Part of The Gentle Commentary (series completed) · Lesson 116 of 117

The nice comment on the book of cards identifying the surahs of the Holy Qur’an | D. Muhammad Nassif | Surah Al-Baqarah (2)

◉ 792 views ⏱ 8:27 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

In this second segment of his commentary on Surah Al-Baqarah, Dr. Muhammad Nseif presents three points. First, he corrects a printing error in the book: the heading «تأريخها» (its date) should read «the period in which the surah was revealed», since the chronological order of revelation and its dating fall under one heading. Second, he explains that the second section of the surah (verses 168 to 197) details legal rulings, such as Hajj and fasting, after the first section prepared the souls for them. Third, he notes that the Quran points to inner, faith-related dimensions of worship that complement the outward rulings explained by fiqh and the Sunnah.

Key takeaways

  • Correction: the heading «تأريخها» should be replaced by «the period in which the surah was revealed», as revelation order and dating are closely related.
  • Structure of the surah: the second section begins with «O mankind, eat of what is on earth, lawful and good» and details many rulings.
  • Key rulings detailed in this section: Hajj and fasting.
  • Complementary sources: fiqh relies mostly on the Prophetic hadiths for details, which is a great good, but it is only part of the reality of worship.
  • Inner dimension of worship: the Quran alludes to faith-based meanings, such as «fear Allah and know that you will be gathered to Him» in the days of Tashreeq.
  • Remembrance of the Gathering: the dispersal of pilgrims and their departure from Mina remind one of the great Gathering, which the pilgrim should keep in mind.
  • Purpose of fasting: the phrase «so that you may become righteous» shows that taqwa, whose place is the heart, is the greatest aim of fasting.

Questions & answers

What error did Dr. Nseif point out in the book Bitaqat al-Ta'reef?

A printing error: the heading «تأريخها» appears in the book, while the correct wording should be «the period in which the surah was revealed», because revelation order and dating fall under one heading.

What rulings does the second section of Surah Al-Baqarah cover?

It details legal rulings, most notably Hajj and fasting, after the first section prepared the souls for them. It spans verses 168 to 197, as the sheikh mentions.

Why should one learn the inner dimension of worship alongside fiqh?

Fiqh generally explains the outward rulings, while the Quran points to inner faith-based meanings that give worship a different taste, such as remembering the Gathering during Hajj and taqwa in fasting.

What is the purpose of fasting according to the verse «so that you may become righteous»?

The sheikh highlights that the goal of fasting is taqwa, a matter whose place is the heart.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Qur’an verses cited in this lesson

  • Al-Baqarah 2:203 — Remember Allah through the appointed days. Then whoso hasteneth (his departure) by two days, it is no sin for him, and whoso delayeth, it is no sin for him; that is for him who wardeth off (evil). Be careful of your duty to Allah, and know that unto Him ye will be gathered.
  • Al-Baqarah 2:207 — And of mankind is he who would sell himself, seeking the pleasure of Allah; and Allah hath compassion on (His) bondmen.

Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Entirely Merciful, the Especially Merciful.
0:30 The Graceful Commentary
0:32 on the book "Identification Cards
0:35 for the Surahs of the Noble Qur'an"
0:38 by Dr. Muhammad ibn 'Abd al-'Aziz ibn 'Umar Nasif,
0:42 may Allah preserve him.
0:44 Surah al-Baqarah.
0:45 In the name of Allah, the Entirely Merciful, the Especially Merciful.
0:47 Praise be to Allah, the Lord of all worlds,
0:49 and may peace and blessings be upon the Seal of the Prophets and Messengers,
0:52 and upon his family and Companions all together.
0:55 This
0:57 is the second recording
0:59 concerning Surah al-Baqarah
1:02 from the Graceful Commentary
1:04 on the book
1:06 "Identification Cards."
1:08 It contains three main points, as usual,
1:10 but the first point is extremely important
1:12 due to a major defect in the printed book,
1:14 which occurred in the printing
1:16 and through alterations
1:18 made by the publisher.
1:20 We have "the period in which the surah was revealed,"
1:23 which refers to
1:25 the Makkan and Madinan classification,
1:27 and we also have
1:29 "the chronological order of the surah's revelation."
1:31 If you examine Surah al-Baqarah,
1:33 you will find that "the period in which
1:35 the surah was revealed" does not appear as a heading;
1:37 instead, there is
1:39 "its order of revelation" and "its dating."
1:41 In fact, its dating and its order of revelation
1:43 are one and the same thing,
1:45 or rather both fall under a single category,
1:47 as I will clarify shortly.
1:49 Because of this, there is a major defect here:
1:51 if you turn to Surah al-Baqarah
1:53 and look
1:56 under the heading "its order of revelation,"
1:58 some text has been written,
2:00 and under the heading
2:03 "its dating," other text has been written.
2:05 The reality is that the heading "its dating,"
2:07 across almost the entire book—
2:09 though I have not checked every single page,
2:11 it appears throughout the book that "its dating"
2:13 is an error, and in its place should be written:
2:15 "the period in which it was revealed."
2:17 Thus, this surah is Madinan
2:19 by consensus, without any authentic exception.
2:21 This pertains to the period
2:23 in which it was revealed,
2:25 and for this point I relied
2:27 on the two scholarly
2:29 theses
2:31 mentioned
2:33 in the book on page ten;
2:35 likewise, both
2:37 are referenced in footnote number three
2:39 in the attached file which
2:41 I shared in the first lesson,
2:43 and perhaps I will post it here once again,
2:45 which contains the introductory portals and their scholarly sources.
2:47 As for the question of the order of revelation
2:49 and the dating of revelation, the order of revelation—which
2:51 I previously commented on in an earlier clip—
2:53 alongside the dating of revelation,
2:56 signifies chronological placement.
2:58 This order—
3:00 namely, that this surah is the eighty-sixth,
3:02 for instance, in the case of Surah al-Baqarah—
3:04 helps in determining the dating of its revelation,
3:06 though it alone is not sufficient;
3:08 rather, alongside it, the occasions of revelation
3:10 and other factors lead to establishing the dating of revelation.
3:12 Regarding the dating of revelation, if you observe
3:14 in Surah al-Baqarah,
3:16 as I mentioned, the heading "its dating"
3:18 should become "its revelation period,"
3:20 and what is there should be moved to "its order of revelation."
3:22 Its order of revelation and its dating
3:24 belong together, and the heading
3:26 I chose for it in the book is "its dating,"
3:28 which encompasses its order of revelation;
3:30 hence, it is the first surah revealed in
3:32 Madinah, and so forth.
3:34 This discussion relates,
3:46 as we have explained in detail,
3:48 to what may require listening to this
3:50 clip several times to verify the information and master it. Whoever has a question may
3:56 ask it. So this is the first point, and it is vital for understanding the entire book.
4:01 Thus, dating and the order of revelation fall under a single heading, whereas the period
4:06 in which the surah was revealed stands on its own. This period is always mentioned in
4:12 the book—for whoever possesses the complete book—in the detailed commentary at
4:18 the top of the page along with the surah's number, verse count, and juz'. The second point
4:25 pertains to the second passage of the surah, or let us say, the second section of the surah.
4:30 We spoke about the first section, the change of the Qiblah, and so forth. The second section contains
4:35 a detailed exposition of legal rulings, after hearts were prepared for them in the first
