Part of The Gentle Commentary (series completed) · Lesson 54 of 117

The nice comment on the book of cards identifying the surahs of the Holy Qur’an | D. Muhammad Nassif | Surat Al-Saff

◉ 219 views ⏱ 8:31 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

In this installment of the series Al-Ta'liq Al-Latif, the lecturer presents three observations on Surah As-Saff: first, a correction to how the opening of the surah is described so that it fits the book's own method; second, the surah's connection to the preceding Al-Mumtahanah, where purifying the hearts from allegiance to disbelievers comes before fighting them; and third, the dating of its revelation and the multiple narrations of its cause. He notes that the cause of revelation mentioned in the book is incomplete, and that the surah was revealed all at once.

Key takeaways

  • The surah opens with a declarative sentence, and it belongs among the surahs that begin with glorification (tasbih), a correction of the wording used in the book, in line with the book's own method.
  • The opening with glorification covers types of praise such as tasbih, tahmid and tabrik, so the surah is classed among those that begin with tasbih.
  • The variation in opening formulas is explained not merely by chronological sequence but by the fit of each formula to the setting (maqam) of each surah.
  • Purification comes before adornment: cleansing the hearts from allegiance to disbelievers precedes fighting them, which is the link between As-Saff and the preceding surah.
  • The cause of revelation cited in the book is incomplete; the full narration shows the Prophet ﷺ recited the whole surah, and that it was revealed in one go.
  • Multiple narrations of the cause help pin down the date of revelation by gathering the chains and noting names of Companions, events and places.
  • Authentic causes of revelation are drawn from the book cited by Dr. Usama al-Humaydan, and other causes exist that were not included because they did not meet the book's conditions.

Questions & answers

How is the opening of Surah As-Saff described in this explanation?

The lecturer says the surah opens with a declarative sentence and is among the surahs beginning with tasbih, since types of praise such as tasbih, tahmid and tabrik fall under this category, consistent with the book's method.

What is the connection between Surah As-Saff and Surah Al-Mumtahanah before it?

The lecturer explains that Al-Mumtahanah commands purifying the hearts from allegiance to disbelievers, and this purification precedes the fighting discussed in As-Saff: purification (takhliyah) comes before adornment (tahliyah).

Was Surah As-Saff revealed all at once?

Yes, according to the full narration the lecturer cites, the Prophet ﷺ recited the entire surah, indicating it was revealed in one go.

Why are multiple narrations of the cause of revelation useful?

Gathering the chains can mention Companions whose timelines are known, or events and places, which helps determine the date of revelation precisely with knowledge of the biography of the Prophet ﷺ.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Qur’an verses cited in this lesson

  • Al-Hadid 57:1 — All that is in the heavens and the earth glorifieth Allah; and He is the Mighty, the Wise.

Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:30 "The Graceful Commentary
0:32 on the Book of Introductory Profiles
0:35 to the Surahs of the Noble Qur'an"
0:38 by Dr. Muhammad ibn 'Abd al-'Aziz ibn 'Umar Nassif,
0:42 may Allah preserve him.
0:44 Surah al-Saff.
0:46 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:48 Praise be to Allah, Lord of the worlds,
0:50 and may peace and blessings
0:52 be upon the Seal of the Prophets and Messengers,
0:55 and upon all his family and Companions.
0:57 We continue with our graceful commentary
0:59 on the introductory profiles,
1:01 and we have arrived at Surah al-Saff.
1:03 I have three observations regarding it.
1:06 The first observation
1:08 concerns what was mentioned about the opening of the surah.
1:10 He stated that it opens
1:12 with a declarative sentence,
1:14 and that it is among the surahs that begin
1:17 with glorification (tasbih).
1:19 In truth,
1:21 this is not consistent
1:23 with the methodology of the book
1:25 as established earlier in Surah al-Isra'
1:27 and in the introduction of the book.
1:29 If you look at the beginning of the book,
1:31 on pages fourteen and fifteen,
1:33 you will find a lengthy citation
1:35 from Imam al-Suyuti
1:37 explaining the various types of surah openings.
1:39 What he mentioned
1:41 is a fine scholarly effort (ijtihad),
1:43 though it may be contested in certain aspects.
1:45 However, if one adheres
1:47 throughout the book, as noted there,
1:49 to what Imam al-Suyuti mentioned,
1:51 then consequently,
1:54 the most precise phrasing here,
1:56 which is appropriate and consistent
1:58 with what preceded in Surah al-Isra',
2:00 is to say:
2:02 "It opens with a sentence
2:04 of praise (thanā'),"
2:06 which is one of the categories mentioned
2:08 in *Al-Itqan*.
2:10 Thus, we should say: "It opens with a sentence of praise,
2:12 and it is among the surahs
2:14 that begin with glorification," because praise
2:16 encompasses various forms, as previously noted:
2:18 among them is tasbih (glorification),
2:20 tahmid (praise), and tabrik (exaltation of blessings).
2:22 Therefore, it is among the surahs that begin with tasbih,
2:24 so it should read:
2:26 "It opens with a declarative sentence [of praise],
2:28 and it is among the surahs that begin with tasbih."
2:30 It may also be added
2:32 that it opens with a verb
2:34 in the past tense.
2:36 If you return to that same passage,
2:38 you will find an explanation
2:40 for that on page
2:43 fourteen
2:45 specifically.
2:47 I mentioned page fourteen,
2:49 or page fifteen,
2:51 where this quotation appears:
2:53 "Glorification is an expression reserved exclusively for Allah;
2:55 thus, He began with the verbal noun (masdar)
2:57 in [the Surah of] the Children of Israel (Bani Isra'il),"
2:59 meaning in Surah al-Isra', where He said, "Exalted is He
3:01 who took His Servant by night..."
3:03 He stated: "Because it is the root form;
3:05 the root of derived words
3:07 is the verbal noun"—
3:09 although this is actually a contested linguistic issue.
3:11 He continued: "Then with the past tense in al-Hadid and al-Hashr,
3:13 because it is the earlier of the two timeframes;
3:15 for we have the past tense
3:17 and we have the present tense,
3:19 and of the two, the past is prior."
3:21 Thus, He began with al-Hadid and al-Hashr.
3:23 He continued: "Then with the present/imperfect tense in al-Jumu'ah
3:25 and al-Taghabun,"
3:27 meaning the timeframe of the present and the future.
3:29 Then he stated: "Then with the imperative form in al-A'la,"
3:31 and the imperative pertains to the future.
3:33 He explained: "In order to encompass
3:35 this word from all its grammatical facets."
3:37 While what he mentioned
3:39 is subtly insightful in itself,
3:41 it is not the most precise explanation
3:43 for such stylistic variation.
3:45 Rather, this variation is grounded in
3:47 contextual suitability.
3:49 For each surah has its own context
3:51 and its own core purpose,
3:53 and the grammatical form arrives
3:55 perfectly suited to that context.
3:57 I have devoted specialized research to this,
3:59 including a study
4:01 dedicated specifically to these
4:03 openings featuring glorification,
4:05 detailing the distinctions
4:07 between them and the appropriateness of each
4:09 to its specific context,
4:11 while considering the verse in its entirety.
4:13 “All that is in the heavens and the earth glorifieth Allah; and He is the Mighty, the Wise.” (57:1)
4:15 Thus,
4:17 the formulation varies
4:19 across the entire verse,
4:21 which is
4:23 a delightful topic of study
4:25 indeed,
4:27 and one that requires
4:29 deep reflection.
4:31 As for the second
4:33 observation,
4:35 it concerns what was mentioned
4:37 regarding the thematic placement of the surah.
4:39 It was noted therein
