Part of Concepts of Ahl as-Sunnah (series completed) · Lesson 217 of 1251

Summary of Sunni concepts | Concept (215) | Atonement

◉ 58 views ⏱ 3:21 Translated audio — English
0:000:00

Lesson summary

The lesson explains takfir, which is ruling that a responsible person is a disbeliever, whether an original disbeliever such as a Jew or Christian, or an apostate from Islam who has committed a act of disbelief. The sheikh stresses that takfir is a right of Allah, has nothing to do with personal desire or whims, and occurs only when its conditions are met and its preventing factors are absent, such as coercion, error, ignorance, or interpretation. The lesson shows that Ahl al-Sunnah take a middle position between the Khawarij, who declare everyone who sins a disbeliever, and the Murji'ah, who do not declare a specific person a disbeliever except through denial and considering sin lawful. It concludes that disbelief occurs through belief, speech, and action, and that committing an act of disbelief or shirk makes the doer described as a disbeliever even if he does not consider it lawful.

Key takeaways

  • Takfir is a legal ruling that a responsible person is a disbeliever, and it is a right of Allah, not something based on personal desire or whim.
  • Takfir happens only when its conditions are fulfilled and its preventing factors are absent, such as coercion, error, ignorance, and interpretation.
  • Ahl al-Sunnah take a middle position between the Khawarij, who declare every sinner a disbeliever without regard to conditions and preventing factors, and the Murji'ah, who do not declare a specific person a disbeliever except through denial and considering sin lawful.
  • Ahl al-Sunnah do not declare disbelief for every sin, only for what the texts state is disbelief, such as abandoning prayer entirely, ruling by other than what Allah revealed, and cursing the Prophet ﷺ or his religion.
  • According to Ahl al-Sunnah, disbelief occurs through belief, such as believing that Allah has a rival or partner in His lordship, His divinity, or His names and attributes, and also through speech and action.
  • Considering sins lawful is itself disbelief, and it is not a condition for disbelief except in sins that fall short of disbelief and shirk.
  • Acts that are disbelief or shirk, such as prostrating to an idol or cursing the Prophet ﷺ, make the doer described as a disbeliever by the act itself, even if he does not consider it lawful, once the conditions are met and the preventing factors are absent.

Questions & answers

What is takfir in the creed of Ahl al-Sunnah?

Takfir is ruling that a responsible person is a disbeliever, whether an original disbeliever such as a Jew or Christian, or an apostate from Islam who has fallen into an act of disbelief. It is a right of Allah.

Does Ahl al-Sunnah declare a Muslim a disbeliever for every sin?

No. Ahl al-Sunnah declare disbelief only for the sins that the texts describe as disbelief, such as abandoning prayer entirely, ruling by other than what Allah revealed, and cursing the Prophet ﷺ or his religion.

When is a specific person declared a disbeliever according to Ahl al-Sunnah?

A specific person is declared a disbeliever only when the conditions for takfir are met and the preventing factors, such as coercion, error, ignorance, and interpretation, are absent. Disbelief is not limited to denial and considering sin lawful.

How do Ahl al-Sunnah differ from the Khawarij and the Murji'ah on takfir?

The Khawarij declare disbelief for every sin without regard to conditions and preventing factors. The Murji'ah judge the act as disbelief but do not declare the specific doer a disbeliever unless he denies or considers it lawful. Ahl al-Sunnah take a middle position between them.

Auto-generated from the lesson transcript; the lesson itself is the reference.

Transcript

Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00 The essence of the concepts of Ahl al-Sunnah
0:08 Takfir (excommunication)
0:11 Takfir is the judgment that a responsible person is an unbeliever.
0:15 This applies whether it is original disbelief, like that of a Jew or a Christian,
0:20 or if a Muslim apostatizes from Islam
0:23 by committing an act that nullifies faith.
0:27 And takfir is Allah's right alone.
0:30 It has nothing to do with personal inclination, desire, or whim.
0:35 It only occurs when its conditions are met and its impediments are absent,
0:40 such as coercion, error, ignorance, or misinterpretation.
0:44 And Ahl al-Sunnah are moderate in takfir, between the Khawarij,
0:49 who excommunicate for every sin,
0:52 without regard for conditions and impediments,
0:55 and the Murji'ah, who judge an action as disbelief
1:00 but do not excommunicate the specific doer,
1:03 unless they openly deny it and deem it permissible.
1:07 For them, there is no disbelief of refusal and arrogance,
1:10 nor disbelief of mockery.
1:12 It is sufficient for them that one utters the two testimonies of faith,
1:15 for them to become a Muslim,
1:17 even if the actions and words of the heart are absent,
1:21 even if all types of deeds are absent.
1:24 So Ahl al-Sunnah wa al-Jama'ah do not excommunicate for every sin.
1:29 They only excommunicate for the sin for which the texts state it is disbelief,
1:35 such as abandoning prayer absolutely,
1:37 and ruling by other than what Allah has revealed,
1:40 and reviling the Messenger, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and reviling his religion,
1:44 and so forth.
1:46 And they do not excommunicate a specific individual
1:48 unless the conditions for their excommunication are met and the impediments are absent.
1:53 And they do not limit this to denial and deeming permissible,
1:56 because disbelief, according to Ahl al-Sunnah, occurs through numerous matters.
2:01 Among them is belief,
2:03 such as believing that Allah has a peer and partner in His Lordship, Divinity, or Names and Attributes.
2:11 And among them is deeming the forbidden as permissible.
2:14 So deeming sins permissible is disbelief in itself, even if the one who deems it permissible does not commit them.
2:19 And deeming permissible is not a condition for disbelief
2:22 except in sins that are less than disbelief and polytheism.
2:26 As for actions that are disbelief and polytheism,
2:29 such as prostrating to an idol or reviling the Messenger, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,
2:34 the permissibility of performing them is not a prerequisite for deeming their doer an unbeliever.
2:39 Rather, they are described as such merely by performing them, even if they do not deem it permissible.
2:44 As long as the conditions have been met and the impediments have been absent.
2:49 And disbelief occurs through the tongue, such as reviling Allah and His Messenger,
2:54 praising polytheism, reviling prophets and angels, and mocking the divine law.
3:00 And disbelief occurs through action, such as one who fights prophets,
3:05 aids disbelievers against Muslims, or insults the Qur'an,
3:10 and slaughters or prostrates to other than Allah, or legislates apart from Allah.
3:15 The essence of the concepts of Ahl al-Sunnah