Part of Concepts of Ahl as-Sunnah (series completed) · Lesson 256 of 1251

Summary of Sunni concepts | Concept (254) | Mu'tazilites

◉ 84 views ⏱ 3:28 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

This lesson covers the origin of the Mu'tazila. The sheikh explains that it goes back to Wasil ibn 'Ata', who disagreed with Imam al-Hasan al-Basri رحمه الله about the one who commits a major sin: al-Hasan said he is a believer in his faith and a sinner in his major sin, while Wasil said he is in an intermediate position, neither believer nor disbeliever. Wasil withdrew from al-Hasan's circle, and those who agreed with him were called the Mu'tazila. The sheikh notes that their ideas then developed and branched out, adopting the doctrine of the Qadariyya, and their innovation settled on five principles: justice, tawhid, the intermediate position, the promise and threat, and enjoining good and forbidding evil. The lesson criticizes placing reason above revelation and warns against those who agree with the Mu'tazila today in this.

Key takeaways

  • The lesson explains that the origin of the Mu'tazila lies in the disagreement of Wasil ibn 'Ata' with al-Hasan al-Basri رحمه الله over the one who commits a major sin.
  • It clarifies the Sunni position on the one who commits a major sin: a believer in his faith and a sinner in his major sin.
  • It explains that the Mu'tazila deny Allah's decree over the actions of servants, holding that servants create their own actions.
  • It states that, in their view, tawhid means negating attributes from Allah under the pretext of exalting Him above resembling His creation.
  • It criticizes placing reason above the text, interpreting the texts of the Qur'an and Sunnah when they contradict reason, and rejecting single-narration hadiths.
  • It describes their view that Allah is obliged to carry out His promise and threat, so the one who commits a major sin is eternal in the Fire, though in a level lighter than that of the disbeliever.
  • It warns that agreeing with the Mu'tazila in exalting reason today serves the secularists in their release from the creed and rulings of religion.

Questions & answers

What is the origin of the name Mu'tazila?

The sheikh explains that Wasil ibn 'Ata' disagreed with al-Hasan al-Basri about the one who commits a major sin, so he and those who agreed with him withdrew from al-Hasan's circle and were named the Mu'tazila.

What are the five principles on which Mu'tazili innovation settled?

They are justice, tawhid, the intermediate position, the promise and threat, and enjoining good and forbidding evil, as the sheikh enumerates them.

What is the Mu'tazili position on the one who commits a major sin?

Wasil said he is in an intermediate position, neither believer nor disbeliever. They hold that Allah must enforce the threat, so he is eternal in the Fire, though in a lighter level than the disbeliever.

What does the lesson criticize in the Mu'tazili method?

The sheikh criticizes placing reason above revelation, interpreting the texts of the Qur'an and Sunnah that contradict their reasoning, and rejecting single-narration hadiths that oppose their principles.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 A summary of the concepts held by the Ahl al-Sunnah.
0:08 The Mu'tazila.
0:12 The origin of the Mu'tazila.
0:14 It traces back to Wasil Ibn 'Ata'.
0:16 Who differed with Imam al-Hasan al-Basri, may Allah have mercy on him, regarding the one who commits a major sin.
0:21 For al-Hasan stated regarding him:
0:23 He is a believer by virtue of his faith,
0:25 but a transgressor (fasiq) by virtue of his major sin.
0:27 That is the position of the Ahl al-Sunnah.
0:30 Wasil then said:
0:32 He is in a position between the two positions.
0:35 Neither a believer nor a disbeliever.
0:38 Consequently, it followed that
0:40 Wasil Ibn 'Ata' withdrew,
0:42 along with some who agreed with his view,
0:44 from the circle of al-Hasan al-Basri.
0:46 Thus, they were named the Mu'tazila (the Withdrawers).
0:49 Their ideas then developed and branched out.
0:52 They were joined by the Jahmiyyah,
0:54 and they adopted the doctrine of the Qadariyyah,
0:56 who deny the divine decree (qadar),
0:58 and Allah’s foreknowledge of events before they occur.
1:02 They also deny that Allah created evil or willed it.
1:06 They do not distinguish between the legislative will and the universal will.
1:11 Their innovation eventually settled upon five principles.
1:15 First: Justice.
1:17 By this, they mean denying that Allah ordains or creates the actions of His servants.
1:22 Rather, they claim that servants create their own actions.
1:25 Second:
1:27 Monotheism (Tawhid).
1:29 Its reality, according to them, is the negation of attributes from Allah,
1:33 under the pretext of declaring Him, the Almighty and Majestic, free from resembling His creation.
1:37 Third:
1:39 The position between the two positions.
1:41 This is the foundational innovation of the Mu'tazila, as previously mentioned.
1:45 Fourth:
1:47 The Promise and the Threat.
1:49 Its meaning, according to them, is
1:51 that it is incumbent upon Allah, the Exalted,
1:53 just as He made it incumbent upon Himself, to fulfill His promise.
1:56 Thus, they consign the one who commits a major sin to eternal fire, just as the Khawarij say,
2:02 although they place him in a level of the Fire lighter than that of the disbeliever.
2:07 Fifth:
2:09 Enjoining good and forbidding evil.
2:12 Its reality, according to them, is
2:14 rebelling with the sword against unjust leaders,
2:17 and breaking away from the community of Muslims who have gathered under them.
2:22 They rebel against the ruler simply for committing any type of sin or injustice.
2:29 When the leaders of the salaf confronted the Mu'tazila with the proofs of the Qur'an and Sunnah,
2:34 which refute their false principles,
2:37 and demolish their flimsy arguments,
2:40 they resorted to another innovation which they made one of their principles of deduction:
2:45 the innovation of prioritizing reason over revelation.
2:49 They interpret the texts of the Qur'an and Sunnah if they contradict what their corrupt reasoning dictates.
2:55 They also rejected solitary hadiths (ahad)
2:57 that contradict their theological principles.
3:02 Today, the Mu'tazila are joined in their sanctification of reason and prioritizing it over the text
3:07 by a fringe group of outcasts
3:10 who call themselves "Modernists,"
3:13 or "Rationalists,"
3:15 or "Enlightenment thinkers."
3:17 They label the Mu'tazila as the "Enlightened Rationalist School."
3:22 In doing so, they have served the secularists in their efforts to abandon the beliefs and rulings of the religion.