Part of Concepts of Ahl as-Sunnah (series completed) · Lesson 247 of 1251

Summary of Sunni concepts | Concept (245) | Loyalty and disavowal between excess and negligence

◉ 98 views ⏱ 3:21 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

The lesson explains that Islam is a religion of balance and justice between excess and negligence, and that people's understanding of al-walā' wal-barā' (loyalty and disassociation) falls into two extremes and a middle path. The first extreme went to excess by declaring anyone who dealt with the disbelievers a disbeliever, without distinguishing between disbelief-causing and merely prohibited loyalty. The second extreme was negligent, befriending and flattering the disbelievers under the pretext of diplomacy. The People of the Sunnah and the Community hold the middle position: they show loyalty to believers according to their faith, disassociate from shirk and hypocrisy and their people, and distinguish between the types of loyalty to disbelievers.

Key takeaways

  • The People of the Sunnah believe in the obligation to love Allah, His Messenger, and the believers, and to love what Allah loves of faith and deeds.
  • They believe in the obligation to disassociate from and hate what Allah hates: shirk and its people, and hypocrisy and its people.
  • They show loyalty to people of disobedience according to the faith they have, and disassociate from their sins according to the disobedience they persist in, neither absolutely loyal nor absolutely disassociated.
  • They distinguish between loyalty to disbelievers that expels one from the religion, such as loving their religion and supporting them against the believers, and loyalty that is prohibited but not disbelief-causing.
  • They distinguish between permissible diplomacy to repel the disbelievers' harm and the prohibited flattery (mudāhana).
  • They are balanced in their love and hatred of Muslims: they neither exaggerate love for individuals to the point of sanctification, nor hatred to the point of injustice, violating rights, or accusing people of what they did not say or believe.
  • This moderation in this matter is part of Islam's general method in belief, worship, and conduct.

Questions & answers

What is the People of the Sunnah's position on al-walā' wal-barā'?

The People of the Sunnah and the Community believe it is obligatory to love Allah, His Messenger, and the believers, and to hate shirk and its people and hypocrisy and its people. They show loyalty to believers according to their faith and disassociate from sin according to its extent.

Does dealing with disbelievers make a person a disbeliever?

No. According to the lesson, the extremists declared anyone who dealt with disbelievers a disbeliever without distinction. The correct view distinguishes between disbelief-causing loyalty and prohibited loyalty that does not cause disbelief.

What is the difference between diplomacy and flattery?

Permissible diplomacy (mudārā) is repelling the disbelievers' harm wisely, whereas flattery (mudāhana) is prohibited loyalty. The lesson warns that the negligent blurred the two, flattering disbelievers under the pretext of diplomacy.

How do the People of the Sunnah treat disobedient Muslims?

They show general loyalty to believers according to their faith, and disassociate from the sins they persist in, avoiding both excess and negligence.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 A summary of the concepts held by the Ahl al-Sunnah.
0:08 The concept of loyalty and disavowal (al-wala’ wa-l-bara’) between excess and negligence.
0:14 Islam is the religion of balance, justice, and moderation, steering between excess and negligence in all matters of creed, worship, and conduct.
0:24 Regarding the understanding and application of loyalty and disavowal, people fall into two extremes and a middle path.
0:30 The first extreme consists of those who have exaggerated and gone to excess in the matter of loyalty and enmity.
0:36 They judge anyone who engages in any transaction with disbelievers as having committed apostasy and disbelief.
0:42 They fail to distinguish between loyalty that constitutes disbelief and loyalty that is forbidden but does not reach the level of disbelief.
0:49 Indeed, they may judge certain permissible actions—which involve diplomacy or warding off the evil of disbelievers—
0:56 as acts of apostasy and disbelief, failing to differentiate between permissible diplomacy and forbidden compromise of one’s faith.
1:04 The second extreme consists of those who are negligent and lax, having fallen into showing loyalty to and compromising with disbelievers.
1:12 They do so under the guise of diplomacy or precautionary dissimulation (taqiyya), failing to distinguish between what is forbidden and what expels one from the fold of Islam.
1:19 In their view, such actions are merely permissible, forbidden, or disliked.
1:25 They do not recognize any form of loyalty that would expel one from the fold of Islam.
1:30 The middle path is that of the Ahl al-Sunnah wa-l-Jama'ah, the Companions and those who followed them in righteousness until the Day of Judgment.
1:38 They believe in the obligation to love Allah, His Messenger, the believers, and everything that Allah loves of faith and righteous deeds.
1:47 They also love those whom Allah loves, including His prophets and their believing followers in every age.
1:54 Likewise, they believe in the obligation of disavowal and hating everything and everyone that Allah, the Almighty, hates, such as polytheism and its people, and hypocrisy and its people.
2:04 As for the sinful and disobedient, they show them loyalty in proportion to the faith they possess.
2:11 And they disavow them in proportion to the disobedience they commit.
2:15 They do not show them absolute loyalty, nor do they show them absolute disavowal.
2:21 Rather, they show them the general loyalty due to all believers while disavowing the sins and disobedience they persist in.
2:30 Furthermore, they do not apply a single ruling to all forms of loyalty to disbelievers.
2:35 Instead, they hold that some forms expel one from the fold of Islam, such as loving their religion or aiding them against the believers.
2:43 Other forms are merely forbidden without reaching the level of disbelief.
2:48 They are also moderate in their love for Muslims and in their dislike of them.
2:53 They do not exaggerate in their love for certain individuals to the point of sanctification or attributing infallibility to them.
3:00 Nor do they exaggerate in their dislike for certain individuals to the point of oppressing them, denying their rights, or failing to treat them with justice.
3:08 Or accusing them of things they did not say, believe, or do.