Part of The Gentle Commentary (series completed) · Lesson 49 of 117

The nice comment on the book of cards identifying the surahs of the Holy Qur’an | D. Muhammad Nassif | Surat Al-Tahrim

◉ 226 views ⏱ 7:04 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

In this installment of the commentary on Bitaqat al-Ta'reef, the sheikh examines Surat al-Tahrim at three points: the qualities of the believing woman mentioned in the verse of replacement, the sincere repentance (tawbah nasuh) which is singled out in this surah, and the examples of the wives of Nuh and Lut and the wife of Pharaoh, along with the connection between the surah's end and its beginning. He stresses that the surah is a unified, interconnected whole that is worth reciting in one rak'ah, and urges attention to reciting it in full to grasp its coherence.

Key takeaways

  • The qualities of the believing woman in the verse: Muslimat, Mu'minat, Qanitat, Ta'ibat, 'Abidat, Sa'ihat, which the sheikh says should be instilled in girls from a young age.
  • The importance of including these qualities in educational curricula so that Muslim women grow up strong and firmly attached to their religion.
  • The singling out of sincere repentance in this surah; the sheikh explains that reflecting on its context and allusions can reveal aspects of tawbah nasuh beyond what scholars' explanations typically cover.
  • The interconnectedness of a single surah, illustrated by the clear link between the example at the end of the surah and what happened with the Mothers of the Believers at its beginning.
  • The recommendation to recite Surat al-Tahrim in full in one rak'ah, since this aids understanding of its coherence and the meanings it discloses.
  • The point that reciting a surah in full during prayer is a reasonable length and not the excessive burden many people assume.
  • The sheikh notes that the Prophet's ﷺ transmitted practice was the regular norm, while avoiding undue hardship for worshippers.

Questions & answers

What qualities of the believing woman does the sheikh mention in Surat al-Tahrim?

From the verse of replacement he cites: Muslimat, Mu'minat, Qanitat, Ta'ibat, 'Abidat, Sa'ihat, and explains they are among the most important qualities of a believing Muslim woman and should be taught to girls.

Why is sincere repentance singled out in Surat al-Tahrim?

The sheikh says he does not have a definitive answer, but explains that reflecting on the surah's context and allusions can portray sincere repentance more broadly than what scholars have typically stated in their explanations.

Is it recommended to recite Surat al-Tahrim in one rak'ah?

