Part of The Gentle Commentary (series completed) · Lesson 95 of 117

The nice comment on the book of cards identifying the surahs of the Holy Qur’an | D. Muhammad Nassif | Surah Taha

◉ 147 views ⏱ 4:39 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

In this session of the series "Al-Ta'liq al-Latif" on the book Bitaqat al-Ta'rif bi-Suwar al-Mushaf al-Sharif, Dr. Muhammad Nusayf offers three reflections on the opening and occasions of revelation of Surah Ta-Ha. He explains that the book follows al-Suyuti's classification of the openings of surahs, and that "Ta-Ha" is not agreed upon as one of the disjoined letters, as its meaning is disputed; al-Tabari preferred that it means "O man". He then clarifies that the disjoined letters should not all be treated the same way when affirming that they belong to that category. Finally, he explains that the book mentions no occasion of revelation for the surah, and that this differs from saying "I did not find one"; the author, Dr. Isam al-Humaydan, did not accept the occasion of revelation reported for the beginning of the surah and therefore did not mention it.

Key takeaways

  • Al-Suyuti's division of surah openings into ten types, including the disjoined letters, is the framework the book follows.
  • "Ta-Ha" is not agreed upon as a disjoined letter group, since its meaning is disputed.
  • Al-Tabari preferred that "Ta-Ha" means "O man", which the speaker indicates is the view a researcher should adopt.
  • Disjoined letters are not all equal in affirming their category; some openings, such as Qaf and Nun, need separate consideration.
  • The difference between the author saying "no occasion of revelation is mentioned" and saying "I did not find one": the first reflects reliance on a specific reference, not a blanket denial.
  • Dr. Isam al-Humaydan did not accept the occasion of revelation for the beginning of the surah and therefore omitted it from his book.
  • A student of the occasions of revelation should begin with al-Humaydan's book to build a sound understanding, then broaden reading in other works and add what is established or valid as evidence.

Questions & answers

Is "Ta-Ha" one of the disjoined letters?

The speaker explains that "Ta-Ha" is not agreed upon as one of the disjoined letters; there is a dispute about it, and al-Tabari preferred that it means "O man".

What does "Ta-Ha" mean according to al-Tabari?

Al-Tabari chose that it means "O man", which is the preference the speaker mentions.

Does Surah Ta-Ha have an occasion of revelation?

The book mentions no occasion of revelation for it, and Dr. Isam al-Humaydan did not accept the occasion reported for its beginning, so he did not mention it.

How should a student proceed in studying occasions of revelation after al-Humaydan's book?

