Al-Shamail Al-Muhammadiya | Episode (13) | Chapter on what was mentioned about the walking, sitting, and reclining of the Messenger of God, peace and blessings be upon him.

◉ 138 views ⏱ 17:12 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson timeline

  1. 00:00 The Prophet's ﷺ manner of walking
  2. 03:06 Moderation in walking and his conduct with companions
  3. 04:07 On the Prophet's ﷺ covering of the head
  4. 05:10 The reason for covering in Aisha's narration
  5. 06:14 The Prophet's ﷺ sitting postures and al-qarfaa
  6. 07:17 Reclining with one leg over the other
  7. 08:20 The ruling on placing one leg over the other
  8. 10:21 Al-ihtiba and sitting in the mosque
  9. 12:25 On the Prophet's ﷺ reclining support
  10. 14:26 Reclining while teaching and the hadith on the greatest sins
  11. 16:38 The prohibition of eating while reclining

Lesson summary

This lesson is the thirteenth episode of the series Al-Shama'il Al-Muhammadiyya, covering the chapters on the Prophet's ﷺ walk, sitting, and reclining. The sheikh draws on the hadith of Abu Hurairah رضي الله عنه to describe the Prophet's ﷺ graceful and swift walk without strain, then discusses covering the head, the various sitting postures, and the reclining position, along with the related reports. He concludes with the prohibition of eating while reclining and the scholars' explanations of its wisdom. The sheikh notes that the lesson will continue in a later part.

Key takeaways

  • The Prophet ﷺ was the most beautiful of people in appearance; Abu Hurairah رضي الله عنه said he had never seen anything more beautiful than the Prophet ﷺ.
  • His ﷺ walk was swift yet dignified, without weakness or laziness, and moderate, between excess and deficiency.
  • The Prophet ﷺ sometimes walked ahead of his companions, saying: Leave my back to the angels, and during travel he would attend to the weak and pray for them.
  • The sheikh explains that humility is an inner act whose effects appear in a person's bodily posture, as seen in the Prophet's ﷺ kneeling-style sitting.
  • Iḥtibā (sitting with arms around the knees) is a restful posture that the Prophet ﷺ used in the mosque, and it may be adopted when rest is needed.
  • Lying on one's back with one leg over the other is disliked only when the private parts may be exposed; if done without exposure, there is no harm, according to An-Nawawi as quoted by the sheikh.
  • The Prophet ﷺ prohibited eating while reclining, and scholars gave reasons such as avoiding overeating and the difficulty of swallowing food comfortably, and Allah knows best.

Questions & answers

What was the Prophet's ﷺ manner of walking?

The sheikh explains from the hadith of Abu Hurairah رضي الله عنه that the Prophet's ﷺ walk was swift, to the point that the Companions strained themselves to keep up while he remained unhurried. This was his usual walk without affectation, and it was balanced between excess and deficiency.

Did the Prophet ﷺ recline while eating?

The hadith reports him saying: As for me, I do not eat while reclining. Scholars differed on the meaning of the prohibited reclining; the wisdom given is that it may lead to overeating, and that food does not pass smoothly when one reclines.

What is iḥtibā and was it part of the Prophet's ﷺ practice?

Iḥtibā is sitting on the buttocks with the belly and legs drawn up to the thighs, the arms clasped around the shins, or a cloth wrapped around the back and knees in place of the arms. It is a restful posture, and the Prophet ﷺ regularly sat this way in the mosque.

Is it permissible to lie down with one leg over the other?

The sheikh cites An-Nawawi saying that the prohibition applies to situations where the private parts may be exposed. If it is done in a way that nothing is exposed, there is no harm or disapproval, and the Prophet ﷺ did it to show that it is permissible.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Qur’an verses cited in this lesson

  • Luqman 31:13 — And (remember) when Luqman said unto his son, when he was exhorting him: O my dear son! Ascribe no partners unto Allah. Lo! to ascribe partners (unto Him) is a tremendous wrong -

Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:07 With pens of longing and ink of love,
0:11 We inscribe words more precious than gold,
0:15 In describing the Master of Creation, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him.
0:20 The Prophetic characteristics (Shama'il).
0:30 Chapter: On the manner of the Messenger of Allah’s walking, peace be upon him.
0:36 The "walk" refers to the posture a person habitually adopts while walking.
0:44 Abu Hurayrah, may Allah be pleased with him, said:
0:47 "I have never seen anything more beautiful than the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him;
0:53 It was as if the sun were coursing across his face.
0:56 Nor have I seen anyone walk faster than the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him;
1:03 It was as if the earth were drawn together for him.
1:06 We would exert ourselves, while he walked with ease."
1:11 In this hadith, Abu Hurayrah, may Allah be pleased with him, says:
1:18 "I have never seen anything more beautiful than the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him."
1:24 He did not say, "I have never seen a person,"
1:27 Rather, he said, "I have never seen anything,"
1:30 To encompass everything he had seen,
1:32 Whether human, moon, sun,
1:35 Or any other beautiful, radiant, and lovely thing.
1:40 His saying, "It was as if the sun were coursing across his face,"
1:43 Means due to the intense radiance and brilliance of his face, peace be upon him,
1:49 It appeared to the observer as if the sun were shining upon his face.
1:53 And his saying:
1:56 "Nor have I seen anyone walk faster than the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him,"
2:02 This is the evidence (the point of focus) of the hadith.
2:05 "It was as if the earth were drawn together for him,"
2:07 Meaning it was as if the earth he walked upon would contract and bring its parts closer together.
2:13 And his saying:
2:14 "We would exert ourselves, while he walked with ease,"
2:18 Meaning he walked in this manner,
2:20 Not out of exertion or affectation,
2:23 But it was his natural gait.
2:26 Yet,
2:27 The Companions would exert themselves when walking with him.
2:32 This points to the strength of his physique, peace be upon him.
2:38 Ibn al-Qayyim, may Allah have mercy on him, said:
2:41 "When he walked, he would lean forward as if descending a slope.
2:45 He had the fastest, most beautiful, and most composed walk of all people."
2:50 A benefit:
2:53 His guidance, peace be upon him, in walking was the most perfect guidance.
2:57 It was moderate, as was his way in all his affairs,
3:02 Acting upon the words of Allah the Exalted:
3:04 ﴾ And be moderate in your pace ﴿
3:06 Meaning, let your walk be between excess and negligence.
3:11 When he walked, peace be upon him,
3:14 It was as if he were descending from a slope,
3:17 Meaning as if he were walking down a decline in the earth.
3:22 Ibn Abbas, may Allah be pleased with them both, said:
3:25 "The Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, would walk in a manner
3:29 Whereby it was known he was neither weak nor lazy."
3:34 As for his walking with his Companions, peace be upon him,
3:38 They would walk in front of him while he was behind them,
3:42 And he would say, "Leave my back for the angels."
3:46 He would walk both barefoot and wearing sandals.
3:49 He would walk with his Companions both individually and in groups.
3:53 Once, during one of his military expeditions, he was walking,
3:56 And his finger bled, and blood flowed from it.
3:59 He said, "You are but a finger that has bled;
4:04 It is in the path of Allah that you have suffered."
4:07 While traveling, he would walk behind his Companions,
4:10 Assisting the weak, letting them ride with him, and praying for them.
4:14 Chapter: On the Messenger of Allah’s covering his head (taqannu'), peace be upon him.
4:23 Taqannu' is the placing of a covering over the head.
4:28 It refers to covering the head with a piece of cloth or the like.
4:33 There is a weak hadith in this chapter that contains an objectionable element in its text,
4:39 But what is mentioned in Sahih al-Bukhari is appropriate for this chapter.
4:44 Aisha, may Allah be pleased with her, said:
4:48 "While we were sitting one day in Abu Bakr’s house at the height of noon,
4:53 Someone said to Abu Bakr,
4:57 'This is the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, with his head covered,'
5:02 Meaning he was covering his head.
5:04 The Prophet, peace be upon him, only did this at that hour
5:10 Because he was hiding from the people of Makkah while heading to Madinah.
5:15 He did it out of necessity, and it was not his habit to cover his head."
5:20 Chapter: On the Messenger of Allah’s manner of sitting, peace be upon him.
5:28 Meaning, an explanation of the hadiths regarding the description of the Messenger of Allah’s sitting, peace be upon him.
5:36 The "sitting" refers to the posture and state of the one who is seated.
5:43 Qaylah bint Makhramah, may Allah be pleased with her, reported
5:49 That she saw the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, in the mosque
5:54 Sitting in the *iq'a* (squatting) position.
5:57 She said, "When I saw the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, so humble in his sitting,
6:05 I trembled with awe."
