difference between matters of disagreement and matters of ijtihad?
Matters of ijtihad are those without a clear, binding text. A disagreement that contradicts an explicit text of the Qur'an or Sunnah is an anomalous, rejected view, and it is not a valid excuse to abandon rejecting an evident wrong.
Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.
Qur’an verses cited in this lesson
Al-Baqarah 2:102 — And follow that which the devils falsely related against the kingdom of Solomon. Solomon disbelieved not; but the devils disbelieved, teaching mankind magic and that which was revealed to the two angels in Babel, Harut and Marut. Nor did they (the two angels) teach it to anyone till they had said: We are only a temptation, therefore disbelieve not (in the guidance of Allah). And from these two (angles) people learn that by which they cause division between man and wife; but they injure thereby no-one save by Allah's leave. And they learn that which harmeth them and profiteth them not. And surely they do know that he who trafficketh therein will have no (happy) portion in the Hereafter; and surely evil is the price for which they sell their souls, if they but knew.
Al-Baqarah 2:120 — And the Jews will not be pleased with thee, nor will the Christians, till thou follow their creed. Say: Lo! the guidance of Allah (Himself) is Guidance. And if thou shouldst follow their desires after the knowledge which hath come unto thee, then wouldst thou have from Allah no protecting guardian nor helper.
Al-Baqarah 2:159 — Lo! Those who hide the proofs and the guidance which We revealed, after We had made it clear to mankind in the Scripture: such are accursed of Allah and accursed of those who have the power to curse.
Ali 'Imran 3:28 — Let not the believers take disbelievers for their friends in preference to believers. Whoso doeth that hath no connection with Allah unless (it be) that ye but guard yourselves against them, taking (as it were) security. Allah biddeth you beware (only) of Himself. Unto Allah is the journeying.
Al-A'raf 7:163 — Ask them (O Muhammad) of the township that was by the sea, how they did break the Sabbath, how their big fish came unto them visibly upon their Sabbath day and on a day when they did not keep Sabbath came they not unto them. Thus did We try them for that they were evil-livers.
Al-A'raf 7:166 — So when they took pride in that which they had been forbidden, We said unto them: Be ye apes despised and loathed!
Al-A'raf 7:169 — And a generation hath succeeded them who inherited the scriptures. They grasp the goods of this low life (as the price of evil-doing) and say: It will be forgiven us. And if there came to them (again) the offer of the like, they would accept it (and would sin again). Hath not the covenant of the Scripture been taken on their behalf that they should not speak aught concerning Allah save the truth? And they have studied that which is therein. And the abode of the Hereafter is better, for those who ward off (evil). Have ye then no sense?
Yusuf 12:79 — He said: Allah forbid that we should seize save him with whom we found our property; then truly we should be wrong-doers.
Al-Isra 17:36 — (O man), follow not that whereof thou hast no knowledge. Lo! the hearing and the sight and the heart - of each of these it will be asked.
Al-Isra 17:85 — They are asking thee concerning the Spirit. Say: The Spirit is by command of my Lord, and of knowledge ye have been vouchsafed but little.
Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.
Transcript
Machine translation — may contain errors
0:01A summary of the concepts held by the Ahl al-Sunnah.
0:09Harmful knowledge.
0:12Some knowledge is harmful to people.
0:15Indeed, it is even harmful to the learner himself.
0:18It may even constitute disbelief, as Allah the Almighty said:
0:22"But the devils disbelieved,"
0:25"teaching people magic."
0:27“And follow that which the devils falsely related against the kingdom of Solomon. Solomon disbelieved not; but the devils disbelieved, teaching mankind magic and that which was revealed to the two angels in Babel, Harut and Marut. Nor did they (the two angels) teach it to anyone till they had said: We are only a temptation, therefore disbelieve not (in the guidance of Allah). And from these two (angles) people learn that by which they cause division between man and wife; but they injure thereby no-one save by Allah's leave. And they learn that which harmeth them and profiteth them not. And surely they do know that he who trafficketh therein will have no (happy) portion in the Hereafter; and surely evil is the price for which they sell their souls, if they but knew.” (2:102)
0:29"And what was revealed to the two angels at Babylon, Harut and Marut."
0:32“And follow that which the devils falsely related against the kingdom of Solomon. Solomon disbelieved not; but the devils disbelieved, teaching mankind magic and that which was revealed to the two angels in Babel, Harut and Marut. Nor did they (the two angels) teach it to anyone till they had said: We are only a temptation, therefore disbelieve not (in the guidance of Allah). And from these two (angles) people learn that by which they cause division between man and wife; but they injure thereby no-one save by Allah's leave. And they learn that which harmeth them and profiteth them not. And surely they do know that he who trafficketh therein will have no (happy) portion in the Hereafter; and surely evil is the price for which they sell their souls, if they but knew.” (2:102)
0:34"But they do not teach anyone unless they say, 'We are a trial,"
0:37"'so do not disbelieve.'"
0:39"And [yet] they learn from them"
0:41"that by which they cause separation"
0:43"between a man and his wife."
