Part of Concepts of Ahl as-Sunnah (series completed) · Lesson 514 of 1251

Summary of Sunni concepts | Concept (512) | Issues of disagreement and issues of diligence

◉ 22 views ⏱ 2:58 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

The lesson clarifies the difference between matters of disagreement (khilaf) and matters of ijtihad. The sheikh explains that the common saying "there is no denunciation in matters of disagreement" is an incorrect belief, since a disagreement that contradicts a text of the Qur'an or Sunnah is an anomalous view that is not valid and is rejected. He states that disagreement is not in itself a proof, and that the Qur'an and Sunnah are the proof over all who differ, citing the reasons scholars may oppose a text as explained by Ibn Taymiyyah in "Raf' al-Malam 'an al-A'immah al-A'lam". The correct expression, he says, is "there is no denunciation in matters of ijtihad", which are matters without a clear binding text, or where ijtihad involves weighing benefits against harms.

Key takeaways

  • Distinguishing between matters of disagreement and matters of ijtihad is essential for understanding when denunciation applies.
  • The saying "there is no denunciation in matters of disagreement" is, as the sheikh explains, a false claim.
  • A disagreement that opposes a text of the Qur'an or Sunnah is anomalous, invalid, and rejected.
  • Disagreement is not a proof in itself; the Qur'an and Sunnah are the proof over those who differ.
  • A scholar may oppose a ruling because the hadith did not reach him, because he considered it unauthentic, or because he forgot it, as Ibn Taymiyyah explains in "Raf' al-Malam".
  • The correct expression in this area is "there is no denunciation in matters of ijtihad".
  • Matters of ijtihad are those without a clear binding text, or those involving weighing benefits and harms; the scholar follows his own ijtihad, and the layperson follows the scholars' ijtihad he trusts.

Questions & answers

Is there no denunciation in matters of disagreement?

The sheikh explains that this saying is incorrect, because a disagreement that contradicts a text of the Qur'an or Sunnah is anomalous and not valid. The correct expression is "there is no denunciation in matters of ijtihad".

What is the difference between matters of disagreement and matters of ijtihad?

Matters of ijtihad are those with no clear binding text that must be acted upon, or where ijtihad involves weighing benefits against harms. A disagreement that opposes a clear text is not a valid disagreement.

Why do some scholars oppose a text?

The sheikh notes it may be because the hadith did not reach the scholar, because he believed it was not authentic, or because he forgot it at the time of the disagreement. Ibn Taymiyyah explains these reasons in "Raf' al-Malam 'an al-A'immah al-A'lam".

Is it permissible to follow a scholar who opposes a clear proof?

The sheikh explains that it is not permissible to follow a scholar's view when there is a proof contradicting it, since the Qur'an and Sunnah are the proof over all who differ.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 A summary of the concepts held by the Ahl al-Sunnah.
0:08 Issues of disagreement and issues of ijtihad (independent legal reasoning).
0:14 Some people fail to distinguish between issues of disagreement and issues of ijtihad.
0:19 It is common among those who hold this erroneous understanding
0:22 to cite the maxim: "There is no censure in matters of disagreement."
0:26 This is a mistaken maxim and a corrupt belief,
0:30 for not every disagreement is considered valid such that one may act upon it in any of its forms.
0:36 Rather, any disagreement that contradicts a text from the Qur'an or the Sunnah
0:41 is an irregular, invalid disagreement that is rejected upon the one who holds it.
0:46 A consequence of this corrupt assertion
0:49 is that censure in the Sharia of Islam would be limited
0:53 only to those matters that are definitively and necessarily known to be prohibited by consensus.
0:58 Disagreement is not an argument in itself;
1:01 rather, the Qur'an and the Sunnah are the argument against those who disagree, whether they are of the early or later generations.
1:07 A scholar may disagree on an issue
1:10 because the hadith concerning it did not reach him,
1:13 or because he believed it to be inauthentic,
1:16 or because he was unaware of it at the time of the disagreement.
1:19 In such cases, it is not permissible to follow that scholar when there is evidence that contradicts his view,
1:26 among other reasons mentioned by Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah in his valuable book,
1:33 "Raf' al-Malam 'an al-A'immah al-A'lam" (Removing Blame from the Illustrious Imams).
1:37 Among the implications of this corrupt assertion
1:40 is a dangerous theological deviation.
1:43 For when an authentic, established Sunnah from the Prophet, peace be upon him, is rejected
1:49 simply because someone has disagreed on the matter,
1:52 this implies that the statements and commands of the Prophet, peace be upon him,
1:58 only acquire their legitimacy when people agree upon them.
2:03 This is a dangerous path that contradicts the foundation of Islam,
2:07 which means submission to the commands of Allah the Exalted
2:11 and the commands of His Messenger, peace be upon him.
2:15 The correct expression that is acceptable in this field
2:19 is: "There is no censure in matters of ijtihad."
2:23 Matters of ijtihad are those in which there is no binding evidence or explicit text
2:29 that must be followed as an apparent obligation,
2:32 or where the ijtihad pertains to the fiqh of balancing interests and harms.
2:38 In such cases, ijtihad is permissible due to the conflict or obscurity of the evidence,
2:45 and a person may adopt what his own ijtihad leads him to if he is a scholar,
2:50 or what he finds reassuring and trusts from the ijtihad of the scholars if he is a follower.