Part of The Gentle Commentary (series completed) · Lesson 20 of 117

The nice comment on the book of cards identifying the surahs of the Holy Qur’an | D. Muhammad Nassif | Surat Al-Tin

◉ 171 views ⏱ 5:58 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

In this session of the series "Al-Ta'liq al-Latif" on the Cards of Introduction to the Surahs of the Noble Qur'an, Dr. Muhammad Nassif presents three reflections on Surah At-Tin: its position after Surah Ash-Sharh and the connection between them regarding following and turning away from revelation, the meaning of the oath by the fig, the olive, Mount Sinai and the secure city, and the iltifat (shift of pronoun) in the verses, from the third person to a rebuking question. He concludes that following revelation fits the dignity of creation in the best of forms, while turning away from it leads to a lowly state.

Key takeaways

  • The link with the previous surah: after Surah Ash-Sharh described the most complete people in having their hearts opened, Surah At-Tin points to the opposite by mentioning being returned to the lowest of the low.
  • A person is protected from being returned to the lowest of the low to the degree they follow revelation; although this is fully in the Hereafter, it has an effect in this world that appears in the state of the follower and the one who turns away.
  • A person who turns away from revelation may be in the best of created forms, yet their conduct places them in a base state, closer to animals, and indeed they may be more astray.
  • The oath by the fig, the olive, Mount Sinai and the secure city is understood, by the principle of thematic correspondence in rhetoric, as referring to places where revelation descended, not merely to the two fruits.
  • The shift in "then We returned him" to "so what makes you deny" draws the listener's attention to an important statement containing rebuke, though it takes the form of a question.
  • Religions differ: the more a religion has been distorted and distanced from truth, the more its adherents are humbled in this world, in addition to what Allah has prepared for them in the Hereafter.

Questions & answers

What is the connection between Surah At-Tin and Surah Ash-Sharh?

The speaker explains that Surah Ash-Sharh mentioned the most complete people in having their hearts opened, and that following gives a person a share in proportion to it, while Surah At-Tin points to the opposite: being returned to the lowest of the low.

What is meant by the fig, the olive and Mount Sinai in Surah At-Tin?

The speaker favours, by the principle of thematic correspondence, that the intended meaning is the places of revelation, namely the places where the fig and olive grow in the Levant, rather than the two fruits alone.

What is iltifat in Surah At-Tin?

