Part of The Hadith of Umm Zar' (series completed) · Lesson 3 of 25

Types of men in the hadith of Umm Zara’ | Episode (3) | Do you believe a woman when she talks about her husband?

◉ 309 views ⏱ 10:06 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson timeline

  1. 00:00 Intro: Can a wife be trusted describing her husband?
  2. 01:00 The hadith of Umm Sulaym and women's modesty
  3. 02:02 A woman's modesty and how she expresses desire
  4. 03:02 How women's view of men has changed over time
  5. 04:02 The influence of internet culture and celebrities
  6. 05:02 A wife presenting her husband better than he is
  7. 06:02 The prohibition of boasting about what one lacks
  8. 07:04 Environment's effect on how a wife describes her husband
  9. 08:05 Aisha's hadith on contentment and anger
  10. 09:05 Fairness in speaking about one's husband and conclusion

Lesson summary

This episode addresses whether a woman's account of her husband can be trusted. The sheikh explains that women generally tend to present their husbands in the best light before others, which may not match reality. He cites the hadith of Umm Sulaym and the hadith of Asma on pretending to have what one has not been given, and shows how environment, culture, contentment and anger shape a woman's description of her husband. He concludes that a righteous woman maintains fairness in speaking of her husband, both in contentment and in anger, and follows the example of Aisha رضي الله عنها.

Key takeaways

  • Modesty is part of a woman's nature, so she often conceals matters related to her need for a man; a husband should not demand that his wife openly declare her desire, as hinting and quick responsiveness suffice.
  • Women naturally admire a man's bravery and strength, though this view has changed with shifting culture and ideas of independence from men.
  • Social media presents idealized images of celebrities that contradict reality, and a woman may discover the bitter truth after marriage.
  • The Prophet ﷺ forbade pretending to have what one was not given and counted it as a form of false speech, since it creates division between a woman and her co-wife.
  • The surrounding environment influences how a woman describes her husband: she portrays him as righteous in a righteous setting, or as generous and indulgent in a luxurious one.
  • Contentment and anger change a woman's description of her husband; only a righteous believing woman is safe from this flaw.
  • Being just in contentment and anger is among the saving qualities, so a woman neither diminishes her husband's rights nor elevates him above his station.

Questions & answers

Can a woman's account of her husband be trusted?

The sheikh explains that women generally do not give a fully accurate account of their husbands, as they tend to present them in the best possible light before other women, even if they live with them in hardship, and may exaggerate when they have a co-wife.

What is the ruling on pretending to have been given more by one's husband?

The sheikh notes that the one who pretends to have what was not given is like one who wears a garment of falsehood, and the Prophet ﷺ counted it as false speech, because it creates a false impression of virtue and divides a woman from her co-wife.

How can a woman be fair when speaking of her husband?

A righteous woman is fair in both contentment and anger: she does not diminish her husband's rights, nor raise him above his station, nor attribute to him flaws he does not have when she is angry, following the example of Aisha رضي الله عنها.

How do contentment and anger affect a woman's description of her husband?

