Part of The Hadith of Umm Zar' (series completed) · Lesson 12 of 25

Types of men in the hadith of Umm Zara’ | Episode (12) | Take it easy, so-and-so, don't break the bottles

◉ 122 views ⏱ 10:58 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson timeline

  1. 00:00 Introduction: Women as glass vessels and men's gentleness
  2. 01:00 Explanation of the hadith of Anjasha and weak women
  3. 02:03 Why women are compared to glass: tender hearts
  4. 03:04 The Prophet's character: never striking women or servants
  5. 04:08 Advice on gentleness and the ruling on striking
  6. 05:09 Prohibition of insulting appearance and humiliation
  7. 06:09 The hadith 'do not strike your wife' and al-Khattabi's explanation
  8. 07:10 The hadith 'do not strike God's maidservants' and Umar's story
  9. 09:11 Farewell sermon: the command to treat women well
  10. 10:11 Conclusion: advising husbands to treat wives kindly

Lesson summary

The twelfth episode of the Umm Zar' series addresses the types of men and the etiquette of treating one's wife, based on the Prophet's ﷺ saying "Gently, O Anjasha, do not break the glass vessels." The speaker explains that women are like glass in their tender hearts and quick sensitivity, so they must be treated gently. He then cites hadiths forbidding beating and disparaging wives, and the permission for non-severe striking in specific cases, stressing that patience and good companionship are better. The lesson concludes with the Prophet's ﷺ counsel to treat women well.

Key takeaways

  • Women resemble glass in their tender hearts and quick sensitivity, so men are commanded to be gentle with them.
  • Disparaging and humiliating a wife is forbidden, since such words can penetrate the heart and leave lasting effects, possibly more than beating.
  • The Prophet's ﷺ conduct shows he never struck a woman or servant with his hand and did not take revenge for himself.
  • Striking, if permitted in certain cases, must be non-severe and is not the first or best solution a wise man turns to.
  • Patience with a wife's poor manners and overlooking her faults is better, and through it one attains goodness.
  • The Prophet's ﷺ counsel to treat women well, since wives are like captives under the husband's right, as explained by al-Qurtubi.

Questions & answers

What does the Prophet's ﷺ saying "Gently, O Anjasha, do not break the glass vessels" mean?

The Prophet ﷺ compared women to glass vessels for their tender hearts and quick sensitivity, so he commanded the camel driver to be gentle to avoid harming them through speed and rough motion, as the speaker explains.

Did Islamic law permit hitting a wife?

The speaker notes that al-Khattabi interpreted the prohibition as referring to severe beating, and that non-severe striking was permitted when necessary under conditions, but it is not the first or best solution, and patience is better.

What is the Prophet's ﷺ counsel regarding treating women?