4:41 regarding its correlation with al-Mumtahanah
4:43 that it commands
4:45 fighting in Allah's cause.
4:47 In truth, this matter
4:49 is very important.
4:51 As scholars of spiritual purification always say:
4:53 "Purging impurities precedes adorning with virtues (al-takhliyah qabl al-tahliyah)."
4:55 It is essential
4:57 first to purify
4:59 hearts from every
5:01 sentiment
5:03 that does not please Allah, the Exalted and Glorified,
5:05 which includes
5:08 loyalty to the disbelievers
5:10 and taking them as close allies.
5:12 Thus, the fighting mentioned in al-Mumtahanah—
5:14 the preceding surah—
5:16 purifies the hearts of the believers
5:18 from this taint.
5:20 And it is a taint that directly affects
5:22 what is addressed in this surah,
5:24 for the believers fighting
5:26 in unified ranks and in solidarity
5:28 requires beforehand,
5:30 or necessitates prior to it, the cleansing of their hearts
5:32 and their purification
5:34 from the impurities of allegiance to disbelievers.
5:36 Thus, between the two surahs, there is
5:38 a clear thematic harmony and mutual reinforcement.
5:40 As I said, this relates to the principle of purging
5:42 occurring before
5:44 adorning.
5:46 Fighting the disbelievers is an act of adornment,
5:48 but prior to it, the heart must be purged
5:50 of these impurities.
5:52 As for the third
5:54 observation,
5:56 it concerns what was stated regarding the chronological order of the surah's revelation,
5:58 where it was stated at the end:
6:00 "And its multiple revelation narratives
6:02 may help in
6:04 dating its revelation."
6:06 Regarding its multiple revelation narratives:
6:08 when we consult the occasion of revelation (sabab al-nuzul),
6:10 we find only a single occasion.
6:12 Before I conclude this point,
6:14 I wish to make a brief digression and say:
6:16 the occasion of revelation mentioned
6:18 is incomplete.
6:20 If you refer to the *Musnad* of Ahmad,
6:22 you will find it in full,
6:24 and in its completion, it states that the entire surah
6:26 was revealed,
6:28 contrary to the apparent meaning of this text.
6:30 For the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) recited to us:
6:32 "Whatever is in the heavens and whatever is on the earth glorifies Allah..."
6:34 up to His words: "...most hateful in the sight of Allah,"
6:36 and then the rest of the narration mentions that he
6:38 completed the entire surah.
6:40 This has a significant bearing
6:42 on its revelation,
6:44 as it was revealed all at once.
6:46 Consequently, if its date of revelation is identified,
6:48 whether approximately or precisely,
6:50 it encompasses every single one of its verses.
6:52 Returning to the multiple narratives of its revelation:
6:54 how can there be multiple narratives when we have
6:56 only one occasion?
6:58 This comes down to two matters:
7:00 first, that this single occasion has
7:02 multiple transmission chains (riwayat),
7:04 which can be helpful, because by compiling them,
7:06 mention might be made of one
7:08 of the Companions whose date
7:10 of accepting Islam is known, or
7:12 the date of his martyrdom, and so forth.
7:14 This aids us in achieving precise
7:16 a meticulous compilation of the transmission chains.
7:18 Some names may be mentioned,
7:20 or certain events or places,
7:22 which, through our knowledge of the Seerah, aid us
7:24 in determining the precise dating
7:26 of revelation. And we say "may",
7:28 because this comprehensive research has not yet been conducted,
7:30 so one might arrive,
7:32 after collecting these narrations,
7:34 at a precise determination
7:36 of the date of revelation.
7:38 Furthermore, regarding the multiplicity of narrations from another perspective,
7:40 of course, only one occasion of revelation was mentioned here,
7:42 but there are other reasons
7:44 mentioned in other books.
7:46 I have only restricted myself—as I have explained
7:48 on multiple occasions
7:50 and in the book itself—
7:52 to the book *Al-Sahih min Asbab al-Nuzul*
7:54 by Shaykh Dr. Issam Al-Humaydan,
7:56 which is the adopted source in this work.
7:58 Other narrations of reasons for revelation have also been reported
8:00 that likewise aid in knowing
8:02 the precise date of revelation.
8:04 Thus, the narrations
8:06 regarding the occasion itself are numerous,
8:08 and they help; and there are other narrations
8:10 not mentioned here because they do not meet the criteria of
8:12 the book, which are also helpful.
8:14 I will conclude with this much regarding Surah As-Saff,
8:16 and I ask Allah
8:18 to illuminate my heart and yours,
8:20 and my path and yours,
8:22 through the Magnificent Qur'an.
8:24 May Allah send blessings upon our Prophet Muhammad,
8:26 and upon all his family and Companions,
8:28 and praise be to Allah, Lord of the worlds.