Part of The Hadith of Umm Zar' (series completed) · Lesson 22 of 25

Types of men in the hadith of Umm Zara’ | Episode (22) | Was Zara's mother grateful to her husband?

◉ 112 views ⏱ 11:21 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson timeline

  1. 00:00 Men in the Hadith of Umm Zar': Introduction on Gratitude
  2. 01:00 The Prophet's choice offered to his wives
  3. 02:00 Story of Ibrahim, Isma'il and his ungrateful wife
  4. 03:01 Ibrahim's command to divorce the wife
  5. 04:01 Ibrahim's prayer for the household
  6. 05:01 Ibrahim's advice to keep the threshold
  7. 06:04 Ingratitude to the spouse and the danger of Hell
  8. 07:04 Was Umm Zar' grateful to her second husband?
  9. 08:06 Umm Zar's description of her second husband's kindness
  10. 09:06 A wife's love does not mean she is grateful
  11. 10:07 Verses on gratitude and ingratitude; consequences of divorce

Lesson summary

This episode of the Umm Zar' hadith series addresses gratitude and ingratitude in marriage, which the sheikh describes as among the most dangerous bad traits for a woman. He cites the story of Ibrahim and Isma'il (peace be upon them) and the Prophet's ﷺ saying about ingratitude to the spouse and ingratitude for kindness. He then examines whether Umm Zar' was grateful to her husband, based on what she said about her second husband, and concludes that a woman's love for her husband does not necessarily mean she is grateful to him.

Key takeaways

  • The sheikh warns against ingratitude for kindness and complaining about one's living conditions, which the Prophet ﷺ cautioned against.
  • Allah gave the wives of the Prophet ﷺ the choice between worldly life and its adornment or Allah, His Messenger and the Hereafter, and they chose Allah and His Messenger.
  • The story of Ibrahim and Isma'il shows that Ibrahim would not accept a daughter-in-law who was ungrateful for her blessings, so he ordered his son to divorce her.
  • Ibn 'Abbas's narration that most of the people of Hellfire are women because they are ungrateful to their spouses and to kindness.
  • Gratitude to a husband is part of gratitude to Allah, since whatever good a husband provides for his family is a blessing from Allah that flows through him.
  • A wife's love for her husband does not mean she is grateful to him, and good character appears in dealing with everyone.
  • Blessings do not last without gratitude, as Allah says: "If you are grateful, I will surely increase you."

Questions & answers

Was Umm Zar' grateful to her husband?

The sheikh argues she was not grateful to her first husband, as she belittled what her second husband gave her, and so the blessing she had with her first husband was lost.

What does 'kufr al-'ashir' (ingratitude to the spouse) mean in the Prophet's ﷺ hadith?

According to Ibn Battal's explanation quoted by the sheikh, it means ingratitude for kindness and disdain for the spouse's circumstances.

Why did Ibrahim (peace be upon him) order his son to divorce his wife?

Because she was not grateful for the blessings she had, and Ibrahim did not accept that, so he commanded his son to divorce her.

Does a woman's love for her husband show that she is grateful to him?

No. Attachment to a man has many causes, and loving him does not mean she necessarily treats him well in terms of gratitude.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Qur’an verses cited in this lesson

  • An-Nisa 4:147 — What concern hath Allah for your punishment if ye are thankful (for His mercies) and believe (in Him)? Allah was ever Responsive, Aware.
  • Al-Ahzab 33:28 — O Prophet! Say unto thy wives: If ye desire the world's life and its adornment, come! I will content you and will release you with a fair release.
  • Al-Ahzab 33:29 — But if ye desire Allah and His messenger and the abode of the Hereafter, then lo! Allah hath prepared for the good among you an immense reward.

Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:03 Categories of men in the Hadith of Umm Zar'.
0:16 Was Umm Zar' grateful to her husband?
0:21 Among the most dangerous bad traits for a woman in her marital life
0:27 Are ingratitude for kindness, unthankfulness,
0:30 And constant discontent with her living conditions.
0:34 The Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, warned against these traits,
0:39 And our Lord deemed contentment appropriate for the wives of the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him.
0:44 Allah Almighty says:
0:46 “O Prophet! Say unto thy wives: If ye desire the world's life and its adornment, come! I will content you and will release you with a fair release.” (33:28)
0:54 “O Prophet! Say unto thy wives: If ye desire the world's life and its adornment, come! I will content you and will release you with a fair release.” (33:28)
1:00 Ibn Kathir, may Allah have mercy on him, said:
1:03 "This is a command from Allah to His Messenger, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,
1:08 To give his wives the choice between separating from him,
1:11 So they may go to others who can provide them with the worldly life and its adornment,
1:17 Or remaining patient with the straitened circumstances he lived in,
1:21 For which they would have a immense reward with Allah.
1:25 So they chose Allah and His Messenger, may Allah be pleased with them.
1:29 “But if ye desire Allah and His messenger and the abode of the Hereafter, then lo! Allah hath prepared for the good among you an immense reward.” (33:29)
1:32 Thus Allah combined for them after that the good of this world and the happiness of the Hereafter."
1:38 So Allah, the Mighty and Sublime, nurtured the wives of the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,
1:45 Upon gratitude for the blessings they were enjoying,
1:49 And forbade them from complaining about straitened living conditions,
1:52 So that they might be role models for the women of the world.
1:56 Nor was Abraham, the Intimate Friend of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, pleased
2:00 For his son Ishmael's wife to be ungrateful for the blessings she enjoyed,
2:06 So he commanded his son to divorce her.
2:09 It was narrated in the long hadith of al-Bukhari regarding the story of Abraham and Ishmael,
2:14 On the authority of the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, who said:
2:18 "Abraham came after Ishmael had married to check on his estate,
2:24 But he did not find Ishmael.
2:26 So he asked his wife about him,
2:28 And she said:
2:30 'He has gone out hunting for us.'
2:32 Then he asked her about their living conditions and state,
2:34 And she said:
2:36 'We are in bad shape;
2:38 We are in hardship and distress.'
2:40 Thus she complained to him.
2:42 He said:
2:43 'When your husband comes,
2:45 Convey my greetings of peace to him,
2:47 And tell him
2:49 To change the threshold of his door.'
2:51 When Ishmael came,
2:53 He seemed to sense something,
2:55 So he asked:
2:57 'Has anyone come to you?'
2:59 She said: 'Yes,
3:01 An old man of such-and-such description came to us,
3:03 And he asked us about you,
3:05 So I informed him.
3:07 Then he asked me how our living was,
3:09 So I informed him that we were in hardship and distress.'
3:13 He said:
3:14 'Did he advise you with anything?'
3:16 She said: 'Yes,
3:18 He commanded me to convey his greetings of peace to you,
3:20 And he says:
3:22 "Change the threshold of your door."'
3:24 Ishmael said:
3:25 'That was my father,
3:26 And he has commanded me to part from you.
3:29 Go back to your family.'
3:31 So he divorced her,
3:33 And married another woman from among them.
3:35 Abraham stayed away from them
3:37 For as long as Allah willed,
3:39 Then he came to them later,
3:41 But did not find Ishmael.
3:42 So he entered upon his wife
3:44 And asked her about him.
3:45 She said:
3:46 'He has gone out hunting for us.'
3:48 He said:
3:50 'How are you?'
3:51 And he asked her about their living conditions
3:53 And state.
3:54 She said:
3:55 'We are in good health and abundance,'
3:57 And she praised Allah.
3:59 So he said:
4:01 'What is your food?'
4:03 She said:
4:04 'Meat.'
4:05 He said:
4:06 'And what is your drink?'
4:08 She said:
4:09 'Water.'
4:10 He said:
4:11 'O Allah, bless them
4:13 In their meat and water.'"
4:15 The Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, said:
4:18 "They had no grain at that time,
4:21 And if they had had any,
4:23 He would have supplicated for them in it."
4:25 He said:
4:26 "Thus, no one confines themselves to these two
4:28 Anywhere outside of Mecca
4:30 Except that they will suffer digestive distress."
4:32 He said:
4:33 "When your husband comes,
4:35 Convey my greetings of peace to him,
4:37 And command him to keep
4:39 The threshold of his door."
4:41 When Ishmael came,
4:43 He said:
4:44 "Has anyone come to you?"
4:46 She said:
4:47 "Yes,
4:48 A handsome old man came to us,"
4:50 And she praised him.
4:52 "He asked me about you,
4:54 So I informed him.
4:55 Then he asked me how our living was,
4:58 So I informed him that we were doing well."
5:00 He said:
5:01 "Did he advise you with anything?"
5:03 She said:
5:04 "Yes,
5:05 He conveys his greetings of peace to you,
5:07 And commands you to keep the threshold of your door."
5:11 Ishmael said:
5:12 "That was my father,
5:13 And you are the threshold;
5:15 He commanded me to keep you."
5:20 Thus, Ishmael's first wife was not grateful,
5:23 So Abraham commanded him to divorce her.
5:26 Ingratitude for the husband's favor
5:29 Is among the causes of a woman entering the Fire.
5:32 On the authority of Ibn 'Abbas, may Allah be pleased with them both,
5:35 Who said:
5:36 The Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, said:
5:39 "I was shown the Fire,
