Part of The Gentle Commentary (series completed) · Lesson 70 of 117

The nice comment on the book of cards identifying the surahs of the Holy Qur’an | D. Muhammad Nassif | Surah Al-Jathiya

◉ 158 views ⏱ 7:56 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

In this episode of "Al-Ta'liq al-Latif" on the book Bitaqat al-Ta'rif bi-Suwar al-Mushaf al-Sharif, the sheikh presents three points on Surat al-Jathiyah: the special attention some of the early scholars gave to the surahs beginning with Ha Mim and the need to study its narrations and the wisdom behind it; the occasion of revelation mentioned for the surah and the conditions for a report to count as one; and the division of the surah's sections, including the use of the transitional idrab in the verse "Am hasiba alladhina ijtarahu al-sayyi'at". He stresses that understanding the Qur'an requires the sciences of Arabic such as grammar, morphology and rhetoric. He closes by quoting Ibn Ashur that although the verse concerns disbelievers, it contains a lesson for the believer about the difference between the good-doers and the wrongdoers among believers.

Key takeaways

  • Some scholars gave special attention to the surahs beginning with Ha Mim; this deserves collecting the reports, studying their chains, and reflecting on the understanding behind these reports.
  • The book mentions one occasion of revelation for the surah, and the sheikh notes that it may not be a cause of revelation at all.
  • One condition for an occasion of revelation is that the event be new; if it was an existing Arab custom that Islam then nullified, it is not considered an occasion of revelation.
  • The report in al-Istiab fi al-Asbab, which does not use the term "revelation" at all, is cited as supporting the view that the mentioned report is not an occasion of revelation, and knowledge rests with Allah.
  • Naming the sections and openings of surahs is an ijtihadi matter tied to the language, so anyone studying Qur'anic tafsir needs the sciences of Arabic.
  • Idrab has two types: the cancelling kind that negates prior speech, and the transitional kind that moves to new speech without negating it; the verse uses the transitional kind.
  • The use of the relative clause "those who committed evil deeds" points to the difference in standing between wrongdoers and good-doers among believers, with the good-doer having a higher reward in the Hereafter.
  • The verse was called "the weeping place of worshippers" because of reports that Tamim al-Dari and Rabi' ibn Khuthaym wept at it, and it alerts the believer to correct shortcomings and do righteous deeds.

Questions & answers

What are the three points made about Surat al-Jathiyah?

The first is the special attention some early scholars gave to surahs beginning with Ha Mim and the study of their narrations and understanding; the second is the occasion of revelation of the surah and its conditions; the third is the sections of the surah and the transitional idrab in the verse "Am hasiba alladhina ijtarahu al-sayyi'at".

Is the report from Ibn Abbas an occasion of revelation for a verse of Surat al-Jathiyah?

The sheikh explains that a condition for an occasion of revelation is that the event be new; a practice already known among the Arabs and then nullified by the Sharia does not count as an occasion of revelation. He suggests the mentioned report may not be one, and knowledge rests with Allah.

What does the transitional idrab mean in the phrase "Am hasiba"?

It is a move from one speech to another without cancelling what came before. This is the type used in the verse, where "am" is used for transitional idrab.

What lesson does the believer take from the verse "Am hasiba alladhina ijtarahu al-sayyi'at"?

Quoting Ibn Ashur, the sheikh explains that the relative clause points to the difference between wrongdoers and good-doers among believers, prompting the believer to correct shortcomings and strive in good deeds.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Qur’an verses cited in this lesson

  • Al-Jathiyah 45:21 — Or do those who commit ill-deeds suppose that We shall make them as those who believe and do good works, the same in life and death? Bad is their judgment!

Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:02 "The Graceful Commentary
0:32 upon the Book of Introductory Profiles
0:35 to the Surahs of the Noble Qur'an,"
0:38 by Dr. Muhammad ibn Abdul-Aziz ibn Umar Nasif,
0:42 may Allah preserve him.
0:44 Surah al-Jathiyah.
0:46 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful. Praise be to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah.
0:51 We continue with our graceful commentary upon the introductory profiles,
0:54 and we arrive at Surah al-Jathiyah.
0:56 I have three points of reflection concerning it.
0:59 The first point of reflection—
1:01 which pertains to all the surahs beginning with Ha-Meem—
1:05 is that certain figures among the salaf (early generations),
1:08 as noted regarding the virtues of this surah,
1:10 explicitly stated in connection with the virtues of this surah
1:12 and the virtues of the other "Family of Ha-Meem" surahs preceding and succeeding it,
1:15 they observed that some of the salaf gave special attention to these surahs.
1:19 This special attention warrants scholarly study,
1:23 requiring both the compilation of the narrations and the examination of their chains of transmission.
1:26 The third matter, which is no less important than the previous two,
1:32 is the effort to derive fiqh from them and understand the secret and wisdom behind this keen interest.
1:40 In Ibn Kathir, at the beginning of Surah Ghafir,
1:43 there is a collection of such traditions, along with remarks
1:47 by Imam Ibn Kathir on some of those reports that truly merit deep reflection,
1:52 or rather, on one specific report among them.
1:54 I have explicitly emphasized these three dimensions
1:58 because many researchers restrict themselves merely to compiling narrations,
2:01 or, along with compiling, they evaluate the chains of transmission,
2:04 both of which are undoubtedly important.
2:07 Yet the research is only made complete by this third element:
2:10 clarifying the fiqh and deeper understanding of these traditions.
2:14 As for the second point of reflection,
2:17 it pertains to the occasion of revelation mentioned
2:20 or referenced in the book.
2:22 For this surah, according to the relied-upon reference,
2:25 has only one occasion of revelation cited.
2:27 The author noted that it might not actually constitute an occasion of revelation,
2:31 because the narrated report referenced from Ibn Abbas, may Allah be pleased with him and his father,
2:36 states: "An Arab man used to worship a stone;
2:39 when he found a better one, he would take it and discard the other."
2:43 Thereupon, Allah revealed the verse.
2:46 Now, among the fundamental criteria for an occasion of revelation to be validly considered as such—
2:50 as concluded in the book *Al-Muharrar*,
2:53 a work I repeatedly praise,
2:58 and which I only refrained from adopting because it restricted itself to the Nine Books,
3:01 whereas in terms of critical editing and meticulous precision
3:04 it is an invaluable work—
3:06 one of these criteria is that the occurrence must be an unprecedented event.
3:09 A new, specific incident must have occurred,
3:11 whether a spoken statement or an action,
3:13 to the end of what he stated.
3:15 Thus, there must be a novel event,
3:17 whereas this was an ongoing custom among the pre-Islamic Arabs,
3:19 or a practice well known among them
3:22 that the divine Law came to abolish;
3:24 hence, it cannot properly be called an occasion of revelation.
3:26 What further supports this view—
3:29 namely, that this narration does not constitute an occasion of revelation—
3:32 is that there is another narration in the book *Al-Isti'ab*,
3:35 graded as fair (hasan) by the author of the book,
3:37 *Al-Isti'ab fi Bayan al-Asbab*,
3:39 which does not contain the word "revelation" (nuzul) at all.
3:43 And knowledge belongs to Allah, the Exalted and Glorified.
3:45 The third and final point of reflection
3:47 concerns the thematic passages of the surah,
3:49 specifically in the second section.
3:52 The author stated: "In it is a digressive (idrabi),
3:55 transitional opening."
3:57 Of course, designating openings with such terms,
3:59 as previously mentioned, is a matter of scholarly ijtihad,
4:01 and it is intrinsically tied to linguistics.
4:04 Arabic linguistics is indispensable
4:06 for anyone studying the Tafsir of the Qur'an.
4:08 When you examine the opening of a verse
4:10 and wish to describe it,
4:12 you must employ the terminology of the linguists and rhetoricians.
4:14 Among these terms
4:16 is *idrab* (digression or retraction).
4:18 The most common way *idrab* is expressed
4:20 is through the use of
4:22 the particle *bal* (nay / rather).
