Part of Concepts of Ahl as-Sunnah (series completed) · Lesson 546 of 1251

Summary of Sunni concepts | Concept (544) | The excesses of the Sufis in the actions of the hearts

◉ 36 views ⏱ 3:35 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

In this lesson from the series on the concepts of Ahl al-Sunnah, the sheikh explains the deviation of the Sufis in matters of the heart. He notes that they cared for the heart and its deeds as the righteous predecessors did, but exaggerated beyond the limits of the Book and the Sunnah, going astray in contentment, love, reliance on Allah and asceticism. According to the sheikh, these deviations led to determinism, belittling fear and hope, passivity, and abandoning knowledge and lawful sustenance. The correct path, he concludes, is the balance brought by the Sharia.

Key takeaways

  • Caring for the deeds of the heart is a principle of the predecessors; the Sufis shared this concern but exaggerated it beyond the limits of the Book and the Sunnah.
  • Contentment with Allah's decree does not mean contentment with disbelief or sin, as one must distinguish between Allah's universal will and His legislated will.
  • Love for Allah does not replace fear and hope; proper worship combines love, fear and hope together.
  • True reliance on Allah does not mean abandoning lawful means and supplication, but includes upholding Allah's religion, striving in His cause and resisting corruption.
  • Asceticism is a positive act of the heart, not forbidding good provision or abandoning the pursuit of knowledge.
  • Calling themselves 'the poor' and considering poverty as ignorance is a departure from the correct understanding of asceticism.

Questions & answers

What was the Sufis' deviation regarding contentment?

The sheikh explains that they confused Allah's universal will with His legislated will, believing it obligatory to be content with disbelief, transgression and disobedience because they occur in the universe, which led them into pure determinism.

What was the Sufis' position on fear and hope?

According to the sheikh, they exaggerated love to the point of belittling the fear of Allah and His punishment and the hope for His Paradise and reward, considering them the weakest stations of the travelers, whereas the correct view is to worship Allah with love, fear and hope together.

How did the Sufis understand asceticism?

The sheikh states that they turned asceticism from a positive act of the heart into a negative outward appearance, forbidding themselves good provision and the pursuit of knowledge, and made asceticism into poverty and ignorance.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 A summary of the concepts held by the Ahl al-Sunnah.
0:08 The excesses of the Sufis regarding the actions of the heart.
0:12 Just as the salaf, may Allah be pleased with them, concerned themselves with the heart, its actions, and its states,
0:19 the Sufis also concerned themselves with these matters.
0:23 However, they exaggerated to a degree that exceeded the boundaries of the Book and the Sunnah in describing and detailing the actions of the heart.
0:32 Consequently, they strayed in that field and went astray while intending to seek guidance.
0:39 You can hardly find an action of the heart in which they do not have some form of deviation or error.
0:46 First among these is their error regarding contentment (rida).
0:51 They exceeded the proper limits in being content with the decree and predestination of Allah.
0:55 They conflated Allah’s universal will with His legislative will.
1:00 They believed it was mandatory to be content with disbelief, immorality, and disobedience,
1:04 arguing that if contentment with these were not required, they would not have occurred in the universe.
1:10 In doing so, they fell into pure determinism under the guise of extremist and obscure terminology,
1:18 such as "witnessing the universal reality" and "gaining insight into the secret of Allah in predestination."
1:24 Second is their error regarding the love of Allah.
1:28 Their exaltation of this love led them to disparage both fear and hope,
1:34 by which I mean fear of Allah the Exalted and His punishment, and hope for His Paradise and reward.
1:40 They considered these to be the weakest stations for those traveling toward Allah.
1:44 They claimed that the worship of Allah should be for His Essence alone,
1:49 not out of desire for His Paradise nor fear of His Fire.
1:53 They established the pinnacle of love to be "annihilation in the Beloved,"
1:57 a state they believe is exclusive to the saints (awliya) of Allah,
2:01 and they hold their station to be higher than that of the prophets.
2:05 Because of this error regarding love, the salaf said of them:
2:11 "Whoever worships Allah through love alone is a heretic (zindiq)."
2:15 The correct approach is to worship Allah through a combination of love, fear, and hope.
2:21 Third is their error regarding reliance upon Allah (tawakkul).
2:27 They turned reliance into cheap passivity and beggary.
2:32 They intentionally caused harm to themselves
2:35 by abandoning legitimate means and supplication,
2:38 which is the greatest form of worship and its very core.
2:42 This is in addition to their neglect of the highest degree of reliance,
2:46 which is relying upon Allah in establishing His religion, striving in His path,
2:51 and resisting disbelief and corruption,
2:54 just as was the reliance of the prophets, peace be upon them.
2:58 Fourth is their error regarding asceticism (zuhd).
3:02 They transformed it from a positive, internal action of the heart
3:06 into a negative outward display through which they forbade themselves the good things of provision.
3:11 They likewise forbade the pursuit of knowledge,
3:13 claiming that those who occupy themselves with it possess the Shari'ah,
3:17 whereas they themselves possess the "Truth" (haqiqa).
3:20 They argued that knowledge leads to people holding the scholar in high esteem,
3:24 and distracts one from total focus upon Allah,
3:27 which they claim contradicts asceticism.
3:29 Thus, they reduced asceticism to poverty and ignorance,
3:32 and called themselves "the poor" (al-fuqara').