Yes, the sheikh explains the surah is a complete, interconnected unit worth reciting in one rak'ah, which helps in understanding how its end connects to its beginning, while noting this is not the consistently transmitted practice of the Prophet ﷺ.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Entirely Merciful, the Especially Merciful.
0:02 A Gentle Commentary
0:32 on the Book *Identification Cards
0:35 for the Surahs of the Noble Qur'an*
0:37 by Dr. Muhammad ibn 'Abd al-'Aziz ibn 'Umar Nasif,
0:42 may Allah preserve him.
0:44 Surah al-Tahrim.
0:46 In the name of Allah, the Entirely Merciful, the Especially Merciful.
0:48 All praise is due to Allah, Lord of the worlds.
0:50 Peace and blessings be upon the Seal of the Prophets and Messengers,
0:53 and upon all his family and Companions.
0:55 We continue with our gentle commentary on the identification cards,
0:58 and we have arrived at Surah al-Tahrim.
1:00 I have three points of reflection concerning it.
1:03 The first point relates to what was mentioned regarding the central theme of the surah:
1:06 namely, that it sets forth the ideal model
1:09 for the believing woman,
1:11 who serves as a fundamental building block in constructing a faithful home.
1:14 And what a magnificent building block she is!
1:16 For if it is lost,
1:19 or if what is required
1:21 of its essential qualities
1:23 becomes deficient,
1:24 the entire household is weakened.
1:26 Where do we find these qualities?
1:27 We find them in several places within the surah,
1:29 but I will focus on one passage in particular,
1:31 which is the words of Allah, the Exalted:
1:32 "Perhaps his Lord, if he divorces you,
1:33 will substitute for him wives better than you—
1:35 submitting [to Allah], believing,
1:36 devoutly obedient,
1:37 repentant,
1:38 worshipping,
1:39 given to fasting [or migrating],
1:40 both previously married and virgins."
1:42 This last part represents a natural classification:
1:44 a woman is either previously married or a virgin,
1:47 and this does not affect
1:48 the ideal spiritual depiction of a believing woman.
1:51 Consider how Allah chooses for His Prophet,
1:54 and how He addresses his wives:
1:56 "Perhaps his Lord, if he divorces you,
1:57 will substitute for him wives better than you."
1:59 So what are the qualities
2:00 that Allah chooses for His Prophet?
2:02 "Submitting [to Allah], believing,
2:03 devoutly obedient,
2:04 repentant,
2:05 worshipping,
2:06 given to fasting."
2:07 These are the characteristics upon which
2:12 believing women ought to be nurtured from an early age,
2:14 and they should be integrated into educational curricula.
2:17 The most important qualities of the woman—
2:19 the Muslim,
2:20 the believer—
2:21 are precisely those mentioned here;
2:23 they represent the foremost traits of the female believer.
2:26 Although we cannot do without other verses
2:29 found in other surahs,
2:30 these are focused, explicit verses
2:33 that every believing woman should heed,
2:36 and which ought to be carefully considered by
2:38 educational curriculum developers.
2:40 In educating the Muslim woman,
2:42 whom we want to emerge strong
2:44 and firmly holding
2:45 to her religion.
2:46 The second point of reflection
2:48 concerns what is mentioned in the second passage of the surah:
2:51 the mention of sincere repentance (*al-tawbah al-nasuh*).
2:53 Indeed, sincere repentance
2:55 is not mentioned except in this surah.
2:58 And topics that are mentioned only once
3:01 are worthy of special attention.
3:04 Some works have been written on this:
3:06 Why was this surah specifically distinguished
3:09 with the mention of sincere repentance,
3:11 even though repentance is mentioned in many other surahs?
3:13 And what is sincere repentance?
3:15 I believe this requires careful study; I do not possess a definitive answer to this, but
3:21 I wished to open the door to exploring sincere repentance in the light of Surah al-Tahrim, within its context,
3:27 its subtle nuances, and its contents, which can portray the true essence of sincere repentance. It is true
3:31 that the scholars explained sincere repentance, but interpreting it in light of
3:37 the entire Surah al-Tahrim reveals many profound insights that were perhaps left unaddressed
3:43 by the scholars who defined it. This broader understanding,
3:50 attained through examining the context and the whole surah, increases our yearning for
3:56 this repentance and deepens our prior knowledge of it. As for the third
4:00 and final point of reflection, it concerns what is mentioned at the end of the surah regarding the parables drawn for
4:06 good and evil through women of earlier times: the wife of Noah, the wife of Lot, and the wife of Pharaoh.
4:12 This leads me to an issue that I frequently emphasize: that a surah
4:19 is profoundly interconnected. A single surah constitutes a tightly knit unity. The parable
4:25 at the end of the surah has an unmistakably clear connection to its beginning
4:30 and to what occurred regarding the Mothers of the Believers at the start of the surah. Thus, the claim that the surah
4:36 lacks internal coherence is thoroughly refuted by such clear examples. At times,
4:42 the connection is subtle and requires further scholarly effort and reflection; however, in
4:47 a surah such as this, the link between its ending and its beginning is self-evident.
4:53 Here I stress that since the surah is interconnected and forms
4:58 an integral whole, it deserves to be recited in a single rak'ah, as
5:04 the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, used to do. His predominant practice in recitation was
5:07 to complete the surah, though he might occasionally divide it. Yet this is a short surah of merely two pages.
5:12 We find long recitations burdensome—and I marvel at myself and others when we feel burdened by
5:17 a prayer that lasts for twenty minutes. In our standard practice,
5:20 the obligatory prescribed prayer almost never lasts twenty-five
5:24 minutes. Perhaps if one were to recite Surah al-Sajdah and Surah al-Insan
5:28 deliberately and slowly, it might reach this duration. How much time do we spend on
5:32 other matters? What harm would come to us if every prayer
5:36 were performed in half an hour, so that we might recite what the Prophet used to recite?
5:40 His recitation was lengthy compared to ours. I am not speaking
5:45 of what the Prophet, peace be upon him, forbade regarding driving people away by
5:48 excessively prolonging the prayer to the point of undue hardship. No; I am speaking of a moderate recitation.
5:52 When an imam recites Surah al-Tahrim in one rak'ah and Surah al-Talaq
5:55 before it in the other, it is considered by the general public today
5:59 an excessive prolongation, though it is not. If you were to calculate the duration of the prayer in which
6:05 these two surahs are recited, for instance, you would find that ultimately
6:08 it would not exceed fifteen minutes or something similar, which is not much.
6:13 It is certainly not much when one recognizes that prayer is light, that it restrains
6:18 from shameful and unjust deeds, that it is a means of drawing near to one's Lord, and that it holds
6:22 whatever virtues you wish to enumerate regarding prayer. This may be
6:26 a digression, but I emphasize that completing the entire surah
6:29 in one rak'ah greatly aids in understanding it, and realizing that the end
6:34 of this surah is intimately tied to its beginning reveals many profound meanings
6:37 thereafter—a realization largely achieved only through reciting it as a whole.
6:39 But if the imam begins his recitation after al-Fatihah with: "Allah presents
6:44 an example of those who disbelieved: the wife of Noah and the wife of Lot...",
6:46 the question remains: why did Allah set forth this parable, and how is it connected
6:49 to what came before it? Such insight is lost in this type of permissible recitation,
6:53 which does not reflect the regular, consistent Sunnah transmitted
6:57 from our Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. I will content myself with this,
6:59 and I invoke blessings upon our Prophet Muhammad and upon all his family and Companions.
7:01 All praise is due to Allah, Lord of the worlds.