Part of Concepts of Ahl as-Sunnah — Collected Episodes (series completed)
· Lesson 5 of 77
Summary of Sunni concepts | 71- Concepts about secularism | Concepts (1105-1116)
0:000:00
Transcript
Machine translation — may contain errors
0:00
Summary of the Concepts of Ahl al-Sunnah
0:09
Machiavellianism:
0:12
It was named after Machiavelli, author of the book *The Prince*, published in the year 1513 CE,
0:22
and it is considered the initial seed that paved the way for secularism.
0:27
In his aforementioned book, Machiavelli advocated
0:30
an explicit call to exclude religion from the realm of governance and politics,
0:36
establishing three interconnected foundations
0:39
derived from a purely non-religious worldview.
0:43
The first is that man is evil by nature,
0:48
and his desire for good is artificial, aimed solely at achieving personal gain;
0:53
therefore, in his view, there is no harm in this innate nature,
0:58
nor any blame in being swayed by it.
1:01
Second is the absolute separation between politics, religion, and morality,
1:07
emphasizing that there is no connection whatsoever between them;
1:11
while he did not reject religion and morality in themselves,
1:15
he freed the ruler from adhering to their constraints,
1:20
arguing that religion and morality should be confined exclusively to individual citizens.
1:25
Third is that the end justifies the means,
1:29
which served as his practical substitute for religion and ethics,
1:35
and through this principle, Machiavellianism became widely recognized and renowned,
1:39
though in reality it is merely one of its three pillars,
1:43
not the entirety of Machiavellianism.
1:48
Machiavellianism was a source of inspiration for most fascist, communist, and capitalist leaders:
1:57
Mussolini chose *The Prince* as the subject of his doctoral dissertation,
2:03
Hitler kept the book close to his bed,
2:07
reading from it every night before going to sleep,
2:11
and Lenin and Stalin were likewise disciples of it.
2:15
The spirit of Machiavellianism is clearly evident in the statement of Engels:
2:20
"The morality in which we believe
2:23
is any action that leads to the triumph of our principles,
2:27
no matter how much that action contradicts prevailing moral standards."
2:32
Lenin stated:
2:34
"The true communist fighter must
2:37
master all forms of deceit, deception, and misdirection,
2:42
for the struggle for communism
2:44
blesses every means that brings communism about."
2:48
Miles Copeland,
2:50
author of *The Game of Nations*, affirms
2:53
that Machiavellianism is the methodology of American capitalist politics.
2:59
The Definition of Secularism:
3:03
It is a mistranslation of the English word *secularism*
3:11
or the French *sécularité*.
3:15
As defined by the *Encyclopædia Britannica*, it means
3:19
a social movement
3:21
that aims to divert people
3:23
and direct them away from concern for the Hereafter
3:26
to an exclusive preoccupation with this worldly life alone.
3:29
The *Oxford English Dictionary* defines
3:31
the word *secular* with two meanings:
3:34
the first is worldly or temporal,
3:37
neither religious nor spiritual,
3:40
such as non-religious education,
3:43
non-religious authority,
3:45
or government as opposed to the church;
3:48
the second is the view which holds
3:52
that religion should not be the basis for morality and education.
3:57
Thus, it becomes clear from the definitions of the *Encyclopædia Britannica*
4:00
and the *Oxford English Dictionary*
4:02
that secularism
4:04
denotes irreligion or temporalism—
4:07
that is, whatever has no relation to religion,
4:10
or stands in direct opposition to religion.
4:14
It is a movement and concept aimed at separating religion
4:18
from the entirety of practical life,
4:20
not merely from politics.
4:23
This began to emerge in the late Middle Ages
4:27
as a resistance against the intense urge
4:29
toward worldly renunciation
4:31
and contemplation of Allah and the Last Day,
4:34
which were predominant during those ages.
4:37
Thus, secularism arose,
4:39
calling for devotion to humanism
4:42
and human achievements in this worldly life,
4:46
while antagonizing and opposing religion;
4:50
it continued to evolve
4:52
until it culminated in an explicit call
4:54
to separate religion from the entirety of practical life.
4:58
As for "knowledge" in English,
5:00
it is "science,"
5:02
its adjective is "scientific,"
5:04
meaning based on science,
5:06
and scientism denotes the scientific doctrine.
