Part of The Gentle Commentary (series completed) · Lesson 89 of 117

The nice comment on the book of cards identifying the surahs of the Holy Qur’an | D. Muhammad Nassif | Surat Al-Shu'ara

◉ 143 views ⏱ 7:36 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

In this episode of Al-Ta'leeq Al-Latif, Sheikh Muhammad Nusayf discusses Surat Ash-Shu'ara from three angles: the meaning of its name and the place of poetry and narrative as the pillars of literature, the context of its revelation linked to the time the call was openly proclaimed in Makkah, and some connections between the end and the beginning of the surah. He explains that the surah ends by affirming that the Quran is the truth, responding to the disbelievers' claims about the Prophet ﷺ being a poet, and that the poets followed by the misguided are distinguished from the believers who do righteous deeds.

Key takeaways

  • The sheikh looks at the name Ash-Shu'ara together with the names of the other surahs and finds that poetry and narrative are the pillars of literature and have a strong influence on people's minds.
  • He explains that the Quranic stories are the finest of stories, and that narrative has a great impact on media and on generations.
  • He notes that the revelation of the surah is linked to the time the call was openly proclaimed in the Makkan period, which Ibn Ishaq dated to three years after the beginning of the prophethood, though this is debated and the well-known view is three years.
  • He shows that the ending of the surah ("And indeed, it is a revelation from the Lord of the worlds") returns to its beginning ("the clear Book"), and that this confirms the value of reading the whole surah.
  • He explains that mentioning the poets at the end of the surah serves as a response to the disbelievers' accusations against the Prophet ﷺ and the Quran.
  • He cites Ibn Ashur's explanation that the Arabs believed a poet has a devil who dictates to him, which explains the connection between their claims about the Quran and about the Prophet ﷺ.
  • He notes that the exception is made for those who believe, do righteous deeds, remember Allah often, and defend themselves after being wronged.

Questions & answers

Why are the poets mentioned at the end of Surat Ash-Shu'ara?

The sheikh explains that the mention of poets responds to the disbelievers' slander against the Prophet ﷺ and the Quran, as they claimed the Quran was poetry and the Prophet ﷺ was a poet.

When was Surat Ash-Shu'ara revealed according to this lesson?

The sheikh says its revelation is linked to the time the call was openly proclaimed in the Makkan period. Ibn Ishaq dated it to three years after the beginning of the prophethood, though the well-known view is three years.

Who are the poets excepted from the blame in the surah?

They are those who believe, do righteous deeds, remember Allah often, and defend themselves after being wronged, as the sheikh explains.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Qur’an verses cited in this lesson

  • Yusuf 12:3 — We narrate unto thee (Muhammad) the best of narratives in that We have inspired in thee this Qur'an, though aforetime thou wast of the heedless.
  • Ash-Shu'ara 26:192 — And lo! it is a revelation of the Lord of the Worlds,
  • Al-Haqqah 69:41 — It is not poet's speech - little is it that ye believe!
  • Al-Haqqah 69:42 — Nor diviner's speech - little is it that ye remember!

Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:30 Gentle Commentary
0:32 on the book "Identification Cards"
0:35 for the Surahs of the Noble Qur'an,
0:38 by Dr. Muhammad Ibn Abd al-Aziz Ibn Umar Nasif,
0:42 may Allah preserve him.
0:44 Surah al-Shu'ara' (The Poets).
0:46 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful. Praise be to Allah,
0:48 and may the peace and blessings of Allah be upon the Messenger of Allah.
0:50 We continue with our gentle commentary,
0:52 and with Surah al-Shu'ara'.
0:55 There are three points of reflection.
0:57 The first point concerns the name of the Surah.
0:59 Naturally, its well-known name is "al-Shu'ara'" (The Poets),
1:01 and it is also mentioned as "al-Zullah" (The Shadow).
1:03 However, we will focus on "al-Shu'ara'",
1:05 because some scholars,
1:07 or one researcher in particular—
1:09 whom I have mentioned to you before—
1:11 who looked at all the Surahs in their entirety
1:13 from the perspective of their names,
1:15 examined them collectively,
1:17 and found that "al-Shu'ara'" (The Poets) and "al-Qasas" (The Stories)
1:19 cover
1:21 what we call the field of literature.
1:24 He pointed out that poets
1:26 and storytelling
1:28 are the pillars of literature.
1:30 There are many literary forms and genres,
1:32 but these two are the pillars
1:34 of literature.
1:35 When the Qur'an was revealed,
1:37 poetry held a high status,
1:39 and it still holds a status today,
1:41 though it has diminished, while the importance
1:43 of storytelling and fiction has increased.
1:45 And the best of stories are in this Qur'an.
1:47 We must not forget
1:49 that when the Companions said
1:51 to the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,
1:53 "Tell us stories," Allah revealed:
1:55 “We narrate unto thee (Muhammad) the best of narratives in that We have inspired in thee this Qur'an, though aforetime thou wast of the heedless.” (12:3)
1:57 The stories of the Qur'an deserve much attention.
2:00 But the point is that naming
2:02 these two Surahs,
2:04 al-Shu'ara' and al-Qasas, alludes
2:06 to two great
2:08 pillars
2:10 of literature. And literature
2:12 has an influence on media;
2:14 it has an influence on people's minds.
2:16 We all know what
2:18 the state of fiction
2:20 and storytelling has become in terms of influence,
2:22 even films and the like;
2:24 they are originally stories
2:26 that were turned into films,
2:28 and thus they influenced
2:30 entire generations
2:32 at times.
2:34 This is the first point of reflection.
2:36 As for the second point,
2:38 it concerns what is mentioned
2:40 at the end of the history of revelation,
2:42 regarding the chronological order of the Surah's revelation.
2:44 It is said that this revelation is attributed
2:46 to the time of the public proclamation of the message
2:48 during the Meccan period.
2:50 It is established in the Sahih that the saying of the Almighty:
2:52 "And warn your closest kindred,"
2:54 when it was revealed to the Prophet, peace be upon him,
2:56 he gathered the people,
2:58 spoke to them, and called them to Allah.
3:00 So this revelation is attributed to the time
3:02 of the public proclamation of the message in the Meccan period.
3:04 This time was chronicled by
3:06 Ibn Ishaq,
3:08 and it is in the Seerah of Ibn Hisham, of course,
3:10 that this was after three
3:12 years of
3:14 the call. There is
3:16 research and discussion regarding this,
3:18 and some have remained silent on the exact timing,
3:20 but the well-known view
3:22 is that it was three years
3:24 from the beginning of the mission.
3:27 During that time, the call was secret,
3:29 then it became, with this verse,
3:31 public.
3:33 The third and final point of reflection
3:35 concerns
3:37 a passage in the Surah
3:39 that relates to the science of "Munasabat" (thematic coherence),
3:41 which some dear brothers ask about,
3:43 saying: "Is there affectation in it,
3:45 and how does one learn it?"
3:47 I know Dr. Muhammad Umar Bazmul
3:49 teaches the science of Munasabat;
3:51 it is useful for establishing a foundation in this field,
3:53 but the practitioner
3:55 finds it broader than that.
3:57 However, in terms of theory, it is good.
3:59 Then I say, notice
4:01 at the conclusion of the Surah's sections,
4:03 there is an informative opening,
