Part of Concepts of Ahl as-Sunnah (series completed) · Lesson 1190 of 1251

Summary of Sunni concepts | Concept (1189) | One-eyed thinking

◉ 9 views ⏱ 5:15 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

This concluding lesson in the Ahl al-Sunnah concepts series addresses the flaw of one-sided, monocular thinking, which looks at matters from only one angle. The sheikh explains that most people fall into this pattern, and that its adherents select the evidences that suit their desires, leading to contradictions and double standards. He stresses that comprehensive, just thinking requires weighing benefits against harms, and viewing disbelievers and sinners with both eyes: the eye of the Sharia, which calls them to it, and the eye of divine decree, with mercy and a desire to save them from the Fire. This lesson completes the series.

Key takeaways

  • Avoid viewing a matter from one side when accepting or rejecting it, and weigh benefits against harms.
  • Do not select evidences according to desire; gather all the evidences without setting some against others, which is the method of Ahl al-Sunnah.
  • Look at people's lives comprehensively, rather than choosing only the good or only the bad according to love or dislike.
  • Do not restrict the explanation of problems or opinions to a single one; avoid absolute phrases such as 'the only factor' and 'the only cause'.
  • Avoid contradiction and double standards, not criticizing others for faults one commits oneself, and uphold justice in the scale, as in Allah's words: 'Those who, when they take a measure from people, take in full.'
  • Regard disbelievers and sinners with two eyes: the eye of the Sharia, guiding them to it, and the eye of divine decree, with compassion and a wish to save them from the Fire.

Questions & answers

What is meant by one-sided, monocular thinking in the concepts of Ahl al-Sunnah?

The sheikh explains that one-sided thinking means viewing a matter from only one side, whether its benefits or its harms, and building acceptance or rejection on that alone. A comprehensive, just view requires weighing benefits against harms.

How does the lesson address the blameworthy selection of evidences?

The sheikh notes that the one-sided thinker selects the evidences that match his desires and cuts off those that oppose them, unlike Ahl al-Sunnah, who gather all the evidences and do not set some against others.

How do Ahl al-Sunnah view disbelievers and sinners?

They view them with both eyes: the eye of the Sharia, calling them to it, and the eye of divine decree, with compassion and a desire to save them from the Fire, rather than with hatred alone or mercy alone.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Qur’an verses cited in this lesson

  • Al-Mutaffifin 83:3 — But if they measure unto them or weight for them, they cause them loss.

Verses are matched automatically against the Qur’an text; some mentions may be missed. English: Pickthall.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 A summary of the concepts held by the Ahl al-Sunnah.
0:08 One-dimensional, narrow-minded thinking.
0:12 This type of thinking is one into which most people fall,
0:17 Except for those whom Allah the Almighty has shown mercy, granting them success in achieving fairness and comprehensiveness in their perspective and thought.
0:25 Among the characteristics of a person with this narrow outlook:
0:28 First, whenever a matter is presented to them, they consider it only in terms of acceptance or rejection.
0:35 You find that they do not view the matter from all its angles,
0:39 But rather from a single side,
0:42 Upon which they focus their thinking and which dominates them,
0:45 And upon which they base their acceptance or rejection.
0:48 For example, we find them looking only at the merits and positive aspects of a matter,
0:54 Without considering the corruptions and harms,
0:57 And from this, acceptance arises.
0:59 Or, they look at the corruptions and negative aspects,
1:03 Ignoring the positives and merits,
1:06 And thus they reject and dismiss the matter,
1:09 Even though a comprehensive, fair perspective
1:12 Requires balancing the benefits against the harms,
1:16 To see which outweighs the other and is realized.
1:19 Second:
1:22 When a person with this one-dimensional mindset researches
1:26 A topic to read or write about,
1:29 They choose the evidence that appeals to them,
1:32 And which aligns with the emotions they have already decided upon,
1:36 Focusing on it and selecting it,
1:39 While attempting to sever it from the evidence that
1:42 Contradicts their idea or confuses it.
1:45 In other words, selectivity is what dominates them,
1:49 In accordance with their desires.
1:51 This perspective has been adopted by
1:53 Many of the people of innovation,
1:55 Who have selected the evidence in which they see
1:58 Support for themselves,
2:00 Unlike the Ahl al-Sunnah,
2:02 Who gather all the evidence together,
2:05 And do not pit one part against another.
2:08 Third:
2:10 A person with a one-dimensional outlook,
2:12 When evaluating people,
2:14 Looks at only one side of their lives,
2:17 Either the good deeds or the bad,
2:20 Choosing from them what aligns with their love or hatred
2:24 For the party they wish to evaluate,
2:27 And turning a blind eye to what does not suit their desires.
2:30 Fourth:
2:33 A person with a one-dimensional outlook
2:35 Views the problems or differences
2:38 Presented to their mind
2:40 As having only one interpretation,
2:43 And one path,
2:45 And that there is only one valid opinion,
2:48 While everything else is rejected,
2:50 No matter how many alternatives are presented to them.
2:53 Therefore, those with this mindset use
2:56 Terms that indicate a one-dimensional view,
2:59 So you see them saying:
3:01 "The only factor,"
3:03 "The only reason,"
3:05 "The only interpretation,"
3:07 "The only opinion,"
3:09 "The only flaw,"
3:11 And so on.
3:13 Fifth:
3:15 A person with one-dimensional thinking
3:17 Falls into contradiction
3:19 And double standards,
3:21 As they see flaws committed by some people,
3:25 Yet turn a blind eye to the same flaws
3:28 When they commit them themselves,
3:30 Or when those they love commit them.
3:32 As it is said:
3:34 They see the speck in their brother's eye,
3:36 But do not see the log in their own.
3:39 And as the poet said:
3:41 "The eye of contentment is blind to every fault,
3:45 While the eye of displeasure reveals all defects."
3:48 This narrow, one-eyed perspective
3:50 Appears clearly in the policies of disbelieving and oppressive states,
3:55 Where they use double standards,
3:58 One standard for themselves,
4:00 And another for their enemies,
4:02 As Allah the Almighty said:
4:05 "Those who, when they take a measure from people, take it in full."
4:09 “But if they measure unto them or weight for them, they cause them loss.” (83:3)
4:13 Among these examples
4:15 Is their use of the term "terrorism,"
4:18 With which they label their opponents,
4:20 Especially the Muslim mujahideen,
4:23 When they fight the disbelieving invaders.
4:26 As for the killing, displacement, torture, and imprisonment of Muslims they carry out,
4:32 That is not terrorism,
4:34 But rather the spreading of freedom and democracy,
4:37 And a confrontation against terrorism.
4:40 Evil is that which they judge.
4:42 Sixth:
4:44 Among these examples
4:45 Is looking at the disbelievers and the disobedient with one eye:
4:49 Either with an eye of hatred and condemnation,
4:52 Or with an eye of mercy and compassion.
4:55 The correct approach
4:56 Is to look at them with both eyes:
4:59 The eye of the Shari'ah, holding them accountable to it,
5:02 And the eye of Divine Decree,
5:04 Showing them compassion, mercy, and a desire to save them from the Fire.
5:10 A summary of the concepts held by the Ahl al-Sunnah.