5:09
Perhaps translating the term
5:11
*secularism*
5:13
and the concepts it entails
5:15
into the Arabic word *'almaniyyah* (suggestive of knowledge)
5:17
instead of *la-diniyyah* (irreligion)
5:19
was deliberate,
5:21
so that the doctrine would not collide
5:23
in direct confrontation
5:25
with the faith of Muslims in the Arab East
5:27
and their understanding of the Hereafter,
5:29
and so that the movement would be able
5:31
to propagate its ideas
5:33
smoothly and quietly,
5:35
while Muslims remained unawares.
5:37
There is no doubt that this concept
5:39
does not exist in Islam whatsoever;
5:41
rather, it is apostasy
5:43
and a complete shedding of the religion.
5:45
There is no secularism in Islam;
5:47
rather, such a concept
5:49
falls under the category of
5:51
*Jahiliyyah* (pre-Islamic ignorance).
5:53
The Qur'an mentions four pillars
5:55
of Jahiliyyah,
5:57
which are the very same pillars of secularism:
5:59
the assumption of Jahiliyyah,
6:01
the ruling of Jahiliyyah,
6:03
the wanton display of Jahiliyyah,
6:05
and the chauvinistic zeal of Jahiliyyah.
6:07
And a fifth pillar
6:09
was mentioned in the Sunnah:
6:11
the lord of Jahiliyyah.
6:13
These pillars of Jahiliyyah
6:15
are implemented today
6:17
in Muslim lands
6:19
with malice and cunning:
6:21
keeping people ignorant of their Lord
6:23
is the assumption of Jahiliyyah;
6:25
setting aside the Sharia of Allah
6:27
and rejecting His judgment is the ruling of Jahiliyyah;
6:29
the westernization of women
6:31
and their unveiling is the wanton display of Jahiliyyah;
6:33
the wanton display of Jahiliyyah;
6:35
basing loyalty and disavowal
6:37
on a homeland, ethnicity, or any banner
6:39
other than the banner of Tawhid
6:41
is the chauvinistic zeal of Jahiliyyah;
6:43
and the worship of wealth and capitalism
6:45
founded on usury
6:47
and gambling
6:49
is the lord of Jahiliyyah.
6:52
Kemalism:
6:55
It is Turkish secularism
6:57
as advocated by
6:59
Mustafa Kemal,
7:01
known as Atatürk,
7:03
who waged a relentless war against Islam
7:05
and its sacred rites:
7:07
he banned the call to prayer in Arabic
7:09
and banned the wearing of the hijab
7:11
in workplaces and public spaces,
7:13
among other measures,
7:15
aggressively combating everything related
7:17
to Islam and its outward manifestations.
7:19
Between Religion,
7:23
Politics, and Corruption:
7:25
The separation of religion
7:28
from politics emerged in the West
7:30
because their religion was corrupt
7:32
and would corrupt politics;
7:34
whereas this separation was introduced in the East
7:36
because politics was corrupt,
7:38
and religion prevents its corruption.
7:40
Secularism
7:43
and Worship:
7:46
Secularism pays
7:48
no regard to religion and worship
7:50
as long as they remain a private matter
7:52
between the servant and his Lord,
7:54
confined strictly to the mosque
7:56
without extending into practical life.
7:58
But if anyone attempts
8:00
to establish the principles of religion in governance
8:02
and politics, secularism confronts
8:04
and fiercely fights against them,
8:06
which
8:08
explains why its war is focused
8:10
against Islam specifically, unlike other
8:12
religions. The case of
8:14
secularists is just like that of
8:16
the people of Madyan with their prophet
8:18
Shu'ayb, peace be upon him,
8:20
when he forbade them from giving short measure
8:22
and weight,
8:24
and they said to him: "Does your prayer
8:26
command you that we should abandon
8:28
what our forefathers worshipped?"
8:30
“They said: O Shu'eyb! Doth thy way of prayer command thee that we should forsake that which our fathers (used to) worship, or that we (should leave off) doing what we will with our own property. Lo! thou art the mild, the guide to right behaviour.” (11:87)
8:33
It is the very same case as the disbelievers of Quraysh
8:35
with the Messenger, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him:
8:38
they did not initially oppose
8:40
him when
8:42
he worshipped Allah alone in the cave of Hira;
8:44
but when he called people
8:46
to adhere to the religion of Allah,
8:48
establish the societal order
8:50
upon its foundation, and renounce
8:52
disbelief, they fought him
8:54
with the utmost hostility.