6:09 This hadith states that Qaylah bint Makhramah, may Allah be pleased with her,
6:14 Saw the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, in the mosque sitting in the *iq'a* position.
6:20 The *iq'a* position is for a man to sit on his buttocks,
6:25 Drawing his thighs toward his abdomen and holding them with his arms.
6:30 It is called *iq'a* because the body is "gathered" (taqarfas) in it,
6:35 Meaning it draws together and joins parts to one another.
6:39 It is also called *ihtiba'*.
6:42 Her saying, "so humble in his sitting,"
6:45 Means the one upon whom complete humility is manifest.
6:49 This provides an explanation of the Prophet’s manner of sitting, peace be upon him,
6:54 And his humility and reverence before his Lord.
6:57 It shows that although humility is essentially an act of the heart,
7:01 It manifests in the posture of the servant.
7:04 Her saying, "I trembled with awe,"
7:07 Means a shivering overtook me,
7:09 Which is the trembling of the body out of fear,
7:12 Due to the majesty Allah had bestowed upon him, peace be upon him.
7:17 From 'Abbad ibn Tamim, from his uncle,
7:22 That he saw the Prophet, peace be upon him,
7:25 Lying down in the mosque,
7:27 Placing one of his legs over the other.
7:31 In this hadith,
7:34 It is the uncle of 'Abbad ibn Tamim,
7:36 Who is the noble Companion,
7:38 'Abdullah ibn Zayd ibn 'Asim, may Allah be pleased with him,
7:42 The one who was shown the Adhan in a dream,
7:45 And who participated in killing Musaylimah with a sword,
7:48 Along with the spear-throw of Wahshi.
7:53 This Companion recounts that he saw the Prophet, peace be upon him,
7:58 Lying down in the mosque,
8:00 Meaning resting on his back.
8:02 This does not necessarily imply sleeping.
8:05 It is well known that if lying down is permissible in the mosque,
8:09 Then sitting in it is permissible a fortiori.
8:12 That is why this hadith is mentioned in this chapter.
8:16 His saying, "placing one of his legs over the other,"
8:20 This applies to placing one leg over the other
8:24 Whether the feet are extended,
8:26 Or by raising one foot,
8:29 And placing the other upon it.
8:31 This posture is sometimes adopted by a person for comfort
8:35 If they have need of it.
8:37 It is not a customary posture that one adopts initially,
8:41 Therefore, it is not usually done in public gatherings.
8:45 Rather, a person does it
8:47 When they are alone in the mosque or elsewhere,
8:51 Or among a small number of companions where they have need of it.
8:56 It has been narrated in Muslim from Jabir, may Allah be pleased with him,
9:00 That the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him,
9:04 Forbade a man from raising one of his legs over the other
9:08 While lying on his back.
9:11 Al-Nawawi, may Allah have mercy on him, said:
9:13 "The scholars said:
9:15 The hadiths forbidding lying down
9:18 While raising one leg over the other
9:21 Are interpreted as referring to a state where the private parts or some part of them might be exposed.
9:26 As for the action of the Prophet, peace be upon him,
9:29 It was done in a way that nothing of that would be exposed.
9:33 This is acceptable,
9:35 And there is no dislike in it when done in that manner."
9:38 He also said:
9:40 "It is possible that the Prophet, peace be upon him, did it to demonstrate its permissibility."
9:46 From Abu Sa'id al-Khudri, may Allah be pleased with him, who said:
9:52 "The Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him,
9:56 When sitting in the mosque, would sit in the *ihtiba'* position with his hands."
10:01 In this hadith, Abu Sa'id al-Khudri, may Allah be pleased with him, informs us
10:06 That the Prophet, peace be upon him,
10:09 When he sat in the mosque, would sit in the *ihtiba'* position with his hands.
10:13 *Ihtiba'* is for a person to sit on their buttocks,
10:18 Drawing the abdomen and shins toward the thighs,
10:21 And clasping them with their hands in front of the shins,
10:24 Or by wrapping a piece of cloth behind the back instead of using the hands.
10:30 It is a posture that rests the body,
10:33 And spares a person from needing to lean against a wall or the like.
10:37 *Ihtiba'* is the sitting posture of the Bedouins.
10:40 In ancient times, they said:
10:42 "*Ihtiba'* is the walls of the Arabs,"
10:45 Meaning there are no walls in the open desert,
10:48 So when they wanted to lean, they would sit in *ihtiba'*,
10:51 As the garment prevents them from falling,
10:54 And serves for them as a wall.
10:57 *Ihtiba'* is confirmed from the Prophet, peace be upon him,
11:01 In several instances.
11:03 It was his constant habit to sit in *ihtiba'* in the mosque.
11:07 A benefit:
11:11 Other hadiths besides these have been narrated
11:14 Regarding the manner of his sitting, peace be upon him.
11:17 Among them is what was narrated from Jabir ibn Samurah, may Allah be pleased with him, who said:
11:23 "The Prophet, peace be upon him,
11:26 When he had prayed the Fajr prayer,
11:28 Would sit cross-legged in his place until the sun rose brightly."
11:32 Chapter: On the Messenger of Allah’s leaning/cushion (tak'ah), peace be upon him.
11:40 Meaning, an explanation of the hadiths narrated
11:44 Regarding the Messenger of Allah’s leaning, peace be upon him.
11:48 The *tak'ah*
11:50 Is that which one leans upon, such as a pillow or other things,