0:45“And follow that which the devils falsely related against the kingdom of Solomon. Solomon disbelieved not; but the devils disbelieved, teaching mankind magic and that which was revealed to the two angels in Babel, Harut and Marut. Nor did they (the two angels) teach it to anyone till they had said: We are only a temptation, therefore disbelieve not (in the guidance of Allah). And from these two (angles) people learn that by which they cause division between man and wife; but they injure thereby no-one save by Allah's leave. And they learn that which harmeth them and profiteth them not. And surely they do know that he who trafficketh therein will have no (happy) portion in the Hereafter; and surely evil is the price for which they sell their souls, if they but knew.” (2:102)
0:49"Except by permission of Allah."
0:51"And they learn what harms them"
0:54"and does not benefit them."
0:56“And follow that which the devils falsely related against the kingdom of Solomon. Solomon disbelieved not; but the devils disbelieved, teaching mankind magic and that which was revealed to the two angels in Babel, Harut and Marut. Nor did they (the two angels) teach it to anyone till they had said: We are only a temptation, therefore disbelieve not (in the guidance of Allah). And from these two (angles) people learn that by which they cause division between man and wife; but they injure thereby no-one save by Allah's leave. And they learn that which harmeth them and profiteth them not. And surely they do know that he who trafficketh therein will have no (happy) portion in the Hereafter; and surely evil is the price for which they sell their souls, if they but knew.” (2:102)
0:58"And he will have no share in the Hereafter."
1:01A person may direct knowledge,
1:06through his own injustice, toward corruption on earth.
1:09Knowledge may be beneficial in its origin,
1:12or capable of being beneficial,
1:15yet a person uses it, through his injustice,
1:18for corruption and spreading mischief.
1:20Like nuclear science and atomic fission,
1:23and what can result from it
1:25in terms of beneficial applications.
1:27Yet, a person turns away from that
1:29and uses it in the manufacture of
1:31atomic and hydrogen bombs,
1:34annihilating with them hundreds of thousands,
1:37or even millions of people.
1:41Whoever is not restrained by his knowledge from transgression,
1:44his knowledge will be of no benefit to him.
1:48The knowledge that does not prevent its possessor
1:50from following the whims of the enemies of Allah
1:53will be of no benefit to its possessor.
1:56Rather, it exposes him to abandonment and torment.
1:59Allah the Almighty said:
2:01“And the Jews will not be pleased with thee, nor will the Christians, till thou follow their creed. Say: Lo! the guidance of Allah (Himself) is Guidance. And if thou shouldst follow their desires after the knowledge which hath come unto thee, then wouldst thou have from Allah no protecting guardian nor helper.” (2:120)
2:04"And never will the Jews or the Christians approve of you until you follow their religion."
2:07"Say, 'Indeed, the guidance of Allah is the [only] guidance.'"
2:10"And if you were to follow their desires..."
2:13“And the Jews will not be pleased with thee, nor will the Christians, till thou follow their creed. Say: Lo! the guidance of Allah (Himself) is Guidance. And if thou shouldst follow their desires after the knowledge which hath come unto thee, then wouldst thou have from Allah no protecting guardian nor helper.” (2:120)
2:16“And the Jews will not be pleased with thee, nor will the Christians, till thou follow their creed. Say: Lo! the guidance of Allah (Himself) is Guidance. And if thou shouldst follow their desires after the knowledge which hath come unto thee, then wouldst thou have from Allah no protecting guardian nor helper.” (2:120)
2:20The arrogance of a scholar regarding his knowledge
2:24stems from his ignorance of himself
2:27and of Allah the Almighty.
2:29If a person knew
2:31that his knowledge is a gift from Allah,
2:34and that it does not equal an atom in the knowledge of Allah the Almighty,
2:37he would not have been arrogant or contended with Allah through his knowledge.
2:40Indeed, the arrogance of a learner regarding his knowledge
2:43is in reality
2:46a result of his ignorance of Allah the Almighty,
2:49and his ignorance of himself and the proportion of his knowledge
2:52to the knowledge of Allah.
2:54Allah the Almighty said:
2:56“They are asking thee concerning the Spirit. Say: The Spirit is by command of my Lord, and of knowledge ye have been vouchsafed but little.” (17:85)
3:00Knowledge is sought by exerting effort and following its paths.
3:05Among the afflictions in seeking knowledge
3:09is negligence regarding it,
3:11and being content with mere snippets of it
3:13through messages, small booklets,
3:16recordings,
3:18and light, rapid clips
3:20published on social
3:23media.
3:25While these means are beneficial and good,
3:28their scope is limited to exhortation and reminders,
3:31or general culture.
3:33As for formal scientific lessons
3:35and academic grounding,
3:37one must exert effort,
3:39sit with scholars
3:41in circles of knowledge,
3:43or specialize in universities
3:45and Sharia schools.
3:47Preferring the worldly life
3:50and true knowledge
3:52do not meet.