8:56
Secularism
8:59
is a Defiance of Truth:
9:01
Reason dictates that the Maker
9:04
is best aware of what He made;
9:06
so whoever advocates
9:08
separating the religion of Allah from politics
9:10
either does not believe
9:12
that Allah is the Creator
9:14
the universe and its Sustainer,
9:16
and He knows best what He created;
9:18
or he is simply a follower of base desires,
9:20
stubbornly defying the truth.
9:24
Secularism is ruling
9:26
by other than what Allah has revealed.
9:29
Since secularism
9:31
is basing life on something other than religion,
9:33
it inherently means
9:35
ruling by other than what Allah has revealed.
9:37
Accordingly,
9:39
it is an order of ignorance (Jahiliyyah)
9:41
that has no place whatsoever within the fold
9:43
of Islam.
9:45
"Is it then the judgment of the time of ignorance they seek?
9:47
And who is better than Allah
9:49
in judgment for a people who are certain in faith?"
9:51
It is an order
9:53
of explicit disbelief,
9:55
by the explicit text of the Qur'an:
9:57
"And whoever does not judge by what
9:59
Allah has revealed, then it is they
10:01
who are the disbelievers."
10:03
Refutation of those who do not
10:06
declare secularism to be disbelief:
10:08
Most
10:11
of the verses concerning the excommunication
10:13
of those who do not judge by what Allah revealed
10:15
and the negation of their faith
10:17
were revealed regarding those who claim
10:19
faith from among the People of the Book,
10:21
or the hypocrites
10:23
who outwardly profess Islam.
10:25
That is—and Allah
10:27
knows best—only because
10:29
whoever makes no claim to faith at all
10:31
does not
10:33
need to be proven as such; he is necessarily a disbeliever,
10:35
and there is no doubt about his disbelief.
10:37
This is unlike someone who claims faith
10:39
yet still rules by other
10:41
than what Allah has revealed;
10:43
his case requires affirmation
10:45
that he is indeed among the disbelievers,
10:47
and his mere claim
10:49
to faith will avail him nothing.
10:51
Thus, the words of Allah Almighty:
10:53
"And whoever does not judge
10:55
by what Allah has revealed,
10:57
then it is they who are the disbelievers,"
10:59
and His saying:
11:01
“Hast thou not seen those who pretend that they believe in that which is revealed unto thee and that which was revealed before thee, how they would go for judgment (in their disputes) to false deities when they have been ordered to abjure them? Satan would mislead them far astray.” (4:60)
11:03
"...that they believe in what
11:05
was revealed to you and what
11:07
was revealed before you?
11:09
They wish to seek judgment
11:11
from the Taghut, even though
11:13
“Hast thou not seen those who pretend that they believe in that which is revealed unto thee and that which was revealed before thee, how they would go for judgment (in their disputes) to false deities when they have been ordered to abjure them? Satan would mislead them far astray.” (4:60)
11:15
and Satan wishes to
11:17
mislead them far astray,"
11:19
as well as His saying:
11:21
"But no, by your Lord, they do not
11:23
believe until they make you judge
11:25
in what disputes arise between them
11:27
“But nay, by thy Lord, they will not believe (in truth) until they make thee judge of what is in dispute between them and find within themselves no dislike of that which thou decidest, and submit with full submission.” (4:65)
11:29
in themselves any hesitation
11:31
regarding what you have decided and submit
11:33
completely"—
11:35
were revealed concerning the hypocrites.
11:37
For these hypocrites
11:39
used to pray
11:41
and fast, and they claimed
11:43
to have faith, observing
11:45
many outward rituals of Islam;
11:47
yet that did not prevent
11:49
them from being branded with disbelief
11:51
and stripped of true faith,
11:53
because they abandoned ruling by what
11:55
Allah revealed and seeking judgment from Him.
11:57
Therefore, let no one argue
11:59
against the disbelief of secularism
12:01
by claiming that it does not deny
12:03
the existence of Allah, nor does it forbid
12:05
performing acts of worship,
12:07
and that it outwardly respects
12:09
religious institutions
12:11
and clerics; for religion
12:13
is an indivisible whole,
12:15
as the Almighty said:
12:17
"O you who
12:19
have believed, enter into Islam
12:21
completely,
12:23
and do not follow the footsteps of Satan.
12:25
Indeed, he is to you
12:27
a clear enemy."
12:29
"Al-Silm" means Islam,
12:31
as the exegetes have stated.
