Part of The Hadith of Umm Zar' (series completed) · Lesson 9 of 25

Types of men in the hadith of Umm Zara’ | Episode (9) | My husband does not touch the palm to know the broadcast

◉ 141 views ⏱ 10:21 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson timeline

  1. 00:00 Types of men in the hadith of Umm Zar'
  2. 01:01 Excess in eating and drinking
  3. 02:03 Etiquette of eating with others and the prohibition of combining dates
  4. 03:06 Food shared between a man and his household
  5. 04:06 Scholars' disagreement on the ruling about combining food
  6. 05:07 A husband's neglect of intimacy with his wife
  7. 06:10 The effect of neglect on the wife's chastity
  8. 07:11 The wife's sorrow and the husband's emotional stinginess
  9. 08:12 The danger of social media and advice to men
  10. 09:13 Its effect on divorce and khul' and advice to spouses

Lesson summary

This lesson covers the third type of husband in the hadith of Umm Zar', the stingy man who is miserly with food, drink and feelings, and who neither approaches nor touches his wife. The sheikh cites the explanations of linguists and scholars such as Abu 'Ubayd al-Harawi, Qadi 'Iyad, Ibn Battal and Ibn Hajar regarding the meanings of gulf (gobbling), ishtifaf (licking the vessel) and 'not inserting the hand'. He explains that good manners at meals and sharing food with the household are among the family's rights. He also explains that neglecting a wife in intimacy greatly harms her and may push her toward sin. He concludes with advice to the husband to fear Allah and learn good treatment of his wife, and to the wife to fear Allah and lower her gaze.

Key takeaways

  • The stingy husband combines miserliness with money and miserliness with feelings; stinginess with money can seep into the heart until it reaches one's emotions.
  • Gulf in eating means eating excessively and mixing its kinds until nothing is left, while ishtifaf in drinking means licking the vessel clean.
  • The prohibition of combining two dates when eating is a matter of good manners with others, and food in the home is shared by the husband and his family, so he may not monopolize it.
  • Scholars differed on whether combining dates is forbidden or disliked; Ibn Hajar's view distinguishes according to whether the food is shared, belongs to others, or belongs to one of them.
  • Intimacy is among the goals of marriage and a means of chastity; neglecting it is among the gravest matters for a normal woman, and may drive her toward haram if she does not fear Allah.
  • A husband who keeps away from his wife and does not touch her saddens her and shows little concern for her needs; she may seek affection elsewhere, and he bears the sin if he was the cause.
  • Advice to the husband is to fear Allah and change this bad trait by learning how to treat his wife; advice to the wife is to fear Allah, lower her gaze and beware of temptation.

Questions & answers

What does Umm Zar' mean when she says: 'My husband, when he eats, gulps everything, and when he drinks, licks the vessel clean'?

The sheikh explains that gulf in eating means eating excessively and mixing its kinds until nothing remains, and ishtifaf in drinking means drinking everything left in the vessel.

What does the phrase 'does not insert his hand to learn her sorrow' mean?

The sheikh cites Ibn Qutaybah: it means he does not put his hand under her clothing to touch her and learn what is in her heart of love and affection; al-bath refers to her sorrow and complaint over his lack of intimacy.

Is combining two dates while eating forbidden or disliked?

The sheikh says scholars differed. Ibn Hajar's preferred view distinguishes: if the food is shared, combining is forbidden without the others' consent; if it belongs to others, it is forbidden; if it belongs to one person, his permission is required. All agree it is bad manners.

What advice does the sheikh give to a husband who withdraws from his wife?