4:24 Furthermore, *idrab* is of two kinds:
4:26 invalidating (*ibthali*), which refutes the preceding statement,
4:28 or transitional (*intiqali*),
4:30 which transitions to another discourse
4:32 without refuting the preceding one.
4:34 And this is what is employed here,
4:36 where it occurs as: "Or do those who..."
4:38 Here, "or" (*am*) serves the function of *idrab*,
4:40 an *idrab* of transition that does not invalidate
4:42 the preceding discourse.
4:45 I reiterate once more
4:47 that anyone who wishes to truly understand the Qur'an
4:49 is in dire need
4:51 of learning the disciplines
4:53 of the Arabic language:
4:55 syntax (nahw), morphology (sarf),
4:57 rhetoric (balaghah),
4:59 and others.
5:01 I conclude my remarks on this same point of reflection
5:03 with this verse:
5:05 ﴾Or do those who commit evil deeds suppose...﴿
5:07 “Or do those who commit ill-deeds suppose that We shall make them as those who believe and do good works, the same in life and death? Bad is their judgment!” (45:21)
5:09 ﴾...and do righteous deeds—﴿
5:11 ﴾—that their life and death will be equal?﴿
5:13 Regarding this verse,
5:15 the scholars have paused for profound reflections.
5:17 I relay to you
5:19 what al-Tahir ibn Ashur remarked,
5:21 which is an essential observation,
5:23 because the context of the verses is addressing the disbelievers,
5:25 yet despite that,
5:27 it contains an admonition for the believer.
5:29 The Shaykh, may Allah have mercy on him,
5:32 illuminate his grave, and elevate his status, says:
5:34 "Know that this verse,
5:36 even though its primary application
5:38 is to the respective states of the polytheists and the believers"—
5:40 meaning it was revealed for this reason
5:42 originally—
5:44 "the fact that the ruling is linked
5:46 to the relative clause 'those who commit evil deeds'..."
5:48 That is, the relative noun was used:
5:50 "those who commit evil deeds";
5:52 Allah did not say: "Or do those who disbelieve suppose...?"
5:54 “Or do those who commit ill-deeds suppose that We shall make them as those who believe and do good works, the same in life and death? Bad is their judgment!” (45:21)
5:56 Rather, He said: "Or do those who commit
5:58 evil deeds suppose...?" Thus, He tied the verdict
6:00 to this relative clause, namely, the committing
6:02 of evil deeds. Why?
6:04 He said: "Linking the ruling
6:06 to the relative clause 'those who commit evil deeds'
6:09 serves as an implicit allusion to
6:12 the disparity between the states of the wrongdoers and the righteous
6:15 among the people of faith."
6:17 For the wrongdoers among the people of faith commit
6:20 misdeeds, even if they do not reach the level of disbelief.
6:23 He said: "An allusion to the disparity between the states of the wrongdoers and the righteous
6:26 among the people of faith, even if none
6:29 among the believers would suppose such a thing"—meaning that both the believer
6:32 who falls into error and the righteous believer know that the righteous
6:35 is superior to the wrongdoer in reward in the Hereafter,
6:37 yet this rhetorical phrasing
6:40 drew attention to this distinction as a poignant reminder.
6:43 He added: "It is reported regarding Tamim al-Dari
6:45 that he spent an entire night reciting this verse, bowing,
6:48 prostrating, and weeping until the morning."
6:51 This report is found in Tafsir Ibn Kathir,
6:54 authenticated by the editor of Ibn Kathir, Dr. Hikmat Bashir.
6:58 He said: "A similar account is narrated on the authority of al-Rabi' ibn Khuthaym,"
7:01 until he said: "Thus, this verse used to be called
7:04 'the weeping place of the worshippers' (*Mubkat al-Abidin*)."
7:07 That is, as if it were the sanctuary where devoted worshippers weep.
7:11 Glory be to Allah! Even though it is a verse we might pass by,
7:14 and someone might assume—as al-Tahir pointed out regarding context—
7:18 someone might assume it only concerns the disbelievers:
7:20 a surah speaking about the disbelievers and their disbelief,
7:22 so a Muslim's mind relaxes, thinking it addresses only the heads of disbelief.
7:24 But Allah honored us by choosing the expression:
7:27 ﴾Or do those who commit evil deeds suppose...﴿,
7:29 so that it serves as an implicit hint and allusion to what may occur
7:33 of misdeeds among Muslims,
7:35 and that this impairs their standing before Allah.
7:37 This alerts us to rectify our affairs,
7:41 to remain heedful of our shortcomings,
7:43 and to remember that if we perform righteous deeds,
7:45 we will be raised higher in ranks.
7:48 And this, without doubt,
7:50 serves as a powerful incentive to righteous action.
7:52 May the peace and blessings of Allah be upon our Prophet Muhammad.