Part of The Gentle Commentary (series completed) · Lesson 112 of 117

Nice comment on the identification cards of the surahs of the Holy Qur’an | D. Muhammad Nassif | Surah Al-Fatihah

◉ 3754 views ⏱ 6:55 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

In this episode of the "Al-Ta'liq al-Latif" series on the book Bitaqat al-Ta'rif bi-Suwar al-Mushaf al-Sharif by Dr. Muhammad Nusayf, the lecturer studies Surat al-Fatiha in three points: its place in the order of revelation, a critique of the well-known narration on the order of revelation in terms of its chain, its text and its arrangement, and finally the great status of the surah. He urges learning its meanings by reading its tafsir and contemplating it in prayer, since it gathers the aims of the Quran and is the key to understanding what follows.

Key takeaways

  • Al-Fatiha is not mentioned in the well-known narration on the order of revelation, and it appears to have been revealed very early; the lecturer notes an error in the book's footnote.
  • The well-known narration has weakness in its chain, but scholars relied on it because of its fame, and its weakness does not entirely discard it.
  • Al-Tahir ibn Ashur is cited as among the best to critique the text of this narration, whereas most who relied on it transmitted it without close scrutiny.
  • The lecturer relies on Abu 'Amr al-Dani's narration in al-Bayan fi 'Add Ayat al-Quran because it has a chain, and it does not mention al-Fatiha.
  • Al-Fatiha is the greatest surah of the Quran; it summarizes the Quran and encompasses all its aims.
  • He advises reading a tafsir of al-Fatiha each month that one has not read before, such as Ibn Kathir and al-Qurtubi, as this renews knowledge and adds new insights.
  • Al-Fatiha is the key to understanding what follows in the Quran, and it should be contemplated in prayer rather than passed over quickly; the hadith indicates that prayer is divided between Allah and His servant, and that al-Fatiha is the prayer.

Questions & answers

Is Surat al-Fatiha mentioned in the order of revelation of the surahs?

The lecturer explains that al-Fatiha is not mentioned in the well-known narration on the order of revelation, and it appears to have been revealed very early. He relies on Abu 'Amr al-Dani's narration because it has a chain and does not mention al-Fatiha.

What is the benefit of studying the tafsir of al-Fatiha and how should I use it?

The lecturer advises reading a tafsir of al-Fatiha each month that you have not read before, such as Ibn Kathir or al-Qurtubi, because this renews what you know and adds new meanings to it.

Why is it recommended to contemplate al-Fatiha in prayer?