3:54Anyone who prefers the worldly life
3:57among the people of knowledge
3:59will inevitably speak about Allah
4:01without truth in his fatwas
4:03and his rulings,
4:05because the rulings of Allah the Almighty
4:07often come
4:09contrary to the desires of people,
4:11especially those in positions of authority
4:13among them.
4:15If a scholar follows the desire
4:17of love for the world
4:19and seeks to please those in authority,
4:21he will, because of that, concede
4:23much of the truth
4:25and oppose it.
4:27Allah the Almighty said:
4:29"And there came after them"
4:31"successors who inherited the Scripture."
4:33“And a generation hath succeeded them who inherited the scriptures. They grasp the goods of this low life (as the price of evil-doing) and say: It will be forgiven us. And if there came to them (again) the offer of the like, they would accept it (and would sin again). Hath not the covenant of the Scripture been taken on their behalf that they should not speak aught concerning Allah save the truth? And they have studied that which is therein. And the abode of the Hereafter is better, for those who ward off (evil). Have ye then no sense?” (7:169)
4:35"And they say, 'It will be forgiven'"
4:37"for us.'"
4:39“And a generation hath succeeded them who inherited the scriptures. They grasp the goods of this low life (as the price of evil-doing) and say: It will be forgiven us. And if there came to them (again) the offer of the like, they would accept it (and would sin again). Hath not the covenant of the Scripture been taken on their behalf that they should not speak aught concerning Allah save the truth? And they have studied that which is therein. And the abode of the Hereafter is better, for those who ward off (evil). Have ye then no sense?” (7:169)
4:41"They take it."
4:43“And a generation hath succeeded them who inherited the scriptures. They grasp the goods of this low life (as the price of evil-doing) and say: It will be forgiven us. And if there came to them (again) the offer of the like, they would accept it (and would sin again). Hath not the covenant of the Scripture been taken on their behalf that they should not speak aught concerning Allah save the truth? And they have studied that which is therein. And the abode of the Hereafter is better, for those who ward off (evil). Have ye then no sense?” (7:169)
4:45"The Scripture, that they should not say"
4:47"about Allah except the truth."
4:49"And they studied what is in it."
4:51"And the home of the Hereafter"
4:53"is better for those who fear Allah."
4:55"Do you not understand?"
4:57So He, glory be to Him, informed us that
4:59the people of knowledge among the Jews who
5:01inherited the Scripture
5:03took the fleeting worldly goods,
5:05meaning the enjoyment of the worldly life.
5:07And if that were repeated for them,
5:09they would prioritize the world
5:11over speaking the truth in every
5:13instance.
5:16The abstinence of the people of knowledge
5:18from the gifts of the ruler.
5:20The abstinence of the people of knowledge
5:22from the gifts of the ruler
5:24preserves their dignity,
5:26makes their word heard,
5:28and their status elevated.
5:30Accepting them
5:32involves a degradation of their position
5:34and humiliation for them.
5:37The gifts of the ruler
5:39come with a price.
5:41All the gifts of the ruler
5:43come with a price,
5:45sooner or later.
5:47So let the scholar beware
5:49of accepting them,
5:51lest he be asked to pay the price,
5:53and that would be at the expense of his religion.
5:55It is among the greatest
5:57forms of illicit gain (suht).
5:59Allah the Almighty said regarding the likes of
6:01these scholars
6:03of the Children of Israel:
6:05"[They are] avid listeners to falsehood,"
6:07"[and] devourers of the illicit."
6:09Concealing the truth
6:12when there is a need for it
6:14is like speaking falsehood.
6:16Concealing the truth
6:19when people need it
6:21is like someone who speaks falsehood,
6:23and it is among the greatest injustices.
6:25Allah the Almighty said:
6:27"And who is more unjust than one"
6:29"who conceals a testimony"
6:31"he has from Allah?"
6:33Allah has cursed the one who conceals
6:35the truth among the people of knowledge.
6:37He, the Almighty, said:
6:39"Indeed, those who conceal"
6:41"what We sent down of"
6:43"clear proofs and guidance"
6:45“Lo! Those who hide the proofs and the guidance which We revealed, after We had made it clear to mankind in the Scripture: such are accursed of Allah and accursed of those who have the power to curse.” (2:159)
6:47"for the people in the Scripture,"
6:49"those are cursed by"
6:51"Allah and cursed by"
6:53"those who curse."
6:56The one who conceals the truth
6:58and clothes it with falsehood
7:00is unjust to people and to himself.
7:02Just as he is unjust by
7:05concealing the truth and clothing it
7:07with falsehood toward people through his sinful
7:09action, he is also unjust to
7:11himself in the severest way
7:13by burdening it with the sins
7:15of all those who are led astray because of him.
7:17Allah the Almighty said:
7:19"That they may bear their own burdens"
7:21"in full on the Day of Resurrection"
7:23"and of the burdens of those"
7:25"whom they misguide without knowledge."
7:27"Unquestionably, evil is"
7:29"that which they bear."