In his Farewell Pilgrimage sermon the Prophet ﷺ said: "Be good to women," and al-Qurtubi explained that women are like captives with their husbands, bound to their right.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Entirely Merciful, the Especially Merciful.
0:03 The categories of husbands in the hadith of Umm Zar'.
0:16 "Gently, O so-and-so, do not break the glassware!"
0:21 The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) likened women to glass vessels.
0:29 And the nature of glass is that it shatters easily.
0:34 Thus, he commanded men to show consideration and gentleness.
0:37 It is narrated in the hadith of Anas Ibn Malik (may Allah be pleased with him) that he said:
0:42 The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) had a camel-driver named Anjashah,
0:48 and he had a beautiful voice.
0:50 So the Prophet (peace be upon him) said to him:
0:54 "Gently, O Anjashah, do not break the glassware!"
0:59 Qatadah said:
1:00 "He meant the delicate women."
1:03 Narrated by al-Bukhari.
1:06 Ibn Battal (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
1:08 "Because when the camels are stirred by the chanting
1:12 and hasten their pace because of it,
1:14 it is feared that the women might fall,
1:16 and thus suffer the same breaking that happens to glass vessels.
1:22 Indeed, the mere rapid movement of the camels and the excessive swaying while they are atop them
1:28 exhausts them and harms their bodies, even without falling."
1:33 Abu al-Abbas al-Qurtubi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
1:36 "He meant by it the delicate women,
1:39 and he likened them to glass vessels
1:41 due to how quickly they are affected
1:43 and their lack of physical endurance.
1:45 He feared that driving the pace and speeding up would cause some of them to fall,
1:50 or cause them pain from the excessive motion and jostling
1:54 that results from speed and haste."
1:58 There is another meaning pointed out by al-Qadi 'Iyad (may Allah have mercy on him),
2:03 as he said:
2:05 "He likened them to glass due to the fragility of their resolves,
2:08 and glass breaks easily;
2:11 and Anjashah was chanting for their camels,
2:14 singing poetry and rhymed verses containing love-themes,
2:18 so he could not be sure it would not entice them
2:20 or that his chanting would touch their hearts,
2:23 hence he ordered him to refrain from that."
2:26 A woman is tender-hearted like a glass vessel;
2:30 a bitter word breaks her.
2:33 If a woman cannot bear a hurtful word due to the tenderness of her heart,
2:39 how then could she bear someone who strikes her body and her face,
2:43 twists her arm,
2:45 and acts as though he were in a wrestling ring?
2:49 Whoever wishes to emulate the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him)
2:53 in his treatment of his wife,
2:55 let him reflect upon this hadith:
2:58 On the authority of 'A'ishah (may Allah be pleased with her), who said:
3:01 "The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) never struck
3:04 anything with his hand—
3:06 neither a woman nor a servant—
3:09 except when fighting in the cause of Allah.
3:12 Nor was any harm ever done to him for which he took revenge upon the perpetrator,
3:17 unless one of the sacred boundaries of Allah was violated,
3:21 in which case he would take retribution for the sake of Allah, Mighty and Majestic."
3:24 Narrated by Muslim.
3:26 Reflect, dear brother husband,
3:28 upon the Prophetic morals within this Seerah:
3:32 he never struck with his hand,
3:35 and he never took revenge for his own self.
3:37 This is the Prophetic wisdom in interpersonal conduct.
3:41 Indeed, a man's haste in resorting to striking his wife
3:45 is clear proof of a lack of wisdom and sound judgment.
3:49 Had he reflected for a moment,
3:51 he would have found alternatives before striking,
3:54 and resolved the matter in a better and more lasting way.
3:58 But it is haste conjoined with anger and vindication of the ego.
4:03 Looking at the Seerah of the Prophet (peace be upon him)
4:08 in his counsel to his Companions
4:10 regarding how to treat their wives,
4:13 we find that he directs them toward gentleness and good companionship,
4:17 and clarifies that striking—
4:19 even if permitted in specific cases with strict conditions—
4:23 is neither the first resort nor the ideal solution
4:26 that a sensible man begins with.
4:29 Here, dear brother husband, are some hadiths:
4:33 On the authority of Mu'awiyah al-Qushayri (may Allah be pleased with him), who said:
4:37 I said, "O Messenger of Allah,
4:39 what are the rights of our wives upon us, and what should we avoid?"
4:43 He said, "Approach your tilth whenever you wish,
4:47 feed her when you eat,
4:49 clothe her when you clothe yourself,
4:52 do not revile her face, and do not strike her."
4:55 Narrated by Abu Dawud.
4:58 Thus, he forbade him from striking her and from saying:
5:01 "May Allah uglify your face!"
5:03 In reflecting upon this prohibition:
5:06 a man initially approached the woman
5:09 only after looking at her face and admiring it;
5:12 how then can he revile a face he chose himself and desired,
5:17 and spent wealth to be united with?
5:20 The prohibition against reviling indicates the impermissibility of humiliation and degradation,
5:25 and shows that a hurtful word
5:28 may leave a deeper impact than a physical blow,
