Part of The Gentle Commentary (series completed) · Lesson 40 of 117

The nice comment on the book of cards identifying the surahs of the Holy Qur’an | D. Muhammad Nassif | Surat Al-Qiyamah

◉ 501 views ⏱ 6:08 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

In this installment of his commentary series on Bitaqat al-Ta'rif bi-Suwar al-Mushaf al-Sharif, Dr. Muhammad Nusayf discusses three points about Surat al-Qiyamah: its opening with an oath, the occasion of revelation of "Do not move your tongue with it," and the rhetorical denial in its sections along with the interjected verses about the Prophet ﷺ. Al-Suyuti counted its opening among openings with a statement rather than an oath, the reason being the scholarly disagreement over whether it is an oath or a negation. The sheikh stressed the importance of considering the occasions of revelation when discussing the connections between verses.

Key takeaways

  • The opening of Surat al-Qiyamah and Surat al-Balad is a unique form of oath whose meaning is disputed, which is why al-Suyuti classed it as an opening with a statement.
  • The repeated phrase "Does man think..." in Surat al-Qiyamah and Surat al-Balad is a rebuke against one who assumes something wrong.
  • Focusing on connections between verses while neglecting the occasion of revelation can lead to misunderstanding a verse, as Ibn Ashur noted.
  • The occasion of revelation of "Do not move your tongue with it" has no connection to the verses before or after it; verses may be placed together because they were revealed at the same time.
  • "Does man think that We will not assemble his bones?" is a denial directed at one who thinks God will not gather his bones, fitting the surah's conclusion.
  • The interjected verses about the Prophet's ﷺ reception of revelation draw attention to his status and his role as a witness over his nation.

Questions & answers

What type of opening does Surat al-Qiyamah have?

The sheikh explains that it opens with an oath, one of the types of openings, and that it is a unique form of oath whose meaning is disputed: some scholars see it as an oath and others do not. For this reason al-Suyuti counted it among openings with a statement.

What is the occasion of revelation of "Do not move your tongue with it"?

The Prophet ﷺ was experiencing difficulty in receiving revelation and would move his lips. The sheikh notes this occasion has no connection to the verses before or after it, and that it is mentioned alongside them because they were revealed at the same time.

Why should occasions of revelation be considered when discussing connections between verses?

Ignoring them and only seeking connections can lead to misinterpreting a verse so that it fits with what comes before and after it. Ibn Ashur pointed out this problem.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Qur’an verses cited in this lesson

  • An-Nisa 4:41 — But how (will it be with them) when We bring of every people a witness, and We bring thee (O Muhammad) a witness against these?

Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Entirely Merciful, the Especially Merciful.
0:03 A gentle commentary
0:32 on the book "Identification Cards
0:35 for the Surahs of the Noble Qur'an"
0:38 by Dr. Muhammad ibn 'Abd al-'Aziz ibn 'Umar Nasif,
0:42 may Allah preserve him.
0:44 Surah al-Qiyamah.
0:46 In the name of Allah, the Entirely Merciful, the Especially Merciful. All praise is due to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon His Messenger.
0:50 Returning now to this gentle commentary
0:53 on the identification cards,
0:55 the last surah we covered was Surah al-Muddaththir,
0:58 and today we take up Surah al-Qiyamah.
1:01 I have three points of reflection upon it.
1:03 The first point pertains to the opening of the surah.
1:05 The author stated that it begins with an oath,
1:07 which is the fifth type of opening among those mentioned in *Al-Itqan*.
1:10 Furthermore,
1:12 it and Surah al-Balad—
1:14 though written as feminine dual, the phrasing should indicate singular concord—
1:17 meaning Surah al-Qiyamah along with Surah al-Balad,
1:19 are uniquely characterized by a distinctive style of oath,
1:22 the signification of which is debated,
1:24 because some scholars regard it as an oath,
1:26 while others do not consider it an oath.
1:29 Therefore,
1:31 he noted that it could be classified under the fourth category,
1:34 which is opening with an informative statement,
1:36 meaning the fourth of the various types of openings.
1:38 The fifth type is the oath.
1:40 Indeed, al-Suyuti himself,
1:42 upon whom the author relied in this book regarding surah openings,
1:44 classified it
1:46 among the openings
1:48 by informative statements
1:50 and did not count it among the oaths.
1:52 The apparent reason for this is the scholarly difference:
1:54 is this an oath,
1:56 or is it a negation of an oath?
1:58 Moreover, both surahs,
2:00 by virtue of sharing this opening,
2:02 merit deep reflection and comparison.
2:04 It is also observed that in both of these surahs,
2:06 there occurs
2:08 the phrase "Does man think...?" twice
2:10 in each surah.
2:12 Thus, the two surahs beginning with "Nay, I swear"
2:14 resemble each other
2:16 in the fact that
2:18 both contain this specific expression.
2:20 And this phrase, "Does man think...?",
2:22 is a recurring motif
2:24 throughout the Qur'an,
2:27 expressing denunciation
2:29 against anyone who harbors a false assumption,
2:31 as though it delivers him from the darkness
2:33 in which he resides into the light,
2:35 should he be guided by the words
2:37 of the Subtle, the All-Aware.
2:39 As for the second point of reflection, it concerns the occasion of revelation.
2:41 The author mentioned a single occasion of revelation,
2:43 which relates to an issue
2:45 connected to the science of textual correlations (*'ilm al-munasabat*).
2:47 There is an important principle in the science of textual correlations
2:49 that al-Tahir ibn 'Ashur pointed out
2:51 frequently.
2:53 Sometimes an exegete attempts
2:55 to
2:57 forge a link between verses,
2:59 and this endeavor in itself
3:01 is good and accepted by the vast majority of scholars,
3:03 save for a few who hesitated regarding this matter
3:05 and objected to the study of textual correlations.
3:07 But the problem arises
3:09 when speaking of textual correlations
3:11 without taking into account the occasions of revelation.
3:13 Thus, you find someone interpreting a verse
3:15 incorrectly merely
3:17 to make it cohere neatly
3:19 with what precedes it and what follows it,
3:21 completely disregarding the occasion of revelation.
3:23 Here,
3:25 the occasion of revelation for Allah's words, "Do not move your tongue therewith
3:27 to make haste with it,"
3:29 is that the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, used to endure
3:31 great hardship during revelation
3:33 and would frequently move his lips—
3:35 to the end of the narration.
3:37 Thus, it is evident
3:39 that this occasion has no thematic link
3:42 to the verses preceding it or following it.
3:44 And we said that this relates back to the science of textual correlations,
3:46 in the sense that
3:48 verses may be revealed for a specific reason,
3:50 and their descent happens to coincide with
3:52 the revelation of verses
3:54 treating an entirely different topic.
3:56 Thus we understand the rationale for their mention alongside them:
3:58 namely, that they coincided
4:00 in the time of revelation, not that there is an intrinsic
4:02 correlation between them—a point emphasized by al-Tahir ibn 'Ashur.
4:04 By keeping this in mind, the scholar treating
4:06 this subject is spared from forced contrivance
4:08 regarding certain verses.
4:10 The third and final point of reflection
4:12 concerns the thematic sections.
4:14 Under the single section, it says: "And in it [fem.]..."
4:16 We should assume it means: "And in it [masc.]..."
4:18 "The opening with a denunciatory interrogative,
4:20 and the denunciation of those who deny
4:22 the gathering of bones..." It would be better phrased as:
4:24 "and the denunciation of him who assumes
4:26 that Allah will not assemble his bones,"
4:28 and the like,
4:30 because this aligns
4:32 with the statement in the last two lines: "and the refutation of
4:34 whoever assumes that he will be left neglected,"
4:36 in reference to "Does man think
4:38 that We will not assemble his bones?" at the beginning of the surah,
4:40 and "Does man think that he will be left neglected?"
4:42 at the end of the surah.
4:44 So it is preferable for the wording
4:46 to point to this parallelism.
4:48 Furthermore, it is noteworthy
4:50 that there are parenthetical verses
4:52 mentioned in the occasions of revelation a moment ago,
4:54 and they are noted here in the third line
4:56 of the single thematic section.
4:58 He stated: "Parenthetical verses discussing
5:00 the manner required of the Prophet,
5:02 peace be upon him, in his reception of the Qur'an."
5:04 It is clear that these verses
5:06 are not directly
5:08 connected to the verse preceding them.
5:10 I spoke about this a moment ago,
5:12 but I wish to add here
5:14 that such parenthetical insertions
5:16 remind anyone who reads the Qur'an
5:18 and listens to these verses
5:20 that the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,
5:22 holds a sublime status with Allah,
5:24 and that he, peace be upon him,
5:26 is the one upon whom
5:28 the revelation descended.
5:30 This reminds me
5:32 that the Prophet, peace be upon him, received the revelation,
5:34 conveyed it to us,
5:36 and was then taken by Allah, Exalted is He;
5:38 so it must remain ever-present in our hearts
5:40 that he is the one who received the revelation,
5:42 who conveyed it,
5:44 and who will be a witness
5:46 over his Ummah: "So how will it be when We bring from every nation a witness
5:48 “But how (will it be with them) when We bring of every people a witness, and We bring thee (O Muhammad) a witness against these?” (4:41)
5:50 and We bring you as a witness over these?"
5:52 Thus, such verses that appear
5:54 parenthetically speaking about the Messenger of Allah
5:56 ought to draw our attention
5:58 to this reality and to other insights that emerge
6:00 through deep contemplation.
6:02 I content myself with this, and I invoke blessings upon the best of Messengers,
6:04 and upon his family and Companions.