7:31Concealing the truth
7:34and clothing it with falsehood are intertwined.
7:36Often,
7:39the concealment of truth
7:41is coupled with clothing it in falsehood,
7:43or one necessitates
7:45the other. So the scholar
7:47who is misguided
7:49finds people ignorant,
7:51so he conceals the truth from them.
7:53And if he finds they have something
7:55of knowledge of the truth,
7:57he clothes it for them and mixes it
7:59with falsehood to divert them
8:01from the pure truth.
8:03Two things, either of which
8:06causes the concealment of
8:08the truth or clothing it
8:10with falsehood.
8:13What drives a scholar to conceal
8:15the truth or clothe it with falsehood
8:17whether it be out of fear of harm from
8:19the people of falsehood, or out of love for
8:21and greed for this fleeting worldly life,
8:23then concealing the truth,
8:25and obscuring it with falsehood,
8:27out of greed for the world,
8:29is never permissible under any circumstances.
8:31It is among the gravest of sins, as previously mentioned.
8:33Furthermore, clothing the truth with falsehood
8:35out of fear of harm is not justified,
8:37also because it
8:39leads people into misguidance,
8:41and there may be no one else to clarify
8:43that to them and protect them from it.
8:45As for mere silence
8:47regarding the truth
8:49due to severe harm that a person may not be able to bear,
8:51and fearing that he might be tempted away from his religion
8:53because of it,
8:55then perhaps that silence
8:57may be excused for him
8:59if he hopes that someone else will speak out
9:01for the truth, someone who is
9:03more capable than he is of enduring the harm,
9:05or who is removed from the possibility of it
9:07befalling him.
9:09The matter hinges, first and last,
9:11on the fear of Allah, the Exalted,
9:13and on averting harm as much as possible.
9:15In summary:
9:17if you are unable to speak the truth,
9:19do not speak falsehood.
9:21A corrupt
9:24fatwa legitimizes
9:26evil deeds and entrenches them
9:28in society.
9:30No matter how widespread evil deeds become
9:32in society, they do not become entrenched
9:34except by legitimizing them.
9:36And they are legitimized by an evil scholar
9:38through his fatwa that obscures
9:40the truth with falsehood,
9:42or by his concealing the truth
9:44and remaining silent instead of denouncing it,
9:46so people mistake his silence
9:48for legislation and approval
9:50of the evil.
9:52This is most dangerous and severe
9:54when an evil scholar colludes
9:56with an oppressive ruler,
9:58for this leads
10:00to the effacement of the Shari'ah and the alteration
10:02of concepts.
10:05Institutionalizing the concealment of truth:
10:07the greatest form of concealing
10:10the truth and obscuring it with falsehood
10:12is the institutionalization of concealing
10:14the truth itself,
10:16by granting it a veneer of legitimacy,
10:18and moving it from the status of a temporary,
10:20forced exception
10:22to becoming the established norm,
10:24thereby flipping
10:26what is known and true in the understanding of
10:28people into something evil and false.
10:30Among its dangerous manifestations
10:32is that a person becomes unable
10:34to openly declare his disavowal
10:36of the polytheists and his disbelief in the Taghut (false deities),
10:38for a temporary
10:40reason among many.
10:42As Allah, the Exalted, said:
10:44"Let not the believers take the disbelievers
10:46as allies instead of
10:48the believers."
10:50"And whoever does that..."
10:52“Let not the believers take disbelievers for their friends in preference to believers. Whoso doeth that hath no connection with Allah unless (it be) that ye but guard yourselves against them, taking (as it were) security. Allah biddeth you beware (only) of Himself. Unto Allah is the journeying.” (3:28)
10:54"...except when taking precaution against them in prudence."
10:56"And Allah warns you of Himself,"
10:58"and to Allah is the final destination."
11:00Thus, a person may become accustomed to
11:02appeasing the disbeliever
11:04at all times,
11:06and this appeasement turns into
11:08sycophancy and allegiance.
11:10He claims this sycophancy,
11:12which stems from weak faith,
11:14has become the foundation,
11:16and calls for religious tolerance
11:18and the alleged
11:20convergence of
11:22religions.
11:24Preconceiving a ruling
11:27for a matter before
11:29seeking evidence for it:
11:32among the pitfalls in knowledge
11:34is to hold a specific ruling
11:36for a matter and adopt it
11:38before seeking evidence for it,
11:40for that is a product of caprice.
11:42A seeker of truth must
11:44strip himself of caprice
11:46before seeking evidence for a ruling,
11:48because one who follows his caprice
11:50will never lack a semblance of evidence
11:52for his desires.
11:54Iblis even claimed evidence
11:56for the validity of his arrogance in refusing to prostrate,
11:58saying:
12:00"I am better than him; You created me
12:02from fire and created him
12:04from clay."
12:06Committing a wrong without seeking evidence
12:08for it, while acknowledging that it is
12:10wrong,
12:12is all lighter in the sight of Allah
12:14than seeking evidence to justify it.
