Part of The Gentle Commentary (series completed) · Lesson 109 of 117

The nice comment on the book of cards identifying the surahs of the Holy Qur’an | D. Muhammad Nassif | Surah Al-An'am

◉ 244 views ⏱ 5:23 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

In this commentary on Surah Al-An'am, the sheikh presents three reflections: first, on the occasions of revelation, noting that the reliable reference work lists eight causes for this surah, and that occasions of revelation are fewer for Meccan surahs than Medinan ones because the details of the Prophet's ﷺ biography in Mecca are less known. Second, on the dating of revelation, which is harder for Meccan surahs, so one should be cautious with anyone who asserts a specific year for a Meccan surah. Third, on the surah's sections, which fall into two parts that both return to its opening: making Allah known and expressing wonder at the disbelievers' conduct, and further making Allah known while expressing wonder at the disbelievers' prohibitions and legislation for themselves. The sheikh notes that the surah's knowledge of Allah is unmatched by most others, and some scholars compared it to Surah Al-Baqarah among the Medinan surahs.

Key takeaways

  • A clarification that the eight occasions mentioned come from the reliable reference work, not that they are every occasion reported in books on the causes of revelation.
  • The occasions of revelation for Meccan surahs are fewer than for Medinan ones, because the Prophet's ﷺ biography in Medina is known in far more detail.
  • Dating a Meccan surah precisely is difficult, unlike a Medinan surah tied to well-known events.
  • Caution is advised when someone asserts the year of revelation of a Meccan surah, since many such claims rest on taste and reflection and may contain errors.
  • Surah Al-An'am falls into two parts that both return to its opening: making Allah known, and expressing wonder at the disbelievers.
  • The surah offers an unusually full account of knowing Allah, to the point that some scholars likened it to Surah Al-Baqarah among the Medinan surahs, since Al-Baqarah gathers most rulings while Al-An'am gathers the foundations of belief.
  • The sheikh points out that a Meccan surah may be closely linked to another surah in its theme, a matter worth reflecting on.

Questions & answers

What are the causes of revelation of Surah Al-An'am?

The sheikh notes that the reliable reference work lists eight causes for this surah, and this does not mean that the causes of revelation are limited to them.

Why is it hard to determine the date of revelation of a Meccan surah?

Because the occasions and detailed events in Mecca are fewer, there are not the many reports that pin down the date of revelation precisely, as there are for Medinan surahs.

What are the main themes of Surah Al-An'am according to the sheikh?

The surah is built on making Allah known and expressing wonder at the disbelievers' conduct, as well as their prohibitions and their legislating for themselves what Allah has not sent down authority for.

What is the link between Surah Al-An'am and Surah Al-Baqarah?

