Part of The Gentle Commentary (series completed) · Lesson 79 of 117

The nice comment on the book of cards identifying the surahs of the Holy Qur’an | D. Muhammad Nassif | Surah Yasin

◉ 154 views ⏱ 5:58 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

In this final episode of the series Al-Ta'leeq Al-Latif on the book Bitaqat At-Ta'reef bi-Suwar Al-Mushaf Ash-Sharif, the sheikh discusses Surah Yasin and addresses three points: correcting the numbering of some verses in the surah's sections, discussing a reported occasion of revelation, and explaining the arrangement of its sections. He explains that the opening of the surah describes the severity of the disbelievers' denial, followed by the story of the People of the Town, which has no parallel in the Quran and fits the theme of intense rejection. He then mentions the signs of Allah addressed specifically to them. He concludes that the surah aims to awaken the heedless by warning of punishments and reminding of blessings.

Key takeaways

  • Correcting the numbering of some verses in the surah's sections, noting where the discrepancy lies.
  • Explaining that a reported occasion of revelation with a clear, authentic chain does not prevent a Meccan surah from containing a Medinan verse, and that there is no difficulty in this in itself.
  • Weakening the reported occasion of revelation linked to the Banu Salama, because its chain is weak and it contradicts what is in the Sahih, as detailed in the book Al-Muharrar.
  • The fit between the opening of the surah, which describes the disbelievers' severity with shackles, raised heads and barriers, and what follows about their condition.
  • The story of the People of the Town is unique: three messengers were sent to one town, and the Quran has no parallel to it.
  • The repetition of 'and a sign for them' in the second section, highlighting the intensity of their denial and urging gratitude to Allah.
  • The surah's purpose is to awaken the heedless through warning of punishments and reminding of blessings.

Questions & answers

What is the general purpose of Surah Yasin according to this episode?

The sheikh explains that the surah aims to awaken the heedless, by warning of punishments as in the story of the People of the Town, and by reminding of blessings as in the verses about the night, the day and the laden ship.

Can a Meccan surah contain a Medinan verse?

The sheikh explains that if a reported occasion of revelation has a sound chain and clearly states causation, it may be considered that a verse of a Meccan surah was revealed in Medina, and there is no problem with this. However, the occasion mentioned for Surah Yasin has a weak chain and contradicts the Sahih, so it is not relied upon.

Why is the story of the People of the Town distinctive in the Quran?

Because it is a unique story not mentioned elsewhere, in which three messengers were sent to one town, with no parallel in the Quran. It comes to illustrate the intensity of the denial mentioned before it.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Qur’an verses cited in this lesson

  • Ya-Sin 36:9 — And We have set a bar before them and a bar behind them, and (thus) have covered them so that they see not.
  • Ya-Sin 36:14 — When We sent unto them twain, and they denied them both, so We reinforced them with a third, and they said: Lo! we have been sent unto you.
  • Ya-Sin 36:33 — A token unto them is the dead earth. We revive it, and We bring forth from it grain so that they eat thereof;
  • Ya-Sin 36:37 — A token unto them is night. We strip it of the day, and lo! they are in darkness.

Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:30 A Gentle Commentary
0:32 on the book *Profile Cards*
0:35 *for the Surahs of the Noble Qur'an*
0:38 by Dr. Muhammad Ibn 'Abd al-'Aziz Ibn 'Umar Nasif,
0:42 may Allah preserve him.
0:44 Surah Ya-Sin.
0:46 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:48 Praise be to Allah, Lord of the worlds,
0:50 and may peace and blessings be upon the seal of the prophets and messengers,
0:53 and upon his family and all his companions.
0:55 We are still with *A Gentle Commentary on the Profile Cards*,
0:58 and we have arrived at Surah Ya-Sin.
1:02 I have three points to make regarding it.
1:05 The first point is a very brief correction of some verse numbers
1:10 in the structural sections of the Surah.
1:12 The introduction runs from the first verse to the twelfth verse,
1:16 contrary to what is written.
1:18 The first section is from verse thirteen
1:20 to verse thirty,
1:22 also contrary to what is written there.
1:24 As for the second section, it begins at verse thirty-one,
1:28 up to verse seventy, which is correct,
1:30 just as written.
1:33 As for the sub-sections, they are:
1:35 thirty-one, then forty-eight, and then
1:37 sixty-six.
1:39 This pertains to the sections of the Surah.
1:44 As for the second point,
1:46 it concerns what was noted regarding the reasons for revelation (asbab al-nuzul).
1:49 The author mentioned two reasons, the first of which would make part of the Surah
1:52 Medinan, but this view is questionable.
1:54 Here I wish to point out something:
1:56 sometimes an occasion of revelation is transmitted
1:58 with an authentic chain of narration
2:01 and is explicit regarding causality,
2:03 showing that a verse
2:05 within a Meccan Surah
2:07 is Medinan, or vice versa.
2:09 There is nothing wrong with this,
2:11 nor is it problematic.
2:13 One should not object to this
2:15 by saying, "This Surah is Meccan, so how can an exception be made?"
2:17 Exceptions are entirely permissible.
2:19 However, the cited reason here
2:21 is that Banu Salimah
2:23 complained to the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,
2:25 about their homes being far from the mosque, so the verse was revealed,
2:27 and they remained in their dwellings.
2:29 This reported reason
2:31 is questionable from the standpoint of its chain of transmission.
2:33 Otherwise, had it been authentic,
2:35 uncontradicted, and explicit,
2:37 it would have been accepted, just as we saw
2:39 in Surah Hud, which is Meccan,
2:41 yet the verse, "And establish
2:43 prayer at the two ends of the day," was excepted from it and deemed Medinan.
2:45 This presents no problem whatsoever.
2:47 Here, however, the chain of narration
2:49 contains weakness,
2:51 and it contradicts
2:53 what is in the *Sahih*,
2:55 which makes no mention of this occasion of revelation.
2:57 This reinforces its deeming as weak,
2:59 as detailed in the book *Al-Muharrar*.
3:01 The book we rely upon here,
3:03 as I mentioned to you, is moderate in its critical evaluation;
3:05 at times it simply accepts the authentications of certain scholars.
3:07 Otherwise,
3:09 the soundest view—and Allah knows best—
3:11 which was adopted in the book *Al-Muharrar*
3:13 *fi Asbab al-Nuzul*
3:15 *min al-Kutub al-Tis'ah*,
3:17 is that this report is weak,
3:19 and its text is contradicted
3:21 from multiple angles.
3:23 Consequently, it cannot be relied upon
3:25 as an occasion of revelation.
3:27 Now, the third point
3:29 concerns the thematic segments of the Surah.
3:31 In truth, we observe that the introduction to the Surah
3:33 contains
3:35 a depiction of the sheer severity of the disbelievers' rejection
3:37 unlike anything illustrated in any other Surah.
3:39 He said, "Indeed, We have placed shackles upon their necks,
3:41 and they are up to their chins, so their heads are forced back,"
3:43 “And We have set a bar before them and a bar behind them, and (thus) have covered them so that they see not.” (36:9)
3:45 "...a barrier, and behind them..."
3:47 is not described in any other Surah.
3:49 This profound description
3:51 of the obstinacy of their disbelief
3:53 perfectly harmonizes with
3:55 the first section, which contains
3:57 the story of the people of the town.
3:59 It is a unique story,
4:01 unlike any other recounted in the Qur'an;
4:03 it is mentioned only in this passage,
4:05 and no parallel to it appears elsewhere in the Qur'an,
4:07 as it mentions three messengers
4:09 sent to a single town,
4:11 assigned to a single town,
4:13 assigned to a single town,
4:15 one single town:
4:17 "And present to them an example: the people of the city,
4:19 when the messengers came to it—
4:21 “When We sent unto them twain, and they denied them both, so We reinforced them with a third, and they said: Lo! we have been sent unto you.” (36:14)
4:23 when We sent to them two but they denied them, so We strengthened them with a third."
4:25 There is nothing like this
4:27 in the Qur'an.
4:29 Thus, this parable came
4:31 in complete accord with the preceding verses
4:33 in demonstrating the intensity of their denial.
4:35 Then follows the second section,
4:37 in which there are
4:39 tremendous signs.
4:41 We also observe a stylistic usage
4:43 not repeated elsewhere in the Qur'an,
4:45 namely His saying:
4:47 "And a sign for them..."
4:49 three times:
4:51 "And a sign for them..."
4:53 “A token unto them is night. We strip it of the day, and lo! they are in darkness.” (36:37)
4:55 "...and behold, they are plunged into darkness," and before it,
4:57 “A token unto them is the dead earth. We revive it, and We bring forth from it grain so that they eat thereof;” (36:33)
4:59 "...and We gave it life..."
5:01 Then He said, "And a sign for them is the night;
5:03 We strip from it the day..."
5:05 Then He said, "And a sign for them
5:07 is that We carried their forefathers in the laden ship."
5:09 Then He described their condition:
5:11 "We strip from it the day..."
5:13 Then He said, "And no sign comes to them from the signs of their Lord
5:15 except that they turn away from it."
5:17 Rather, they used to mock
5:19 and deny, saying, as He stated,
5:21 "When is this promise, if you should be truthful?"
5:23 Thus, this reminder
5:25 of the divine signs
5:27 and specifying that they were given "for them"
5:29 was suited to the sheer extremity of their denial,
5:31 urging them to
5:33 show gratitude to Allah, Glorified and Exalted is He.
5:35 For this reason, it arrived
5:37 as the central theme of the Surah:
5:39 awakening the heedless
5:41 by warning of divine retribution—
5:43 as recounted in the story of the town—
5:45 and reminding them of divine blessings,
5:47 as shown in these verses.
5:49 I ask Allah to grant success to me and to you
5:51 in that which He loves and is pleased with.
5:53 May the peace and blessings of Allah be upon our Prophet Muhammad, and upon his family and all his companions.
5:55 And all praise is due to Allah, Lord of the worlds.