He should first read al-Humaydan's book to form a good overview, then expand by reading other books on occasions of revelation and add whatever he finds established or valid for argument.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:02 A Gentle Commentary
0:32 on the book "Identification Cards
0:35 for the Surahs of the Noble Qur'an"
0:37 by Dr. Muhammad Ibn Abd al-Aziz Ibn Umar Nasif,
0:42 may Allah preserve him.
0:44 Surah Ta-Ha.
0:46 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:48 Praise be to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah.
0:52 We are still continuing with our gentle commentary on the identification cards,
0:55 and here we are with Surah Ta-Ha.
0:57 The first point of reflection
0:59 concerns the opening of the Surah.
1:01 He mentioned here in the book that it opens generally with the letters of the alphabet,
1:04 which are known as the disjointed letters (al-huruf al-muqatta'ah).
1:06 In truth, I followed in this regard the source
1:09 upon which I relied, namely al-Suyuti,
1:11 who followed those before him
1:13 in classifying the openings of the Surahs
1:15 into ten categories,
1:18 among which are the disjointed letters,
1:21 and he included "Ta-Ha" among them.
1:23 Otherwise, "Ta-Ha"
1:25 is not considered one of the disjointed letters
1:27 by consensus.
1:29 We have "Alif-Lam-Mim",
1:31 which is definitively among the disjointed letters,
1:33 and we have "Alif-Lam-Mim-Sad", which is also among the disjointed letters.
1:35 As for "Ta-Ha", there is disagreement concerning it,
1:37 and Imam al-Tabari preferred
1:39 a different view,
1:41 giving preponderance to the meaning: "O man."
1:43 However, I followed
1:45 al-Suyuti's classification
1:47 for the sake of simplicity.
1:50 Here is a second point of reflection,
1:52 and this second point
1:54 stems from the first:
1:56 namely, that the disjointed letters
1:58 should not all be treated
2:00 in the exact same manner.
2:02 Imam al-Tabari,
2:04 across many Surahs,
2:06 states: "The discussion regarding the disjointed letters has preceded,"
2:08 and then he cites some other narrations.
2:10 Yet his methodology requires further induction
2:12 in the way he cites
2:14 the discussion on the disjointed letters throughout the different Surahs.
2:16 In certain Surahs, however,
2:19 such as Surah Ta-Ha,
2:21 he mentions a dispute that takes it outside the category of disjointed letters,
2:23 and indeed,
2:25 he concluded, as I mentioned to you,
2:27 that "Ta-Ha"
2:29 means: "O man."
2:31 This is what is expected of a researcher:
2:33 the disjointed letters
2:35 are not all equal
2:37 in terms of the certainty of their belonging to this category.
2:39 There are certain openings
2:41 concerning which there is extensive debate,
2:43 and which warrant
2:45 closer examination,
2:47 such as Surah Qaf, Surah Ta-Ha,
2:49 and Surah Nun.
2:51 These,
2:53 even if the preponderant view
2:55 among the reciter or reader
2:57 is that they are disjointed letters,
2:59 ought not to be treated
3:01 in the same way as those that are
3:03 unequivocally considered disjointed letters by consensus.
3:05 It is an issue that requires
3:07 thorough research,
3:09 and perhaps some researchers will step forward
3:11 to undertake this matter.
3:13 The third and final point of reflection
3:16 concerns the occasions of revelation (asbab al-nuzul) of the Surah.
3:18 He said: "No occasion of revelation has been mentioned for it."
3:20 I have previously clarified
3:22 that when I say "none has been mentioned for it,"
3:24 it differs from saying "I did not
3:26 find any for it."
3:28 When I state on the very same page,
3:30 regarding the virtues of the Surah: "and I did not find for it
3:32 an independent virtue,"
3:34 this means that I searched across various works
3:36 to the best of my ability and found none.
3:38 However, "no occasion of revelation has been mentioned for it" is said
3:40 because regarding the occasions of revelation,
3:42 despite the abundance of references, I relied
3:44 specifically on sources where no occasion of revelation was recorded for it.
3:46 Otherwise, the author himself,
3:48 Dr. Isam al-Humaydan,
3:50 the author of "Al-Sahih min Asbab al-Nuzul",
3:52 in his critical editing
3:54 of al-Wahidi's "Asbab al-Nuzul"—
3:56 meaning, this scholar
3:58 critically edited al-Wahidi's "Asbab al-Nuzul"—
4:00 and in al-Wahidi's work,
4:02 an occasion of revelation is mentioned for the beginning of the Surah,
4:04 but it was not deemed acceptable
4:06 by Isam al-Humaydan in terms of chain of transmission (isnad),
4:08 so he did not cite it.
4:11 I have noted that once a person reads al-Humaydan's book,
4:13 they gain a sound conception of the occasions of revelation,
4:15 after which they should expand further,
4:17 according to whatever Allah grants them,
4:19 by reading other works on the occasions of revelation.
4:21 One should add to it whenever finding a report
4:23 that appears verified or suitable
4:25 for citation, incorporating it
4:27 into what they already know.
4:29 With this, I conclude
4:31 these points of reflection
4:33 on Surah Ta-Ha.
4:35 May the blessings of Allah be upon our Prophet Muhammad,
4:37 and upon his family and all his Companions.
4:39 And all praise is due to Allah, the Lord of all the worlds.