The book of the elegance of knowledge among the wise | Episode (20) | The danger of scientific fatwas
Lesson summary
The lesson addresses the gravity of giving religious rulings (fatwa). The sheikh cites Imam Abd al-Rahman ibn Abi Layla, may Allah have mercy on him, who said that he would wish that his brother would suffice him in answering a question on a hadith or a ruling. The sheikh explains that a fatwa is a attribution to Allah, which is why the righteous feared it and passed it to others seeking safety. He contrasts the caution of the early scholars with the hastiness of those who came later, and mentions how Umar, may Allah be pleased with him, would gather the virtuous people of Badr for grave matters rather than rush to answer.
Key takeaways
- A fatwa is grave because it is an attribution to Allah, so the righteous fear it.
- Abd al-Rahman ibn Abi Layla said that a person would wish his brother would suffice him in answering a question on a hadith or ruling.
- Seeking safety and avoiding hardship lead to passing fatwas to others out of caution for one's religion.
- The safety of the scholar and the student lies in guarding the tongue, protecting the heart, and fearing Allah, the All-Knowing.
- Hasty speech and saying things about Allah without knowledge lead to error and sin.
- Umar, may Allah be pleased with him, gathered the virtuous people of Badr for grave matters and did not rush to answer, recognising the limits of the individual.
- Relying on the sound judgement and agreement of the majority is safer than hastening to pronounce a ruling.
Questions & answers
What is the danger of giving a fatwa without knowledge?
The sheikh explains that a fatwa is an attribution to Allah, and saying something about Allah without knowledge is among the gravest sins; the verse he cites links it with indecency and shirk.
Why did the early scholars pass fatwas to one another?
They understood its consequences and feared it, so one would wish his brother would answer instead, to avoid hardship and to preserve safety and religion.
How did the early scholars differ from those who came later regarding fatwa?
The early scholars were more careful and fearful of speaking about Allah without knowledge, whereas those after the best generations rushed to issue rulings, and ignorance spread and pretenders to knowledge appeared.
How did Umar, may Allah be pleased with him, handle grave matters?
He gathered the virtuous people of Badr and consulted them, without rushing to answer, knowing the individual's limited reason and mastery, so he relied on the agreement of the majority.
Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.
Qur’an verses cited in this lesson
- Al-A'raf 7:33 — Say: My Lord forbiddeth only indecencies, such of them as are apparent and such as are within, and sin and wrongful oppression, and that ye associate with Allah that for which no warrant hath been revealed, and that ye tell concerning Allah that which ye know not.
- Az-Zumar 39:9 — Is he who payeth adoration in the watches of the night, prostrate and standing, bewaring of the Hereafter and hoping for the mercy of his Lord, (to be accounted equal with a disbeliever)? Say (unto them, O Muhammad): Are those who know equal with those who know not? But only men of understanding will pay heed.
Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.