Part of The Gentle Commentary (series completed) · Lesson 115 of 117

The nice comment on the book of cards identifying the surahs of the Holy Qur’an | D. Muhammad Nassif | Surah Al Imran (2)

◉ 500 views ⏱ 11:00 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson timeline

  1. 00:00 Introduction to the commentary on Surah Al-Imran
  2. 01:02 Sources of the surah's division and its ijtihadi nature
  3. 04:04 Key to dividing the surah by similar opening phrases
  4. 05:05 Dividing the surah into three parts and a conclusion
  5. 07:09 Part two: disputing the People of the Book and Najran Christians
  6. 08:10 Part three: the Battle of Uhud and faith-based guidance
  7. 09:13 The character of the believers in surahs about fighting
  8. 10:14 Believing People of the Book and the closing verses

Lesson summary

In this second part of the commentary on the introduction cards to Surah Al Imran, the sheikh explains how the surah is divided into sections, stressing that the division is an ijtihadi (scholarly-inferred) aid to understanding and carries no legal ruling. He relies mainly on the tafsirs of al-Tabari and Ibn Ashur while examining the context. He sees the surah as an introduction defining Allah, then a section on the debate with the People of the Book (linked to the Christians of Najran), then a section on the Battle of Uhud and the training of the believers afterward, closing with a conclusion that reminds of the character of the believers.

Key takeaways

  • The division presented is ijtihadi and not definitive; its purpose is to bring the surah's meaning closer and organize its topics, and no legal ruling is built on it.
  • The sheikh's main sources for determining meaning and context are the tafsirs of Imam al-Tabari and Imam Ibn Ashur.
  • One key to dividing the surah is the similarity of verse openings, such as the vocative opening (O you who...) at the start of sections.
  • The first section defines Allah, and it connects to the following sections, as in the verse: Allah, there is no deity except Him, the Ever-Living, the Sustainer.
  • The second section deals with the debate with the People of the Book, which the sheikh links to the Christians of Najran.
  • The third section addresses the Battle of Uhud and what the Muslims suffered, and how Allah trained them in belief and strengthened their faith.
  • The conclusion reminds of the believers' noble character and warns against being deceived by the disbelievers' movements, and notes that some People of the Book do believe.

Questions & answers

Into how many sections does Sheikh Muhammad Nseif divide Surah Al Imran?

The sheikh explains that the surah can be divided into three sections and a conclusion, noting that this division is ijtihadi and not definitive.

What key helps in dividing the surahs of the Quran?

Among the most important keys is the similarity of verse openings, such as the repeated vocative opening (O you who...) at the start of sections, though the meaning-based aspect is also important.

What is the topic of the third section of Surah Al Imran?

The third section deals with the Battle of Uhud and what the Muslims suffered in it, and how Allah trained them in belief and kept them firm in faith afterward.

Why does the sheikh consider the first section an introduction to the surah?

Because the first section defines Allah, and this definition is connected to the second and third sections, such as the verse: Indeed, the religion in the sight of Allah is Islam, and the verse: Say, O Allah, Owner of sovereignty.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Qur’an verses cited in this lesson

  • Ali 'Imran 3:100 — O ye who believe! If ye obey a party of those who have received the Scripture they will make you disbelievers after your belief.
  • Ali 'Imran 3:113 — They are not all alike. Of the People of the Scripture there is a staunch community who recite the revelations of Allah in the night season, falling prostrate (before Him).
  • Ali 'Imran 3:196 — Let not the vicissitude (of the success) of those who disbelieve, in the land, deceive thee (O Muhammad).

Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:30 A Brief Commentary
0:32 on the Book "Introductory Cards
0:35 to the Surahs of the Noble Mus-haf"
0:38 by Dr. Muhammad ibn Abd al-Aziz ibn Umar Nassif,
0:42 may Allah preserve him.
0:44 Surah Al 'Imran.
0:46 In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.
0:48 All praise is due to Allah, and peace and blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah.
0:53 We continue with the brief commentary
0:55 on the introductory cards,
0:57 and this is the second segment
0:59 pertaining to Surah Al 'Imran.
1:02 In this segment, there are three pause points.
1:04 The first pause point:
1:06 we have a heading
1:08 which is "The Passages of the Surah,"
1:10 and in the diagram, "Its Passages."
1:12 Here, an inquirer might ask:
1:14 What reference work was relied upon
1:16 for this introductory overview?
1:18 Was it a single reference or more?
1:20 Because in some of the overviews I referenced,
1:22 I relied upon a single book,
1:24 such as the occasions of revelation (Asbab al-Nuzul),
1:26 to which I referred in this manner.
1:28 What about this thematic division?
1:30 I say: the truth is that I
1:32 initially began with one of the contemporary books,
1:34 following its lead, because
1:36 most of the books that divided—
1:38 and within the limits of my reading, the books that divided—
1:40 the surah into passages,
1:42 or what they might call passages,
1:44 or call sections, or otherwise,
1:46 are mostly contemporary works.
1:48 So I followed the approach of some of them,
1:50 but then I noticed that I needed
1:52 to ponder the context more deeply
1:54 and determine the intended meaning
1:56 of each
1:58 verse, in order to know whether this
2:00 division that I initially adopted
2:02 was precise or not.
2:04 Thus, it was as though the main works
2:06 I returned to—indeed,
2:08 perhaps the only works I returned
2:10 to—were just two books:
2:12 the book of Imam al-Tabari,
2:14 *Jami' al-Bayan*,
2:16 the Tafsir of Imam al-Tabari,
2:19 and the book of Imam
2:21 Ibn Ashur, may Allah have mercy on them all,
2:23 in his Tafsir, *al-Tahrir
2:25 wa-l-Tanwir*.
2:27 These two references are distinguished
2:29 by several features.
2:31 They are distinguished by
2:33 their keenness to specify
2:35 the intended meaning; that is, when
2:37 the People of the Book are mentioned, are they the Jews or the Christians
2:39 in this particular verse?
2:41 When the believers are addressed, which specific group is being addressed?
2:43 And so forth. These two
2:45 scholars are meticulous
2:47 in this regard,
2:49 and they are keen on paying close attention to context.
2:51 People might know this—
2:53 rather, I think they know it—
2:55 regarding Ibn Ashur, but some
2:57 readers do not pay attention to this
2:59 in Imam al-Tabari's work,
3:01 and I do not exaggerate when I say that the attention
3:03 Imam al-Tabari gives to this
3:05 is exceptionally profound.
3:07 Therefore, I relied upon these two books
3:09 after the initial division.
3:11 Consequently, the division presented here
3:13 now
3:15 is not confined
3:17 to a single book,
3:19 and you will not find any single book that matches it
3:21 entirely, while still benefiting
3:23 from what I have mentioned.
3:25 Then, the second pause point:
3:27 these structural divisions are a matter of ijtihad (scholarly discretion).
3:29 That is to say, it is possible
3:32 for us to ponder the surah further,
3:34 and it is not non-discretionary.
3:36 Moreover, someone else who reads the surah
3:38 might see something different.
3:40 These are divisions
3:42 upon which no legal ruling (hukm shar'i) is built;
3:44 rather, they are divisions meant to facilitate our understanding
3:46 of the surah due to its length.
3:48 The surah contains several themes,
3:50 so we need
3:52 to divide it in order
3:54 to grasp the context, the themes,
3:56 and the like.
3:58 Therefore, if you ponder the surah,
4:00 you may notice that it
4:02 could be divided in another way.
4:04 This is why you find me
4:06 also saying:
4:08 "It is possible to divide
4:10 the surah," or "it is divided,"
4:12 or "it has been divided,"
4:14 and similar expressions
