Part of Concepts of Ahl as-Sunnah (series completed) · Lesson 1069 of 1251

Summary of Sunni concepts | Concept (1067) | Causes of temptation

◉ 12 views ⏱ 4:34 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

The sheikh explains, citing Ibn al-Qayyim rahimahu Allah, that the causes of falling into trials (fitan) go back to two major causes: doubts (shubuhat) and desires (shahawat), with many branches beneath them. The trial of doubts is the greater of the two and arises from weak insight and little knowledge; the only protection from it is to follow the Messenger ﷺ and to take him as the judge in all of the religion. The trial of desires is rooted in whims, where a person knows the truth but turns away from it. The sheikh states that the root of every trial is putting opinion before the sharia or desire before reason, and he lists further secondary causes such as haste, neglecting istikhara and consultation, and associating with people of worldliness, immorality and innovation.

Key takeaways

  • Trials stem from two causes, doubts and desires, which may combine in a person or occur separately.
  • The trial of doubts is the greater one; it arises from weak insight and little knowledge, often with corrupt intention and following of whims.
  • Protection from the trial of doubts comes only through fully following the Messenger ﷺ and judging by him in all matters of the religion, outward and inward.
  • The trial of desires is caused by whims rather than ignorance: the person knows the truth but prefers what his soul desires.
  • The root of every trial is placing personal opinion above the sharia, or desire above reason.
  • Patience with desires and a complete intellect protect against desires, while a sharp insight protects against doubts.
  • Secondary causes of falling into trials include haste, neglecting istikhara and consultation, sitting with people of worldliness, immorality and innovation, and being absorbed in worldly life.

Questions & answers

What are the causes of falling into trials?

The sheikh explains that trials are rooted in two major causes, doubts and desires, with many secondary causes branching from them, such as haste, neglecting consultation, and associating with people of innovation.

What is the difference between the trial of doubts and the trial of desires?

The trial of doubts comes from weak insight and little knowledge and is the greater of the two. The trial of desires comes from whims, where the person knows the truth but turns away from it.

How can one be protected from the trial of doubts?

According to the lesson, only by fully following the Messenger ﷺ and taking him as the judge in all of the religion, including beliefs, actions, realities and laws.

What is the root of every trial?

The root of every trial is placing opinion before the sharia or desire before reason. The first is the root of the trial of doubts and the second is the root of the trial of desires.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Qur’an verses cited in this lesson

  • An-Najm 53:23 — They are but names which ye have named, ye and your fathers, for which Allah hath revealed no warrant. They follow but a guess and that which (they) themselves desire. And now the guidance from their Lord hath come unto them.

Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 A summary of the concepts held by the Ahl al-Sunnah.
0:08 The causes that lead one into tribulations (fitan).
0:11 Imam Ibn al-Qayyim, may Allah have mercy upon him, has sufficiently detailed the causes of tribulations and falling into them.
0:19 He categorized them into two major causes, under which many branches fall.
0:25 These two causes are doubts (shubuhat) and desires (shahawat).
0:29 He, may Allah have mercy upon him, says:
0:32 Tribulation is of two types:
0:34 The tribulation of doubts, which is the greater of the two.
0:38 And the tribulation of desires.
0:40 A person may be afflicted by both, or by one of them individually.
0:45 The tribulation of doubts stems from a weakness of insight and a lack of knowledge.
0:49 Especially when this is coupled with a corrupt intention and the influence of caprice (hawa).
0:54 That is where the greatest tribulation and the gravest calamity lie.
0:58 Say what you will about the misguidance of one whose intention is corrupt.
1:01 One who is governed by his caprice rather than by guidance.
1:04 Along with his weak insight and lack of knowledge regarding what Allah sent His Messenger with.
1:10 He is among those of whom Allah the Almighty said:
1:13 “They are but names which ye have named, ye and your fathers, for which Allah hath revealed no warrant. They follow but a guess and that which (they) themselves desire. And now the guidance from their Lord hath come unto them.” (53:23)
1:19 The ultimate end of this tribulation is disbelief and hypocrisy.
1:23 It is the tribulation of the hypocrites.
1:25 And the tribulation of the people of innovation, according to the severity of their innovations.
1:30 For all of them only innovated out of the tribulation of doubts.
1:33 In which the truth became obscured for them by falsehood, and guidance by misguidance.
1:39 Nothing saves one from this tribulation except the absolute dedication to following the Messenger.
1:44 And making him the judge in both the minor and major aspects of the religion.
1:47 In its outward and inward aspects, its beliefs and its deeds.
1:51 Its realities and its laws.
1:54 This tribulation arises sometimes from a corrupt understanding.
1:58 Sometimes from a false report.
2:01 Sometimes from an established truth that remained hidden from a person, so he did not attain it.
2:06 And sometimes from a corrupt motive, while he is following it.
2:10 Thus, it is a blindness of insight and a corruption of the will.
2:14 The second type of tribulation:
2:18 The tribulation of desires.
2:20 This is the tribulation whose cause is caprice.
2:23 It is not caused by ignorance of the truth or confusion regarding it.
2:26 Rather, the one afflicted by this tribulation has knowledge of the truth.
2:30 But he turns away from it and prefers something else.
2:33 From what his heart craves and his soul desires.
2:37 The root of every tribulation:
2:39 Is the prioritization of opinion over the Sacred Law (Shar').
2:42 And caprice over intellect.
2:44 The former is the root of the tribulation of doubts.
2:47 And the latter is the root of the tribulation of desires.
2:50 It has been narrated in a mursal hadith:
2:53 Which some scholars have deemed weak.
2:55 But its meaning is correct:
2:57 "Allah loves the critical eye,"
3:00 When doubts arise.
3:02 "And He loves the sound intellect,"
3:04 When desires present themselves.
3:06 Therefore:
3:07 The root of all tribulations:
3:09 Is either a doubt or a desire.
3:11 If tribulations coincide with:
3:13 A lack of knowledge and ignorance of the truth,
3:16 Or a doubt based on a corrupt interpretation,
3:18 The person falls into tribulations,
3:20 Because of the doubt.
3:22 And if there is knowledge of the truth within the servant,
3:25 But his patience against desires is weak,
3:28 He falls into tribulation because of desire,
3:31 Not because of doubt.
3:33 The third type of cause for tribulations:
3:36 Is a mixture of doubt and desire.
3:39 Meaning that one who falls into tribulation,
3:41 Does not admit that he is weak in patience,
3:43 Or that he has been overcome by caprice.
3:45 Rather, he attempts, through affectation,
3:48 To find evidence for his caprice,
3:50 Using a religious doubt to justify his falling into what he has fallen into.
3:55 Meaning he does not admit his error and his caprice.
3:58 Instead, he claims that he is upon the truth through his doubt,
4:01 By way of a corrupt interpretation or a weak piece of evidence.
4:05 There are other secondary causes for falling into tribulations.
4:09 Among them are haste and impulsiveness.
4:11 Neglecting the prayer for guidance (istikhara) and consultation (istishara).
4:14 Sitting with the people of this world, the immoral, and the innovators.
4:18 Reading their books and their articles.
4:21 Being preoccupied with this world and relying upon it.
4:24 And preferring it over the Hereafter.