5:31 because it penetrates the heart and its traces endure.
5:35 This is part of the perfection of his guidance (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him)
5:39 in building households
5:41 upon the foundation of dignity and good companionship,
5:44 not upon insult and belittlement.
5:48 In the lengthy hadith of Laqit Ibn Sabirah, he said:
5:52 I said, "O Messenger of Allah,
5:54 I have a wife who has something sharp in her tongue"—
5:58 meaning foul language.
6:00 He said, "Divorce her then."
6:03 He replied, "O Messenger of Allah,
6:06 she has been a companion to me, and I have children with her."
6:09 He said, "Then command her"—
6:12 meaning: admonish her—
6:14 "for if there is any good in her, she will comply;
6:17 and do not beat your wife as you beat your bondwoman."
6:21 Narrated by Abu Dawud.
6:24 Al-Khattabi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
6:26 "His saying:
6:28 'Do not beat your wife as you beat your bondwoman':
6:31 for al-dha'inah refers to the wife,
6:34 and she is called dha'inah
6:36 because she travels (tadh'anu) with the husband
6:38 and moves wherever he moves.
6:40 There is nothing in this that prohibits striking them
6:43 or makes it unlawful for husbands when necessary,
6:47 for Allah Almighty has permitted that in His saying:
6:51 'Admonish them, forsake them in bed, and strike them.'
6:56 Rather, it contains a prohibition against severe, agonizing beating,
6:59 as slaves are beaten
7:01 according to the customs of those who deem beating them permissible
7:04 and mistreat their charges.
7:07 Citing the beating of slaves as an example
7:10 does not necessitate that beating them is permissible;
7:12 rather, it was mentioned here by way of censuring their conduct,
7:17 and forbidding him from emulating it."
7:20 On the authority of Iyas Ibn 'Abdillah Ibn Abi Dhubab (may Allah be pleased with him), who said:
7:26 The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said:
7:30 "Do not strike the female servants of Allah."
7:33 Then 'Umar came to the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) and said:
7:38 "The women have become emboldened against their husbands."
7:41 So he granted a concession to strike them.
7:43 Thereupon, many women surrounded the family of the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him),
7:49 complaining about their husbands.
7:51 So the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said:
7:54 "Many women have gone around the family of Muhammad,
7:58 complaining about their husbands;
8:00 those [husbands] are not the best among you."
8:03 Narrated by Abu Dawud.
8:05 Al-Khattabi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
8:08 "His word 'dha'irna'
8:10 means bad character and defiance toward husbands;
8:14 according to this, its meaning is
8:16 that they became insolent toward their husbands
8:19 and disregarded their rights.
8:22 The hadith contains the fiqh
8:24 that disciplining women regarding the withholding of marital rights is permissible,
8:28 provided it is a non-severe blow.
8:31 It also contains a clarification that being patient with their ill-temper
8:35 and overlooking what comes from them is superior."
8:39 Al-Tibi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
8:42 "He negated their being among the best,
8:44 since they did not show patience and did not endure their annoyance."
8:48 Do you wish, dear brother husband,
8:53 to be deprived of being among the best
8:55 through your lack of patience with a woman of your own choosing,
8:58 with whom you have lived for years,
9:00 and who bore you sons and daughters?
9:03 On the authority of Sulayman Ibn 'Amr Ibn al-Ahwas:
9:06 he said, my father told me that he witnessed the Farewell Pilgrimage
9:11 with the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him).
9:14 He praised Allah, extolled Him,
9:17 reminded, and admonished.
9:19 He mentioned a narrative in the hadith,
9:21 saying: "Behold, treat women well,
9:26 for they are like captives under your care;
9:29 you possess nothing more from them than that,
9:33 unless they commit manifest indecency.
9:37 If they do so, forsake them in bed
9:40 and strike them with a non-severe blow.
9:44 But if they obey you, seek no means against them."
9:49 Narrated by al-Tirmidhi.
9:51 Abu al-Abbas al-Qurtubi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
9:54 "'For they are like captives ('awan) under your care':
9:57 'awan is the plural of 'aniyah, which means a captive,
10:00 and al-'ani is the captive,
10:02 because she is bound to the right of the husband.
10:06 Thus, a woman is like a captive with her husband:
10:11 she cannot go out except with his permission,
10:14 nor can she marry another because she is under his marital bond;
10:18 she belongs exclusively to him, with no one sharing her with him."
10:22 The great Prophetic injunction is:
10:26 "Behold, treat women well!"
10:30 So are you, dear brother husband,
10:32 among those who treat their wives well?
10:35 I ask Allah that you be so,
10:38 and I seek refuge in Allah that you be
10:40 among those about whom the seventh woman said:
10:43 "Every flaw is found in him:
10:45 he fractures your head, or breaks your bone,
10:47 or combines both against you."
10:52 We will continue in our next session, if Allah wills.
10:55 And all praise is due to Allah, Lord of the worlds.