4:16 in the passive voice,
4:18 or with a passive participle,
4:20 to indicate that it is not a definitive,
4:22 absolute division,
4:24 nor that the surah objectively only divides into this
4:26 specific structure.
4:28 I will give you one of the keys
4:30 for dividing passages that helps,
4:33 and it is a tremendous key
4:35 that I have pointed out in many
4:37 sections,
4:39 though it is not the only key:
4:41 the similar openings of verses.
4:43 If you observe
4:45 now in the surah,
4:47 you will find that the first section contains
4:49 a vocative opening,
4:51 the second section contains a vocative opening,
4:53 and the third section contains a vocative opening.
4:55 These vocative openings
4:57 serve as a key,
4:59 because
5:01 "O you..."
5:03 Pardon me, my eyes wandered to Surah al-Baqarah;
5:05 it has this exact pattern:
5:07 a vocative opening—
5:09 "O mankind, worship," "O mankind, eat," "O you who have believed, enter."
5:13 Thus, the opening is similar, and this helps in identifying new themes
5:18 or new sections; this is helpful in many surahs of the Qur'an, though perhaps
5:24 the short surahs from Surah al-Duha to al-Nas are an exception. As for most
5:29 surahs, they exhibit this verbal connection: the repetition or similarity of verse openings.
5:37 This is a textual feature, and it is not the only one, as I mentioned, that aids in understanding
5:45 the division or dividing the surah; rather, the thematic aspect is also crucial, and the discussion
5:51 on this is extensive. It may become clear to whoever listens to the full lessons and the detailed explanation;
5:56 many things will also become apparent to them that I have not highlighted here. The third and final pause point
6:02 concerns the division of Surah Al 'Imran: it is divided into three sections, or we can say
6:09 it can be divided into three sections, and after these three sections comes an epilogue.
6:14 This word "Epilogue" was omitted from the text of the book but was mentioned in the diagram; it was not mentioned on
6:23 the page preceding the diagram, but it was mentioned in the diagram. We have a first section, a second
6:28 section, a third section, and an epilogue. The first section contains an introduction to Allah, the Exalted,
6:33 and we can make this introduction a prologue; that is, we can make this first section
6:40 the prologue of the surah. Why? Because it is an introduction to Allah that connects to the second section
6:47 and the third: a part of this introduction connects to the second section—as al-Tabari pointed out—
6:52 and a part connects to the third section. A part of the first section,
7:00 which introduces Allah,
7:01 connects to the second section,
7:03 and a part of the first section
7:05 connects to the third section.
7:07 So, what is the content of the second section and the third section?
7:09 The second section—
7:10 and this relates to the events of the surah that we discussed—
7:13 the second section
7:14 debates the People of the Book,
7:15 especially the Christians,
7:17 and connects this
7:18 to the Christians of Najran.
7:21 The third section relates to the Battle of Uhud
7:24 and what befell the Muslims during it,
7:26 and how Allah, Glorified and Exalted, nurtured
7:29 the Muslims after the Battle of Uhud with a creedal upbringing, drawing their attention to matters
7:35 that were the cause of the defeat,
7:37 correcting their perceptions, and reaffirming them in faith.
7:40 I mentioned that the first section
7:42 contains a part relating
7:44 to the second section, which is the dialogue with the People of the Book.
7:47 Among the clearest examples of this is His saying: "Allah, there is no deity except Him, the Ever-Living, the Sustainer of existence" at the beginning of the surah,
7:51 and His saying: "It is He who forms you in the wombs however He wills,"
7:55 and His saying: "Indeed, the religion in the sight of Allah is Islam."
7:59 As for
8:01 the part that relates to the third section,
8:04 it is exemplified by His saying, Exalted is He: "Say, 'O Allah, Owner of Sovereignty, You give sovereignty to whom You will
8:08 and You take sovereignty away from whom You will,