Because it is the greatest thing the worshipper recites or hears in prayer, it gathers the aims of the Quran, and it is the key to understanding everything after it. The hadith indicates that the prayer is divided between Allah and His servant, and that al-Fatiha is the prayer.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:30 A Gentle Commentary
0:32 on the book "Identification Cards
0:35 for the Surahs of the Noble Mus-haf"
0:38 by Dr. Muhammad ibn 'Abd al-'Aziz ibn 'Umar Nasif,
0:42 may Allah preserve him.
0:44 Surah al-Fatihah.
0:46 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:48 All praise is due to Allah, the Lord of the worlds,
0:50 and may peace and blessings be upon the Seal of the Prophets and Messengers.
0:53 Our lesson today, within the gentle commentary
0:56 on the identification cards,
0:58 focuses on Surah al-Fatihah.
1:00 Discussion on this surah could easily be vast and prolonged,
1:04 but I shall confine myself to three main points.
1:09 The first point
1:12 concerns the author's text regarding the chronological order of its revelation.
1:15 Surah al-Fatihah is not mentioned
1:18 in the well-known transmission concerning the chronological order of revelation,
1:21 although it is evident that it was revealed very early on.
1:26 In the footnote,
1:28 I indicated what is actually intended
1:30 by the well-known transmission,
1:32 contrary to what appears in the printed book.
1:35 For the author confined himself in the footnote
1:37 to citing
1:39 another weak transmission
1:41 that ought not to have been mentioned.
1:43 Anyone who has the book will find
1:47 this flaw in the footnote
1:50 on page nineteen.
1:52 As for the second point,
1:54 it concerns the analysis of this narration itself:
1:56 this well-known transmission
1:58 upon which I relied.
2:00 I will address it from three perspectives.
2:02 First, its chain of transmission (isnad):
2:04 its isnad contains weakness.
2:06 Although some contemporary researchers declared it strong,
2:09 they did so without any clear evidence.
2:11 Nevertheless, the scholars
2:13 relied upon it due to its renown,
2:16 and its weakness does not warrant discarding it altogether.
2:19 The scholars have thus relied upon it.
2:21 This is the first matter,
2:23 concerning the weakness in its isnad.
2:25 The second matter relates to its text (matn):
2:27 its text requires critical examination.
2:29 Among the best
2:31 of those who relied upon it
2:33 and cited it
2:35 in his Tafsir
2:37 for every surah—
2:39 while simultaneously critiquing its text—
2:42 was Shaykh al-Tahir ibn 'Ashur.
2:44 In his Tafsir,
2:46 you will find him at the beginning of each surah
2:48 saying, "It is counted as the ninth,"
2:50 "It is counted as the tenth,"
2:52 and the like.
2:54 Then he mentions what contradicts
2:56 that statement,
2:58 or presents
3:00 other evidence that he favors,
3:02 scrutinizes,
3:04 and uses to debate
3:06 this well-known transmission.
3:08 As for most others who relied on this transmission,
3:10 to the best of my knowledge,
3:12 they would simply cite it without
3:14 significant critical scrutiny.
3:16 Perhaps
3:18 Muhammad 'Izzat Darwazah's book,
3:20 "Al-Tafsir al-Hadith",
3:22 also paid some attention to it, but it does not match
3:24 the attention given by al-Tahir ibn 'Ashur.
3:26 Indeed, al-Tahir ibn 'Ashur is among the finest to critique
3:28 the text of Jabir ibn Zayd's transmission,
3:30 the famous narration
3:32 mentioned by al-Suyuti in
3:34 "Al-Itqan" and other works.
3:37 The third matter is that there is
3:39 confusion in the sequencing of this transmission;
3:41 that is, those who relied on this transmission
3:43 confounded it, advancing some surahs and delaying others.
3:45 Even al-Tahir ibn 'Ashur
3:47 fell into this, among others.
3:49 For this reason, I relied upon
3:51 the narration that I referenced
3:53 in the footnote
3:55 on that very page,
3:57 where the modification in the footnote occurred.
3:59 I relied on the transmission of Abu 'Amr al-Dani
4:01 in his book
4:03 "Al-Bayan fi 'Add Ay al-Qur'an",
4:05 because it is a narration with a connected isnad; later authors transmitted it from it,
4:07 yet when they transmitted it,
4:09 errors occurred in their ordering.
4:11 And this transmission,
4:13 which is found with Abu 'Amr,
4:15 may Allah have mercy on him, contains no mention of al-Fatihah.
4:17 Therefore, al-Fatihah
4:20 is not counted within
4:22 the well-known transmission
4:24 upon which I relied. These were two points,
4:26 both of which were related
4:28 to the chronological order of revelation.
4:30 With each surah,
4:32 we will attempt to pause over an aspect we have not previously addressed.
4:34 We have now paused over the order of revelation,
4:36 and with another surah we shall examine
4:38 the occasions of revelation (asbab al-nuzul) and other matters,
4:40 to clarify various issues, if Allah wills.
4:42 The third point is the most important of all,
4:44 so lend it your hearing
4:46 and your hearts;
4:48 I ask Allah to grant spiritual opening to me and to you,
4:51 reminding both myself and my beloved listeners.
4:53 Give your full attention to Surah al-Fatihah,
4:55 for it is the greatest surah of the Qur'an.
4:58 It is the one that encapsulates the entire Qur'an,
5:00 encompassing all of its core objectives.
5:02 Here, I wish to draw attention
5:05 to two essential dimensions:
5:07 the scholarly and the practical.
5:09 As for the scholarly dimension,
5:11 I say: one must attain deep understanding (fiqh)
5:13 of the meanings of al-Fatihah.
5:15 Make a habit, every so often, of reading
5:17 a Tafsir of al-Fatihah
5:19 that you have not read before.
5:21 If you read Ibn Kathir this month,
5:23 read al-Qurtubi the next month,
5:25 then a third exegete, and a fourth.
5:27 Read as abundantly as you can
5:29 from the works of Tafsir on al-Fatihah,
5:31 because this continually renews
5:33 what you already know and provides you with fresh
5:35 insights. This is directly connected
5:38 to the other dimension, which is the practical
5:40 application: be diligent
5:42 in contemplating al-Fatihah
5:44 during prayer whenever you recite it or hear it.
5:46 Never pass over it
5:48 hastily;
5:50 rather, know and be certain that it is greater
5:52 than anything you will recite or hear after it.
5:54 Indeed,
5:56 as we mentioned, it encompasses the objectives of the Qur'an,
5:58 serving as the key
6:00 to understanding everything that follows it.
6:02 When you recite al-Fatihah in prayer,
6:04 realize that whatever follows is understood through it,
6:06 and that it is the key to that understanding.
6:08 So focus deeply upon it
6:10 and give it its due reverence.
6:12 In fact, al-Fatihah is the prayer itself,
6:14 as indicated by the hadith: "I have divided the prayer
6:16 between Myself and My servant into two halves."
6:18 Thus, He designated al-Fatihah
6:20 as the prayer itself,
6:23 which is by way of elevating its supreme status.
6:25 For that reason, it has been named
6:27 the Surah of Prayer.
6:30 I shall content myself with this discussion regarding this
6:32 surah; otherwise, speech
6:34 concerning it could extend indefinitely, as I noted.
6:36 Whoever wishes
6:38 may listen to the detailed commentary.
6:40 Furthermore, seek an abundance
6:42 of learning and spiritual tasting
6:44 of Surah al-Fatihah,
6:46 and you will find immense good,
6:48 by Allah's leave.
6:50 May peace and blessings be upon his family and all his Companions,
6:52 and all praise is due to Allah, the Lord of the worlds.