11:53 Which have been prepared and arranged for that purpose.
11:56 From Jabir ibn Samurah, may Allah be pleased with him, who said:
12:02 "I saw the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him,
12:06 Leaning on a pillow on his left side."
12:11 In this hadith,
12:13 It is stated that the Prophet, peace be upon him, was leaning on a pillow,
12:18 Which is a cushion,
12:20 As it was the *tak'ah* of the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him.
12:25 His saying, "on his left side,"
12:27 Means on his left flank.
12:29 He might also lean on his right side.
12:32 This leaning
12:34 Is something a person needs because it rests the body.
12:39 In a narration from Jabir ibn Samurah, may Allah be pleased with him, he said:
12:44 "I entered upon the Prophet, peace be upon him,
12:48 And saw him leaning on his elbow."
12:51 This narration clarifies
12:53 That the Prophet, peace be upon him,
12:56 Was relying on his elbow in that leaning of his.
13:00 This posture is neither contrary to dignity nor to humility.
13:05 On the authority of 'Abd al-Rahman ibn Abi Bakrah, from his father, who said:
13:09 The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, said:
13:13 "Shall I not inform you of the greatest of the major sins?"
13:18 They replied, "Yes, O Messenger of Allah."
13:21 He said, "Associating partners with Allah,"
13:24 "and disobedience to parents."
13:26 He said: The Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, then sat up,
13:31 for he had been reclining.
13:33 He said: "And bearing false witness, or speaking falsehood."
13:38 He said: The Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, continued to repeat this,
13:44 until we wished he would fall silent.
13:47 In this hadith, the noble Companion Abu Bakrah, may Allah be pleased with him, informs us
13:54 that the Prophet, peace be upon him, said to his Companions one day:
13:59 "Shall I not inform you of the greatest of the major sins?"
14:03 This is a method the Prophet, peace be upon him, frequently employed,
14:08 as it is effective in teaching and guidance,
14:11 for it captures hearts and commands attention.
14:15 Regarding his statement, "Associating partners with Allah,"
14:18 this is the greatest of the major sins and the most grievous injustice.
14:21 Allah the Almighty says:
14:23 “And (remember) when Luqman said unto his son, when he was exhorting him: O my dear son! Ascribe no partners unto Allah. Lo! to ascribe partners (unto Him) is a tremendous wrong -” (31:13)
14:26 Regarding his statement, "and disobedience to parents,"
14:29 the term "disobedience" encompasses every form of mistreatment toward parents.
14:34 The Prophet, peace be upon him, mentioned the rights of parents immediately after the major sin of polytheism,
14:40 which is evidence of the gravity of their rights and the severity of disobeying them.
14:45 Regarding his statement, "The Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, sat up, for he had been reclining,"
14:51 this is the point of evidence in the hadith.
14:54 It is understood from this that there is no harm in a person reclining while teaching certain matters of knowledge,
15:01 and changing one's posture serves to signal the importance of the matter,
15:06 and to emphasize its prohibition and extreme vileness.
15:09 Regarding his statement, "and bearing false witness, or speaking falsehood,"
15:13 the doubt is from the narrator.
15:16 "Falsehood" (al-zur) refers to concealment and deception,
15:19 and presenting things contrary to their true reality, as a lie and a fabrication.
15:24 Regarding his statement, "The Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, continued to repeat this until we wished he would fall silent,"
15:33 this was out of compassion and mercy for him, peace be upon him.
15:40 On the authority of Abu Juhayfah, may Allah be pleased with him, who said:
15:44 The Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, said:
15:47 "As for me, I do not eat while reclining."
15:51 This hadith indicates that the Prophet, peace be upon him, would not eat in a reclining position.
15:59 There is a difference of opinion regarding the interpretation of the prohibited reclining.
16:03 Some said it means to sit comfortably for eating in any manner, including sitting cross-legged.
16:11 Some scholars asserted that it specifically means leaning on one of the sides.
16:17 They also differed regarding the wisdom behind the prohibition; according to the first interpretation, it is so the eater does not consume too much food,
16:24 which would lead to obesity and an enlarged abdomen.
16:27 According to the second interpretation, which is leaning on one side,
16:32 it is said that this is the habit of the arrogant and those who eat gluttonously.
16:38 It is also said that one who eats while reclining does not allow the food to descend easily through its passage,
16:44 nor does it go down smoothly, and one might be harmed by it, so it is for a health-related reason.
16:51 As for eating while lying down, it is even more disliked, as some scholars have stated.
16:58 The hadith has more to follow, if Allah wills, and Allah knows best.
17:04 May the peace and blessings of Allah be upon our Prophet Muhammad, and upon all his family and companions.