The sheikh says that a content woman elevates her husband to the heavens, while an angry one lowers him to the lowest depths, and only a righteous believing woman is spared this flaw.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Entirely Merciful, the Especially Merciful.
0:03 Categories of Men in the Hadith of Umm Zar'.
0:16 Is a woman truthful when she speaks about her husband?
0:20 The answer to this question may come as a shock to men,
0:27 yet it is generally well known among women,
0:31 even if they conceal it from men.
0:34 For it is innate to a woman's nature
0:36 to hide some of her traits from a man,
0:39 even if such a trait is an intrinsic part of her disposition.
0:43 Consider, noble brother,
0:45 the statement of 'A'ishah, may Allah be pleased with her,
0:48 in the hadith of Anas Ibn Malik,
0:50 when he related:
0:52 Umm Sulaym came to the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,
0:56 and asked him,
0:58 while 'A'ishah was present with him:
1:00 "O Messenger of Allah,
1:02 a woman may experience in a dream what a man experiences,
1:05 seeing from herself what a man sees from himself."
1:09 Thereupon 'A'ishah said:
1:11 "O Umm Sulaym,
1:13 you have disgraced women! May your hands be covered with dust!"
1:16 So he said to 'A'ishah:
1:18 "Nay, rather may your hands be covered with dust!
1:20 Yes,
1:22 let Umm Sulaym perform ghusl
1:24 if she sees that."
1:26 Recorded by Muslim.
1:28 Al-Qadi 'Iyad, may Allah have mercy on him, said:
1:31 "'A'ishah's remark to Umm Sulaym,
1:33 'You have disgraced women,'
1:35 meant: you have exposed their secrets
1:37 and what they conceal of their desire for men
1:40 and experiencing wet dreams."
1:42 And Ibn Hajar, may Allah have mercy on him, remarked:
1:45 "This indicates that concealing such matters is customary for them."
1:50 Thus the Mother of the Believers
1:54 disliked that men should know that a woman desires a man
1:58 and that she experiences during sleep what a man experiences,
2:02 because this is something a woman is customarily shy about.
2:07 Therefore, it is inappropriate for a man to demand that his wife
2:11 explicitly state her desire for him
2:13 just as he explicitly states his desire for her,
2:16 because such a demand goes against a woman's natural disposition and modesty.
2:21 It is enough for her to hint, entice,
2:24 and respond swiftly to her husband.
2:27 To pose the question once more:
2:30 Is a woman truthful when she speaks about her husband?
2:34 Before answering this question,
2:37 we need to understand the nature of a woman's perception of her husband.
2:43 Al-Tahir Ibn 'Ashur, may Allah have mercy on him, observed:
2:46 "A woman deeply admires chivalry and valor in a man,
2:50 due to her own inability to do what men can do,
2:54 and because she sees in the valor of her husband and kinsfolk
2:58 that which sets her mind at ease against the threat of enemies and raids."
3:02 This is what women traditionally valued in their husbands in times past.
3:08 Has this disposition undergone any shift over time?
3:13 Yes, this natural inclination has indeed altered in some women
3:17 due to shifts in societal culture, female culture,
3:22 and a changing perception of men—
3:25 whether that man be a son, a brother,
3:29 a husband, or a guardian.
3:32 For among the ideas instilled in women today
3:35 is that she must be financially independent of men,
3:40 that she should take up any job merely to earn money,
3:44 that the concept of freedom requires her to reject
3:47 male authority in any form whatsoever,
3:51 that she has absolute autonomy in all her actions
3:55 without deferring to a man,
3:58 and that she must rebel against male guardianship
4:02 in order to become her own guardian.
4:04 All of this, alongside other notions disseminated among women,
4:09 has led to a shift in how a woman perceives a man.
4:13 So one wonders, in light of this modern culture,
4:16 what does a woman now value in a man?
4:19 And what will she boast about among other women?
4:22 The culture of the internet
4:26 and social media has engendered
4:29 a new archetype that a woman admires in a husband:
4:32 the archetype of fame,
4:35 and the celebrities who appear on these platforms
4:38 with an idealized image
4:40 that contradicts reality and truth,
4:42 misleading women.
4:45 Then, if a woman marries such a public figure,
4:49 she discovers the bitter reality.
4:52 Here the question arises once again:
4:55 Is a woman truthful when she speaks about her husband?
