Part of The Gentle Commentary (series completed) · Lesson 47 of 117

The nice comment on the book of cards identifying the surahs of the Holy Qur’an | D. Muhammad Nassif | Surat Al-Qalam

◉ 231 views ⏱ 6:57 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

In this commentary the sheikh examines Surah Al-Qalam from three angles: its order of revelation, its placement in the Mushaf, and its sections. He explains that the well-known ordering attributed to Jabir ibn Zayd conflicts with the established early revelation of Surah Al-Muddaththir, and that the surah's debates with the disbelievers do not fit its being the second revealed, although some of it may have come early and the rest later. He also shows how it relates to the preceding Surah Al-Mulk, and affirms that connections between surahs are a broad field for reflection. Finally, he corrects several errors in the book's numbering of sections and in the start of the second part.

Key takeaways

  • The well-known ordering places Surah Al-Qalam as the second revealed, after Surah Al-Alaq, an opinion attributed to Jabir ibn Zayd in the popular narration.
  • The earlier revelation of Surah Al-Muddaththir is a established fact that makes this ordering problematic, according to the sheikh.
  • The surah contains debates with the disbelievers, such as Allah's words, "Ask them which of them will stand surety for that," which does not suit its being among the earliest revelations; some of it may have come early and the rest later.
  • Surah Al-Qalam is the sixty-eighth in the Mushaf, and its link to the preceding Surah Al-Mulk lies in the ending of Al-Mulk, which mentions the water of the garden's people vanishing, reflecting that sovereignty belongs to Allah who removes it from whom He wills.
  • Both surahs contrast the people of truth with the people of falsehood and describe the traits of each group.
  • The connections between surahs are varied and numerous, and this is a broad field open to reflection.
  • The surah is divided into two parts, and the sheikh notes that the second part begins at verse 42, with some section markers in the book needing correction.

Questions & answers

Where does Surah Al-Qalam stand in the order of revelation according to the sheikh?

The sheikh notes that the popular ordering makes it the second revealed after Al-Alaq, but this conflicts with the established early revelation of Al-Muddaththir, and its debates with the disbelievers do not suit such early placement.

What is the link between Surah Al-Qalam and Surah Al-Mulk?

The sheikh explains that the end of Al-Mulk describes the destruction of the garden's water, which fits the theme that sovereignty belongs to Allah, who removes it from whomever He wills.

What comparisons appear in Surah Al-Qalam?

The surah compares the people of truth with the people of falsehood, describing the qualities of each group, a theme that recurs in Surah Al-Mulk.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Qur’an verses cited in this lesson

  • Al-Mulk 67:30 — Say: Have ye thought: If (all) your water were to disappear into the earth, who then could bring you gushing water?
  • Al-Qalam 68:41 — Or have they other gods? Then let them bring their other gods if they are truthful

Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:03 A brief commentary
0:32 on the book *Identification Cards*
0:35 *for the Surahs of the Noble Qur'an*,
0:38 by Dr. Muhammad ibn Abdul Aziz ibn Umar Nassif,
0:42 may Allah preserve him.
0:44 Surah al-Qalam.
0:46 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:47 All praise is due to Allah, the Lord of all creation,
0:49 and may peace and blessings
0:50 be upon his brothers among the prophets and messengers,
0:52 and upon all his family and companions.
0:54 We continue our brief commentary on the *Identification Cards*,
0:57 and we have arrived at Surah al-Qalam,
1:00 for which we have three points of discussion.
1:02 The first point pertains to the chronological order of the Surah's revelation.
1:06 He said: "It is counted as the second after al-'Alaq and before al-Muzzammil."
1:11 It has been frequently noted that this count is based on the well-known narration from Jabir ibn Zayd,
1:18 and that within this text transmitted
1:22 from this Tabi'i, there is significant scrutiny required,
1:26 which I have pointed out in numerous places throughout this book,
1:29 including this very place.
1:32 He said, and regarding this:
1:34 There is an evident issue with this chronological ordering
1:37 and a contradiction to what has been authentically established concerning the revelation of al-Muddaththir.
1:40 For we know that the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,
1:42 after the beginning of al-'Alaq was revealed to him,
1:45 returned to the Mother of the Believers, Khadijah,
1:48 and then after that,
1:50 verses from Surah al-Muddaththir were revealed;
1:52 thus it was the second in order of revelation.
1:54 So this contradicts something that is firmly and clearly established.
1:58 Then he stated: "Along with its containment of debate with the disbelievers,
2:03 which indicates a relatively later period of revelation."
2:06 Likewise, when we look at the content
2:08 of this Surah, we find polemics and debates with the disbelievers,
2:12 such as the Almighty's saying: "Ask them which of them will guarantee that?"
2:15 “Or have they other gods? Then let them bring their other gods if they are truthful” (68:41)
2:18 And this is not consistent with it being the second surah revealed,
2:26 even though it might be said that some of it was revealed second,
2:32 and the rest of it was revealed at other times.
2:35 However, the initial objection remains: al-Muddaththir
2:38 is what followed Surah al-'Alaq, or the beginning of Surah al-'Alaq.
2:44 As for the rest of the text written here—
2:48 "and it is the second according to all narrations,
2:50 so perhaps what is meant is part of it," and so forth—
2:53 this is not part of the original book;
2:55 rather, it appeared here by mistake.
2:59 As for the second point, it concerns the placement of the Surah in the Mushaf.
3:02 He said: "It is the sixty-eighth in the order of the Mushaf,
3:07 and its correlation with Surah al-Mulk
3:10 is that the conclusion of the latter corresponds to the fate of the companions of the garden mentioned in this one."
3:15 At the end of that surah,
3:18 “Say: Have ye thought: If (all) your water were to disappear into the earth, who then could bring you gushing water?” (67:30)
3:23 and this story corresponds
3:25 to that conclusion in the sense that all dominion belongs to Allah, Glorified and Exalted be He,
3:30 and He strips it away from whomever He granted it to
3:33 whenever He wills, Glorified and Exalted be He.
3:37 And the recurrent phrase "and among its thematic links,"
3:41 across many surahs,
3:45 indicates that these thematic links are diverse and manifold.
3:50 Therefore, you will also find that in this Surah
3:54 there is a contrast between the people of truth and the people of falsehood,
3:57 parallels both in Surah al-Qalam
4:00 and in Surah al-Mulk.
4:09 It is as though the one who walks fallen on his face possesses the traits
4:12 mentioned in Surah al-Qalam,
4:15 whereas the one who walks upright on a straight path
4:18 embodies: "And indeed, you are of a great moral character."
4:20 Then He said: "So do not obey the deniers,"
4:22 up to His saying: "And do not obey every worthless swearer,
4:25 scorner, going about with malicious slander."
4:27 These are also among the thematic correlations,
4:30 and correlations are a vast field
4:35 that offers wide scope for reflection and contemplation.
4:38 As for the third and final point,
4:41 it concerns the thematic sections of the Surah,
4:43 containing several typographic errors and missing details.
4:47 He said: "It is divided into two parts, the first of them..."
4:50 meaning it is more accurate to say "the first of the two parts."
4:54 Then he said: "As for the first part..."
4:57 until he said: "In it are three passages."
5:00 Then only the numbers 1 and 17 were written;
5:03 only two numbers were printed
5:07 even though there are three passages,
5:08 and the starting verse numbers for all passages ought to have been placed.
5:11 The third passage begins at verse thirty-five,
5:14 so this number should be added.
5:17 I have mentioned before that the word "then"
5:20 indicates the beginning of a new passage.
5:22 If you read what is written under this,
5:24 you find: "Then the story of..." which begins from verse 17;
5:29 "Then a return to the comparison between the two groups,"
5:32 which is in the last line of the first part.
5:35 This word "Then" ought to be bolded
5:37 so that it stands out,
5:39 and it begins from verse thirty-five.
5:41 This marks the return to the comparison between the two groups,
5:43 and we add the phrase "along with debate with the disbelievers."
5:48 Then he said: "As for the second part..."
5:50 In reality, the second part begins from verse forty-two,
5:53 because the first part extends from verse one to verse forty-one,
5:56 just as is outlined in the book's charts.
5:58 Here it was written: "As for the second part, from verse eighteen,"
6:01 which is an error;
6:02 it is from verse forty-two
6:04 to verse fifty-two.
6:09 At the conclusion of this second part,
6:11 he said: "Ending with exposing the futility of the disbelievers' plots
6:16 and praising..."
6:18 the Qur'an as being a reminder for all the worlds.
6:21 That is, there is an addition and an edit
6:23 to make the text more eloquent with rhymed prose:
6:29 "Ending with exposing the futility of the disbelievers' plots,
6:32 and praising the Qur'an as a reminder for all the worlds."
6:36 I would also like to point out a related note: regarding the overall theme of the Surah, he said "by contemplating its paragraphs," whereas it should accurately be "by contemplating its two main parts."
6:48 I will suffice with this; and may Allah send blessings upon our Prophet Muhammad and upon all his family and companions, and all praise is due to Allah, the Lord of all creation.