12:16The former is a sin,
12:18while the latter is declaring the forbidden lawful,
12:20which leads to disbelief, we seek refuge in Allah.
12:22The factions opposing
12:25Islam and its
12:27divine methodology:
12:30everyone who opposes Islam
12:32and its divine methodology
12:34only does so out of caprice,
12:36far removed from knowledge
12:38and sound deduction.
12:40First:
12:43those who oppose it with what they deem
12:45rational arguments,
12:47which they prioritize
12:49over the revealed texts.
12:51Second:
12:53those who oppose textual evidence
12:55with analogy and personal opinion,
12:57while claiming to possess fiqh in religion.
12:59Third:
13:01those who oppose the evidence
13:03with mere taste and subjective experience,
13:05calling themselves
13:07"the people of reality,"
13:09as opposed to the scholars committed
13:11to the legal evidence,
13:13whom they call "the people of the Shari'ah,"
13:15or they say,
13:17"You are the people of the outward,
13:19and we are the people of the inward."
13:21Fourth:
13:23those who oppose the Shari'ah with politics,
13:25such as the tyrannical
13:27rulers
13:29who violate the law of Allah
13:31for the sake of establishing their own kingdom,
13:33and do not care about that.
13:36Argumentation and the harms of
13:38argumentation and disputation in religion:
13:41it is evil and a warning,
13:43a cause of division and hostility.
13:45No one engages in it
13:47except one who follows his caprice,
13:49searching for controversial issues
13:51and stirring them up,
13:53while remaining silent on matters of consensus,
13:55neither supporting them
13:57nor confronting the people of misguidance with them.
13:59Among the characteristics of
14:02those firmly grounded in knowledge:
14:04the scholars who are firmly grounded
14:06do not argue with falsehood,
14:08nor do they dispute the truth,
14:10in compliance with the saying of
14:12the Prophet (peace be upon him):
14:14"I guarantee
14:16a house in the outskirts
14:18of Paradise for one who leaves
14:20disputation, even if he is in the right."
14:22Narrated by Abu Dawud.
14:24And where they differ
14:26among themselves,
14:28they only differ in matters where
14:30there is room for disagreement,
14:32and their disagreement is based
14:34on evidence and the ijtihad applied to it.
14:36This is the argumentation
14:38in the best possible manner,
14:40and it is hoped that there is mercy in it.
14:42As for disagreement based on falsehood
14:44for the sake of prestige and status,
14:46or position or wealth,
14:48it is a curse and a calamity,
14:50and there is no mercy in it.
14:52Taqlid (blind imitation):
14:55the taqlid of a layman
14:58for a scholar whom he trusts
15:00in his religion and his adherence to evidence
15:02is permissible,
15:04and one cannot do without it.
15:06As for the taqlid of a sheikh's actions,
15:08Even if it contradicts the evidence,
15:10it remains a form of fanaticism
15:12for the opinions of men.
15:14It is a blameworthy and forbidden practice,
15:16as it leads to the claim
15:18of the infallibility of the Imams and scholars
15:20against error,
15:22and the belief that everything contradicting their statements
15:24from the revealed texts must be interpreted away
15:26or rejected.
15:28The stance of these
15:30fanatical followers is:
15:32"We found our forefathers
15:34following a path,
15:36and we are, in their footsteps,
15:38following."
15:40Al-Shafi'i said:
15:42"The Muslims have reached a consensus
15:44that whoever has the
15:46Sunnah of the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, made clear to him,
15:48it is not permissible for him
15:50to abandon it for the opinion
15:52of anyone among the people of knowledge."
15:54The harm of blind
15:57imitation:
16:00Blind imitation
16:02and fanaticism for the opinions of men
16:04is a sin that leads to factionalism
16:06and division in the ranks of the Muslims,
16:08distancing the Ummah
16:10from the evidence
16:12and tethering it to the opinions
16:14of men, who are prone to error
16:16and correctness.
16:19No one should take the lead in issuing fatwas
16:21except those firmly grounded in knowledge.
16:24It is not appropriate for anyone to take the lead
16:26in issuing fatwas for people
16:28unless he is a scholar firmly grounded in his knowledge,
16:30possessing insight into the texts of the Book
16:32and the Sunnah,
16:34and the methodology of deriving rulings from them.
16:36Due to the gravity of issuing fatwas,
16:38the salaf, may Allah have mercy upon them,
16:40used to avoid it
16:42as much as possible,
16:44and each one of them would wish
16:46that his brother would spare him the burden
16:48of issuing fatwas.
16:50If no one else was found,
16:52he would then be compelled to issue a fatwa,
16:54while remaining mindful of the fear of Allah
16:56and speaking only of what he knows.
16:58If he was ignorant of
17:00the ruling, he would say, "I do not know."
17:02Pretending to have knowledge and the rushing of
17:05the young and inexperienced
17:07to issue fatwas
17:09is one of the dangerous afflictions
17:12in the realm of knowledge and fatwas.