4:59 The hadith of Umm Zar' indicates
5:02 that women are often not truthful
5:05 when they speak about their husbands.
5:08 For that reason, they pledged and covenanted together
5:11 not to conceal anything regarding their husbands,
5:14 because they were fully aware
5:17 that a woman is typically not truthful when speaking of her husband;
5:20 rather, she strives to portray him
5:23 in the best possible light before other women
5:26 in order to boast of him over them,
5:29 even though she may be living with him amid injustice and severe harshness.
5:32 Yet before other women,
5:35 she displays the exact opposite.
5:38 This is especially true if a woman has a co-wife,
5:41 for she may feign satisfaction and abundance from her husband
5:44 merely to spite her co-wife.
5:47 As reported on the authority of Asma', may Allah be pleased with her,
5:50 a woman said: "O Messenger of Allah,
5:53 I have a co-wife;
5:56 would there be any blame on me if I pretend to have received from my husband
5:59 that which he did not give me?"
6:02 The Prophet, peace be upon him, replied:
6:05 "The one who pretends to have received what they were not given
6:08 is like one who wears two garments of falsehood."
6:12 The pretender is one who feigns satiety
6:15 while not being sated.
6:19 The meaning here is that she makes it seem
6:22 as though she has attained a favor
6:25 when she has not.
6:28 Thus the Prophet, peace be upon him, deemed her action
6:31 a form of prohibited falsehood.
6:34 He only disliked this for a woman
6:37 because it creates discord with the other woman,
6:40 acting like sorcery that drives a wedge between a man
6:43 and his wife.
6:46 Yet even this reality
6:49 has been affected by societal culture.
6:52 A woman today does not boast
6:55 of a man's physical strength, his courage,
6:58 or his fierce prowess in battle;
7:01 rather, she boasts of the degree of her dominance
7:04 over the man, among other things—
7:07 may Allah have mercy on the righteous women.
7:10 There are also other factors influencing
7:13 how a woman portrays her husband,
7:16 such as the social circle she frequents:
7:19 if it is a righteous environment,
7:22 she presents her husband as one of the righteous and ascetic;
7:25 if she is in an affluent environment,
7:28 she presents her husband as generous
7:31 and never refusing any of her requests;
7:34 and if among women who predominantly dominate their husbands,
7:37 she highlights the extent of her control
7:40 in dominating him.
7:43 Likewise, her state of contentment or anger plays a role:
7:46 if pleased, she elevates him to the heavens,
7:49 and if displeased, she casts him down
7:52 to the lowest of the low.
7:56 None escapes this pitfall
7:59 except the righteous, believing woman,
8:02 and her role model in that regard
8:05 is the Mother of the Believers, 'A'ishah, may Allah be pleased with her.
8:08 For on the authority of 'A'ishah, may Allah be pleased with her,
8:11 she said: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, said to me:
8:14 "I certainly know
8:17 when you are pleased with me
8:20 and when you are angry with me."
8:23 She said: I asked, "From where do you know that?"
8:26 He replied: "As for when
8:29 you are pleased with me,
8:32 you say: 'No, by the Lord of Muhammad';
8:35 and when you are angry with me,
8:38 you say: 'No, by the Lord of Ibrahim.'"
8:41 She said: I replied:
8:44 "Yes, by Allah, O Messenger of Allah,
8:47 I only omit your name."
8:50 Recorded by Al-Bukhari.
8:53 Indeed, the believing woman—
8:56 as stated in the hadith of Anas Ibn Malik
8:59 from the Prophet, peace be upon him, who
9:02 said: "Three things are destructive:
9:05 greed that is obeyed,
9:08 desire that is followed,
9:11 and a person being conceited with vanity;
9:14 and three things are salvific:
9:17 justice in contentment and anger,
9:20 moderation in wealth and poverty."
9:24 Recorded by Al-Tabarani in Al-Awsat.
9:27 She adheres to fairness
9:30 when speaking of her husband:
9:33 she does not deprive him of his due rights,
9:36 nor does she elevate him above his actual station,
9:39 nor does she claim virtues for him
9:42 that he does not possess,
9:45 nor does she attribute flaws to him
9:49 in moments of anger that are not in him.
9:52 And what is it that you love about your husband,
9:55 and what qualities do you cherish in him?
9:59 We shall continue in the next gathering, if Allah wills.
10:02 And all praise is due to Allah, Lord of the worlds.