Part of Concepts of Ahl as-Sunnah (series completed) · Lesson 1125 of 1251

Summary of Sunni concepts | Concept (1123) | Negatives resulting from implementing previous goals

◉ 8 views ⏱ 3:40 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

The lesson explains the negative consequences of applying the previously discussed goals within the socialist communist system, including central planning of resources, its high cost, and the slow return on its projects. The sheikh explains that this system resorts to nationalization, taxes, and interest-based foreign borrowing, which lead to poverty and injustice instead of the claimed prosperity. He also discusses the drawbacks of central government administration, such as slow decision-making, laziness, absence of incentives, and favoring loyalty over competence. He concludes that these flaws are evaluated from the perspective of worldly interests, in addition to their conflict with Sharia.

Key takeaways

  • Central planning of resources requires huge projects with high costs that drain the country's resources.
  • The returns on these projects are slow and do not appear until after a long time that peoples cannot afford to wait for.
  • Nationalization, which the system resorts to, is an injustice to private ownership that Sharia does not approve.
  • Taxes, fees, and interest-based foreign loans used to cover deficits erase blessing and often leave the state unable to repay.
  • Central administration suffers from slow decisions and lost investment opportunities, and from laziness due to the lack of incentives tied to quality.
  • Giving preference to the loyal over the competent leads to the failure of public-sector institutions, forcing the state to sell them to the private sector.

Questions & answers

What are the negative effects of central planning of resources?

The sheikh explains that central planning requires huge projects with very high costs that drain the country's resources, and their returns are slow and do not appear for a long time that peoples cannot afford to wait for.

Why are nationalization and interest-based borrowing considered drawbacks?

The sheikh explains that nationalization is an injustice that Sharia does not approve, as it affects properties of individuals who sacrificed greatly to establish them, and interest-based borrowing erases blessing and often leaves the state unable to repay.

What are the defects of central government administration?

Among them are slow decision-making, laziness because the employee knows his salary comes at month's end regardless of performance, the absence of satisfying incentives, and appointing those trusted over those with competence, which leads to the failure of public-sector institutions.

Are these negative effects only worldly?

The sheikh clarifies that these flaws are assessed from the perspective of worldly interests and gains, in addition to the Sharia violations they contain and their clear conflict with the way Allah has chosen for His servants to achieve both their religious and worldly interests in full balance and harmony.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 A summary of the concepts held by the Ahl al-Sunnah.
0:08 The negative consequences resulting from implementing the aforementioned objectives.
0:12 The attempt to implement these previous objectives is sustained by several negative outcomes.
0:20 Among them, firstly:
0:22 Centralized planning for resource management necessitates,
0:26 The establishment of massive projects to cover the needs of society.
0:31 The cost of this is extremely high and drains the country's resources.
0:37 Furthermore, its returns are slow, and its impact does not appear until after a long time,
0:43 A duration that the people cannot endure.
0:46 Secondly:
0:47 The previous negative outcome forces the socialist-communist system into three matters,
0:53 All of which have dire consequences.
0:56 The first of these:
0:58 Resorting to the nationalization of companies, factories, and farms already existing under the system,
1:04 Which are owned by individuals who sacrificed everything precious and valuable to establish them.
1:10 This is an injustice that the Sharia does not approve of.
1:13 The second of these:
1:15 Imposing sales taxes and transaction fees,
1:19 In an attempt to cover the state budget deficit.
1:23 The third of these:
1:25 Borrowing from abroad to cover the cost of the projects intended to be realized,
1:31 And also to cover the budget deficit when taxes fail to do so.
1:37 This borrowing is usurious, which wipes out blessings,
1:42 And often the state is unable to repay it.
1:46 All of this prevents the realization of the alleged prosperity,
1:50 And instead plunges people into further poverty, injustice, and hardship,
1:56 As is the reality of communist societies.
2:00 Thirdly:
2:02 Centralized government administration is characterized by several negatives,
2:07 Among them is the slowness in making the necessary decisions for any task,
2:12 Which squanders opportunities for investment and success.
2:16 Also, laziness and laxity in work,
2:18 Because the employee knows he will receive his salary at the end of the month,
2:22 Whether he performs his work successfully or falls short in it,
2:27 Due to the lack of satisfactory incentives commensurate with the quality of work and production.
2:33 And officials in charge of work prioritize those whose loyalty they trust at the expense of those with competence.
2:40 All of this results in the failure of public sector institutions owned by the state,
2:47 So it is forced to sell these institutions in the end to the private sector,
2:52 Which means an admission of the failure of this system,
2:55 And the restoration of private ownership once again,
2:59 After missing out on profitable investment opportunities throughout the period of operating under this system.
3:05 It goes without saying that all these flaws and negatives,
3:10 Are from the perspective of worldly interests and gains,
3:14 Not to mention the violations of Sharia contained in these matters,
3:18 And the explicit contradiction of the system and path that Allah has chosen for His servants,
3:24 To achieve their religious and worldly interests alike,
3:29 In perfect balance and harmony.