He advises the husband to fear Allah and change this bad trait by learning how to treat his wife before it is too late, and to give her her right of intimacy even if his heart does not incline to her.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:03 Types of men in the hadith of Umm Zar‘.
0:13 "My husband: he does not insert his palm to feel my grief..."
0:24 This represents a category of men who are miserly in every respect.
0:29 He combines financial stinginess with emotional stinginess.
0:33 Perhaps financial stinginess penetrated so deeply into his heart that it reached his emotions, rendering him emotionally withholding.
0:39 For this reason, his wife—who is the sixth woman in the hadith—described him by saying:
0:45 "My husband: if he eats, he devours everything; if he drinks, he drains every drop; if he lies down, he rolls himself up alone;
0:52 and he does not insert his palm to feel my grief."
0:55 Abu ‘Ubayd al-Harawi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
0:59 *"Al-Laff"* (devouring) regarding food means:
1:01 Eating excessively while mixing various kinds of dishes,
1:05 to the point that nothing remains of it.
1:07 *"Al-Ishtifaf"* regarding drink means:
1:10 Consuming every last drop in the vessel,
1:12 leaving no leftover drink whatsoever.
1:15 It is derived from *"al-shufafah"*,
1:17 which is the small remnant of drink left in a container.
1:21 When a person drinks it all,
1:23 it is said: *"Ishtaffaha"* (he drained it completely).
1:26 Al-Qadi ‘Iyad (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
1:29 This woman disparaged her husband,
1:32 describing him first with meanness, stinginess,
1:35 irritation, gluttony, and extreme greed,
1:38 as well as terrible companionship and marriage relations.
1:41 She noted that he leaves nothing behind of what he eats or drinks,
1:46 gathering everything he finds and consuming it entirely.
1:50 This is certainly not from noble character.
1:53 Thus, this category of men
1:57 exhibits baseness, stinginess, and gluttony in eating.
2:00 He eats all the food around him,
2:03 showing no consideration for his wife or children,
2:06 which stems from his ill-mannered disposition.
2:10 The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) clarified for us
2:13 proper etiquette when eating with others:
2:15 he forbade combining two dates at once while eating,
2:18 when people are eating date by date.
2:21 Regarding this, there is the hadith of Ibn ‘Umar (may Allah be pleased with him and his father), who said:
2:26 "The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) forbade
2:28 that a man should combine two dates together [while eating],
2:32 unless he seeks permission from his companions."
2:35 Recorded by al-Bukhari.
2:37 Ibn Battal (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
2:40 According to scholars, the prohibition against combining dates
2:43 falls under proper table manners and etiquette,
2:46 because the group before whom the dates are placed
2:50 are equal partners in sharing the food.
2:52 If one of them takes more than his companion,
2:55 such self-preference is unacceptable.
2:58 Al-Isbahani (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
3:01 He forbade that
3:02 because it demonstrates greed, excessive desire, and gluttony,
3:06 all of which bring disgrace upon the perpetrator,
3:09 bringing sin upon anyone who mentions or criticizes him for it.
3:13 The food in the home is shared between a husband, his wife, and his children.
3:20 If he monopolizes the food to their exclusion, he wrongs them,
3:24 even if he was the one who provided the food,
3:27 because his household has a right to be fed and maintained by him.
3:32 It is sufficient condemnation of this man's behavior
3:34 that scholars differed over its legal ruling:
3:37 whether it is prohibited (*haram*) or merely disliked (*makruh*).
3:40 Ibn Hajar (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
3:43 Scholars differed regarding this prohibition,
3:45 whether it implies absolute prohibition or mere dislike.
3:48 The correct view requires nuance:
3:51 if the food is shared equally among them,
3:54 combining dates is forbidden (*haram*) unless they consent,
3:57 which can be established by explicit statement
3:59 or by circumstantial evidence that serves as a substitute,
4:03 such that there is a strong probability of their consent.
4:06 If the food belongs entirely to others, it is prohibited.
4:09 If it belongs to one of them who granted permission to eat,
4:12 his consent remains required;
4:14 it is forbidden for others [to take extra] while permissible for the owner,
4:17 though it remains recommended for him to seek permission from those eating with him.
4:23 Despite the differing legal interpretations on this matter,
4:26 scholars unanimously agree that one who acts this way
4:29 has committed a grave breach of dining etiquette.
4:32 As for the second matter criticized by the woman in her statement:
4:37 "...and if he lies down, he rolls himself up alone,
4:39 and he does not insert his palm to feel my grief,"
4:42 Ibn Qutaybah al-Dinawari (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
4:46 She meant that when he sleeps,
4:49 he wraps himself up on one side and does not lie next to her,
4:52 nor does he initiate intimacy with her as a man normally does when desiring relations with his wife—
4:58 by placing his hand beneath her garment to sense her feelings and sorrow.
