Summary of Sunni concepts | Concept (1104) | Disadvantages of democracy
Lesson summary
In this final installment of the series Concepts of Ahl as-Sunnah, the sheikh presents the drawbacks of democracy, which he describes as the political practice of the doctrine of popular sovereignty. He considers its foremost evil to be that it establishes shirk (associating partners with Allah) in ruling, since worship shifts from rulers and the clergy to peoples and parliaments. He then mentions further flaws that democratic thinkers themselves acknowledged, such as low real participation, the control of wealthy interests over the media, partisan conflict, equal weighting of votes, and the short lifespan of governments.
Key takeaways
- Democracy establishes shirk in ruling, because it is built on the doctrine of popular sovereignty.
- Tyranny moves from the claimed divine right of the church and rulers to the claimed divine right of peoples and parliaments.
- The sovereignty of the Sharia is replaced by the rule of law, and what Allah has forbidden or permitted is replaced by man-made legislation.
- Democracy is not truly rule by the majority, since many people abstain from elections.
- Wealthy owners effectively control the system through their control of the media, which shapes public opinion.
- Political parties differing in thought and method lead to strife rather than cooperation for the good of the country and its people.
- Equal weighting of votes deprives the nation of the benefit of expert opinion, unlike the consultation (shura) system in Islam that draws on people of solution and binding (ahl al-hall wal-aqd).
- Over half a century, democratic governments averaged less than eight months in office, too short to carry out their reform and development plans.
Questions & answers
What is the gravest drawback of democracy according to the sheikh?
The sheikh holds that its gravest flaw is that it establishes shirk in ruling, because it rests on popular sovereignty, transferring worship and legislation from Allah to humans.
Is democracy truly rule by the majority?
The sheikh explains that it is not, in reality, because most people abstain from voting and do not take part in elections, as voter turnout figures show.
How does Islamic shura differ from democracy in the sheikh's view?
Shura benefits from the experience of people of solution and binding, whereas democracy gives the vote of the expert and the uneducated equal weight, depriving the nation of the views of qualified people.
Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.