Part of Rawnaq Al-Ilm (series completed) · Lesson 31 of 50

The book of the elegance of knowledge among the wise | Episode (31) | The virtue of fairness

◉ 288 views ⏱ 3:52 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

The lesson addresses the virtue of fairness (al-insaf) in seeking knowledge. Quoting Imam al-Shawkani, may Allah have mercy on him, the speaker says the student of knowledge should accustom himself to fairness and to not being biased toward any school of thought or any scholar. The sheikh considers fairness and devotion to the truth among the most precious benefits of knowledge, and explains that infallibility belongs to the legal evidence, not to the jurist. The lesson cites Imam Ahmad, may Allah have mercy on him, who told people not to follow him blindly but to take from where the imams took, namely revelation. It encourages reading the works of opponents with respect and a search for truth, with the Book and the Sunnah as the criterion in disputes.

Key takeaways

  • Fairness and freedom from bias toward any school or scholar are among the greatest benefits of knowledge.
  • Infallibility belongs to the legal evidence, not to the jurist, who is human and may be right or wrong.
  • Scholarly courtesy that avoids criticism is a form of partisanship that turns one away from the truth.
  • Devotion to the truth and abandoning personal desire is the path to becoming a true scholar.
  • Take from the same sources the imams took, namely the Book and the Sunnah, rather than blind imitation.
  • Read the books of opponents with respect and a desire for truth, without partisanship for one jurisprudential school.
  • The Book and the Sunnah, with sound reasoning from them, are the judge in matters of disagreement.

Questions & answers

What is the virtue of fairness in seeking knowledge?

The sheikh holds that fairness and devotion to the truth are among the most precious benefits of knowledge, and that a student cannot be a true scholar until he devotes himself to knowledge, abandons desire, and lives by the evidence.

Is it obligatory to follow one particular scholar?

The lesson, quoting Imam al-Shawkani, states that no one in the Ummah is obliged to act upon the opinion of a single scholar or to follow him blindly, because infallibility belongs to the legal evidence and not to the scholar.

What did Imam Ahmad say about imitation?

Imam Ahmad, may Allah have mercy on him, said: Do not imitate me, nor Malik, al-Shafi'i, al-Awza'i or al-Thawri, but take from where they took, and the source of their taking was revelation.

How should a student deal with the books of opponents?

The sheikh advises reading the books of those who differ with us with respect, learning their views, and not being partisan to one jurisprudential school, since some school-based books belittle others.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Qur’an verses cited in this lesson

  • Az-Zumar 39:9 — Is he who payeth adoration in the watches of the night, prostrate and standing, bewaring of the Hereafter and hoping for the mercy of his Lord, (to be accounted equal with a disbeliever)? Say (unto them, O Muhammad): Are those who know equal with those who know not? But only men of understanding will pay heed.

Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:03 “Is he who payeth adoration in the watches of the night, prostrate and standing, bewaring of the Hereafter and hoping for the mercy of his Lord, (to be accounted equal with a disbeliever)? Say (unto them, O Muhammad): Are those who know equal with those who know not? But only men of understanding will pay heed.” (39:9)
0:10 The Splendor of Knowledge in Wisdom.
0:16 By Dr. Hamzah Ibn Fayi' Al Fathi.
0:21 May Allah preserve him: The Virtue of Fairness.
0:29 The great scholar Al Shawkani, may Allah have mercy on him, said:
0:35 Who passed away in the year 1250 AH.
0:40 If you prepare your soul, O student, for fairness,
0:44 And for avoiding partisanship toward any school of thought,
0:47 Or toward any specific scholar,
0:50 And instead regard all people as being on the same footing,
0:53 In that they all belong to the Sharia,
0:56 Governed by it in a way from which they can find no escape,
1:01 Nor can they turn away from it,
1:04 Let alone ascend to a position above that,
1:08 Where it would be mandatory for anyone in the Ummah to act,
1:12 According to the opinion of only one of them,
1:14 Or be bound to follow him and accept his word,
1:17 Then you have attained the greatest benefits of knowledge,
1:20 And gained its most precious treasures.
1:23 Among the most noble qualities of a student of knowledge,
1:27 Is preparing the soul for fairness and justice toward opponents,
1:31 In matters of debate, ijtihad, and critiques.
1:35 There is no sanctity for a school of thought, a sheikh, a method, or a book,
1:40 At the expense of a proof or an established text,
1:43 Or a transmitted consensus.
1:46 Infallibility belongs only to the legal proof,
1:49 Not to the scholar or the jurist,
1:51 Because he is a human being who is sometimes right and sometimes wrong,
1:54 And everyone’s opinion may be accepted or rejected,
1:57 Except for the occupant of the greatest grave, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him.
2:02 This is the most precious benefit of knowledge:
2:05 Fairness and devotion to the truth,
2:08 And showing no favoritism to anyone whatsoever,
2:12 Because academic sycophancy is a form of partisanship,
2:15 And a distancing from the truth,
2:17 And a corruption of the path and of ijtihad.
2:20 And in the Qur'an:
2:22 "Do not follow desire."
2:25 If a student is raised upon this,
2:28 His religion remains intact and his approach becomes wholesome,
2:31 His qualities improve, and his knowledge is blessed.
2:35 He will never be a true scholar,
2:39 Until he devotes himself to knowledge, casts aside desire,
2:43 Lives for the proof,
2:45 And follows the path of the Imams who preceded us,
2:48 By drinking from the ocean of the Book and the Sunnah,
2:51 Rather than the abyss of blind imitation and partisanship.
2:54 As Imam Ahmad, may Allah have mercy on him, said:
2:57 "Do not imitate me, nor imitate Malik, nor Al Shafi'i,
3:01 Nor Al Awza'i, nor Al Thawri,
3:04 But take from where they took."
3:06 And the source of their taking is the Revelation,
3:09 Not the venerated books of the school of thought,
3:11 Nor the reliance upon sheikhs,
3:13 Or the repetitive texts studied by students.
3:16 And Allah is the One whose help is sought.
3:18 How beautiful it is for jurists to read,
3:21 The books of those who disagree with them,
3:23 And to receive them with respect,
3:25 Without partisanship for one school of fiqh over another,
3:29 But rather seeking the truth,
3:31 And becoming acquainted with the views of their opponents,
3:35 Especially since some sectarian books,
3:38 Diminish the status or the proofs of others.
3:42 Our judge, for all of us, is the Book and the Sunnah,
3:45 And the proper application of evidence from them.
3:48 Peace.