Some scholars said that Al-An'am among the Meccan surahs is like Al-Baqarah among the Medinan ones: Al-Baqarah gathers most of the rulings, and Al-An'am gathers the foundations of belief.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:02 Concise commentary
0:32 on the book *Introductory Cards*
0:35 *for the Surahs of the Noble Qur'an*
0:37 by Dr. Muhammad ibn 'Abd al-'Aziz ibn 'Umar Naseef,
0:42 may Allah preserve him.
0:44 Surah al-An'am.
0:46 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:48 Praise be to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah.
0:51 We are still engaging with this concise commentary,
0:53 and today we arrive at Surah al-An'am.
0:56 I would like to make three brief points regarding it.
0:58 The first point
1:00 concerns the occasions of revelation.
1:02 The author mentions eight occasions for this surah.
1:04 Of course, I have explained before
1:06 that this is according to
1:08 the reference book adopted here, namely
1:10 *Al-Sahih min Asbab al-Nuzul* (The Authentic Occasions of Revelation).
1:12 It does not mean that
1:15 no other occasions of revelation were mentioned
1:17 except these eight across all books of
1:19 occasions of revelation—
1:21 that would be incorrect.
1:23 Rather, the intended meaning of the adopted reference text
1:25 is the authentic occasions of revelation.
1:27 However, I wanted to address
1:29 another matter, which is
1:31 that having only eight occasions
1:33 across more than twenty pages—
1:35 given the length of this surah, which
1:37 is not far removed
1:39 from Al 'Imran
1:41 and An-Nisa' in length—
1:43 why are there so few
1:45 occasions of revelation cited for it?
1:48 The truth is that occasions of revelation
1:50 in Meccan surahs are few
1:52 when compared to Medinan ones.
1:54 That is because in the Prophetic biography (Seerah),
1:56 we know
1:58 its details regarding the Medinan period far more
2:00 than we know of its details
2:02 regarding the Meccan period.
2:04 This brings us to the second point,
2:06 which is the dating
2:08 of revelation—a distinct issue,
2:10 as we agreed previously.
2:12 Dating revelation during the Meccan period
2:14 is difficult. It is easy
2:16 to date a Medinan surah in most cases;
2:18 indeed, sometimes you know that
2:20 an entire surah was connected
2:22 to a specific year,
2:24 even if the surah is long,
2:26 or medium-length spanning ten
2:28 pages, such as Surah al-Anfal.
2:30 But in Meccan surahs,
2:32 you might find a short surah,
2:34 such as al-Qari'ah or at-Takathur,
2:36 or others,
2:38 and yet you cannot determine
2:40 a precise date for its revelation.
2:42 Therefore, you often find
2:45 scholarly opinions regarding Meccan surahs
2:47 and their dating
2:49 that rely merely on
2:51 subjective taste and textual reflection,
2:53 which can contain flaws
2:55 or represent weak opinions
2:57 lacking solid evidence—
2:59 unlike Medinan surahs,
3:01 where the abundance of narrations
3:03 regarding occasions of revelation and other
3:05 biographical events makes it easy
3:07 for us to know
3:10 the date of revelation with precision.
3:12 For instance, consider the difference with the Isra' (Night Journey):
3:14 when did the Isra' occur?
3:16 There is a long-standing disagreement.
3:18 You do not find such disagreement regarding the timing of
3:20 Badr, Uhud, or other events;
3:22 if you do find disagreement, it is minor
3:24 or due to differences in terminology,
3:26 which is addressed elsewhere.
3:28 The point is that dating the revelation of Meccan surahs
3:30 is far more difficult. So when you see
3:32 someone speaking about a Meccan surah
3:34 and asserting that a certain surah was revealed in such-and-such a year,
3:36 exercise caution—
3:38 especially regarding Meccan surahs—
3:40 for overreaching has occurred
3:42 in a number of studies and books.
3:44 The third
3:47 and final point regarding Surah al-An'am
3:49 concerns its main sections.
3:51 It can be divided into two parts:
3:53 A part that introduces Allah
3:55 and expresses wonder
3:58 at the disbelief of the disbelievers,
4:00 which is evident from the very first verse of the surah:
4:02 "Praise be to Allah, who
4:04 created the heavens and the earth
4:06 and made the darknesses and the light."
4:08 It introduces Allah, then says: "Yet those who
4:10 disbelieve equate others with their Lord,"
4:12 expressing astonishment at the state of the disbelievers.
4:14 In the second part,
4:16 there is further introduction to Allah,
4:19 as well as astonishment at the prohibitions imposed by the disbelievers
4:22 and their legislating for themselves
4:24 things for which Allah sent down no authority,
4:26 along with an exposition of the true prohibitions.
4:28 Thus, both parts trace back
4:30 to the beginning of the surah.
4:32 I want to emphasize that the introduction
4:34 to Allah in this surah
4:36 is perhaps unmatched by
4:38 any other surah,
4:40 because it is a long surah—
4:42 among the longest Meccan surahs—
4:44 and it is filled with introducing Allah,
4:46 to the extent that some
4:48 scholars noted that it is
4:50 like Surah al-Baqarah
4:52 among Medinan surahs.
4:54 Surah al-Baqarah encompasses
4:56 most of the legal rulings, whereas this surah
4:58 encompasses the fundamentals of creed.
5:00 It is as if the Medinan surahs
5:02 are an elaboration of al-Baqarah, and as if
5:04 the Meccan surahs are all linked
5:06 to Surah al-An'am—a concept
5:08 truly worth pondering.
5:10 With this, I conclude my commentary
5:12 on Surah al-An'am.
5:14 I ask Allah to fill our hearts with His recognition,
5:16 and may Allah send blessings upon our Prophet Muhammad,
5:18 and upon his family and all his Companions.
5:20 Praise be to Allah, Lord of the worlds.