Part of Concepts of Ahl as-Sunnah (series completed) · Lesson 826 of 1251

Summary of Sunni concepts | Concept (824) | One of the disadvantages of modern education

◉ 18 views ⏱ 3:13 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

This lesson, the twenty-fourth in the series Concepts of Ahl al-Sunnah, examines some of the shortcomings of modern educational systems as presented by the speaker. He explains that Islamic education in the past allowed gifted students to advance according to their attainment rather than their age, and he criticizes abolishing memorization and teaching the whole before the parts in language learning. He stresses that memorization is not to be abolished, but rather the flaws that come with relying on it alone, and that language is taught beginning with the letter, then the word, then the sentence, referring to the Baghdadi and Nurani methods.

Key takeaways

  • Islamic education in the past allowed gifted students to advance to higher levels according to their attainment, regardless of their age.
  • The grade promotion the West introduced for gifted students was an attempt to overcome the flaw of placing the clever and the slow together in one class.
  • Memorization is an essential part of education and is not abolished because of the flaws of relying on it alone and neglecting reasoning.
  • The flaws that accompany an excessive focus on memorization should be addressed without abolishing memorization itself.
  • Images are perceived by sight, which grasps wholes before parts, whereas language is perceived by hearing, whose basis is the part, so the two require different teaching methods.
  • Language teaching in the Islamic civilization begins with the letter in its various vowel forms, then the word, then the sentence, so the child masters the details of his language's letters.
  • The Baghdadi and Nurani methods are examples of learners excelling and acquiring language quickly through this approach.

Questions & answers

What are the main shortcomings of modern education according to the lesson?

The lesson mentions placing the clever gifted student together with the slow one, abolishing memorization on the claim that it restricts creativity, and teaching language starting from the sentence, then the word, then the letter, which the speaker criticizes.

Does the lesson call for abolishing memorization in education?

No. The speaker accepts that some flaws of relying solely on memorization are valid, but says this does not mean abolishing memorization; rather, the flaws that accompany overemphasis on it and the neglect of reasoning should be removed.

How does the lesson say a child is taught language in the Islamic civilization?

The child is first taught the letter with its different vowel marks, then the word, then the sentence, and the Baghdadi and Nurani methods are cited as examples of rapid and superior learning.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 A summary of the concepts held by the Ahl al-Sunnah.
0:08 Regarding the shortcomings of modern education.
0:11 There are many flaws in modern educational systems.
0:17 We shall mention some of them and their detrimental effects.
0:21 First, placing the intelligent, gifted student alongside the dull, slow-witted student.
0:27 Whereas traditional Islamic education, in the past,
0:31 allowed individual talents to flourish and advance to higher study circles,
0:37 according to their level of achievement, regardless of their age.
0:42 The West has attempted to overcome this negative aspect,
0:45 by introducing a system to promote gifted students to a higher level.
0:51 Second, modern education seeks to abolish rote memorization, highlighting its perceived faults.
0:57 They claim that it restricts the faculty of creativity and critical thinking.
1:02 While we may agree on some of the drawbacks resulting from limiting education to memorization,
1:07 and neglecting the aspect of critical thinking,
1:09 this does not mean, under any circumstances, the abolition of memorization itself.
1:14 Rather, we should only eliminate the flaws that may accompany an over-reliance on it,
1:19 and the neglect of the other aspect.
1:22 Third:
1:23 Modern education adopts the principle of teaching from the whole to the part.
1:30 They base this on the idea that the eye perceives an image in its entirety first,
1:36 and then begins to recognize its details.
1:39 Therefore, they begin teaching language through whole sentences,
1:44 then move from there to the word, and finally to the letter.
1:48 They have forgotten that there is a vast difference between an image and a language.
1:53 An image is a visual object perceived by the sense of sight,
1:57 which perceives the whole before the parts.
2:01 Whereas language relies on hearing, which perceives sound,
2:06 the origin of which is the part of a composite thing.
2:10 For this reason, if someone were to hear speech in a language they know nothing about,
2:15 they would neither understand what is heard nor perceive it.
2:18 But if they begin to learn the letters of the language and combine them with one another,
2:23 they become able to recognize what they hear, bit by bit,
2:28 until they eventually grasp the meanings and understand the language and its implications.
2:34 Language instruction in Islamic civilization,
2:37 relies on the letter, then the word, then the sentence.
2:42 In fact, it teaches the child the letter with its various vowel marks first,
2:47 so the child excels in understanding their language through the details of its letters and their vocalizations.
2:53 Look at those who study the Baghdadi Primer or the Noorani Primer,
3:00 how they surpass others and learn the language with incredible speed.