Résumé des concepts sunnites | Concept (68) | L'hérésie de la délégation et la réponse à celle-ci
Résumé de la leçon
In this episode, the Sheikh explains the innovation of tafwid (delegation of meaning), to which the Ash'aris resort when they are unable to interpret the attributes, under the pretext of exalting Allah above resemblance to His creation. They claim it is the creed of the Salaf. The Sheikh holds that this statement contains two errors: a bad assumption about the Salaf and preferring the later scholars over them, and attributing incapacity and futility to Allah in addressing His servants with speech they do not understand. He cites verses showing that the Qur'an is made easy for remembrance, understanding, reflection and reasoning, and clarifies that the inimitability of the Qur'an does not mean its meanings cannot be understood.
Points clés
- Tafwid is the statement that the intended meaning of an attribute is entrusted to Allah alone; the Ash'aris resort to it after failing to interpret.
- Its proponents claim tafwid is the creed of the Salaf, which the Sheikh denies, considering it a false attribution to them.
- The claim that the method of the Salaf is safer while the method of the later scholars is more knowledgeable and wiser contains a bad assumption about the Salaf and preference of the later generations over them.
- Tafwid is in reality incapacity and helplessness, and it involves a bad assumption about the All-Wise, All-Aware Allah and attributing futility to Him in addressing His creation.
- The Qur'an is made easy for remembrance, which includes making its words easy to memorize, its meanings easy to understand, and its commands and prohibitions easy to comply with.
- Reflecting upon the Qur'an and reasoning about its meanings cannot be achieved without understanding its meanings, as indicated by His saying: "Indeed, We have sent it down as an Arabic Qur'an that you might use reason."
- The inimitability of the Qur'an means the eloquent are unable to produce its like, while it flows in the styles of Arabic speech and is made easy to understand, not that its meanings cannot be grasped.
Questions et réponses
What is tafwid in creed?
Tafwid is saying that one entrusts the intended meaning of an attribute to Allah the Exalted, since He knows His own intent. The Ash'aris resort to it when they cannot interpret an attribute, under the pretext of tanzih (exaltation above resemblance), as the Sheikh explains.
Is tafwid the creed of the Salaf?
The Sheikh notes that the Ash'aris claim this, but he holds that this tafwid, falsely attributed to the Salaf, is in reality incapacity, helplessness and a bad assumption about Allah.
Why does the Sheikh reject the claim that the method of the Salaf is safer while the method of the later scholars is more knowledgeable?
Because this claim contains a bad assumption about the Salaf and makes the later scholars more knowledgeable and wiser than them, though the Salaf were closer to the revelation of the Qur'an and received its meanings from the Messenger ﷺ.
Does the inimitability of the Qur'an mean that its meaning cannot be understood?
No. The Sheikh clarifies that the inimitability of the Qur'an means silencing the eloquent and the inability of the eloquent to produce its like, while it flows in the styles of Arabic speech and is made easy for understanding and reflection.
Résumé généré automatiquement à partir de la transcription ; la leçon elle-même fait foi.