17:14Pretending to have knowledge and the rushing of
17:16the youth and the inexperienced
17:18to issue fatwas,
17:20and their direct recourse
17:22to the texts of the Book and the Sunnah
17:24to derive rulings from them,
17:26in isolation from the understanding of the salaf,
17:28and without possessing
17:30the necessary knowledge and principles
17:32for issuing fatwas and judging matters,
17:34especially if they are
17:36complex issues,
17:38leads us to find that
17:40one of them might issue a fatwa
17:42that the text does not truly indicate,
17:44due to his lack of knowledge
17:46of the Arabic language
17:48and the methods of linguistic indication
17:50regarding rulings.
17:52Or he may issue a fatwa based on his knowledge
17:54of a single text regarding the issue,
17:56without gathering all the other texts
17:58mentioned therein,
18:00which, when considered
18:02collectively, would change the ruling of the issue
18:04from what he had decreed.
18:06Or he may issue a fatwa based
18:08on a text from the Sunnah
18:10whose authenticity is not established,
18:12and he has no knowledge of that.
18:14Or he may stop at the ambiguous texts
18:16and not refer them back to the clear, definitive ones.
18:18Because of all this,
18:20and other factors
18:22that only the scholars
18:24firmly grounded in knowledge can grasp,
18:26the young and inexperienced person misses the mark of truth.
18:28Al-Shafi'i said:
18:30"If a young person takes the lead,
18:32he misses much knowledge."
18:34The primary reason
18:37for the youth taking the lead
18:39in issuing fatwas:
18:41The primary reason for the rushing of
18:44the youth and the inexperienced to issue fatwas
18:46is the negligence
18:48or exclusion of the scholars
18:50from performing their duty,
18:52and their abandonment of the responsibility
18:54entrusted to them by the Shari'ah.
18:56Thus, the youth turn
18:58to fill the void that
19:00the scholars' reluctance
19:02left behind.
19:04The youth do this
19:06with good intentions or otherwise,
19:08as a person is rarely free
19:10from a love for fame,
19:12taking the lead in gatherings,
19:14vanity, showing off,
19:16or other diseases
19:18of the heart.
19:21Good intentions do not absolve
19:23the pretender to knowledge among the youth of responsibility;
19:25they do not absolve him.
19:28For error in a fatwa
19:30does not relate to intentions,
19:32but to speaking about Allah
19:34without knowledge
19:36and leading people astray.
19:38In this lies a severe warning
19:40and certain sin.
19:42Allah the Almighty said:
19:44“(O man), follow not that whereof thou hast no knowledge. Lo! the hearing and the sight and the heart - of each of these it will be asked.” (17:36)
19:46"of which you have no knowledge."
19:48"Indeed, the hearing, the sight,
19:50and the heart—about all
19:52of these, one will be
19:54questioned."
19:56The Prophet,
19:58peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, said:
20:00"Indeed, Allah does not
20:02take away knowledge by snatching it away,
20:04but He takes it away
20:06by the death of the scholars,
20:08until, when no
20:10scholar remains, people take
20:12ignorant leaders,
20:14who are asked and they issue fatwas
20:16without knowledge,
20:18so they go astray and lead others astray."
20:20Narrated by Al-Bukhari.
20:22And he, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, said:
20:24"Among the signs of the Hour
20:26is that knowledge will be sought
20:28from the young (the inexperienced)."
20:30Narrated by Ibn Al-Mubarak
20:32in *Al-Zuhd*,
20:34and authenticated by Al-Albani.
20:36The remedy for the phenomenon
20:39of pretending to have knowledge
20:42and speaking
20:44about Allah without knowledge
20:46lies in an intellectual revival
20:48that includes
20:50increasing scientific activities,
20:52highlighting them,
20:54elevating the status of the scholars
20:56who are truly connected to Allah,
20:58and empowering them to perform their role
21:00in society.
21:02It also includes caring for students of knowledge,
21:04qualifying them to reach
21:06the rank of scholars,
21:08and nurturing them in sincerity
21:10and acting upon what they know.
21:12And the establishment of scientific research centers
21:14that examine
21:16the emerging issues of the Ummah
21:18and provide their Shari'ah-based solutions.
21:20Issues of
21:23disagreement and issues of
21:25ijtihad:
21:28Some do not distinguish between issues of
21:30disagreement and issues of
21:32ijtihad.
21:34Among those with this misguided understanding, the saying spreads:
21:36"There is no condemnation
21:38in matters of disagreement."
21:40This is a false statement
21:42and a corrupt belief,
21:44for not every disagreement
21:46is valid, such that one may act
21:48according to it in any way
21:50whatsoever.
21:52If it is rejected by a text from the Book or the Sunnah,
21:54it is an irregular disagreement,
21:56invalid,
21:58and rejected upon its proponent.
22:00This corrupt assertion necessitates
22:03that the act of forbidding evil
22:05in the Sharia of Islam be restricted
22:07solely to those matters that are definitively
22:09and necessarily prohibited, and upon which there is consensus
22:11that they are indeed evil.