4:05 which is His saying: "And indeed, it
4:07 is the revelation of the Lord of the worlds."
4:09 This verse
4:12 refers back,
4:14 as Imam al-Tabari explained,
4:16 to the beginning of the Surah.
4:18 For He mentioned the Book at the beginning of the Surah,
4:20 then said after it,
4:22 narrating all the stories.
4:24 “And lo! it is a revelation of the Lord of the Worlds,” (26:192)
4:26 Then the speech returned to the "Clear Book"
4:28 mentioned at the beginning of the Surah.
4:30 This confirms the importance of
4:32 reading the entire Surah so that
4:34 a person may take from its lights as much as
4:36 possible.
4:38 He said: "And the proof that the Qur'an is the truth,
4:40 and the refutation of the doubts of the disbelievers."
4:42 Among these is their counting the Qur'an as poetry—
4:44 this leads to the reason for mentioning poetry.
4:46 The Surah does not speak about poetry,
4:48 yet at the end of the Surah, there is proof that the Qur'an
4:50 is the truth. So what brought about the mention of
4:52 poetry here? A seeker might ask this question.
4:54 The Surah mentions the stories of the Prophets,
4:56 so why were the poets mentioned at the end
4:58 of this Surah?
5:00 This is a question that crosses the mind.
5:03 I point out that the refutation
5:05 of the doubts of the disbelievers regarding what
5:07 they describe the Prophet, peace be upon him, with,
5:09 and the Qur'an that was revealed to him, was at the end
5:11 of the Surah. Among the doubts was that [it was poetry],
5:13 so the mention of the poets came
5:15 for this reason.
5:17 And notice that He said:
5:19 "The poets—the deviators follow them."
5:21 As for the followers of the Prophet, peace be upon him,
5:23 they were not deviators; this contains praise
5:25 for the Companions, that they
5:27 are not among the deviators.
5:29 Rather, it is the deviators who follow the poets.
5:31 But here I wanted to
5:33 point out a subtle,
5:35 delicate issue that
5:37 al-Tahir Ibn Ashur relied upon
5:39 in explaining the relationship here.
5:41 It is an issue that goes back to what
5:43 scholars call—and it is important in the science of Munasabat—
5:45 what is called in the science of rhetoric
5:47 "the connector" (al-jami'), which has types.
5:49 The intended meaning here is the connector
5:51 that refers to people's customs
5:53 and habits. In the custom of
5:55 the Arabs to whom
5:57 the Qur'an was revealed, they used to
5:59 think that a poet had a devil
6:01 who dictated poetry to him.
6:03 Al-Tahir Ibn Ashur says this,
6:05 and adds: "So it was appropriate," meaning
6:07 he compared their falsification of the Qur'an—
6:09 saying it is poetry—and their saying about the Prophet,
6:11 peace be upon him, that he is a poet,
6:13 with their saying that it is the speech of a soothsayer,
6:15 just as he compared them
6:17 in the verse of al-Haqqah.
6:19 “It is not poet's speech - little is it that ye believe!” (69:41)
6:21 “Nor diviner's speech - little is it that ye remember!” (69:42)
6:23 You remember, then,
6:25 I want to arrive at the fact that
6:27 the connector that rhetoricians call
6:29 "imaginary"—which is very important
6:31 in the science of Munasabat—
6:33 refers to knowing the conditions of those to whom
6:35 the Qur'an was revealed, namely the Arabs.
6:37 I knew the Arabs and I knew their view of poetry,
6:39 and of soothsaying, and of devils.
6:41 I knew the relationship that
6:43 brought these verses
6:45 to this place.
6:47 I hope that this
6:49 insight is clear.
6:51 You may review the words of my master
6:53 Ibn Ashur in his Tafsir
6:55 at this passage, for he was brilliant.
6:57 And al-Biqa'i was brilliant before him
6:59 in explaining the description of the poets
7:01 who are saved from this condemnation:
7:03 "Except those who believe
7:05 and do righteous deeds,
7:07 and remember Allah
7:09 often,
7:11 and defend themselves
7:13 after they were wronged.
7:15 And those who have
7:17 wronged
7:19 will come to know
7:21 May their hearts be turned [toward the truth].
7:23 I ask Allah
7:27 to grant me and you success in attaining what He loves and is pleased with.
7:29 I ask Allah [to send blessings] upon our Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him,
7:31 and upon all his family and his Companions.
7:33 And praise be to Allah, Lord of the worlds.