Part of The Hadith of Umm Zar' (series completed) · Lesson 13 of 25

Types of men in the hadith of Umm Zara’ | Episode (13) | Hitting a woman has a reaction

◉ 121 views ⏱ 10:26 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson timeline

  1. 00:00 Permissibility of striking and preferring to leave it
  2. 01:01 When striking is an educational means
  3. 02:02 Striking is permitted for discipline but leaving it is better
  4. 03:02 A righteous wife's response and khul' divorce
  5. 04:02 Women influenced by feminist thought and rebellion
  6. 05:03 Clear immorality and rules on restraint and striking
  7. 06:05 Feminist ideology's call to display and mixing
  8. 07:07 Exceeding the legal limits in striking
  9. 08:09 Criticizing excessive striking and Western imitators
  10. 09:09 Wisdom and consulting scholars

Lesson summary

In this session the sheikh explains when beating a wife becomes a legitimate educational measure, stressing that it is only useful when its legal conditions are met, and that leaving it is better, following the Prophet ﷺ. He then describes the wife's reaction depending on her righteousness and reason, and the two situations of the husband: keeping to the rules or exceeding them. He concludes by advising the husband to act with wisdom and consult people of knowledge.

Key takeaways

  • Beating is a permissible educational measure against a disobedient wife (nushuz), used only after admonition and separation, and within its legal conditions.
  • Leaving it is better, following the Prophet ﷺ, who never struck a woman or a servant, as narrated by Aisha (may Allah be pleased with her) in Sahih Muslim.
  • A righteous, sensible wife who fears Allah will generally return to the right path and obey her husband when advised and disciplined in the lawful manner.
  • If a wife is averse and wronged and has a valid reason, she may seek khul' by returning the dower, and a sensible husband should accept the ransom rather than force her to stay, as in the story of the wife of Thabit ibn Qays.
  • A warning against a wife influenced by feminist ideology calling for rebellion against men and Islamic teachings; the husband should deal with her using the Quranic guidance on 'adl (not restraining wives unjustly).
  • When a husband exceeds the legal limits in beating, the wife may seek divorce because of the harm, while being cautious that her reaction does not go against the Sharia, so the fault is not attributed to Islam.
  • Advice to the husband to reflect on the consequences of his actions, to handle problems with wisdom, and to consult people of knowledge.

Questions & answers

When is beating a wife an educational measure?

The sheikh explains that beating is an educational measure mentioned in the Quran for dealing with a disobedient wife. It is used only after admonition and separation if she persists in disobedience, and within its lawful manner.

Is it better to beat a disobedient wife or to refrain?

The sheikh states that beating is permissible for discipline but refraining from it is better, following the Prophet ﷺ who never struck a woman or a servant, as narrated by Aisha (may Allah be pleased with her) in Sahih Muslim.

When can a wife ask for khul'?

If she dislikes her husband, is wronged, and has a lawful reason, she may ransom herself by returning the dower, and a sensible husband should accept this rather than force her, as in the story of the wife of Thabit ibn Qays.

What should a husband do if he goes beyond the lawful limits in beating?

