Part of The Gentle Commentary (series completed) · Lesson 77 of 117

The nice comment on the book of cards identifying the surahs of the Holy Qur’an | D. Muhammad Nassif | Surah p

◉ 141 views ⏱ 6:53 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

In this final episode of the series "At-Ta'leeq al-Lateef" on the book "Bitaqat at-Ta'reef bi-Suwar al-Mushaf ash-Sharif", Dr. Muhammad Nseif discusses three points about Surah Sad. He first corrects an error in the book regarding the order of the surah's revelation, then explains the surah's method of patience in the face of intense denial and opposition, and mentions what helps one be patient, namely the stories of the prophets and the mention of Paradise and Hellfire. In the final point he clarifies that the required stance toward the disbelievers is patience rather than mere consolation, and closes with a subtle observation that recompense is of the same kind as the deed.

Key takeaways

  • A correction to the book: the correct position is that Surah Sad was revealed after Surah Al-Qamar and before Surah Al-A'raf, and the claim that it came after Al-Furqan is taken from Surah Fatir.
  • A note that some of the surah's verses may suggest a later revelation, namely the verses mentioned in the reports on occasions of revelation, with the mention of disagreement over their authenticity.
  • Patience is required when denial and opposition intensify, and it is not merely a word of comfort for emotions as some people may think.
  • Patience is necessary in calling a disbelieving person who turns away, and also in calling a Muslim who commits sins, so that the caller is not tempted and continues his call.
  • The surah helps one be patient by mentioning the stories of the prophets such as Dawud, Sulayman, Ayyub, Ibrahim, Ishaq and Isma'il, peace be upon them.
  • Mentioning Paradise and Hellfire and the Hereafter in the surah also helps patience, and the required stance toward the disbelievers is patience, not consolation.
  • A subtle point: recompense is of the same kind as the deed; whoever is patient has the gates of Paradise opened for him, and patience involves constraint while the opening of Paradise involves expansiveness and freedom.

Questions & answers

What is the correct position on the revelation order of Surah Sad?

The sheikh explains that the correct position is what is recorded in the table, namely that Surah Sad is counted as the thirty-seventh surah, after Surah Al-Qamar and before Surah Al-A'raf. The book's statement that it is the forty-second, after Al-Furqan, is an error taken from Surah Fatir.

What method does Surah Sad set when denial intensifies?

The method is patience. Allah commanded His Prophet ﷺ to be patient with what the deniers say. Patience is necessary in calling a disbelieving person who turns away, and likewise a Muslim who falls into sin.

What helps a person be patient according to the surah?

Mentioning the stories of righteous prophets such as Dawud, Sulayman, Ayyub, Ibrahim, Ishaq and Isma'il, peace be upon them, along with mention of Paradise, Hellfire and the Hereafter.

What is meant by the principle that recompense is of the same kind as the deed in this surah?

The sheikh notes that the context of patience suited the mention of Paradise in the words "gates of Eden, opened for them". Whoever obeys Allah and is patient has the gates of good opened to him, while whoever abandons patience may find many gates of goodness closed. He does not present this as a tafsir of the verse, but as a principle.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Qur’an verses cited in this lesson

  • Al-Insan 76:12 — And hath awarded them for all that they endured, a Garden and silk attire;

Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Entirely Merciful, the Especially Merciful.
0:03 The commentary entitled *Al-Ta'liq al-Latif*
0:32 on the book *Bitaqat al-Ta'rif*
0:35 *bi-Suwar al-Mushaf al-Sharif*,
0:38 by Dr. Muhammad Ibn 'Abd al-'Aziz Ibn 'Umar Nasif,
0:42 may Allah preserve him.
0:44 Surah Sad.
0:46 In the name of Allah, the Entirely Merciful, the Especially Merciful. All praise is due to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah.
0:50 We continue with our commentary *Al-Ta'liq al-Latif*
0:52 on *Bitaqat al-Ta'rif*,
0:54 specifically with Surah Sad.
0:56 I have three observations concerning it.
0:58 The first observation pertains to an error
1:00 that occurred in the book.
1:02 If you look at the diagram
1:04 regarding the order of the surah,
1:06 specifically its chronological order of revelation,
1:08 and naturally it concerns the dating of Surah Sad,
1:10 it states that it is counted as the thirty-seventh,
1:12 revealed after Surah al-Qamar and before Surah al-A'raf.
1:14 This statement is correct.
1:16 However, in the main body of the book,
1:18 it says that it is widely considered the forty-second, revealed after Surah al-Furqan,
1:20 and so forth.
1:22 That is incorrect.
1:24 That applies to Surah Fatir;
1:26 this text was taken from the entry on Surah Fatir,
1:28 as you would see if you compared them, and erroneously placed here.
1:30 It is a sheer mistake.
1:32 The correct position is what was established in the diagram:
1:34 it is counted as the thirty-seventh, after al-Qamar and before al-A'raf.
1:36 To this should be added
1:38 that some of its verses suggest a later revelation,
1:40 namely the verses mentioned
1:42 in the contexts of revelation (Asbab al-Nuzul).
1:44 There is disagreement
1:46 regarding their authenticity, as it was narrated that they were revealed
1:48 upon the death of Abu Talib,
1:50 or during Abu Talib's illness,
1:52 which was explained as his terminal illness,
1:54 as mentioned by Ibn 'Atiyyah.
1:56 Thus, the first pause is to correct this error.
1:58 The second pause
2:01 concerns a methodology
2:03 outlined for us by this surah
2:05 when denial, turning away,
2:07 and obstinacy intensify
2:09 on the part of opponents.
2:11 What is required of a person?
2:13 We learn the answer from this surah.
2:15 For Allah, Glorified and Exalted be He, after the first page filled
2:17 with the deniers' disbelief, said:
2:19 "Be patient."
2:21 Patience.
2:23 Some people might take this word lightly;
2:25 when someone says
2:27 to another that
2:29 people have turned away from obedience
2:31 and immersed themselves in sins,
2:33 and the response given is, "Be patient,"
2:35 he might think that this word
2:37 is out of place,
2:39 or that it is merely a sedative
2:41 for emotional comfort, as they say.
2:43 But this is entirely untrue.
2:45 Patience is indispensable
2:47 in the face of harm, denial, and rejection.
2:49 If it comes from a disbeliever
2:51 who has turned away completely,
2:53 then without a doubt patience is required.
2:55 And if it comes from a fellow Muslim
2:57 who has fallen into many violations
2:59 and indulged in sins, you equally require,
3:01 while calling him to righteousness, to exercise patience.
3:03 Patience, lest you be seduced and become
3:05 like him, and so that you can persevere in calling him.
3:07 Patience is therefore essential.
3:10 Moreover, Allah, Glorified and Exalted be He,
3:12 has mentioned,
3:14 and explicitly cited in this surah what aids one in patience.
3:16 Clearly, He said: "Be patient over what they say,"
3:18 and then He mentioned—
3:20 and He began mentioning—
3:22 and began recounting the stories:
3:24 "and remember Our servant David," and then He said,
3:26 mentioning Solomon along with him, then He said,
3:28 "and remember Our servant Job," then He said,
3:30 "and remember Our servants,
3:32 Abraham and Isaac,"
3:34 and then He said, "and remember Ishmael."
3:36 Thus, among the things that foster patience
3:38 is remembering the Prophets
3:40 and the righteous—
3:42 here, specifically the Prophets.
3:44 Recalling the stories of the Prophets
3:46 aids in maintaining patience.
3:48 Then He said,
3:50 Glorified and Exalted be He: "This is
3:52 a reminder, and indeed, for the righteous
3:54 is a good place of return," and then He said,
3:56 "This—and indeed, for the transgressors
3:58 is an evil place of return."
4:00 So, mentioning Paradise and Hellfire
4:02 is also among the things that aid
4:04 in this momentous matter:
4:06 patience.
4:09 Proceeding from this point,
4:11 the third observation—
4:13 which is closely connected to it
4:15 and built upon it—
4:17 is that when examining the theme of the surah,
4:19 as known from its sections
4:21 and contents,
4:23 it speaks about the sheer intensity
4:25 of the disbelievers' turning away,
4:27 and the corresponding attitude
4:29 required toward them.
4:31 Then the author wrote: "to console the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him."
4:33 No, it is not quite phrased like that.
4:35 Regarding "the corresponding attitude required toward them,"
4:37 that phrase falls short;
4:39 the required attitude is patience itself,
4:41 not merely being consoled.
4:43 He should have said: "patience,
4:45 recalling the stories of the Prophets,
4:47 and the Hereafter."
4:49 For patience is what is demanded
4:51 in the face of the disbelievers' rejection,
4:53 and what aids in cultivating patience
4:55 are the stories of the Prophets and the Hereafter.
4:57 The accounts of these specific Prophets
4:59 especially foster patience.
5:01 Reflect upon them.
5:03 We also observe—
5:05 and this is an observation of
5:07 subtle insight (lata'if)—
5:09 that since the context
5:11 was one of patience,
5:13 when He described Paradise, He said:
5:15 "Gardens of perpetual residence, whose doors
5:17 will be opened for them."
5:20 It is as though a person—
5:22 and the general principle is that the reward corresponds to the nature of the deed—
5:24 when obeying Allah,
5:26 shuts many of the doors
5:28 that might otherwise bring him
5:30 deceptive worldly
5:32 pleasures,
5:34 by which he would compromise his religion.
5:36 I do not claim that this is the formal Tafsir of the verse,
5:38 but rather I say:
5:40 the reward corresponds to the nature of the deed.
5:42 Whoever desires the doors to be wide open for him
5:44 on the Day of Resurrection
5:46 in Paradise,
5:48 must exercise patience
5:50 here in this life. For patience entails a sense of
5:52 constriction, whereas having doors opened
5:54 offers expansive spaciousness.
5:56 If a place is pleasant,
5:58 it might suffice you even if the door is closed;
6:00 yet opening the door adds further spaciousness
6:02 and freedom.
6:04 Thus, it was most fitting,
6:06 when urging towards patience,
6:08 to remind the believer of this
6:10 reward,
6:12 which stands in direct contrast
6:14 to the constriction of patience—just as He stated in Surah
6:16 al-Insan, where
6:18 He explicitly mentioned patience, saying:
6:20 “And hath awarded them for all that they endured, a Garden and silk attire;” (76:12)
6:22 "and silk garments." For Paradise
6:24 is vast, whereas this world
6:26 and patience entail hardship and constriction;
6:28 Paradise offers soft silk,
6:30 whereas patience involves
6:33 a degree of roughness,
6:35 a psychological hardship.
6:37 So, whenever a person keeps this reward in mind,
6:39 he will endure this
6:41 trial with patience.
6:43 All praise is due to Allah, first and last,
6:45 outwardly and inwardly.
6:47 May Allah send blessings upon our Prophet Muhammad and upon all his family and Companions.
6:49 And all praise is due to Allah, the Lord of all the worlds.