Part of Concepts of Ahl as-Sunnah (series completed) · Lesson 255 of 1251

Summary of Sunni concepts | Concept (253) | Postponed

◉ 96 views ⏱ 3:25 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

The sheikh explains that the Murji'ah emerged as a reaction to the Khawarij: just as the Khawarij excessively declared people disbelievers for sin, the Murji'ah went to the other extreme by making the meaning of faith loose, reducing it to mere affirmation and excluding deeds from its reality. He notes that their trial led to the watering down of religion, the spread of corruption, and the weakening of enjoining good, forbidding evil, and jihad, and that they did not regard rejection of Allah's law as apostasy. He mentions that their groups are many, and the mildest of them are the jurists among them who obligate deeds and say people differ in them, but do not include them in the essence of faith, a view attributed to Abu Hanifa rahimahu Allah.

Key takeaways

  • The Murji'ah emerged as a counter-reaction to the Khawarij: as the Khawarij were extreme in excess, the Murji'ah were extreme in neglect.
  • The Murji'ah held that faith is merely affirmation and removed deeds from its reality; they were named for postponing (irja') deeds from the meaning of faith.
  • They do not accept that faith increases with obedience and decreases with disobedience, nor do they accept making the exception (istithna') regarding it.
  • Some in our time restricted disbelief and apostasy to considering sin lawful or denying it, and did not regard acts of arrogance, mockery, or hatred of Allah and His law as disbelief.
  • The Murji'ah trial led to watering down religion and spreading corruption, and weakened enjoining good, forbidding evil, and jihad in the way of Allah.
  • The sheikh clarifies that considering a sin lawful is a condition for judging its doer a disbeliever in only some sins, not all.
  • The mildest type of Irja' is that of the jurists, who obligate deeds and say people differ in them but do not include them in the name and reality of faith; this view is attributed to Abu Hanifa rahimahu Allah.

Questions & answers

What is meant by the Murji'ah?

The Murji'ah are a sect that emerged as a reaction to the Khawarij. They were named for postponing deeds from the meaning of faith, as they claimed faith is merely affirmation.

What is the difference between the Khawarij and the Murji'ah in their methodology?

The Khawarij went to extremes in excess by declaring sinners disbelievers, while the Murji'ah went to extremes in neglect by loosening the meaning of faith, so the Murji'ah stood in opposition to the Khawarij.

Is considering a sin lawful alone enough to judge every sin as disbelief?

No. The sheikh explains that considering a sin lawful is a condition for judging its doer a disbeliever in only some sins, not all of them, and the Murji'ah confused this point.

What was the effect of the Murji'ah trial on society?

It led to watering down religion and spreading corruption, and weakened the duty of enjoining good and forbidding evil and the duty of jihad in the way of Allah, as the sheikh cited from Ibn Taymiyyah rahimahu Allah.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 A summary of the concepts held by the Ahl al-Sunnah.
0:08 The Murji'ah.
0:09 They are a sect that emerged as a reactionary counter-movement to the Khawarij and their positions.
0:16 Just as the Khawarij adopted a path of extremism through excess,
0:20 The Murji'ah adopted a path of extremism through negligence.
0:24 They countered the methodology of the Khawarij—who declared people disbelievers for committing sins—
0:28 With a methodology of dilution in defining the meaning of faith.
0:32 They claimed that faith is merely inward affirmation.
0:35 They excluded deeds from the reality of faith.
0:38 The Murji'ah were given this name
0:41 Because they "postponed" (arja'a) deeds from the definition of faith.
0:44 The influence of the Murji'ah has reached some who claim to follow the creed of the salaf in our current time,
0:51 As they restrict disbelief and apostasy solely to declaring the forbidden as lawful or outright denial.
0:55 They do not consider actions that demonstrate defiance and arrogance to be disbelief,
0:59 Nor do they consider mockery or hatred of Allah and His law to be disbelief.
1:03 Based on their belief regarding faith and its definition, the Murji'ah
1:09 Do not acknowledge that faith increases with obedience and decreases with disobedience.
1:14 Nor do they accept making an exception (istithna') regarding one's faith.
1:17 They are of various types.
1:19 Among them are the extremists who claim that faith is merely knowledge.
1:25 Others restrict it to affirmation alone.
1:29 Others claim it is the affirmation of the heart and the speech of the tongue only,
1:34 Without including deeds within it.
1:36 Among them are those who say:
1:38 Whoever says "There is no god but Allah" is a believer, no matter what deeds he commits, provided he does not declare the forbidden as lawful.
1:47 Even though declaring the forbidden as lawful is a condition for some sins—not all—to judge the perpetrator as a disbeliever.
1:54 The tribulation of the Murji'ah has led to the dilution of the religion and the spread of corruption,
2:00 As well as the weakening of the duty of enjoining good and forbidding evil,
2:04 And the duty of jihad in the path of Allah.
2:07 Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah, may Allah have mercy on him, says:
2:11 "Others among the Murji'ah and the wicked
2:14 May see fit to abandon enjoining good and forbidding evil,
2:18 Thinking that this is a way to avoid discord."
2:22 Among their most severe tribulations is that they do not consider one who rejects the law of Allah to be an apostate,
2:28 Nor one who supports the enemies of Allah against the Muslims.
2:31 Thus, the atmosphere was cleared for heretics and tyrants by these fatwas from the leaders of the Murji'ah,
2:37 And they spread corruption on earth and legislated disbelief for the people in the name of public interest and other excuses.
2:43 Yet, they remained believers in the view of the Murji'ah,
2:48 Because they say "There is no god but Allah."
2:51 How happy the tyrants are with this school of thought!
2:54 Therefore, it was said that the Murji'ah follow the religion of kings.
2:59 The Murji'ah of the jurists are those who say that deeds are obligatory and that people vary in them,
3:07 But they do not include deeds in the definition and reality of faith.
3:12 This view is attributed to the school of Abu Hanifah, may Allah have mercy on him,
3:17 And it is the mildest form of Irja'.
3:22 A summary of the concepts held by the Ahl al-Sunnah.