22:13Yet, disagreement is not an argument
22:15in and of itself;
22:17rather, the Book and the Sunnah are the argument
22:19against all who disagree, from the first generations to the last.
22:21A scholar may sometimes dissent on an issue
22:23because the hadith
22:25pertaining to it did not reach him,
22:27or because he believed it to be inauthentic,
22:29or because he was unmindful of it
22:31at the time of the disagreement.
22:33In such a case,
22:35it is not permissible to follow that scholar
22:37when there exists evidence to the contrary,
22:39based on his own words,
22:41and other such reasons
22:43mentioned by Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah
22:45in his invaluable book,
22:47*Raf' al-Malam*
22:49*'an al-A'immah al-A'lam* (Removing Blame from the Illustrious Imams).
22:51Among the implications of this
22:53corrupt assertion
22:55is a dangerous theological deviation.
22:57For when the authentic Sunnah,
22:59established from the Prophet,
23:01peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, is rejected
23:03simply because someone
23:05has disagreed on the matter,
23:07this implies that
23:09the statements of the Prophet, peace be upon him,
23:11and his commands
23:13do not derive their legitimacy
23:15except when people agree upon them.
23:17This is a dangerous path
23:19that contradicts the foundation of Islam,
23:21the meaning of which is
23:23submission to the commands of
23:25Allah the Exalted and the commands of
23:27His Messenger, peace be upon him.
23:29The correct expression
23:31that is acceptable in
23:33this field
23:35is: "There is no forbidding of evil in matters
23:37of ijtihad (independent legal reasoning)."
23:39For matters of ijtihad
23:41are those in which there is no binding evidence
23:43or explicit text
23:45that necessitates a clear, obligatory response,
23:47or where the ijtihad
23:49concerns the fiqh of balancing
23:51interests and harms.
23:53In such cases, it is permissible
23:55to exercise ijtihad due to the conflict
23:57or ambiguity of the evidence.
23:59A person may then follow what
24:01his own ijtihad leads him to,
24:03if he is a scholar,
24:05or follow what he finds reassuring
24:07and trusts from the ijtihad of the scholars,
24:09if he is a layperson.
24:11Choosing the easiest
24:13of the scholars' opinions—
24:15this
24:18is also a misguided concept,
24:20branching off from
24:22the previous misguided concept,
24:24and even more severe.
24:26It is based fundamentally
24:28on the idea that the religion is easy and has no
24:30hardship in it, so whenever
24:32a disagreement is found among scholars
24:34regarding a matter,
24:36even if the dissenting opinion is anomalous
24:38and contradicts the evidence,
24:40it is permitted, under the pretext of
24:42this concept,
24:44to adopt the easier opinion and follow it
24:46without looking
24:48at the evidence for each position.
24:50This misguided concept is refuted
24:52by the same arguments used
24:54against the concept preceding it.
24:56Added to this is
24:58that ease in the religion of Allah
25:00is that which conforms to the evidence
25:02and what the Sharia deems
25:04to be easy,
25:06not what conforms to whims and desires.
25:08Adopting rulings by
25:10collecting the anomalous views of the schools of thought
25:13is the tailoring of a new religion.
25:15Whoever collects
25:18the anomalous views of the schools
25:20is not establishing
25:22his religion; rather, he is tailoring
25:24a religion that suits his whims.
25:26Legal stratagems (al-hiyal al-shar'iyyah):
25:29There are no stratagems in the Sharia
25:32used to reach the goal of
25:34abandoning an obligation,
25:36committing a prohibition,
25:38or making the truth falsehood
25:40and falsehood truth.
25:42Allah the Exalted condemned
25:44those who transgressed on the Sabbath
25:46from among the Jews,
25:48and used stratagems to catch fish
25:50on their day of rest and Sabbath.
25:52Allah the Exalted said:
25:54"And ask them about the town..."
25:56“Ask them (O Muhammad) of the township that was by the sea, how they did break the Sabbath, how their big fish came unto them visibly upon their Sabbath day and on a day when they did not keep Sabbath came they not unto them. Thus did We try them for that they were evil-livers.” (7:163)
25:58“Ask them (O Muhammad) of the township that was by the sea, how they did break the Sabbath, how their big fish came unto them visibly upon their Sabbath day and on a day when they did not keep Sabbath came they not unto them. Thus did We try them for that they were evil-livers.” (7:163)
26:00"...when their fish came to them
26:02on the day of their Sabbath,
26:04appearing openly..."
26:06“Ask them (O Muhammad) of the township that was by the sea, how they did break the Sabbath, how their big fish came unto them visibly upon their Sabbath day and on a day when they did not keep Sabbath came they not unto them. Thus did We try them for that they were evil-livers.” (7:163)
26:08"Thus do We test them
26:10because they were defiantly disobedient."
26:12When they engaged
26:14in this stratagem,
26:16they were transformed into apes.
26:18Allah the Exalted said:
26:20“So when they took pride in that which they had been forbidden, We said unto them: Be ye apes despised and loathed!” (7:166)
26:22"...We said to them,
26:24'Be apes, despised.'"