4:39 section. In it, themes from the end of the first section are reiterated: at the end
4:44 of the first section, those who conceal what Allah revealed were mentioned, and here likewise
4:48 they are mentioned at the beginning of this section, followed by the detailed rulings. This second section
4:52 extends from verse 168 to verse 207,
4:56 beginning with His saying, Exalted is He: "O mankind, eat from whatever is on earth [that is] lawful
4:59 and good." This section addresses numerous rulings, the most prominent of which are
5:05 Hajj and fasting. One will notice the difference between the rulings contained herein
5:10 and those in the third section in tomorrow's recording, if
5:15 Allah wills. This passage extends up to the verse: "O you
5:22 who have believed, enter into Islam completely." It concludes with the verses of Hajj, and then
5:27 “And of mankind is he who would sell himself, seeking the pleasure of Allah; and Allah hath compassion on (His) bondmen.” (2:207)
5:31 we move to the third point, which is closely linked to the second
5:34 point. We notice that when the Qur'an speaks of these
5:39 acts of worship, it differs from the way jurists speak about them.
5:44 Therefore, one ought to complete one's conception of acts of worship
5:52 through learning both the Qur'an and the Sunnah. The Sunnah focuses on the outward
5:57 aspects of worship: "Pray as you have seen me pray," and
6:01 similarly, "Take from me your pilgrimage rites," among other legal injunctions.
6:05 In the Qur'an, however, there are indications of other inner dimensions that must
6:10 be observed in fasting, Hajj, and other rituals. I shall provide
6:14 an example, and then try reading these verses, for they
6:19 unveil to you the inward dimension. That is to say, when you study fiqh,
6:27 it largely relies for detailed rulings upon
6:31 the Prophetic hadiths, and this is an immense good; yet it is only
6:35 a part of the reality of that worship. The Qur'an contains
6:39 pointers to those rulings, but it also contains pointers to
6:42 something else. As I said, an example clarifies the matter.
6:46 The Exalted said: "And remember Allah during [specific] numbered days," in
6:49 the verses of Hajj in Surah al-Baqarah, "then whoever hastens in
6:52 “Remember Allah through the appointed days. Then whoso hasteneth (his departure) by two days, it is no sin for him, and whoso delayeth, it is no sin for him; that is for him who wardeth off (evil). Be careful of your duty to Allah, and know that unto Him ye will be gathered.” (2:203)
6:54 “Remember Allah through the appointed days. Then whoso hasteneth (his departure) by two days, it is no sin for him, and whoso delayeth, it is no sin for him; that is for him who wardeth off (evil). Be careful of your duty to Allah, and know that unto Him ye will be gathered.” (2:203)
6:57 to Him you will be gathered." This is a well-known fiqh ruling,
7:01 detailed in the Sunnah and discussed by the jurists: should a person
7:05 hasten or delay his departure during the days of Tashriq? Yet
7:10 the conclusion of the verse—"And fear Allah and know that
7:13 to Him you will be gathered"—is a profound sign; indeed, it holds multiple indications, of which I will mention only one:
7:18 that the dispersal of people during Hajj and their departure
7:23 from Mina, as with all the pilgrimage rites, serves as a reminder of the Resurrection.
7:28 The pilgrim ought to remember, through that gathering, the immense Day of
7:32 Gathering when Allah will assemble all creation. By
7:37 this analogy, judge these few verses concerning Hajj, and those
7:42 verses preceding them on fasting, and what
7:45 lies between them: you will find abundant indications of spiritual meanings
7:49 upon which the exegetes dwelt at great length.
7:51 Whoever wishes to truly learn their religion requires, alongside fiqh—
7:56 which is critically important—this spiritual dimension
7:59 that gives worship an entirely distinct flavor. Let us not forget,
8:05 in conclusion: "O you who have believed, decreed upon you is fasting
8:08 as it was decreed upon those before you that you may
8:10 become righteous." Notice how the words "that you may become righteous" orient fasting
8:15 toward a completely different horizon, drawing attention to a crucial dimension of fasting:
8:19 namely, God-consciousness (taqwa), the seat of which is the heart. I will suffice with
8:22 this much. May Allah send blessings upon our Prophet Muhammad and upon
8:24 his family and all his Companions. Praise be to Allah, the Lord of all worlds.