The sheikh explains that exceeding the limits is contrary to the Prophet's ﷺ instruction, and the wife in this case may seek divorce due to the harm she suffers, while being careful that her response remains within the Sharia.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:03 Categories of Men in the Hadith of Umm Zar'
0:16 A Wife's Reaction to Being Struck
0:23 In the previous talk, I addressed the first point regarding striking:
0:28 namely, its permissibility alongside the preference of avoiding it.
0:32 And now for the second point:
0:35 when does striking serve as a disciplinary measure?
0:39 Striking is a disciplinary measure
0:42 stipulated by the Qur'an for dealing with a recalcitrant wife,
0:46 and stipulated by the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him)
0:49 regarding training a child to pray
0:52 once they reach the age of ten and do not pray.
0:55 Yet this striking is of no avail unless it adheres to
0:58 the legal conditions governing the manner of striking
1:01 and when it may be used.
1:04 Whenever a man violates the conditions of this measure
1:07 in disciplining his wife,
1:10 no benefit can be expected from it;
1:13 rather, the woman's reaction is expected to turn out
1:16 contrary to what the man desires and hopes for.
1:20 The husband faces two scenarios:
1:23 The first scenario is that he abides
1:26 by what the Sharia has prescribed regarding the manner of striking
1:29 and the stage at which it is employed,
1:32 following the steps that precede striking,
1:35 such as admonition and forsaking them in bed,
1:38 should the woman persist in her recalcitrance;
1:41 although it remains better not to resort to striking,
1:44 following the example of the Prophet (peace be upon him).
1:47 As stated in the hadith of 'A'ishah (may Allah be pleased with her),
1:50 she said: "The Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) never struck
1:53 anything at all with his hand,
1:56 neither a woman nor a servant,
1:59 except when fighting in the cause of Allah.
2:02 Nor was he ever harmed in any way and sought retribution
2:05 against the perpetrator, unless one of the
2:08 sacred bounds of Allah was violated, in which case he took retribution
2:11 for the sake of Allah, the Almighty and Majestic." Narrated
2:14 by Muslim. Imam al-Nawawi (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
2:17 "This indicates that striking a wife, a servant,
2:20 or an animal, even if permissible for disciplinary purposes,
2:23 is better avoided."
2:26 As for the wife's reaction toward such a righteous husband,
2:29 it falls into two cases:
2:32 The first is if she is righteous, sensible,
2:35 and fears Allah Almighty;
2:38 she is then expected to return to her senses,
2:41 obey her husband, and abandon her recalcitrance.
2:44 The second is that she persists in recalcitrance,
2:47 even after being struck.
2:50 This may be due to one of two reasons:
2:53 The first reason is that she detests him,
2:56 is forced to remain with him,
2:59 and is pressured by those around her,
3:02 such as her family and friends.
3:05 Thus, she is wronged and finds no one to support her,
3:08 even though the Sharia grants her the right to *khul'* (no-fault divorce).
3:11 So she may ransom herself with what he gave her
3:14 of the bridal gift (mahr) and divorce herself,
3:17 as in the story of the wife of Thabit ibn Qays.
3:21 On the authority of Ibn 'Abbas (may Allah be pleased with them both),
3:24 he said: "The wife of Thabit ibn Qays came
3:27 to the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him)
3:30 and said: 'O Messenger of Allah,
3:33 I do not reproach Thabit
3:36 in his religious commitment or character,
3:39 but I cannot bear to live with him.'
3:42 The Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) said:
3:45 'Will you return his orchard to him?'
3:49 She said: 'Yes.'" Narrated by al-Bukhari.
3:53 If a woman possesses valid
3:56 legal grounds for *khul'*,
3:59 she is permitted to request a *khul'* divorce,
4:02 and a sensible man ought to accept the compensation from her
4:05 and not force her into a life she does not desire.
4:08 The second reason is that the woman
4:11 is influenced by feminist ideology,
4:14 which calls upon her to rebel against the man
4:17 and against the teachings of Islam,
4:20 granting her absolute freedom
4:23 to act upon whatever her desires dictate,
4:26 while humiliating the man and undermining his authority.
4:29 The counsel for the husband here
4:32 is to employ the divine guidance
4:35 in dealing with this type of woman,
4:38 as stated in His words, the Exalted:
4:41 ﴾O you who have believed,
4:45 it is not lawful for you to treat them with harshness in order to take away
4:48 a part of what you have given them,
4:51 unless they commit a clear immorality.﴿
4:54 Ibn Taymiyyah (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
4:57 "It is not permissible for a man to constrain a woman
5:00 by mistreating and pressuring her
5:03 so that she surrenders part of her bridal gift,
5:06 nor may he strike her for that purpose.
5:09 However, if she commits a clear immorality,