26:26Their transgression was
26:28that when they found
26:30the fish coming in abundance
26:32on the Sabbath, which was the day
26:34they were forbidden from working,
26:36they set up nets and dug pits
26:38before the Sabbath,
26:40so that when the fish
26:42fell into them on the Sabbath,
26:44they would extract them on Sunday.
26:46This was their stratagem
26:48for which they were transformed into apes,
26:50despised,
26:52because it was a deception more severe
26:54than the sin of fishing on the Sabbath
26:56itself.
26:58As for what is legislated of stratagems,
27:00it is that which is used
27:02to achieve the goals of the Sharia
27:04and to recover rights
27:06from an oppressor who withholds them.
27:08This type of stratagem
27:10is praiseworthy and legitimate.
27:12An example of this
27:14is what the Prophet of Allah,
27:16Yusuf, peace be upon him, did
27:18by the stratagem of placing the King's cup
27:20in his brother's luggage
27:22to thereby succeed
27:24in keeping him with him,
27:26and subsequently, the arrival of
27:28the rest of his family thereafter.
27:30It is noted that despite his performing
27:32this stratagem,
27:34and despite his implying and describing his brother as a thief—
27:36for he did not say,
27:38“He said: Allah forbid that we should seize save him with whom we found our property; then truly we should be wrong-doers.” (12:79)
27:40"except the one who stole,"
27:42but rather he said,
27:44“He said: Allah forbid that we should seize save him with whom we found our property; then truly we should be wrong-doers.” (12:79)
27:46“He said: Allah forbid that we should seize save him with whom we found our property; then truly we should be wrong-doers.” (12:79)
27:48"in his possession."
27:51The claim of dividing the religion
27:53into "husks" and "kernels":
27:55Some claim
27:58a division of the religion into essence and core,
28:00contrasted with husks
28:02and outward forms,
28:04arguing that we should focus on the essence and core
28:06rather than the husks and forms,
28:08and that this
28:10is what is more worthy of focus.
28:12Perhaps some even add to this
28:14by demanding that we deal with
28:16the "spirit" of the text
28:18rather than its literal and explicit meaning.
28:20By Allah,
28:22that is a sweeping claim
28:24and a reprehensible statement
28:26that leads to grave harms.
28:28The truth
28:30is that there are no "husks" in the religion;
28:32rather, it is all core,
28:34perfected and legislated
28:36by the All-Knowing, the All-Aware,
28:38complete and comprehensive.
28:40Nothing in it was legislated in vain;
28:42rather, everything in it is
28:44with wisdom and for the benefit of the servants.
28:46We are commanded
28:48to worship Allah in everything
28:50He has commanded or forbidden,
28:52whether it be small
28:54or great.
28:56Allah the Exalted said:
28:58O you who have believed,
29:00enter into Islam completely,
29:02and do not follow
29:04the footsteps of Satan.
29:06Indeed, he is to you
29:08a clear enemy.
29:10"Peace" here refers to Islam.
29:12The intent is
29:14to commit to the entirety of Islam,
29:16its pillars, its obligations,
29:18and its prohibitions.
29:20Reflect on how Allah warned
29:22at the end of the verse against following
29:24the footsteps of Satan,
29:26which includes his whisperings
29:28to neglect what he claims to be
29:30minor obligations or
29:32mere formalities.
29:34He trivializes the commission of minor sins
29:36under the pretext that they
29:38do not undermine the essence and the core
29:40totality of Islam.
29:42The motives behind the call
29:45to divide the religion into shells
29:47and kernels.
29:50The motive for the aforementioned call
29:52can be attributed to one of
29:54two things.
29:56First: a binary view
29:58of matters,
30:00and the belief that performing one of two things
30:02necessitates and requires
30:04the neglect of the other.
30:06This perspective,
30:08even if one assumes the good intentions
30:10of its proponent and the soundness of their purpose,
30:12remains
30:14a deficient view.
30:16It only holds true in the case of two
30:18contradictory things.
30:20As for other matters,
30:22it is not impossible to combine them;
30:24in fact, it may even be
30:26encouraged or mandatory.
30:28For Islam has pillars,
30:30obligatory acts, duties,
30:32recommended acts,
30:34permissible acts, disliked acts,
30:36and forbidden acts.
30:38Fulfilling its pillars
30:40does not in any way mean neglecting
30:42its obligatory acts and duties.
30:44Rather, the truth is that the obligatory acts
30:46and duties are complementary
30:48and perfect the pillars.
30:50The Messenger, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,
30:52just as he directed
30:54the attainment of the piety of the heart,
30:56also guided us on how to adorn ourselves
30:58with the outward appearance and guidance,
31:00such as shortening one's garments,
31:02letting the beard grow,
31:04and so on.
31:06Second:
31:08ill intent and the malicious purpose
31:10of dismantling Islam
31:12through the call
31:14to adopt the spirit of the text
31:16rather than its literal wording,
31:18under the guise of keeping pace with the times.