5:41 And behold, the majority of its inhabitants were women
5:44 Who commit ingratitude."
5:45 It was asked:
5:46 "Do they disbelieve in Allah?"
5:48 He said:
5:49 "They display ingratitude toward their husbands
5:51 And disavow kind treatment.
5:53 If you were to show kindness to one of them for a lifetime,
5:56 Then she sees something from you that displeases her,
5:59 She says:
6:00 'I have never seen any good from you at all.'"
6:04 Narrated by al-Bukhari.
6:06 Ibn Battal, may Allah have mercy on him, said:
6:09 "The ingratitude here
6:11 Refers to unthankfulness for kindness
6:13 And denial of the husband's favor—
6:15 Meaning the husband—
6:16 As well as discontent with his condition.
6:18 Allah has commanded His Messenger to give thanks for blessings,
6:21 And it is mentioned in the hadith:
6:23 'He does not thank Allah who does not thank people.'
6:26 Expressing gratitude for the husband's blessings
6:28 Falls under giving thanks for Allah's blessings,
6:31 Because every favor bestowed by a husband upon his wife
6:35 Is part of Allah's blessing
6:37 Manifested through his hands."
6:39 On the authority of 'Abdullah ibn 'Umar, may Allah be pleased with him,
6:44 From the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,
6:47 Who said:
6:48 "Allah, Blessed and Exalted is He, does not look
6:51 At a woman who is not grateful to her husband,
6:54 While she cannot do without him."
6:57 Narrated by al-Bazzar.
6:59 This particular trait in married life
7:02 Is deeply disliked by a man,
7:04 And a man's love for his wife may change
7:07 Due to her lack of gratitude toward him,
7:10 Or her constant dissatisfaction with his financial situation.
7:13 So, was Umm Zar'
7:16 Lacking in gratitude toward her husband?
7:18 By examining what Umm Zar' said
7:21 Regarding her second husband,
7:23 We can glean from it
7:25 Whether she was grateful to her husband or not.
7:28 Umm Zar' said:
7:30 "After him, I married a noble man
7:33 Who rode a spirited horse,
7:35 Took a spear,
7:37 Brought me abundant livestock,
7:40 And gave me a pair of every type of animal,
7:43 Saying:
7:45 'Eat, O Umm Zar',
7:47 And provide for your family.'
7:49 She said:
7:50 'Yet, if I gathered everything he gave me,
7:53 It would not fill the smallest vessel of Abu Zar'.'"
7:56 Al-Qadi 'Iyad, may Allah have mercy on him, said:
7:59 "By this statement, she meant
8:02 The vast amount of gifts he brought to her home,
8:06 Consisting of camels, cattle, sheep,
8:09 Servants, and mounts;
8:11 That he gave her various kinds of these,
8:14 Not limiting himself to single items,
8:17 But rather doubling and multiplying them
8:20 Out of kindness and generosity toward her;
8:23 And that he was a man of hunting and game,
8:26 Returning with game in pairs
8:29 Adding it to what I have earned now.
8:32 Then he, may Allah have mercy on him, said:
8:35 "She described this man whom she married
8:38 as possessing nobility in his own person,
8:40 and abundance of wealth in his hands,
8:42 and that he was a man of war and horsemanship—
8:45 or it is as though he were a man of war and horsemanship—
8:48 and that he treated her with excellence
8:51 and was generous to her family.
8:54 Then she reported that despite all of this,
8:57 he did not hold the same place in her heart as Abu Zar',
9:00 and that his abundance fell short of Abu Zar's little—
9:03 so how could it compare to his abundance?
9:06 She considered this second husband's status deficient
9:09 when compared to the status of Abu Zar',
9:12 despite Abu Zar's ill-treatment of her at the end.
9:15 However, her love for him
9:17 made all men distasteful to her after him."
9:20 Yet a woman's love for her husband
9:23 does not necessarily mean she is grateful to him.
9:26 For a woman's attachment to a man
9:28 has many reasons,
9:30 and despite her attachment to him,
9:32 it does not follow that she will display good character toward him—
9:35 especially regarding the issue of ungratefully denying his kindness.
9:39 Good character in a person
9:42 manifests in their dealings with everyone,
9:45 just as bad character
9:47 manifests in their dealings with everyone.
9:50 Um Zar' was not grateful to her second husband,
9:54 despite all the good things he provided for her;
9:57 rather, she belittled it all.
9:59 So can we imagine that she
10:01 was grateful to her first husband?
10:04 Blessings do not endure except through gratitude.
10:07 She was not grateful for the blessing of her first husband,
10:10 so it vanished from her;
10:12 had she been grateful, it would have endured for her.
10:15 Allah Almighty says:
10:17 "And [remember] when your Lord proclaimed:
10:19 'If you are grateful, I will surely increase you [in favor];
10:22 but if you are ungrateful, indeed, My punishment is severe.'"
10:26 And He, Glorified be He, says:
10:28 “What concern hath Allah for your punishment if ye are thankful (for His mercies) and believe (in Him)? Allah was ever Responsive, Aware.” (4:147)
10:30 "If you are grateful and believe."
10:33 “What concern hath Allah for your punishment if ye are thankful (for His mercies) and believe (in Him)? Allah was ever Responsive, Aware.” (4:147)
10:37 Furthermore, a wise man
10:39 who possesses qualities like those of Abu Zar'—
10:42 it is unthinkable that he would toy with divorce,
10:45 especially with a woman he lived with
10:48 and had children with.
10:50 If a wise man
10:52 like Abu Zar' divorces his wife,
10:54 it is expected that he divorced her for a grave matter
10:57 within himself that he did not disclose.
11:00 This is the nature of men:
11:02 they rarely complain about marital troubles,
11:05 unlike a woman,
11:07 who quickly complains about her husband
11:09 at the very first disagreement.
11:12 We will continue in a future gathering, Allah willing.
11:17 And praise be to Allah, Lord of the worlds.