8:10 and You honor whom You will and You humble whom You will.'"
8:12 In these verses, you find a connection
8:14 to what is mentioned in the surah's third section
8:18 regarding the Battle of Uhud,
8:20 and that sovereignty belongs to Allah, and all command belongs to Him, Glorified and Exalted.
8:24 There remains the epilogue of the surah.
8:26 Of course, the first section from the beginning of the surah,
8:29 we can treat as a prologue, as I said.
8:31 The second section begins with: "Indeed, Allah chose Adam and Noah..."
8:34 And the third section—
8:36 if we make the first section a prologue,
8:38 we can make the third section the second main part—
8:42 begins with His saying, Exalted is He:
8:44 "O you who have believed..."
8:46 “O ye who believe! If ye obey a party of those who have received the Scripture they will make you disbelievers after your belief.” (3:100)
8:48 “O ye who believe! If ye obey a party of those who have received the Scripture they will make you disbelievers after your belief.” (3:100)
8:52 As for the epilogue,
8:54 it begins with His saying, Glorified and Exalted:
8:56 "Indeed, in the creation of the heavens
8:59 "and the earth, and the alternation of the night and the day,"
9:01 "are signs for people of understanding—"
9:03 And just as the first section
9:05 connects with the second and third sections,
9:07 as I mentioned, serving as an introduction,
9:09 so too the conclusion connects with both sections.
9:13 For within it is a reminder of the character of the believers,
9:17 and this recurs across the surahs of the Qur'an
9:19 in which fighting and jihad are mentioned:
9:21 the moral virtues of the believers are recalled.
9:23 There are precedents for this
9:25 in Surah al-Anfal and Surah at-Tawbah.
9:27 Here as well, it highlights the traits of the believers,
9:30 and we notice that these are mostly
9:32 virtues that are not physical attributes
9:34 required in combat,
9:36 such as bodily strength and the like;
9:38 rather, they are moral qualities
9:40 or acts of the heart,
9:42 such as the fear
9:44 of Allah, reflection, and similar inner deeds.
9:46 This feature is not unique to this surah.
9:48 Re-emphasizing the moral character of the believers
9:50 is particularly fitting in the context of the Battle of Uhud,
9:52 and also
9:54 relevant to the aftermath of Uhud
9:56 and warfare in general.
9:58 Likewise, in this conclusion,
10:00 there is a prohibition against being deceived by the uninhibited movement of the disbelievers
10:02 “Let not the vicissitude (of the success) of those who disbelieve, in the land, deceive thee (O Muhammad).” (3:196)
10:04 throughout the land, which is deeply pertinent
10:06 to what transpired at Uhud.
10:08 Furthermore, near the end
10:10 of the conclusion, or shortly
10:12 before it, we find a reminder
10:14 that among the People of the Book
10:16 are true believers. This connects directly
10:18 to the debate with the People of the Book
10:20 that appeared earlier in the surah:
10:22 "They are not all alike; among the People of the Book..."
10:24 “They are not all alike. Of the People of the Scripture there is a staunch community who recite the revelations of Allah in the night season, falling prostrate (before Him).” (3:113)
10:26 "...during the hours of the night, prostrating themselves."
10:28 And here Allah says: "And indeed, among the People of the Book are those who believe in Allah
10:30 and what has been revealed to you and what has been revealed to them,
10:32 humbling themselves before Allah. They do not exchange the verses of Allah for a small price.
10:34 Those will have their reward with their Lord.
10:36 Indeed, Allah is swift in account."
10:38 Thus, these verses are tied to the overarching themes of the surah.
10:41 Then comes the final verse of the surah,
10:43 which ties the entire surah together.
10:45 Through deep reflection, you will surely discover
10:47 abundant insights that I have not mentioned,
10:49 and which may not have even crossed my mind;
10:51 its wonders never cease.
10:53 May Allah send blessings upon our Prophet Muhammad,
10:55 and upon his family and all his Companions.
10:57 And all praise is due to Allah, Lord of the worlds.