5:02 There was no "grief" (*bath*) there other than the woman's longing for her husband's closeness,
5:07 and her desire to lie alongside him;
5:09 she used the word "grief" metonymically for this desire,
5:12 because her grief arose directly from its absence.
5:15 Al-Qadi ‘Iyad (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
5:18 She further described him as paying no attention to her,
5:21 leaving her completely neglected.
5:23 When he goes to sleep,
5:25 he wraps himself in his clothes without lying next to her
5:28 or drawing her close to himself.
5:31 He possesses no drive for marital intimacy,
5:34 which is otherwise considered a praiseworthy quality in men,
5:37 for the Arabs used to praise virility and sexual vigor
5:41 as evidence of sound physical health and masculinity,
5:45 while censuring its opposite,
5:47 just as the other woman said: "[He is] impotent and incapable (*‘ayay’a’*)."
5:52 Thus, this man is miserly
5:54 even in granting his wife her marital rights of intimacy.
5:58 When he lies beside her in bed, he turns away from her,
6:02 and such coldness is among the most painful experiences for a emotionally sound woman.
6:06 Marital intimacy is one of the primary purposes of marriage,
6:10 serving as a means to maintain chastity.
6:12 If a man falls short regarding his wife's needs in this area,
6:16 he causes her severe emotional harm.
6:19 If she is a God-fearing woman,
6:22 she will safeguard her virtue while remaining in silent pain;
6:25 but if she is someone whom Satan leads astray,
6:28 she may seek unlawful avenues
6:31 to fulfill her emotional and physical desires.
6:34 The condition of this type of man reaches such an extreme
6:37 that, as she said:
6:39 "He does not insert his palm to feel my grief."
6:42 This means that even affectionate touch or foreplay on her body is entirely absent;
6:46 indeed, his body does not even touch hers
6:49 due to the extreme distance he maintains from her.
6:52 Al-Qadi ‘Iyad (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
6:56 She complained of this specific trait in her husband
6:59 and condemned him for it,
7:01 decrying her meager share of marital affection from him—
7:03 that he neither lies with her nor draws near to her,
7:06 but sleeps turned away on his side.
7:09 As she described:
7:11 "If he lies down, he rolls himself up alone,"
7:13 never bringing her close to him,
7:15 nor reaching out his hand to her,
7:17 nor caressing or touching her,
7:19 failing to offer her
7:21 what men normally offer their wives,
7:24 which would allow him to gauge her emotional state and grief,
7:26 her affection for him,
7:28 her sorrow over his emotional distance,
7:31 and his utter lack of attentiveness to her physical and emotional needs.
7:36 The woman is profoundly sorrowful,
7:39 because this category of men
7:41 pays her no mind whatsoever,
7:43 knowing nothing of her emotional state or personal worries.
7:47 From such a man,
7:49 one cannot expect kind or loving words;
7:52 he is thoroughly destitute of emotion.
7:54 The danger of emotional miserliness
7:57 is that if a woman lacks affection from her husband,
8:00 she may seek it elsewhere.
8:03 If the woman
8:05 works outside the home
8:07 in a mixed-gender environment,
8:09 there is a genuine risk of her falling into temptation
8:12 with the men around her.
8:15 Similarly, if she is overly attached
8:17 to social media platforms and consumed by them,
8:20 there is a danger of her falling
8:22 into the traps of human predators
8:24 present on these platforms.
8:26 In such a case, the husband bears
8:28 a share of his wife's sin alongside her,
8:30 if he was the catalyst for her deviance.
8:33 My advice to this category of men
8:36 is to fear Allah, the Mighty and Sublime,
8:38 and to rectify this harmful disposition
8:40 by learning how to treat one's wife properly
8:44 before it is too late.
8:46 If the reason for a man's detachment from his wife
8:49 is physical weakness or lethargy,
8:51 these are matters
8:53 that can be treated today through various means.
8:56 However, if his detachment
8:59 stems from a lack of love for her in his heart,
9:02 remember that not all homes are built solely on romantic love.
9:05 The very least he can do is grant her marital rights,
9:09 even if his heart does not lean toward her.
9:13 A wife usually harbors deep love for her husband,
9:17 even when he falls short toward her;
9:19 if the man were to seek it out,
9:21 he would find a affectionate, loving heart
9:24 living with him under the same roof,
9:26 yearning for his satisfaction and striving for his happiness.
9:30 While some societies today
9:33 complain about high divorce rates
9:35 and the rising frequency of women seeking *khul‘* (divorce by judicial release),
9:39 this underlying cause among men
9:42 must be acknowledged and addressed,
9:44 as it is one of the primary drivers
9:47 behind widespread divorce and requests for *khul‘*.
9:50 Likewise, the woman must fear Allah, the Mighty and Sublime;
9:53 her husband's neglect should never drive her
9:57 to open doors of inappropriate communication with other men.
10:00 She must be extremely cautious against excessive gazing,
10:04 for it is a trial and temptation for a woman;
10:07 hence, women—just like men—have been commanded
10:10 to lower their gaze.
10:13 We will continue in our next gathering, Allah willing.
10:17 Praise be to Allah, the Lord of all the worlds.