5:12 he may constrain her so that she ransoms herself from him,
5:15 and he may strike her.
5:18 This is between the man and Allah."
5:21 So what is the immorality that permits a man
5:25 to compel her to seek *khul'*
5:28 and return the bridal gift?
5:31 Ibn Jarir (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
5:34 "The most appropriate interpretation of His words,
5:37 ﴾Unless they commit a clear immorality,﴿
5:40 is that it refers to any obscenity, such as foulness
5:43 of tongue directed against her husband,
5:46 harming him, or committing unlawful sexual intercourse.
5:49 That is because Allah, Exalted is His praise,
5:52 encompassed through His words,
5:55 ﴾Unless they commit a clear immorality,﴿
5:58 every manifest and evident obscenity."
6:01 The corruption of a woman's religious commitment through feminist ideology
6:05 is most intolerable to a protective husband.
6:09 For feminist ideology
6:12 urges the woman to rebel against the man
6:15 in every conceivable manner,
6:18 inciting her to go out displaying her adornments and wearing perfume,
6:21 and encouraging her to freely mix with men
6:24 in workplaces, cafes, parties, and elsewhere,
6:27 even if the husband does not approve of it.
6:30 The second scenario
6:33 is when the man exceeds the legal limits in striking,
6:36 beating the woman severely
6:39 in violation of the command of the Prophet (peace be upon him).
6:42 The woman's reaction
6:45 in this situation
6:48 is to seek divorce on grounds of harm inflicted upon her
6:51 by this husband.
6:54 Yet the concern is that this woman's reaction might turn
6:57 in a direction that violates the Sharia,
7:00 because of this husband's violent treatment of her,
7:04 leading her to attribute her husband's misconduct to Islam.
7:07 Then the promoters of misguidance seize upon her—
7:10 those who advocate the destruction of families—
7:13 to use her as an argument for prohibiting the striking of women
7:16 entirely and unconditionally,
7:19 and to call for adopting Western frameworks,
7:22 such as their domestic violence laws and the like.
7:25 Muhammad Rashid Rida (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
7:28 "Some of those who blindly imitate the Westerners act arrogantly,
7:32 decrying the permissibility of disciplining a recalcitrant wife,
7:35 while they do not deem it outrageous that she rebels and exalts herself over him,
7:38 turning him, though he is the head of the household, into a subordinate—
7:41 or rather, an object of contempt!
7:44 She persists in her recalcitrance,
7:47 neither softening at his admonition and counsel,
7:50 nor caring about his turning away and forsaking her.
7:53 I do not know how they propose to remedy such recalcitrant wives,
7:56 or what counsel they offer to their husbands.
8:00 Perhaps they imagine a frail, slender,
8:03 refined, and well-mannered woman
8:06 oppressed by a coarse, harsh man
8:09 who feeds his whip with her tender flesh
8:12 and drenches it in her flowing blood,
8:15 claiming that Allah Almighty permitted him
8:18 such a manner of beating,
8:21 and fabricating accusations against her when she is innocent of any fault,
8:24 as is frequently done by hard-hearted,
8:27 callous men of rigid temperament.
8:30 Far be it from Allah to permit such injustice
8:33 or to be pleased with it!
8:36 Indeed, among men there is the haughty and harsh oppressor
8:39 who wrongs a woman out of pure aggression;
8:42 numerous hadiths have been transmitted regarding the counsel to treat women well
8:45 in rebuke of men like him,
8:48 and what applies to them is what the Qur'anic verse
8:51 prescribed regarding arbitration.
8:55 Likewise, among women there are
8:57 the spiteful, defiant, and insolent wives
9:00 who despise their husbands,
9:03 deny their favors,
9:06 defy them out of vanity and obstinacy,
9:09 and burden them beyond their endurance.
9:12 So what corruption would occur on earth
9:15 if a pious, noble man is permitted
9:18 to curb the arrogance of such a woman
9:21 and bring down her haughty pride
9:24 with a light strike to her hand
9:27 or a light slap aimed at her neck?
9:30 Even many of their Western leaders
9:33 beat their educated, sophisticated wives,
9:36 as well as those who are clothed yet naked,
9:39 seductively swaying and leading others astray.
9:42 This is practiced by their philosophers, their scholars,
9:45 their kings, and their princes;
9:48 it is a necessity indispensable even to those who go to extremes
9:51 in honoring those educated women.
9:54 How then can its permissibility out of necessity be denounced
9:57 in a universal religion meant for both bedouins and urban dwellers,
10:00 encompassing all categories of humanity?"
10:03 So take heed, dear husband,
10:07 of the consequences of your actions with your wife;
10:10 adhere to wisdom in resolving your marital issues,
10:13 and consult the people of knowledge,
10:16 for you will never fail to find goodness in seeking counsel.
10:19 We shall continue in a future session, if Allah wills.
10:22 And all praise is due to Allah, the Lord of all worlds.