12:33
And the Almighty said:
12:35
"Indeed, those who disbelieve
12:37
in Allah and His messengers,
12:39
and wish to discriminate
12:41
between Allah and His messengers,
12:43
saying, 'We believe in some
12:45
and disbelieve in others,'
12:47
and wish to adopt
12:49
a way in between—
12:51
those are the disbelievers,
12:53
in truth.
12:55
And We have prepared
12:57
for the disbelievers a humiliating punishment."
12:59
The constitution:
13:02
The constitution
13:05
is the basic law
13:07
or fundamental statute
13:09
of any country,
13:11
to which all laws are referred;
13:13
hence, it is called
13:15
the mother of all laws.
13:17
It may be amended or repealed
13:19
in democratic systems
13:21
through a referendum,
13:23
or a ruler may suspend it
13:25
in positive-law systems
13:27
when ruling under what they call
13:29
emergency law.
13:31
But the constitution of the Muslims
13:33
is the Book and the Sunnah,
13:35
for they reign supreme over governance
13:37
in the Islamic system,
13:39
and to them every subsidiary law must refer.
13:41
If the Muslims
13:43
in any country draft
13:45
a numbered constitution for themselves
13:47
in the form of main articles,
13:49
its primary, foundational article—
13:51
which can never
13:53
be abolished, amended,
13:55
or put to a referendum—must be
13:57
that Islamic Sharia
13:59
is the sole source
14:01
of legislation, nullifying
14:03
any law that contradicts it;
14:05
and this article
14:07
must be effectively implemented on the ground,
14:09
not merely stated
14:11
as dust in the eyes
14:13
through cunning,
14:15
twisted phrasing, such as when some omit
14:17
the definite article from it
14:19
to make it just one source
14:21
among multiple sources,
14:23
rather than the sole source.
14:25
With this aforementioned
14:27
condition, any
14:29
constitution in any Muslim land
14:31
would be a branch of the Book
14:33
and the Sunnah, governed by them,
14:35
and incapable of contradicting
14:37
them.
14:40
Civil law
14:43
is the set of penal or criminal
14:45
rules
14:47
that govern any country
14:49
based on its constitution,
14:51
to which secularists resort for judgment—
14:53
seeking judgment from the Taghut
14:55
while casting Islamic Sharia
14:57
behind their backs.
14:59
The first person to initiate
15:01
codified legislation in the modern era
15:03
was Napoleon,
15:05
in the year eighteen hundred and four
15:07
CE,
15:09
and from him Easterners adopted it.
15:11
Yet Islamic fiqh,
15:13
especially in the section on commercial and civil dealings,
15:15
is the true reference for Muslim judges
15:17
regarding penal rulings
15:19
or criminal matters,
15:21
in place of this so-called
15:23
civil law.
15:26
Civil society
15:28
is an ambiguous term
15:31
with multiple meanings,
15:33
which its proponents employ
15:35
for various purposes;
15:37
it lump-sums anything
15:39
with everything.
15:41
It emerged through a long evolution
15:43
and carries within its folds
15:45
tensions and contradictions
15:47
that are the very cause of its ambiguity.
15:49
Within this term,
15:51
the concepts of
15:53
the believer versus the non-believer,
15:55
man and woman,
15:57
and tribal member versus Bedouin,
15:59
and so forth, disappear entirely,
16:01
and they are all replaced
16:03
by the concept of the individual citizen.
16:05
Among the most essential pillars
16:07
civil society,
16:09
the principle of individual freedom,
16:11
and secular citizenship
16:13
eliminate any other allegiance,
16:15
whether based on religion, ethnicity,
16:17
or the like,
16:19
and lay the foundation for separating religion
16:21
from the state.
16:24
Nowadays, the term
16:26
"civil society organizations" may also be applied
16:28
to non-profit organizations
16:30
that aim to
16:32
serve the community in which they are established.
16:34
There is no objection to that
16:36
in such a case,
16:38
provided that none of these
16:40
organizations operates
16:42
on concepts contrary to Islam,
16:44
and that they are not
16:46
tied to foreign entities—
16:48
which are often
16:50
intelligence agencies—
16:52
that actually exploit them
16:54
to serve their own interests.
16:56
And this is indeed the reality of many
16:58
such organizations,
17:00
as events reveal after
17:02
a period of time,
17:04
during which the goals of these
17:06
suspicious entities are fulfilled,
17:08
or once they are exposed by the security services
17:10
of the countries where they operate.
17:12
The summary of the doctrine of
17:14
Ahl al-Sunnah