Part of The Gentle Commentary (series completed) · Lesson 36 of 117

The nice comment on the book of cards identifying the surahs of the Holy Qur’an | D. Muhammad Nassif | Surah An-Nazi'at

◉ 402 views ⏱ 6:38 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

In this session of "Al-Ta'liq al-Lateef" on the book Bitaqat al-Ta'reef bi-Suwar al-Mushaf al-Sharif by Dr. Muhammad al-Nassif, the sheikh covers three points on Surat An-Nazi'at: the occasions of revelation, its place in the order of revelation and its date, and the story of Musa (Moses) in its middle. He notes that the only reported occasion is the Prophet ﷺ being asked about the Hour, and that this report has been challenged in both its chain and text. To estimate the date, he relies on the widely cited report about the number of verses, and favors a late Meccan revelation. He explains that the story of Musa comes as a parenthetical passage, consoling the Prophet ﷺ and the believers and warning the deniers of the Day of Judgment.

Key takeaways

  • The only reported occasion of revelation is the Prophet ﷺ being asked about the Hour, though its chain and text have been questioned.
  • The sheikh stresses that the more precise term for the ordering is the date of revelation rather than the occasion alone.
  • The widely cited report on the number of verses is used only as a supporting indication of date, since it is weak.
  • He favors the view that the surah was revealed late in the Meccan period, based on these indications.
  • The story of Musa is presented as a parenthetical passage within the discussion of resurrection, consoling the Prophet ﷺ and the believers and warning the deniers.
  • The example of Pharaoh and his people shows that the strength of Quraysh and the Arabs would not avail them if they persisted in arrogance.
  • Tyranny is not limited to those who hold power; anyone who follows Pharaoh's path in arrogance shares in his likeness.

Questions & answers

What is the occasion of revelation of Surat An-Nazi'at?

The sheikh says the only reported occasion is the Prophet ﷺ being asked about the Hour, and that this report has been challenged in its chain and text, so it is not affirmed with certainty.

When was Surat An-Nazi'at revealed?

The sheikh inclines to a late Meccan date, relying on the widely cited report about the number of verses together with the question about the Hour as an indication, while noting that these reports are weak.

Why is the story of Musa mentioned in Surat An-Nazi'at?

The sheikh explains that the story comes as a parenthetical passage within the discussion of resurrection, consoling the Prophet ﷺ and the believers and warning the deniers of the Day of Judgment, with lessons from what befell Pharaoh and his people.

What is the lesson from Pharaoh in this surah?

Pharaoh and his people, despite their power and blessings, were not saved by them, so how much more so are those weaker than them among the disbelievers of Makkah and the Arabs. Anyone who walks the path of arrogance is likened to Pharaoh.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Qur’an verses cited in this lesson

  • Ad-Dukhan 44:25 — How many were the gardens and the watersprings that they left behind,
  • Ad-Dukhan 44:27 — And pleasant things wherein they took delight!
  • Ad-Dukhan 44:29 — And the heaven and the earth wept not for them, nor were they reprieved.

Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:04 The concise commentary
0:32 on the book *Bitaqat al-Ta'rif*
0:34 *bi-Suwar al-Mushaf al-Sharif*
0:38 by Dr. Muhammad ibn 'Abd al-'Aziz ibn 'Umar al-Nusayf,
0:41 may Allah preserve him.
0:44 Surah al-Nazi'at.
0:46 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful. All praise is due to Allah,
0:47 and may peace and blessings be upon His Messenger.
0:50 We continue with our concise commentary on *Bitaqat al-Ta'rif*,
0:53 and we have arrived at Surah al-Nazi'at,
0:55 with which I have three points to highlight.
0:57 The first point
0:59 concerns
1:01 the reasons for the revelation (asbab al-nuzul) of the surah.
1:03 Of course, only one reason has been narrated for it,
1:05 regarding the questioning of the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, about the Hour.
1:07 It has been noted that objections have been raised
1:10 against both its chain of narration and its text.
1:12 The reason for citing it in the first place
1:14 is that the book
1:16 which was adopted
1:18 as a reference for reasons of revelation
1:20 established it and considered it strong.
1:22 Otherwise, it has been contested,
1:25 and indeed the objection carries weight.
1:27 For example,
1:29 the narrations suggest
1:31 that the Prophet, peace be upon him, was asking
1:33 about the Hour
1:35 or continually mentioning it, or as stated
1:37 in the hadith; whereas the verse reads:
1:40 "They ask you about the Hour," confirming
1:42 an individual asking about the Hour,
1:44 or people asking
1:46 about the Hour. Therefore, it was
1:48 subject to scrutiny from this
1:50 aspect, alongside other aspects
1:52 found in the book *Al-Muharrar*
1:54 *fi Asbab al-Nuzul*.
1:56 As for the second point, it concerns the order of revelation
1:58 of the surah, where it is stated
2:00 that it is counted as the eightieth, revealed after Surah al-Naba'
2:02 and before Surah al-Infitar.
2:04 The reason for revelation of its concluding verses,
2:06 despite the critical remarks concerning it, gives an impression
2:08 of its being relatively late in revelation.
2:11 Here, you will observe
2:13 that
2:15 pointing to the reason for revelation while it contains
2:17 weakness—if it indeed has weakness
2:19 and is contested—how can it
2:21 be cited as evidence here?
2:23 The issue has two aspects.
2:25 The first aspect is the absence
2:27 of strong narrations
2:29 that define the exact time
2:31 of the revelation of this surah
2:33 or the dating of its revelation.
2:35 And perhaps I have pointed out
2:37 repeatedly that it is more fitting here
2:39 to say "the dating of the revelation,"
2:41 and I clarify this:
2:43 it is truly about the dating of its revelation.
2:45 Thus, in the absence
2:47 of strong narrations, one may draw supporting evidence
2:49 from these reports. The first is
2:51 its being counted as the eightieth according to the well-known narration
2:53 from Jabir ibn Zayd,
2:55 which I have discussed extensively before.
2:58 Another is the existence of this narration,
3:00 which may suggest a somewhat late period of revelation,
3:02 as the questioning about the Hour did not occur
3:04 at the very beginning. This is merely
3:06 circumstantial evidence, even if weak.
3:08 So its being counted as the eightieth
3:10 indicates its lateness,
3:12 and this reason for revelation also suggests its lateness.
3:14 The convergence of both
3:16 may support the view that it was
3:18 indeed revealed late,
3:20 towards the end of the Meccan period.
3:22 Of course, I mean
3:24 its lateness within the Meccan period,
3:26 because the surahs revealed in the Meccan period
3:28 are slightly more than eighty.
3:30 Thus, its being
3:32 the eightieth means it belongs to the end
3:34 of the Meccan period,
3:36 and Allah knows best.
3:39 As for the third and final point,
3:41 it concerns the story
3:44 of the Prophet of Allah, Musa, mentioned
3:46 in the passages of the surah.
3:48 In the first passage...
3:50 Surah al-Naba' before it
3:52 spoke about the Resurrection from beginning to end,
3:54 along with the proofs of the Resurrection.
3:56 Here, the Resurrection is mentioned
3:58 from the beginning of the surah to its end,
4:00 and then comes this passage
4:02 that speaks of the story of Musa
4:04 with Pharaoh.
4:06 So what is the relationship between this story
4:08 and the Resurrection?
4:10 And what is its connection to the verses before and after it?
4:12 This draws attention:
4:14 when a single story appears
4:16 in a surah rather than a collection of stories,
4:18 and it comes right in the middle of the surah
4:20 or even in
4:22 other placements,
4:24 as will come in Surah al-Shams,
4:26 this is indeed noteworthy.
4:28 The scholars have paused at this
4:30 and considered it a parenthetical remark—
4:32 this is an inserted clause
4:34 or inserted sentences
4:36 within the discourse on the Resurrection,
4:38 serving as a solace
4:40 for the Master of the Messengers,
4:42 peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,
4:44 and for the believers with him,
4:46 and as a warning to the disbelievers who deny
4:48 the Day of Recompense.
4:50 Nevertheless,
4:52 if you consult the Tafsir *Nazm al-Durar*,
4:54 you will find that he elaborated at length
4:56 on the suitability of this specific story,
4:58 to the exclusion of other stories,
5:00 for the theme of the Resurrection.
5:02 The destruction of Pharaoh,
5:04 what befell him and his people
5:07 until they were eradicated,
5:09 is deeply fitting with the theme of the Resurrection.
5:11 You will find this explained in detail there;
5:13 I do not wish to prolong it here,
5:15 at this juncture, upon His saying,
5:17 Exalted is He: "Has there reached you the story of Musa?"
5:19 Among the observations to note,
5:21 which al-Biqa'i also pointed out
5:23 in his Tafsir at this point,
5:25 is that Quraysh and the Arabs
5:27 in general did not possess the power
5:29 that Pharaoh possessed.
5:31 Yet, their power availed neither Pharaoh
5:33 nor those with him:
5:35 “How many were the gardens and the watersprings that they left behind,” (44:25)
5:37 "and crops and noble sites,"
5:39 “And pleasant things wherein they took delight!” (44:27)
5:41 "Thus. And We caused to inherit it another people."
5:43 “And the heaven and the earth wept not for them, nor were they reprieved.” (44:29)
5:45 So what then of those who are
5:47 in a far weaker state than them,
5:49 namely the disbelievers in Mecca
5:51 and the Arabs in general?
5:53 Eradicating them
5:55 is the easiest and most trivial matter for Allah.
5:57 It is as though anyone who acts tyrannically,
5:59 even if
6:01 his capabilities are limited,
6:03 resembles Pharaoh.
6:05 For this reason, Abu Jahl was described as
6:07 the Pharaoh of this Ummah,
6:09 even though he did not possess a kingdom.
6:12 Thus, the character of Pharaoh is not
6:14 restricted to someone who possesses a vast realm,
6:16 but applies to whoever walks
6:18 in his path
6:20 of tyranny—
6:23 we seek refuge in Allah.
6:25 This much is sufficient,
6:27 and I ask Allah to make this surah
6:29 a light for me and for you.
6:31 May Allah send peace and blessings upon our Prophet Muhammad,
6:33 and upon all his family and Companions,
6:35 and all praise is due to Allah, the Lord of all the worlds.