Iltifat here is the shift from the third-person pronoun in "We returned him" to direct address in "so what makes you deny". It is a style that draws the listener's attention to an important statement containing rebuke to those who deny the Day of Judgment.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:03 A brief commentary
0:05 on the book *Bitaqat al-Ta'rif*
0:08 *bi-Suwar al-Mushaf al-Sharif*
0:11 by Dr. Muhammad Ibn 'Abd al-'Aziz Ibn 'Umar Nasif,
0:15 may Allah preserve him.
0:17 Surah at-Tin.
0:19 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:22 All praise is due to Allah, the Lord of all worlds,
0:24 and may peace and blessings be upon the Seal of the Prophets and Messengers,
0:27 and upon his family and all his Companions.
0:29 We are still with the brief commentary on *Bitaqat al-Ta'rif*,
0:31 and with Surah at-Tin.
0:33 I have three reflections upon it.
0:35 The first reflection concerns the placement of the surah:
0:37 it comes immediately after Surah
0:39 ash-Sharh,
0:41 and the connection between the two
0:45 is apparent. For after Surah ash-Sharh
0:47 spoke
0:50 of the most perfect of mankind
0:52 in the expansion of the chest
0:54 and the qualities
0:59 that followed it,
1:01 and as we mentioned, following him
1:04 grants a person
1:07 a share of that in proportion
1:09 to his adherence to the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,
1:11 here came
1:13 this surah pointing
1:15 to
1:17 the very opposite of that,
1:22 namely the descent into the lowest
1:24 of the low. And although this pertains to the Hereafter,
1:26 it also applies
1:28 to whoever turns away from revelation.
1:30 This is because the surah points to revelation
1:33 in "By the fig and the olive,
1:35 and Mount Sinai, and this secure city,"
1:37 as will be explained in the second reflection.
1:39 Thus, in proportion to one's adherence to revelation,
1:41 a person is saved
1:43 from being reduced to the lowest of the low
1:45 after having been created in the finest stature.
1:48 And this, even though
1:50 being reduced to the lowest of the low
1:52 refers, according to a group of scholars,
1:54 to the Day of Resurrection,
1:57 nevertheless has a manifest share in this world
1:59 that you can see right before you.
2:01 You see that the one who follows revelation
2:03 experiences an expansion of the chest
2:05 and an elevation wherein his conduct aligns
2:07 and harmonizes with
2:09 his creation in the finest stature.
2:13 The other, conversely—
2:15 the one who turns away from revelation—
2:17 you may find physically well-formed,
2:19 indeed created in the finest stature,
2:21 yet his deeds
2:23 reduce him to a vile,
2:25 wretched state.
2:29 He becomes closer to a beast, if not
2:31 lower: "They are like cattle;
2:33 nay, they are even more astray."
2:36 The second reflection
2:38 concerns the theme of the surah, where Allah mentions
2:40 an oath and its response.
2:42 Notice the oath:
2:44 in it, there is mention of
2:48 the fig and the olive,
2:50 Mount Sinai,
2:52 and the mention of
2:54 the secure city.
2:57 Mount Sinai and the secure city
2:59 are unanimously recognized as locations.
3:01 As for the fig and the olive,
3:03 are they the two fruits,
3:05 or an allusion to the places
3:07 where they grow?
3:09 In Arabic rhetoric, we have the principle of
3:11 harmonious correspondence (*mura'at al-nazir*),
3:13 which means that when several things are mentioned
3:16 in a single context,
3:18 it is most appropriate that an affinity exists among them.
3:20 If you reflect upon Mount
3:22 Sinai and the secure city,
3:24 the most fitting interpretation
3:26 is that the fig
3:29 and the olive refer to the places
3:31 where figs and olives grow in the lands of
3:33 the Levant (Sham). The common denominator among all these
3:35 locations is that they are sites
3:37 where divine revelation descended—
3:39 the very revelation
3:42 that protects man from what is stated in:
3:44 "Then We reduced him
3:46 to the lowest of the low."
3:50 As for the third and final reflection,
3:52 it concerns the second section
3:54 of the surah, short though it may be.
3:56 Yet this second section deserves
3:58 careful pause because it contains an instance of grammatical shift (*iltifat*).
4:00 And *iltifat*,
4:02 according to rhetoricians,
4:05 occurs when speech proceeds
4:07 using one type of pronoun
4:10 and then shifts to another.
4:12 "We have certainly created man
4:14 in the finest stature;
4:16 then We reduced him"—
4:18 notice "reduced him,"
4:20 a third-person pronoun—
4:22 "to the lowest of the low, except for those who believe and do righteous deeds,
4:24 for they"—and here is another third-person pronoun—
4:26 "will have an uninterrupted reward."
4:28 Then He said: "So what causes you to deny..."
4:30 He did not say:
4:32 "So what causes them to deny..."
4:37 This rhetorical device,
4:40 this method of *iltifat*, arrests the listener's attention
4:42 through the sudden change in the mode of address,
4:44 just as a person might raise his voice
4:46 to alert the listener
4:48 that he has moved to a new topic
4:50 or to a crucial statement.
4:53 And here, it serves that very purpose.
4:55 The topic is not entirely new; it is intimately tied to what preceded,
4:57 but it is a momentous statement
4:59 conveying a sharp rebuke.
5:01 It is framed outwardly as a rhetorical question,
5:03 though our Lord is All-Knowing of everything.
5:05 Thus, it is a rebuke
5:07 directed at whoever denies the Day of Judgment
5:09 after these clear
5:11 proofs,
5:13 despite knowing that Allah
5:15 is the Most Just of judges.
5:17 Among the signs subtly indicated here
5:19 is that those who adhere to revelation
5:21 remain in an elevated,
5:24 virtuous state wherein their actions
5:26 are in harmony
5:28 with their original creation
5:30 and their being fashioned in the finest stature,
5:32 unlike those who distance themselves from revelation.
5:34 You can observe this across different
5:36 religions: the more a religion
5:38 is corrupted and far-removed
5:40 from the truth,
5:42 the more its adherents fall
5:44 to the lowest of the low in this worldly life,
5:46 alongside what Allah has prepared for them in the Hereafter.
5:48 I ask Allah to grant us repentance
5:50 and to cause us to die in a state pleasing to Him.
5:52 And Allah knows best. May Allah send blessings and mercy
5:54 upon his family and Companions.